ironmonk Posted July 13, 2003 Posted July 13, 2003 (edited) Congress Urged to Keep Ban on Funding Groups Involved in Forced Abortions WASHINGTON, D.C., JULY 11, 2003 (Zenit.org).- Cardinal Anthony Bevilacqua urged Congress to keep the ban on U.S. funding of organizations involved in programs of coerced abortion or involuntary sterilization. In a letter dated Thursday, the cardinal called on the House of Representatives to approve the Smith-Oberstar-Hyde Amendment when it takes up the State Department authorization bill. This would allow the Kemp-Kasten amendment to the annual foreign operations appropriations bills to operate as it has since 1985, to prohibit funding of organizations that support, or participate in the management of, programs of coerced abortion or involuntary sterilization. Cardinal Bevilacqua said such action is needed in order to remove the Crowley amendment from the State Department bill. Narrowly approved in committee, the Crowley amendment would earmark $50 million in funding to the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) despite its participation in China's forced-abortion program. The cardinal noted that UNFPA's participation in the Chinese program was uncovered during an investigation by Chinese human rights activists. Cardinal Bevilacqua, archbishop of Philadelphia and chairman of the U.S. bishops' Committee for Pro-Life Activities, said: "American taxpayers must not be forced to fund organizations that support, condone or defend such violations of human rights." Edited July 13, 2003 by ironmonk
Winchester Posted July 13, 2003 Posted July 13, 2003 Ah yes, the only way to maintain the high status of women in society is to forcibly perform surgery on them. I wish I was enlightened enough to understand this. Caesar, Brutus and Judas might get relief in Hell when the monsters responsible for this start thankfully dying. Yes, monsters. These people disgust me. They are vomitous creatures unworthy of their positions in society, sickening wretches whose political power witnesses to our world's state of utter disregard for decency. In a just society, their heads would adorn the city gates, where crows would fight over their eyes. Lest any think this severe, these people support forced sedation and surgery on women. This is akin to rape, a rape supported by our intelligentsia. Anyone who supports this form ogf government power should just pull on their jack boots and swastikas.
Brother Adam Posted July 14, 2003 Posted July 14, 2003 Hell is a place where God is lacking. Totally. God is not in hell- thus whatever punishment these people receive- IF they go to hell- and that is NOT for us to judge, will not be God torturing them.
Winchester Posted July 14, 2003 Posted July 14, 2003 I said "might", and that "might" goes for any of us.
Winchester Posted July 14, 2003 Posted July 14, 2003 Oh, and the reference is to Dante's work. I never said God tortured anyone.
Winchester Posted July 14, 2003 Posted July 14, 2003 It's quite an extreme statement. I would expect such a reaction from a rational person. Certainly my language was vague enough to be interpreted thus.
Red Knight Posted July 18, 2003 Posted July 18, 2003 The American Legion Magazine has a controversial question put to Legislators every month. This month: Is The United Nations Relevant? I will post the side I agree with, if anybody wants the other side, buy the magazine! Really though, I will post the other side if y'all want me to. "Is The United Nations Relevant? Rep. Roscoe Bartlett R-Md. NO The United Nations has proved itself irrelevant. Article I Chapter 1 of the U.N. Charter says the first purpose of the United Nations is to "maintain international peace and security, and to that end: to take effective collective measures for the prevention and removal of threats to the peace, and for the suppression of acts of aggression or other breaches of the peace." The United Nations ignored Cambodia and Rwanda, the most shameful genocidal crises of the past 30 years. In Srebrenica, a U.N. supervised "safe zone,' 8,000 were massacred. Consider Korea and the first Gulf War - the only successful examples of international authority against aggression in the past 50 years. You will find the United Nations, but in a subordinate role to a U.s. - led coalition. Compare the U.N.'s 12 year failure to disarm Saddam hussein and the four-week U.S. - led coalition campaign which eliminated the regime. Consider that while Iraqi's celebrated release from tyranny by welcoming American soldiers as liberators, the U.N. Security Council failed to condemn North Korea for its unilateral withdrawal from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. Consider that Saddam's Iraq was scheduled to chair the U.N. Disarmament conference. The current chair of the U.N. Human Rights Conference is Libya. Worse than irrelevant, the United Nations supports brutal regimes. Worse than irrelevant, the undemocratic majority in the U.N. General Assembly uses democratic means to shake down productive democratic republics for billions of dollars each year. The United nations' massive failure to disarm Iraq has opened Americans' eyes. Rep. Ron Paul's bill, H.R. 1146, to remove the United States from the United Nations, provides an excellent forum for Americans to debate it." Gets ya thinkin' Red Knight
