Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Storm before the Calm


Recommended Posts

DemonSlayer
Posted

[quote name='myduwigd' date='Apr 21 2005, 12:16 PM'] ok, wow I love how no one is listening to me at all. Im not attacking him, IM just saying that he looks scary. Also, this man used to be a Nazi. No, he is not beyond redemption for that fact, but he should never be in a position of spiritual authority. There are some things that a person just simply cannot do and recover from. It would take the rest of one's life to be healed and fight the consequences. [/quote]
Apart from Hitler Youth membership being compulsory, when he tried to leave, he risked death.

Posted (edited)

Im not gonna argue about this anymore because no one is giving me the time of day. But I am gonna say something: Satan is not speaking through me, dont you dare accuse me of that. I dont claim to speak for God, but I am not speaking for Satan. It is very unwise to accuse me of that since it is untrue. Honestly, I dont think that would please God very much.
Also, I am not against the Pope because of the dark circles around his eyes. I actually look at his eyes, and those are creepy. Eyes are windows into one's soul and if your observant you can see that I make a good point.
I will go and read what he has written and if you are willing to listen to me after I read them I will come and state my opinion.
Also, he was a former Nazi; Im a psych major when you teach a child or young teen to live that way it has lasting effects on their psyche. Im seriously worried about this man. I have no intention on bashing him or mocking and rediculing him. There is nothing wrong with stating my opinion. AM i not allowed to dislike the Pope?
I do not give into media lies. I form a prayerful opion on my own.
I feel that i am being rediculed and disrespected. I will leave this forum if yo udo not stop persecutin gme for my opinion. In the Bible it says to shake the dust from your feet and leave the town if they will not accept you. I just want to get you guys thinking about how I feel. Im not trying to force you to agree with me. I am simply stating what I believe. Since when has that been wrong?
I really do love you guys, but I will shake the dust off my feet and leave.

Edited by myduwigd
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='myduwigd' date='Apr 21 2005, 02:25 AM'] Also, he was a former Nazi; Im a psych major when you teach a child or young teen to live that way it has lasting effects on their psychi. [/quote]
Ahem...it's spelled "psyche."

He was never a Nazi. He, like millions of others, was forced into the Hitler Youth program. By your classification, there are currently at least a few hundred thousand Nazis of the Third Reich in Germany right now, just because they were forced into a program.

Can there be psychological effects? Yes. Are there necessarily? No. I would say that the fact that he was a defector from the Nazi cause and that he had the strong anti-Nazi direction of his father, as well as Eugenio Pacelli, i.e. Pope Pius XII, who had been the Nuntio to Munich, are strong factors in making the point that he would not have been brainwashed and affected in this way.

DemonSlayer
Posted (edited)

But the point is that he never wanted to be a Nazi, in fact he abandoned them, it's like conscription being used to get people to serve in Iraq whether or not they want to or agree with the government's position.

Edited by DemonSlayer
faith_my_eyes
Posted (edited)

well I don't know a lot about this topic. I do know that we do not need to go around trying to slay people's opinions. I have no idea why any of you would say such things to myduwigd. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, you can't call someone you've never met satan simply because you disagree with them.
If there is one thing I can't stand it is rudeness, and that is just what this is. If you feel that you need to tear someone else apart because of who they are then I think that you need to say that you are sorry to myduwigd. I don't think that he/she did anything wrong. Proceeding with caution is always a good idea, but what you are doing is against biblical teaching, would Christ have done this, no I don't think so. He did not even call the ones that killed him SATAN.
I would have to say that Christ even when he called Peter Satan he knew since he was omnipotent, ominpresent, omnicient. He would have the rights to do that. He is one of my friends and I know him well. Maybe we should all get to know him well. I think that if myduwigd is saying these things, he/she must have a good reason.
Please think about what I'm saying. Love thy neighbor as thyself, that is the last lesson that I'm going to leave you with.

Edited by faith_my_eyes
Ash Wednesday
Posted

[quote name='faith_my_eyes' date='Apr 21 2005, 02:00 AM'] He is one of my friends and I know him well.  Maybe we should all get to know him well. [/quote]
Probably not a bad idea.... how about he get to know the pope well, too? I think that would be a fair deal. :tiphat:

faith_my_eyes
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Apr 21 2005, 02:09 AM'] Probably not a bad idea.... how about he get to know the pope well, too? I think that would be a fair deal. :tiphat: [/quote]
What if I told you to get lost???

Edited by faith_my_eyes
Ash Wednesday
Posted

What did I say that was so horrible?

Goodness. You come in here talking kumbaya and now you're telling me to get lost? Lovely.

[quote]Please think about what I'm saying. Love thy neighbor as thyself, that is the last lesson that I'm going to leave you with. [/quote]

Just in case you forgot what you just posted.

By the way, I don't really like rudeness, either.

faith_my_eyes
Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Apr 21 2005, 02:17 AM']What did I say that was so horrible?

