Micheal5403 Posted March 23, 2005 Posted March 23, 2005 People have stated earlier that the death penalty is more expensive that life in prison, but i'll give you some numbers: (since I just did a research paper on capital punishment) In NC it costs approximately 2.16 million dollars more for death penalty cases than for non-death penalty cases. Also, some people have given reasons why the death penalty is not wrong, but can anyone give a practical reason for how the death penalty is positive? And just to let you know, one of my major pet peeves is when people bring abortion into every debate. If the question doesn't involve abortion, don't add abortion to your reply. I don't care if you think it is a good example.
cmotherofpirl Posted March 23, 2005 Posted March 23, 2005 (edited) Abortion always murders the innocent. The Death Penalty, properly applied, excutes the guilty. Big difference. Deliberately murdering another means your own life is forfeit. Edited March 23, 2005 by cmotherofpirl
myduwigd Posted March 23, 2005 Author Posted March 23, 2005 [quote name='Micheal5403' date='Mar 22 2005, 11:27 PM'] And just to let you know, one of my major pet peeves is when people bring abortion into every debate. If the question doesn't involve abortion, don't add abortion to your reply. I don't care if you think it is a good example. [/quote] Why I bring it up is because I think that one cannot claim that you are pro life and not have a problem with the penalty also...I think it applies to my point.
argent_paladin Posted March 23, 2005 Posted March 23, 2005 We shouldn't kid ourselves that the death penalty is the only form of "revenge" and all other punishment is not. Why do people want to make sure that prisons are not pleasant places? It is because they want it to be *punishment* and not mere protection of society. So, no tvs, weight rooms, conjugal visits, no voting, internet, etc. And, yes, execution won't bring a loved one back, but neither will life in prison. If killing to show that killing is wrong is stupid, then you have to show why imprisoning someone for imprisoning someone isn't wrong. Any argument you make against the death penalty, also has to allow for prison. I am against the death penalty because it is already rare (only 50 executions last year), arbitrary (Texas and Virgina execute half), expensive (California has spent approximately $1 billion per executed inmate above the life-in-prison expense), racist and biased against the poor, and permanent (if errors occur, they cannot be corrected). Retribution is at the heart of justice and cannot be ignored. Justice is giving people what they deserve and someone who violates the law deserves punishment. We must be careful that our desire for mercy does not create greater injustice. I disagree also that abortion has much to do with the death penalty, de facto or de jure. In fact, most people who are against the death penalty are in favor of abortion and most people who are against abortion are in favor of the death penalty (until very recently). Direct abortion is an intrinsically immoral activity. The death penalty is not (it depends on the circumstances). Abortion kills about 1.5 million a year in the US. The death penalty killed 50. Abortion kills the wholly innocent, in the sanctuary of their mothers' wombs, causing their own mothers to cooperate in the murder of their own child, about the worst crime imaginable. The death penalty kills someone who has committed terrible crimes, has exhausted all appeals, has lived off the government for decades and who has the opportunity to recieve education, medical care and spiritual comfort. Executions took place in Vatican City until the early 20th century. Abortions have never taken place there. The decision as to whether the death penalty is appropriate ultimately rests with the government. That is not true of abortion. Support for the death penalty has ranged from fervent to lukewarm in the Church's history. The Church has always and everywhere condemned abortion.
StPiusVPrayForUs Posted March 23, 2005 Posted March 23, 2005 (edited) [color=red] nope [/color] A true work on what Holy Mother Church teaches about the death penalty. Edited March 24, 2005 by cmotherofpirl
Micheal5403 Posted March 24, 2005 Posted March 24, 2005 (edited) [quote]Why I bring it up is because I think that one cannot claim that you are pro life and not have a problem with the penalty also...I think it applies to my point. [/quote] It does in a way, but the argument about abortion can have so many different views that, in the end, the argument doesn't help. people will just say that, "abortion is always evil, but this '[i]Topic[/i]' is not always wrong." do you understand my point? Edited March 24, 2005 by Micheal5403
Aloysius Posted March 24, 2005 Posted March 24, 2005 St. Pius V pray for us indeed... pray that SCHISMATICS who blatantly, irreverently, and disrespecfully label the Vicar of Christ on Earth an antipope without valid reason (for he was validly elected by the Cardinals who are the successors to the Apostles) will either enter the Church and help her out or die off so that there is not such a nuissance. oh, btw, I agree with everything except the antipope carp in the artical and it is a good exposition on the actual Catholic stance on the death penalty. but I am sure the link will be deleted and I absolutely detest the disobedient attitude that causes one to fall into heretical sedevantacism.
Aloysius Posted March 24, 2005 Posted March 24, 2005 oh how I lament when I read through that website that alot of that Catholic Insight is not being shared WITHIN THE CATHOLIC CHURCH! Latin, Mary, Judaism... if only it wasn't schismatic and sedevanticist.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now