toledo_jesus Posted March 21, 2005 Posted March 21, 2005 By Thomas Wenski | Special to the Sentinel Posted March 20, 2005 On Friday, the feeding tube that provided Terri Schiavo with the normal care of food and water was withdrawn. Barring last-minute intervention, Terri has now begun to die by starvation. One can pray that her husband will have a change of heart or that the state of Florida will find new grounds to intervene so that, in spite of what transpired on Friday, a safer course might still be taken and that Terri "continue to receive nourishment, comfort and loving care" -- as we Catholic Bishops of Florida have continually advocated. As Pope John Paul II points out in his just released book, Memory and Identity, the crisis of our age is rooted in the presumption that we can decide for ourselves what is good and evil without reference to God. Yet, the Decalogue, while certainly an expression of divine positive law, is nonetheless more than a religious code: It is a reflection of natural law -- of the law written on the heart of man. In other words, we cannot not know that it is wrong to kill innocent human life. That we do nevertheless kill is evidence of the misterium iniquitatis at work in the world; but, when we do kill, we usually seek by evasions and subterfuges to make up excuses for our crimes. Thus, we disguise what we do by rationalizations: We don't abort "babies," we remove the "products of conception"; we don't murder unarmed civilians, we engage in "ethnic cleansing"; and when we dispatch with a fatal cocktail the feeble minded it is because such a life is lebensunwerter Leben (life "unworthy of life") -- as euthanasia was justified in the Germany of the Third Reich. In Terri's case, we can speak of the controversial diagnosis of PVS -- persistent vegetative state. Yet, even while to speak of her as a "vegetable" might give a false reassurance to our conflicted consciences, she still remains a human being, no less human than Christopher Reeve, who was kept alive on a respirator until he died late last year of natural causes. No one begrudged his heroic struggle to live, and we were all edified by his courage and that of his family who stood by him. Terri, however, is not being kept alive by any machine as was Reeve for most of his last decade of life. She only needs assistance to be fed. Does the fact that he could speak and she cannot make it right to deprive her of the ordinary means of human sustenance? If so, how can any of our seriously ill brethren ever again trust themselves to sleep while under a doctor's care? Some would argue that to remove her feeding tube is simply to let nature take its course. Yet what is "natural" about starving to death? True, she was fed through a feeding tube -- she depends on others, but so did Christopher Reeve, and so does a newborn baby depend on others for nutrition and hydration. John Donne said: "No man is an island entire of itself". As members of the human race we all are interdependent on each other to one degree or another. The mark of a civilized society was that the helpless had the greatest claim on our protection. Now it would seem that they have the least. And so, Holy Week, the annual remembrance of Jesus' passion and death, begins with the Passion of Terri Schiavo. Terri's agony has already begun and, barring some miracle, the denouement of Terri's drama will be her death. This week, in recalling Jesus' Passover from death to life, we celebrate the fact that the misterium iniquitatis is overcome through the misterium crucis. From the cross Jesus cried out, and his cry is echoed today by all those held captive to a world of pain and sin. As Terri shares in his passion, she will share in his Resurrection. Like Jesus did, Terri Schiavo cries out, though with muted voice: "I thirst!" Thomas Wenski is the bishop of the Diocese of Orlando. He wrote this commentary for the Orlando Sentinel.
Lil Red Posted March 21, 2005 Posted March 21, 2005 [quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 21 2005, 01:16 PM'] In Terri's case, we can speak of the controversial diagnosis of PVS -- persistent vegetative state. Yet, even while to speak of her as a "vegetable" might give a false reassurance to our conflicted consciences, she still remains a human being,[b] no less human than Christopher Reeve, who was kept alive on a respirator until he died late last year of natural causes. No one begrudged his heroic struggle to live, and we were all edified by his courage and that of his family who stood by him. [/b]Terri, however, is not being kept alive by any machine as was Reeve for most of his last decade of life. She only needs assistance to be fed. [b]Does the fact that he could speak and she cannot make it right to deprive her of the ordinary means of human sustenance?[/b] If so, how can any of our seriously ill brethren ever again trust themselves to sleep while under a doctor's care? [/quote] you know, i never thought about this connection....
StPiusVPrayForUs Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 Bishop Wenski? This is the same guy who said no to pro-abortion politicians on various media spots. The day before the election, John Kerry to Orlando had basically a photo opportunity with the curia and school at that particular parish (St. John Vianey). What did Bishop Wenski do to the priests? Scold them? Discipline them? No! One became his Director of Vocations (Fr. Gonzalez) and the other Vicar for Priests (Fr. Henry, Pastor). They got a promotion! Bishop Wenski's words are worthless given his past actions. His words shouldn't be trusted as sincere.
Guest Eremite Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote]His words shouldn't be trusted as sincere.[/quote] No. We should rain down anathemas on a Bishop for expressing pro-life thoughts. That is what True Faithful Catholics [TM] who don't rep the Church do.