MC Just Posted July 19, 2003 Posted July 19, 2003 (edited) I dont like the Un. United Nations sounds like something an Anti-christ made. Edited July 19, 2003 by Mc-Just†
_bc Posted July 19, 2003 Posted July 19, 2003 (edited) I think that's an outrageously populistic and shallow argument. 1) The UN is a huge, broad organization ranging from the UN Development Program and UNESCO to intellectual property rights institutions. Rep. Bartlett focuses exclusively on the headline-grabbing functions of the Security Council, pretending that almost all of the UNs functions don't exist or have no good reason for them. He also pretends that the UN can just go away, totally ignoring the need for a forum in which the nations of the world can pool their resources, manage and influence the development of globalizaton. 2) The UN has no security-related power, no soldiers of its own and no mandate to make any decisions on international security, and this is the way it was intended to be. The security council is composed of the nation states on the council at that time, including the US and the other four permanent members. That the UN didn't act in Cambodia for decades is not the fault of the UN, it is a direct consequence of the fact that the US and the USSR couldn't agree on what to do, if anything, and it was the middle of the cold war. Also, for a republican politician to blame the UN for not stopping the Khmer Rouge is hypocritical at best, considering that the KR would probably never have had any chance of gaining power in Cambodia if it hadn't been for Kissinger and Nixons determinedly immoral sideshow to the Vietnam war in that country. Similarly, if the US and the EU would have permitted the European peacekeepers in Srebrenica to use force to protect the safe havens, there wouldn't have been the Srebrenica massacres - but the states on the Security Council did not permit them to use any kind of force unless directly attacked, so they had no legal mandate and no legal permission to intervene. Also, the US itself refused to supply any troops to help protect civilians in Bosnia, so where the heck does Rep. Bartlett find the nerve to blame the UN for not preventing that massacre? I could go on and on about this, and I would if this was a politics forum. Sorry if I sound angry, but certain sections of the American political establishment just get to my less friendly sides. Edited July 19, 2003 by _bc
_bc Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 The UN really smells of elderberries... Great, convincing point.
Don John of Austria Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 The U.N. Should not exist, either as Bc argues it is impotent ans there for useless or it is not impotent and therefore violates the sovriegnty of nations, either way it should go. Please do not try and tell me-- " totally ignoring the need for a forum in which the nations of the world can pool their resources, manage and influence the development of globalizaton." That kind of statement totally ignores the entire history of the world before the 1940's. Countries did just fine doing those things before the U.N. it is unneeded and frankly should be dismantled.
mp15 Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 (edited) Amen to that Don. Why people here in the US feel the UN is needed is beyond me. I for one do not want other nations telling us, or any other countries for that matter how they should do things. Collectively working with other nations yes, but not dictating policies. Edited July 22, 2003 by mp15
Adam Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 Amen to that Don. Why people here in the US feel the UN is needed is beyond me. I for one do not want other nations telling us, or any other countries for that matter how they should do things. Collectively working with other nations yes, but not dictating policies. Yah I agree there... im not so much down with the U.N. either... they would watch a nation burn in terrorism before they did anything.
