Guest Eremite Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 Michael, That quote is usually attributed to St. Athanasius, but also other Saints. I think it is just an apocryphal saying. I haven't seen any sources cited for it.
Philippe Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 [quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 1 2005, 10:16 AM'] [url="http://www.recongress.org/2005/pix/ydlitb/MVC-042S.htm"]http://www.recongress.org/2005/pix/ydlitb/MVC-042S.htm[/url] What's wrong with this guy???? Doesn't he know about communal posture!? aaaaghhhhh [/quote] lets not judge people. maybe he doesnt know or maybe hes the only one doing it right.
FiZzGiG Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 Hmm... I agree that this liturgical abuse cannot be excused. From the looks of it, they were putting on a show on the altar. Not good. BUT, I like to see the positive with the negative. The positive being the fact that so many youth showed up to go to Mass. And who knows... a lot of them might not have known that there would be dancing anyway. At least they're at least opening themselves up to the Mass. Cut out the dancing, and it's all goooood. Oh and about the holding hands during the Our Father: [url="http://www.catholic.org/featured/headline.php?ID=508"]http://www.catholic.org/featured/headline.php?ID=508[/url] Now I don't know if they changed the rule, and this article is too old. I just found it online and though it explained it nicely. If anyone has any other document to post, that'd be great. Cheers!
Guest Eremite Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 [quote]BUT, I like to see the positive with the negative. The positive being the fact that so many youth showed up to go to Mass. And who knows... a lot of them might not have known that there would be dancing anyway.[/quote] True. Even if they did know, they probably received bad liturgical education/witness their whole life, and don't know any better. They're just eating what they're fed. I think we need to do penance for all the innocents who have to endure an archdiocese like Los Angeles.
MichaelFilo Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 [quote name='Eremite' date='Mar 1 2005, 10:39 PM'] Michael, That quote is usually attributed to St. Athanasius, but also other Saints. I think it is just an apocryphal saying. I haven't seen any sources cited for it. [/quote] Weird, I am sure I heard it from some Marian appirtiion. Although, it's probably from Our Lady of the Roses, in Bayside, NY. That would explain the quote, as it's an invalid apparition.. God bless, Mikey
disturbedxfairy Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 i agree about that girl's skirt. she looks like she's trying to be like Catholic pop diva britney-christina-jessica
MichaelFilo Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 I thought it was Lindsay Lohan, and wher eis the Eucharist? God bless, Mikey
toledo_jesus Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 [quote name='Philippe' date='Mar 1 2005, 10:43 PM'] lets not judge people. maybe he doesnt know or maybe hes the only one doing it right. [/quote] hahaha I was being sarcastic. communal posture is a joke.
Mrs. Bro. Adam Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 Again: Notitiae (Instructions for Sacraments and Divine Worship) Vol. XI, (1975) pp. 202-205 state: "Dance has never constituted an essential part in the official liturgy of the Latin Church. If local Churches have introduced the dance, at times even in the temples, this was on occasion of feasts in order to show feelings of jubilation and devotion. But the dance always took place outside the liturgical actions. Conciliar decisions have often condemned the religious dance, as not befitting worship, and also beacuse it could degenerate into disorders...hence, it is not possible to introduce something of that sort in the liturgical celebration; it would mean bringing into the liturgy one of the most desacrilized and desacrilizing elements: and this would mean the same as introducing an atmosphere of profanity, which would easily suggest to those present worldly places and profane situations."
SevenSorrows Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 [quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 1 2005, 10:16 AM'] [url="http://www.recongress.org/2005/pix/ydlitb/MVC-042S.htm"]http://www.recongress.org/2005/pix/ydlitb/MVC-042S.htm[/url] What's wrong with this guy???? Doesn't he know about communal posture!? aaaaghhhhh [/quote] He was probably the only faithful Catholic there. Or as you would say "geez what is wrong with this guy...kneeling while a miracle takes place as bread becomes Jesus".... if it was a real conference like the national catholic family conference, everyone would have been on their knees on the concrete.
toledo_jesus Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 [quote name='SevenSorrows' date='Mar 2 2005, 03:01 PM'] He was probably the only faithful Catholic there. Or as you would say "geez what is wrong with this guy...kneeling while a miracle takes place as bread becomes Jesus".... if it was a real conference like the national catholic family conference, everyone would have been on their knees on the concrete. [/quote] sorry, let me be clear...I was being way sarcastic. I don't believe in that communal posture garbage. I should have utilized smileys. " ...communal posture!?" there we go. I agree, he might have been one of the few faithful Catholics there. I probably would have been in the fetal position the whole time.
mulls Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 now that's a protestant knee-slappin shindig if i ever seen one!!! "now swing your partner dosey-doe, lift your hands, catch that ghost!" yee-haaww!!
