Didacus Posted April 8, 2010 Posted April 8, 2010 [quote name='StPiusVPrayForUs' date='22 March 2005 - 12:03 AM' timestamp='1111464205' post='552143'] Regarding true obiediance, you might want to dust off your Bible and check Galatians 1:8-9, Galatians 2:11-14, Acts 5:29. There are limits to obiediance. You are advocating error by excess. Basically, "I may never criticize any superior under any circumstances." "Where there is a proximate danger to the faith, prelates must be rebuked, even publicly, by subjects. Thus, St. Paul, who was subject to St. Peter, rebuked him publicly." -St. Thomas Aquinas "All disciplinary authority, all obedience to a bishop presupposes the pure teaching of the Holy Church. Obedience to the bishop is grounded in complete faith in the teaching of the Holy Church. As soon as the ecclesiastical authority yields to pluralism in questions of faith, it has lost the right to claim obedience to its disciplinary ordinances." - Professor Dietrich von Hildebrand [/quote] Great quotes! And yes, I will look up those bible references... Back to you Bob...
Ed Normile Posted April 8, 2010 Posted April 8, 2010 As this started out as a Terry Schiavo topic, I se this was posted back in 2005, I have to share some things I seen while being in the Orlando diocese at that time. They had a video supplied by her parents of an awake and communicative Terry Schiavo responding to her mothers presence with and angelic smile and a nod of approval when she asked her questions. Her mother asked her if she wanted her hair combed, and she smiled and shook her head to reply yes, she smiled when her mother came into the room. It was heartbreaking to see, meanwhile the bulk of the news media played pity pieces showing her husband with his new grilfriend, which he took up residence with, and their plight of how he could not legally marry the new girlfriend until his wife was declared dead, nor could he collect on his insurance policy, which he needed to pay expenses with. I grew to hate the sight of this man, not a very comfortable thing to have to deal with, I prayed for this woman every time I thought about her, which was many times each day, there were members of every faith with bumper stickers and people with signs and it was a constant debate on the radio. It was depressing, enraging, and it ended with such a terrible let down, the forced starvation of a woman, Jeb Bush tried to intervene as did President Bush and a local, liberal judge over ruled both the governor of Florida, Jeb Bush, and the President. I felt betrayed, I felt overwhelmed and helpless, I wanted to hug her mother and father, I wanted to stomp her husbands face in. I asked God how he could allow this to happen, I asked him if there was a reason this woman had too suffer could he let me in on it as I was so depressed it was affecting my ability to be positive about nearly anything. There was all the stories from her mother of the abusiveness of her husband, how, when emergency services responded and found her unresponsive they reported signs of strangulation present on the woman, how he had taken out a large life insurance policy on her, nurses who came forward and stated the signs of abuse present on her body, how he claimed she was accident prone, nobody was able to help this woman, all the prayers and thousands who would show up publicly to support her parents at court and at public rallies. I felt as if the devil was at work in Florida, I still feel that was the case. ed
Bennn Posted April 8, 2010 Posted April 8, 2010 Regardless of what this Bishop may have done in the past, his letter from the first post of this thread can inspire those who support murder to repentance.
