Lil Red Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 the thing i always wonder about is that do people really feel justice has been served when the murderer of their loved one is executed? i can't imagine it...
MagiDragon Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote name='Lil Red' date='Mar 21 2005, 10:57 PM'] the thing i always wonder about is that do people really feel justice has been served when the murderer of their loved one is executed? i can't imagine it... [/quote] well . . . technically it is a just execution . . . but . . . yeah, i've wondered the same thing. I mean . . . basically you're just allowing the murderer to have control over your whole family when you thirst for vengeance.
Lil Red Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 well, personally speaking, if someone murdered someone i love (hubby, parents, siblings) i would want them to do hard labor until they die naturally than let them get a "get out of jail free card" by getting executed.
Phazzan Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote name='Lil Red' date='Mar 21 2005, 11:16 PM'] well, personally speaking, if someone murdered someone i love (hubby, parents, siblings) i would want them to do hard labor until they die naturally than let them get a "get out of jail free card" by getting executed. [/quote] Actually, many prisoners embrace prison life. Of course, they have lost their freedom, but prison life can actually be appealing to some. Many who have spent most of their lives in prison are released back into society and don't like it so they break their parole and go back in jail. And often, prison involves anything but doing hard labour.
Phazzan Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote name='MagiDragon' date='Mar 21 2005, 11:06 PM'] well . . . technically it is a just execution . . . but . . . yeah, i've wondered the same thing. I mean . . . basically you're just allowing the murderer to have control over your whole family when you thirst for vengeance. [/quote] If someone murders your family, you would want retribution for that crime. Just because you would want that person to pay the ultimate penalty for what they did doesn't mean you want bloodthirsty revenge.
Lil Red Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote name='Phazzan' date='Mar 21 2005, 09:44 PM'] Actually, many prisoners embrace prison life. Of course, they have lost their freedom, but prison life can actually be appealing to some. Many who have spent most of their lives in prison are released back into society and don't like it so they break their parole and go back in jail. And often, prison involves anything but doing hard labour. [/quote] well, that's why i want to go to a system that requires it ya, i know, wishful thinking
Guest Eremite Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 A man gets a last meal (whatever he wants), is walked down a hallway, gently injected with drugs, and goes to sleep. Some retribution.
Aloysius Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 precisely, this is not revenge- this is giving to him what by the natural law is DUE to him. whosoever shed a man's blood by man shall his blood be shed. this is not about making him suffer or anything, this is giving him what is due to him. you have just proven the point that this is not some big revenge thing, which when analyzing this from a Catholic point of view is actually a PLUS for the death penalty. many a man has been brought to repentence when facing death. The Church has long held it as extremely virtuous to repent and accept the execution that you deserve for the crime you committed. the death penalty has probably brought more people to conversion than life imprisonment. anyway, I see a big contradiction in the anti-dp ideas. On one hand you say that it's so bad because we're seeking revenge. then you're saying the revenge isn't enough. we are ending the person's life. it is more vengeful to want them to suffer than to civilly separate their body from the soul and commend them to God's Justice.
jiyoung Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 as far as politics goes--it costs less to keep someone in life imprisonment than it does to use the death penalty. and the whole thing with the prisoners "liking" prison life--it's not that they like it, but it's like i think plato's cave--people want to go back to what they're used to because the dangers are familiar, and so will forsake the sunlight, which is the unknown, for the darkness, which is familiar to them. the criminals know how prison works; they might've been out of society for so long that they're completely unfamiliar with it. on the one hand...since it's justified killing i'm not against it. however, first of all there's the off chance that one might repent and do good in their lives (case in point: st. alejandro, who was st maria goretti's murderer/rapist). there's the fact that a lot of times people on death row are wrongly convicted--why take that chance? and also, like i said the fact that death penalty costs more...i think DP should only be used when absolutely necessary--when someone is such a menace to society that keeping him locked up would do virtually nothing.
MagiDragon Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote name='Phazzan' date='Mar 21 2005, 11:47 PM'] If someone murders your family, you would want retribution for that crime. Just because you would want that person to pay the ultimate penalty for what they did doesn't mean you want bloodthirsty revenge. [/quote] Actually, i think that's exactly what it means, since you put is so succinctly. I wouldn't *want* a person who had killed my loved one to die . . . but if they were a threat to others then i would want the to defused . . . which could well mean execution. Peace, Joe
Ash Wednesday Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote name='Eremite' date='Mar 21 2005, 10:20 PM'] I think the Bishops have been very vocal in their opposition to abortion. See, for example, their document "Living the Gospel of Life" [/quote] Thanks for pointing that out, Eremite. I guess I was thinking of bishops that were fudging on the whole Kerry issue (i.e. Catholics "voting their 'conscience'") that had my hackles up... Or maybe I was thinking of Catholics that have no problem opposing DP but not abortion... never mind...