_bc Posted July 25, 2003 Posted July 25, 2003 (edited) I didn't argue that the UN was impotent. I argued that the UN is an organization of sovereign states, and has no power to impose its will on the members or to commandeer their soldiers around. That does not mean it's useless, just like a neighborhood watch group is not automatically useless if nobody is forced to join. Why does inserting peacekeepers (volunteered by sovereign states) between Lebanon and Israel (with the invitation of both countries) violate the sovereignty of any state? Before 1945 there was the League of Nations. Also coming in handy in coordinating world affairs was colonialism, and the fact that 25% of Earth's landmass was under the British crown. Anyway, 18th or 19th century international relations - and certainly early 20th century international relations - are hardly a model for modernity. Claiming so is to ignore the history of the world - especially the history of the modern world. In addition to ignoring all the non-security related functions of the UN, you are basically giving no regard to all the good it does. One example: What would you have done with East Timor without the UN? Who or what would have been able to provide legitimacy for intervention there without the UN, or would you rather have left the Timorese to perish? Edited July 25, 2003 by _bc
Don John of Austria Posted July 25, 2003 Posted July 25, 2003 bc your joking right---- So Iraq's sovreignty wasn't violated --for the last ten years, come on. The U.N. most certianly does have security related powers--- THATS WHAT THE SECURITY COUNCIL is for. Second very few countries have ever asked for peacekeepers until they were pressured by other countries with threats of UN sanctions or UN militaryaction unilateral action. I am afraid you are going to have to explain to me why 19th century world relations are not a model for modernity( economies were globalized( the britsh colonial system and commonwealth for instance) lacck of any giant wars () lots of little ones but nothing really big. And a few big powers telling every one else what to do. sounds a lot like modernity to me( technically everything from around 1650 is modrnity but I used your terms so people wouldn't get confused.) Most of the non -security functions of the UN are either unimportant or EVIL such as the above group or UNICEF. furthermore any of the big five ( U.S. Russia, Britian, france, and China) can Veto any act the UN passes and therfore even if every member state wanted something if one of the big five don't like it they can violate everyones sovereignty and simply veto it. As for the East Timorese - well if Portugal had done right by them it would have defended them, as it as responsable for their predicament, but since you asked I really think Rome should have called a Crusade and a Catholic army should have driven the Muslims it to the sea. The call of Rome is more Legetimate than anything the UN might say or not say.
Red Knight Posted July 28, 2003 Posted July 28, 2003 bc your joking right---- So Iraq's sovreignty wasn't violated --for the last ten years, come on. The U.N. most certianly does have security related powers--- THATS WHAT THE SECURITY COUNCIL is for. Second very few countries have ever asked for peacekeepers until they were pressured by other countries with threats of UN sanctions or UN militaryaction unilateral action. I am afraid you are going to have to explain to me why 19th century world relations are not a model for modernity( economies were globalized( the britsh colonial system and commonwealth for instance) lacck of any giant wars () lots of little ones but nothing really big. And a few big powers telling every one else what to do. sounds a lot like modernity to me( technically everything from around 1650 is modrnity but I used your terms so people wouldn't get confused.) Most of the non -security functions of the UN are either unimportant or EVIL such as the above group or UNICEF. furthermore any of the big five ( U.S. Russia, Britian, france, and China) can Veto any act the UN passes and therfore even if every member state wanted something if one of the big five don't like it they can violate everyones sovereignty and simply veto it. As for the East Timorese - well if Portugal had done right by them it would have defended them, as it as responsable for their predicament, but since you asked I really think Rome should have called a Crusade and a Catholic army should have driven the Muslims it to the sea. The call of Rome is more Legetimate than anything the UN might say or not say. Once again Don, you put into words that which I was thinking, but was unable to put down on electrons. Red