CatherineM Posted April 8, 2010 Posted April 8, 2010 I was also in Florida when this was going on, in St. Pete where she was, not Orlando. There were very good reasons our Bishop didn't intervene in the way some people believed he should. I do not believe anyone should be denied basic food and water, however, I don't think we do a pro-life issue any good by over looking facts. First and foremost this case was about money, lots of it. Second, Terri was severely brain damaged. Her family wanted to believe otherwise. The autopsy report was very telling on her actual cognitive abilities, namely she was completely blind, and half of her brain was gone. Her family wanted to believe she was responding to things, and in the same situation, I would probably want to believe that as well. What we should take from this case is that the most loving thing you can do for the people in your life that love and care about is to have your affairs in order, even if you think you are too young to become disabled or die. Terri deserved dignity in her life, and in her death. Had she had a basic durable power of attorney or living will, her last days could have been quiet and peaceful instead of a circus. I mean circus in a very literal sense. There was a tent city outside the hospice that had jugglers and street performers and merchants. It was so overflowing that the city had to move the kids who went to the elementary school across the street to another school until it was over. I cried for the family members of the other residents at the hospice who had to go through metal detectors and pat downs to see their dying relatives.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 8, 2010 Posted April 8, 2010 [quote name='CatherineM' date='08 April 2010 - 11:17 AM' timestamp='1270736274' post='2089175'] I was also in Florida when this was going on, in St. Pete where she was, not Orlando. There were very good reasons our Bishop didn't intervene in the way some people believed he should. I do not believe anyone should be denied basic food and water, however, I don't think we do a pro-life issue any good by over looking facts. First and foremost this case was about money, lots of it. Second, Terri was severely brain damaged. Her family wanted to believe otherwise. The autopsy report was very telling on her actual cognitive abilities, namely she was completely blind, and half of her brain was gone. Her family wanted to believe she was responding to things, and in the same situation, I would probably want to believe that as well. [/quote] I somehow doubt the videos were faked. I wouldn't put too much faith in the medical exams report, after all she was starved to death, and I have seen brains scans of people with mostly missing brains who functioned normally, and many people who are legally blind can still see movement. No one is claiming she was deaf, and many people respond to the sound of a loved -one's voice when you think they cannot.
CatherineM Posted April 8, 2010 Posted April 8, 2010 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='08 April 2010 - 11:58 AM' timestamp='1270745888' post='2089260'] I somehow doubt the videos were faked. I wouldn't put too much faith in the medical exams report, after all she was starved to death, and I have seen brains scans of people with mostly missing brains who functioned normally, and many people who are legally blind can still see movement. No one is claiming she was deaf, and many people respond to the sound of a loved -one's voice when you think they cannot. [/quote] I didn't mean to imply that I thought the videos were faked. I just think that when dealing with a severely disabled loved one, we can hope to see things that aren't there. To be honest, I never watched the videos when they would play on TV. I considered it a violation of Terri's privacy.
Ed Normile Posted April 9, 2010 Posted April 9, 2010 [quote name='CatherineM' date='08 April 2010 - 09:17 AM' timestamp='1270736274' post='2089175']<br />I was also in Florida when this was going on, in St. Pete where she was, not Orlando. There were very good reasons our Bishop didn't intervene in the way some people believed he should. I do not believe anyone should be denied basic food and water, however, I don't think we do a pro-life issue any good by over looking facts. First and foremost this case was about money, lots of it. Second, Terri was severely brain damaged. Her family wanted to believe otherwise. The autopsy report was very telling on her actual cognitive abilities, namely she was completely blind, and half of her brain was gone. Her family wanted to believe she was responding to things, and in the same situation, I would probably want to believe that as well. <br /><br />What we should take from this case is that the most loving thing you can do for the people in your life that love and care about is to have your affairs in order, even if you think you are too young to become disabled or die. Terri deserved dignity in her life, and in her death. Had she had a basic durable power of attorney or living will, her last days could have been quiet and peaceful instead of a circus. I mean circus in a very literal sense. There was a tent city outside the hospice that had jugglers and street performers and merchants. It was so overflowing that the city had to move the kids who went to the elementary school across the street to another school until it was over. I cried for the family members of the other residents at the hospice who had to go through metal detectors and pat downs to see their dying relatives.<br />[/quote]<br /><br /><br /> A neice of mine was suffering from severe grand maul seizures, so bad that she would break bones from the seizures and almost bit her tongue off, she was severely affected by this condition. The doctors chose to remove "Half Her Brain" the side that was causing the seizures, and she now lives a very normal life and is free of seizures, you see your brain can relearn everything if given time to heal, she is healthy and goes to a regular school and is doing very well, all with half a brain, literally. This is a fairly common procedure for children who suffer from this affliction. Her doctors in reality chose life for her, Terry Schiavo was not as fortunate. ed
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now