Don John of Austria Posted July 28, 2003 Posted July 28, 2003 You asked what I would have done with the East Timorize not what you thought was likely, I really don't give a rats arse what Islamic countries think as I said, Portugal should have steped up and gone to war for its former people, that being said the Church should have called a Crusade the fact that our pope( holy as he might be) is to much of a wuss to do so has nothing to do with wether or not it should be done. You see _bc this is our fundimentale problem you value peace, mans peace, --lack of war---- I don't care one ioda about peace, not mans peace anyway, Christ didn't come to bring peace as man knows it, but HIS Peace and that is all that I care about. If Catholics are being persecuted then we should crush those that are doing it, if that means distruction of a globilized economy Oh well, if that means countries are shattered, oh well, if that means solidify the muslim world into a Super power arrayed agianst the West, oh well, I place no value on stability, only on Christ and his Church, and his Church should defend its people. You asked what I would do I told you, if you want me to tell you what I think would have happened if the UN didn't exist but not what I think should have happened I will tell you, If you would like me to tell you what I think would have happened if the UN had done nothing I will tell yo that as well but I answered your question if you don't like the answer that is tough.
_bc Posted July 31, 2003 Posted July 31, 2003 You asked what I would have done with the East Timorize not what you thought was likely, I really don't give a rats arse what Islamic countries think as I said, Portugal should have steped up and gone to war for its former people, that being said the Church should have called a Crusade the fact that our pope( holy as he might be) is to much of a wuss to do so has nothing to do with wether or not it should be done. I'm sorry, I understood you to mean that you wanted the UN dismantled in this world, not some alternative world existing only in your head. That's why I was asking how you wanted to replace the functions of the UN in this, existing world, and hoped for an answer having something to do with reality. I apologize for misunderstanding your reply. And you're right about one thing: other things being equal, I prefer lack of war. The fifth commandment forbids the intentional destruction of human life. Because of the evils and injustices that accompany all WAR, the Church insistently urges everyone to prayer and to action so that the divine Goodness may free us from the ancient bondage of WAR.[Cf. GS 81 # 4.](My italics.)
Don John of Austria Posted August 1, 2003 Posted August 1, 2003 -bc first lets make somthing clear I don't acknowledge that the UN serves any useful function, the General Council is powerless and irrelevant, the Security council is Tyrranical and totally weighted to the preserval of the Statis Quo---I believe the Status Quo smells of elderberries therefore I see no Function that the UN fills which is meaningful enough to merit replacement certianly not require it. The World got along just fine without it for oh 6000 years of Civilization, and frankly was just as peaceful as it has been in the Last 60 years, so I see no need to replace it, I see many, many reasons to destroy it, starting with the fact that it funds sterilization and abortion, as well as legitimizes 5 countries running the world and crushing aqnyone who opposes them. And you're right about one thing: other things being equal, I prefer lack of war. Your problem here is other things are NEVER equal.
Winchester Posted August 1, 2003 Posted August 1, 2003 I'm sorry, I understood you to mean that you wanted the UN dismantled in this world, not some alternative world existing only in your head. That's why I was asking how you wanted to replace the functions of the UN in this, existing world, and hoped for an answer having something to do with reality. I apologize for misunderstanding your reply. That's hilarious. I had to laugh. I'm way closer to Don on this one. bc, War is quite often the only way, and I wonder what good things about the UN outweigh the bad.
Mary's Knight, La Posted August 3, 2003 Posted August 3, 2003 Don, Personally I think the UN has the capability of setting/enforcing moral standards (Human rights, etc...), Security functions aside, The problem with the UN isn't it's existence, rather it's a lack of morality in it. The UN cannot enforce correct views of right and wrong when it does not have them in the first place. As for the pope being too much a wuss i'm more inclined to believe that war usually causes more problems than it solves... regardless of whether or not it's the only way. As for good outweighing bad in the status quo, I don't think so. Let us instead though pray that those in power make the right decisions, don't forget in the bible it says follow civil authority except when it goes against the mandates of God because they were placed in their position by God. So let us pray that the people He has given us will do their job correctly.
Don John of Austria Posted August 4, 2003 Posted August 4, 2003 Mary's knight--- Well With out getting into the issue of following civil authorities in general--THe UN does not qualify, furthermore many of the UN's policies violate the Mandates of God. Finally and most importantly the UN violates the Soveriegn Power of Nations, in its nature, it does this so it in and of itself violates the Very mandate of which you are speaking.. I don't understand this ---"As for good outweighing bad in the status quo, I don't think so." Are you agreeing with me?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now