Ash Wednesday Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 After 9/11 I know a lot of people wanted to see any radical islamo-fascist terrorists especially related to the attacks dead -- I for one wonder if it would not be better to just make them share a pen with a pig or two since they apparently would find that appalling? They would want to "die" for their "cause" anyway so why grant them that? Here piggy piggy piggy! Soooeeee?
Paphnutius Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 I posted this on the debate board but here it is again: "Forgiveness is giving up your right to see justice enacted." As far as I know, the lex talonis (eye for an eye) was fulfilled when Christ said love your enemy. No moral arguement here, just some thoughts to reflect on...
Carnanc Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 it is a question of prudence. Yes, the death penalty is a just punishment, but prudence asks the question, is it a necessary punishment. In the United States, where we have the ability to put people in prison where they will not harm society, the death penalty is rarely if ever needed. from the Catachism- 2266 The efforts of the state to curb the spread of behavior harmful to people's rights and to the basic rules of civil society correspond to the requirement of safeguarding the common good. Legitimate public authority has the right and duty to inflict punishment proportionate to the gravity of the offense. Punishment has the primary aim of redressing the disorder introduced by the offense. When it is willingly accepted by the guilty party, it assumes the value of expiation. Punishment then, in addition to defending public order and protecting people's safety, has a medicinal purpose: as far as possible, it must contribute to the correction of the guilty party.67 2267 Assuming that the guilty party's identity and responsibility have been fully determined, the traditional teaching of [b]the Church does not exclude recourse to the death penalty[/b], if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor. If, however, non-lethal means are sufficient to defend and protect people's safety from the aggressor, authority will limit itself to such means, as these are more in keeping with the concrete conditions of the common good and more in conformity to the dignity of the human person. Today, in fact, as a consequence of the possibilities which the state has for effectively preventing crime, by rendering one who has committed an offense incapable of doing harm - without definitely taking away from him the possibility of redeeming himself -[b] the cases in which the execution of the offender is an absolute necessity "are very rare, if not practically nonexistent."68[/b]
myduwigd Posted March 22, 2005 Author Posted March 22, 2005 (edited) Ive heardmost people on row are proved inoocent after being killed. Have any of you guys seen Man Walking? Edited March 22, 2005 by myduwigd
Guest Eremite Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 I haven't seen Dead Man Walking, but I've seen the nun who it's based on get interviewed on Fox. She's a feisty one, lol.
Iacobus Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 (edited) [quote name='Lil Red' date='Mar 21 2005, 10:27 PM'] oh whatever. i bolded the part that is important to me. you bolded the part important to you. don't lash out at me because they weren't the same thing. either all or none? gimme a break i can't be responsible for what people choose to read...if they choose to read just the bolded parts or not. [/quote] I wasn't lashing out at you. When I lash out at people I call them thinks like "stupid head (ask Voici when she get back on in Easter)." I didn't lash out at you. I liked that you posted the CCC thing, but when you bold one part it seems, to many people, to give it a sense of "importance." That is why newspapers bold headlines, text books bold key words, etc. It is just something that happens. I disagree with just bolding the part saying it is allowed but not bolding the later part about when it is to be used, a clearification of the first clause. That is just my two cents. myduwigd, I don't know about MOST being cleared of the crime, but a significant number are found to be cleared. My state, IL, has communtied all DPs to life in prison when they found some large number (I want to say 13%, but I am really not sure) were not guilty. What happened in most cases were overzealous DA's wanting to make names for themsevles that withheld importance, clearing, edvandence (sp?). A lot of DNA was withheld and the cops actions after the arrest were "questionable." Edited March 22, 2005 by Iacobus
Lil Red Posted March 22, 2005 Posted March 22, 2005 [quote name='Iacobus' date='Mar 22 2005, 04:17 PM'] I wasn't lashing out at you. When I lash out at people I call them thinks like "stupid head (ask Voici when she get back on in Easter)." I didn't lash out at you. I liked that you posted the CCC thing, but when you bold one part it seems, to many people, to give it a sense of "importance." That is why newspapers bold headlines, text books bold key words, etc. It is just something that happens. I disagree with just bolding the part saying it is allowed but not bolding the later part about when it is to be used, a clearification of the first clause. That is just my two cents. [/quote] i understand your view...i may disagree, but i understand
Iacobus Posted March 23, 2005 Posted March 23, 2005 [quote name='Lil Red' date='Mar 22 2005, 06:34 PM'] i understand your view...i may disagree, but i understand [/quote] It isn't nice to stick your tounge out at people or point with anything sharper than an elbow, silly. *Points elbow at screen saying, "She isn't nice"*
jmjtina Posted March 23, 2005 Posted March 23, 2005 Abortion and the death penalty are not the same. When people compare them, they usually throw the baby out with the bathwater.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now