StPiusVPrayForUs Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 (edited) You don't! You know the clergy by their fruit and this bishop is dangering the faithful in Orlando with SCANDAL such as the activity I mentioned above. There is what the bishop says and then what he does afterwords when people don't know much about since it's not in the media. But if one does their research, they find that all is not well. Before you apologize for the scandal a Bishop is doing, remember the words of the great Church doctor, St. John Chrysostom; "The floor of hell is paved with the skulls of bishops!" Edited March 22, 2005 by StPiusVPrayForUs
Guest Eremite Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote]Before you apologize for the scandal a Bishop is doing, remember the words of the great Church doctor, St. John Chrysostom; "The floor of hell is paved with the skulls of bishops!"[/quote] Perhaps you can provide a citation for that quote? I CAN provide a citation from a more relevant quote, that of Pope Leo XIII in his Encyclical Letter "Sapientiae Christianae": [quote]Among the prelates, indeed, one or other there may be affording scope to criticism either in regard to personal conduct or in reference to opinions by him entertained about points of doctrine; but no private person may arrogate to himself the office of judge which Christ our Lord has bestowed on that one alone whom He placed in charge of His lambs and of His sheep. Let every one bear in mind that most wise teaching of Gregory the Great: 'Subjects should be admonished not rashly to judge their prelates, even if they chance to see them acting in a blameworthy manner, lest, justly reproving what is wrong, they be led by pride into greater wrong. They are to be warned against the danger of setting themselves up in audacious opposition to the superiors whose shortcomings they may notice. Should, therefore, the superiors really have committed grievous sins, their inferiors, penetrated with the fear of God, ought not to refuse them respectful submission. The actions of superiors should not be smitten by the sword of the word, even when they are rightly judged to have deserved censure.'[/quote]
StPiusVPrayForUs Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 KERRY TAKES COMMUNION DURING VISIT TO ORLANDO SOME SAY HE SHOULD NOT RECEIVE THE SACRAMENT BECAUSE HE BACKS ABORTION RIGHTS. Orlando Sentinel, The (FL) November 3, 2004 Author: Mark I. Pinsky, Sentinel Staff Writer Estimated printed pages: 2 Despite opposition from some Roman Catholic bishops across the country, and from Coadjutor Bishop Thomas Wenski of Orlando, Sen. John Kerry received Holy Communion at St. John Vianney Catholic Church on Monday. The official press pool accompanying Kerry, a Catholic who has supported abortion rights, confirmed that the Democratic candidate received the sacrament during a morning service celebrating the Feast of All Saints. With Vatican support, bishops in St. Louis and Colorado have said they would not permit Kerry to receive Communion in their dioceses. Archbishop Sean O'Malley of Boston has said Catholics such as Kerry who do not support the church's position on abortion should not request the sacrament. When Kerry is at home in Massachusetts, he does not worship at one of the parish churches in the archdiocese of Boston. Instead, he receives Communion at a worship center in his Beacon Hill neighborhood led by the Paulist Order of priests. The Diocese of Orlando had no comment on Kerry's Communion. However, in a May 11 column in the Orlando Sentinel, Wenski wrote: "Pro-abortion politicians who insist on calling themselves Catholics without seeing the contradiction between what they say they believe and their anti-life stance" should change their views "before they approach the Eucharistic table." The Rev. Paul Henry of St. John Vianney, who celebrated the Mass on Monday, would neither confirm nor deny that he had served Communion to Kerry. "It's not a matter of public discussion," he said Tuesday. The Kerry campaign asked for permission to attend the scheduled Mass. "We indicated that he would be welcome to attend," Henry said. "He is Catholic, and all are welcome to celebrate the feast. Mass is not the moment to make judgments about where people are in their spiritual lives." Memo: Mark I. Pinsky can be reached at mpinsky@orlandosentinel.com or 407-420-5589. Edition: FINAL Section: A SECTION Page: A14 Appointments of the Fathers are found at: [url="http://www.orlandodiocese.org/clergy_religious/official_appointments/official_appointments.htm"]http://www.orlandodiocese.org/clergy_relig...ppointments.htm[/url] Please note, the article above is very very limited in reporting the details.
Guest Eremite Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 What's your point? Perhaps you missed the exhortation of Pope Leo XIII: [quote]Among the prelates, indeed, one or other there may be affording scope to criticism either in regard to personal conduct or in reference to opinions by him entertained about points of doctrine; but no private person may arrogate to himself the office of judge which Christ our Lord has bestowed on that one alone whom He placed in charge of His lambs and of His sheep. Let every one bear in mind that most wise teaching of Gregory the Great: 'Subjects should be admonished not rashly to judge their prelates, even if they chance to see them acting in a blameworthy manner, lest, justly reproving what is wrong, they be led by pride into greater wrong. They are to be warned against the danger of setting themselves up in audacious opposition to the superiors whose shortcomings they may notice. Should, therefore, the superiors really have committed grievous sins, their inferiors, penetrated with the fear of God, ought not to refuse them respectful submission. The actions of superiors should not be smitten by the sword of the word, even when they are rightly judged to have deserved censure.'[/quote]
StPiusVPrayForUs Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 Regarding true obiediance, you might want to dust off your Bible and check Galatians 1:8-9, Galatians 2:11-14, Acts 5:29. There are limits to obiediance. You are advocating error by excess. Basically, "I may never criticize any superior under any circumstances." "Where there is a proximate danger to the faith, prelates must be rebuked, even publicly, by subjects. Thus, St. Paul, who was subject to St. Peter, rebuked him publicly." -St. Thomas Aquinas "All disciplinary authority, all obedience to a bishop presupposes the pure teaching of the Holy Church. Obedience to the bishop is grounded in complete faith in the teaching of the Holy Church. As soon as the ecclesiastical authority yields to pluralism in questions of faith, it has lost the right to claim obedience to its disciplinary ordinances." - Professor Dietrich von Hildebrand
Guest Eremite Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote]You are advocating error by excess. Basically, "I may never criticize any superior under any circumstances."[/quote] Take it up with Pope Leo XIII. Oh yah, I forgot, you don't rep the Church.