_bc Posted July 28, 2003 Posted July 28, 2003 bc your joking right---- So Iraq's sovreignty wasn't violated --for the last ten years, come on. The U.N. most certianly does have security related powers--- THATS WHAT THE SECURITY COUNCIL is for. The S.C. is made up of 15 sovereign states, five of which are permanent members and have vetos. Obviously, the sovereignty of Iraq has been violated constantly for at least the past 12 years, but not by the UN. It's not the UN that has been bombing Iraq every week for 12 years, rather the United States and the United Kingdom. As you may know, American soldiers have never been under the command of foreigners, because that would be a violation of the constitution, so the UN has never had command over the forces in Iraq. The Security Council provided legitimacy by authorizing the first Gulf War, but it didn't conduct the war - actually, it just declared that Iraq's invasion of Kuwait was in violation of international law, and that consequently member states could legally 'use every means necessary' to drive them out. The war was conducted by a coalition led by the US, as you should know. The inspections were part of a cease fire agreement which was ratified by the SC, not a unilateral decree by the 'UN'. So the violations of Iraq's sovereignty are not by the UN, but by the member states that invaded the country. This is all in keeping with the fact that the UN has no power of its own, as you can easily see from the fact that Israel has been able to blatantly violate virtually every Security Council resolution on its situation since 1949. Second very few countries have ever asked for peacekeepers until they were pressured by other countries with threats of UN sanctions or UN militaryaction unilateral action.The UN can only authorize or recommend sanctions, but no country is required to actually impose them. That is exactly the difference between a voluntary forum and one that violates the sovereignty of states. The UN is a voluntary forum of sovereign states. This is a matter of fact, which I can hardly explain much better than I already have: if you still hold contrary beliefs they are false, and you might visit un.org to read up for yourself. Most of the non -security functions of the UN are either unimportant or EVIL such as the above group or UNICEF. furthermore any of the big five ( U.S. Russia, Britian, france, and China) can Veto any act the UN passes and therfore even if every member state wanted something if one of the big five don't like it they can violate everyones sovereignty and simply veto it. Again, you are fundamentally in the wrong, as regards the facts. The five permanent members have vetos in the Security Council, not in the UN as a whole and certainly not in the non-security related functions. They can veto anything the UN wants to do in their country, because of their sovereignty, and they can refuse to pay their membership fees if they don't like what the UN does - like the US has done time and time again. But no member has a right to veto any non-security function in another country. That's simply not true. Also, you're using the concept of sovereignty in a muddled way: sovereignty is for a country to be free from foreign interference in its own matters. The UN doesn't 'pass acts' in any traditional sense of these words. It is not a legislature. If the US Congress passes acts, and you violate them, the US Government will send it's agents calling on your door and either force you to comply or put you in jail. The UN has no such agents. The UN member states can come together to make agreements, which any member state can then refuse to sign or ratify (as the US does time and time again). If the member state does not ratify the agreements, and so put them into domestic law through its domestic legislature, then these agreements don't have force of law in that country. That's part of what sovereignty means. The matters and institutions of the UN are not the sovereign purview of any state, so for one or more states not to be able to impose their will on the organizations of the UN - say, if they are unable to get UNESCO to fund a program in their country or to stop doing something in another country - is not a violation of their sovereignty. Quite obviously, in fact. As for the East Timorese - well if Portugal had done right by them it would have defended them, as it as responsable for their predicament, but since you asked I really think Rome should have called a Crusade and a Catholic army should have driven the Muslims it to the sea. The call of Rome is more Legetimate than anything the UN might say or not say. Enjoy fantasy, do we? Oh, how readily muslim Indonesia would have consented to the intervention of your fictitious Catholic army. Here's news for you: in the real world, people with secular power (unfortunately) don't seem to care much what the Catholic Church says. Who paid attention when the Holy Father denounced the invasion of Iraq? Certainly not Bush - not even Blair, who is married to a Catholic. At least they tried to make it look as if the Security Council was providing legitimacy for that war, but it was obvious how they could care less what the Church had to say. So good luck trying to get the Catholic Church to replace the UN. In this world, the UN would be replaced by anarchy and apathy, not the Catholic Church - however much I would prefer your fantasy scenario.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now