Cesar624 Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 [quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 1 2005, 02:45 PM'] Cesar, American Catholic culture attaches certain meanings to dancing and singing (of course hymns and the like are worshipful...well, they used to be). They are entertainment, not worship. American Catholicism is generally Irish in origin, which is a repressed, persecuted form of it. British rule and all that. So the culture here is and has been predominantly without overmuch pageantry. Go to Mexico, or Portugal, or Italy and see the festivals and parades and what all for an example of different cultural Catholicism. Africa and the Hawaiians have incorporated traditional dance into the Mass, which is standard operating procedure for the Church when she converts new peoples. [/quote] Well, I guess I don't see a problem with it because I didn't grow up in "American Catholic Culture", my family is from Puerto Rico and the way we worship is obviously different from the way "American Catholics" worship. My brand of Catholicism isn't very Irish in origin, it's Spanish with some African and native Taino Indian influence. So, that's why I don't see this as such a big deal. There's no such thing as a SET American culture.
Mrs. Bro. Adam Posted March 2, 2005 Posted March 2, 2005 [quote name='Cesar624' date='Mar 2 2005, 05:18 PM'] Well, I guess I don't see a problem with it because I didn't grow up in "American Catholic Culture", my family is from Puerto Rico and the way we worship is obviously different from the way "American Catholics" worship. My brand of Catholicism isn't very Irish in origin, it's Spanish with some African and native Taino Indian influence. So, that's why I don't see this as such a big deal. There's no such thing as a SET American culture. [/quote] This is why it is wrong. Because it is an official [b]nonfallible[/b] document telling us [b]not[/b] to do it. If you live in America, and are an American, you [b]DO NOT[/b] do liturgical dance. Period. BTW- this will be the [b]third[/b] time I've posted this: [quote]Notitiae (Instructions for Sacraments and Divine Worship) Vol. XI, (1975) pp. 202-205 state: "Dance has never constituted an essential part in the official liturgy of the Latin Church. If local Churches have introduced the dance, at times even in the temples, this was on occasion of feasts in order to show feelings of jubilation and devotion. But the dance always took place outside the liturgical actions. Conciliar decisions have often condemned the religious dance, as not befitting worship, and also beacuse it could degenerate into disorders...hence, it is not possible to introduce something of that sort in the liturgical celebration; it would mean bringing into the liturgy one of the most desacrilized and desacrilizing elements: and this would mean the same as introducing an atmosphere of profanity, which would easily suggest to those present worldly places and profane situations."[/quote] Maybe now that I've posted it in BIG letters it will be read.
jiyoung Posted March 3, 2005 Posted March 3, 2005 i'm ashamed. this is right next to my diocese. thank God for the phatmass phamily! if i hadn't met you guys, i wouldn't know what a (in the words of the document) profanity this is.
Scofizzle Posted March 3, 2005 Posted March 3, 2005 what about spontaneous dancing? I saw soem folks just start dancing in the cnogregation during the closing song......although the MAss is over then......but still.....spontaneous dancing? oh and its just a question im not defending it.
Mrs. Bro. Adam Posted March 3, 2005 Posted March 3, 2005 Mass isn't over until the priests have left the sanctuary.
Scofizzle Posted March 3, 2005 Posted March 3, 2005 see thats what I thought too.....but I talked to my parish priest after our ash wednesday Mass.....They did the ashes after the final blessing.....And everyone left. Me and my friends waited for them to preocess out afterwards (we were the only ones) and they did not.......We asked him abotu it and he said that Mass is actually over when the priest says "the Mass is over go in peace and whatever he says after that"
MichaelFilo Posted March 3, 2005 Posted March 3, 2005 (edited) Another "be careful who you judge" flies out here and I will personally shoot it down. Do you think a bishop can be so uninformed as to not know he is carriying out a sacreligious liturgical abuse? Do you honestly believe, he doesn't notice something is wrong with this Mass, it' snot like all the others? Don't judge him though, he may have to think about what he'sx doing... If you don't admonish the sinner, you fail at being a good person. You have become "nice" and Jesus told us to be good, not nice. This is a disasterously grave sina gainst the liturgy and Mahoney knows it. It would be sick to we shouldn't target Mahoney for this one, if you clearly see him there, possibly the creator of the wonderous idea. *edit* I saw a typo and I had only looked at 3 words, but I'm sure it's understandable (the post that is) God bless, Mikey Edited March 3, 2005 by MichaelFilo
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now