Brother Adam Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 (edited) To everyone who may need to hear it: If you can't exercise charity, any point you try to make is thrown out the window with your witness. No one cares to listen to someone, must less consider what they may have to say if that person can't get the very basics of Christian virtue down. Edited March 22, 2005 by Brother Adam
StPiusVPrayForUs Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 (edited) [quote name='Eremite' date='Mar 21 2005, 11:08 PM'] Take it up with Pope Leo XIII. Oh yah, I forgot, you don't rep the Church. [/quote] Whatever you say. I'm sure St. Paul, St. Pius X, St. Athanasius, and others would have a good talking to you folks. Edited March 22, 2005 by StPiusVPrayForUs
Guest Eremite Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote]I'm sure St. Paul, St. Pius X, St. Athanasius, and others would have a good talking to you folks.[/quote] They'd love to talk to us. They repped the Church, just like us. Unlike some people I know....
toledo_jesus Posted March 22, 2005 Author Posted March 22, 2005 [quote name='StPiusVPrayForUs' date='Mar 21 2005, 11:35 PM'] Bishop Wenski? This is the same guy who said no to pro-abortion politicians on various media spots. The day before the election, John Kerry to Orlando had basically a photo opportunity with the curia and school at that particular parish (St. John Vianey). What did Bishop Wenski do to the priests? Scold them? Discipline them? No! One became his Director of Vocations (Fr. Gonzalez) and the other Vicar for Priests (Fr. Henry, Pastor). They got a promotion! Bishop Wenski's words are worthless given his past actions. His words shouldn't be trusted as sincere. [/quote] listen man, take what you can get. It's a sad reality that in the past most bishops haven't been saints. That hasn't changed. And it's also a sad reality that today the number of priests is not so large, and the number of priests qualified for a particular job is even smaller. He's right in this matter. He's still got authority. If you want everything to be perfect then wait til you go to Heaven.
StPiusVPrayForUs Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 So, are you advocating that priests should disobey their bishops orders by allowing pro-abortionists to receive the Holy Eucharist? I'm not the one being discobiediant here in this case. You folks should take a look at the facts before you start praising others who have lost credibility. Let it be known I praised the Bishop and a local priest in the very same newspaper a few months before this scandal broke. I still stand together with this particar priest, but the bishop has some credibility issues (like it or not) and we will see how this latest fruit turns out.
toledo_jesus Posted March 22, 2005 Author Posted March 22, 2005 [quote name='StPiusVPrayForUs' date='Mar 22 2005, 12:20 AM'] So, are you advocating that priests should disobey their bishops orders by allowing pro-abortionists to receive the Holy Eucharist? I'm not the one being discobiediant here in this case. You folks should take a look at the facts before you start praising others who have lost credibility. Let it be known I praised the Bishop and a local priest in the very same newspaper a few months before this scandal broke. I still stand together with this particar priest, but the bishop has some credibility issues (like it or not) and we will see how this latest fruit turns out. [/quote] I don't dispute that bishops can be in error, but the average layman doesn't care or know about that. I just think we should be thankful they at least said something pro-life that Catholics would see coming from their bishop. Can you agree with that?
cmotherofpirl Posted March 23, 2005 Posted March 23, 2005 [quote name='StPiusVPrayForUs' date='Mar 22 2005, 01:20 AM'] So, are you advocating that priests should disobey their bishops orders by allowing pro-abortionists to receive the Holy Eucharist? I'm not the one being discobiediant here in this case. You folks should take a look at the facts before you start praising others who have lost credibility. Let it be known I praised the Bishop and a local priest in the very same newspaper a few months before this scandal broke. I still stand together with this particar priest, but the bishop has some credibility issues (like it or not) and we will see how this latest fruit turns out. [/quote] This is not the subject of this thread, and this is not the debate board. Back to topic please.
Theoketos Posted March 23, 2005 Posted March 23, 2005 (edited) [quote name='StPiusVPrayForUs' date='Mar 21 2005, 10:35 PM'] His words shouldn't be trusted as sincere. [/quote] This is extra not good for you to say this. But to get back on topic, I am pleased with the current statement from the Bishop. I pray that it will move the hearts of people. Also, I pray that human life will be defended. I honestly think that most people do not understand that Terri is alive, and if they did, they would support our cause. Edited March 23, 2005 by Theoketos
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now