Goodness. You come in here talking kumbaya and now you're telling me to get lost? Lovely.



Just in case you forgot what you just posted.[/quote]
You are trying to be mean and looking for a fight??? You just told somone to do something that they didn't want to do.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I have no idea what you are getting so upset about. I just don't think getting to know someone is such an unreasonable thing to suggest. You suggested it yourself in defense of your friend.

You just criticized other people on here for tearing someone apart without really knowing them and here you are, jumping all over me. If that isn't hypocrisy, I honestly don't know what is.

faith_my_eyes
Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Apr 21 2005, 02:28 AM'] I have no idea what you are getting so upset about. I just don't think getting to know someone is such an unreasonable thing to suggest. You suggested it yourself in defense of your friend.

You just criticized other people on here for tearing someone apart without really knowing them and here you are, jumping all over me. If that isn't hypocrisy, I honestly don't know what is. [/quote]
My friend???

Posted

[quote name='faith_my_eyes' date='Apr 21 2005, 02:00 AM'] well I don't know a lot about this topic. I do know that we do not need to go around trying to slay people's opinions. I have no idea why any of you would say such things to myduwigd. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, you can't call someone you've never met satan simply because you disagree with them.
If there is one thing I can't stand it is rudeness, and that is just what this is. If you feel that you need to tear someone else apart because of who they are then I think that you need to say that you are sorry to myduwigd. I don't think that he/she did anything wrong. Proceeding with caution is always a good idea, but what you are doing is against biblical teaching, would Christ have done this, no I don't think so. He did not even call the ones that killed him SATAN.
I would have to say that Christ even when he called Peter Satan he knew since he was omnipotent, ominpresent, omnicient. He would have the rights to do that. He is one of my friends and I know him well. Maybe we should all get to know him well. I think that if myduwigd is saying these things, he/she must have a good reason.
Please think about what I'm saying. Love thy neighbor as thyself, that is the last lesson that I'm going to leave you with. [/quote]
Thank you faithmyeyes. At least someone on this forum is willing to stand up for me while Im being persecuted for no good reason.
Ash Wednesday, you arenot listening to what faithmyeyes said . You are focusing on only one part of it and ignoring the important part. You seriously look like you are getting ready for a fight with him. I dont even know who this is and you just go claiming that we must be friends because we agree. You're really making me angry and i wouldnt be surprised if you are making some others angry as well.

Posted (edited)

hm

Edited by myduwigd
Defender_of_the_Faith
Posted

[quote]You're really making me angry and i wouldnt be surprised if you are making some others angry as well. [/quote]

Your persistant belief that Pope Benedict XVI was a Nazi makes me and I'm sure many others here very angry Myduwigd. It's ok to express you opinion. But this is not a matter of opinion. This is a genuine falsehood and all accounts prove it to be so. He was adamently against the Nazi movement and maintaining that he was a Nazi is extremely disrespectful and ignorant. Also, can we please not judge people by how they look. Jesus certainly didn't judge people so.

faith_my_eyes
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Defender_of_the_Faith' date='Apr 21 2005, 02:53 AM']
Your persistant belief that Pope Benedict XVI was a Nazi makes me and I'm sure many others here very angry Myduwigd. It's ok to express you opinion. But this is not a matter of opinion. This is a genuine falsehood and all accounts prove it to be so. He was adamently against the Nazi movement and maintaining that he was a Nazi is extremely disrespectful and ignorant. Also, can we please not judge people by how they look. Jesus certainly didn't judge people so. [/quote]
USA Today would disagree with you??? Where are you getting your info from??? Trying to claim that he is not a former Natzi is like trying to claim that this is not a forum

Edited by faith_my_eyes
Myles Domini
Posted

I have not read this enitre thread nor do I intend to. I will simply say that when it comes to anybody, nevermind the Pope it is best to form an opinion of them after getting to know them. Now mywud has already said he will go and read the Pope's prior theological works in order to form an opinion of him, which is good, and we should leave him to it. In the meantime though mywud I would counsel you with caution and tact over what you say about our beloved Benedict. I know you dont mean to be offensive but to a great many of us your words are deeply offensive, especially since you dont appear to know very much about the Holy Father.

Bringing up the fact that he was once a member of the Hitler Youth is not going to sit well with many of us because of its connotations especially when you use it to substantiate a case that the Pope might be evil. Not only does the Holy Father think Nazism is a form of idolatry (which of course it is) but his family were forced to flee to the Alps because his Father was a policeman who would not comply with the Hitler's illigitmate exercise of [i]law[/i]. He was forced into the Nazi ranks and when he was old enough he deserted showing that his own Father's influence bore more upon him than the 'Fuherer's'.

Indeed, if you reflect upon his career as a theologian in his independent works and not in his magisterial ones you can see he has retained a love of freedom. Of independence and pushing the boundaries. There are pictures of him sitting next to Karl Rahner at Vatican II and he was part of the theological clique who acted as the intellectual backbone behind that General Council. Indeed, with the peritus of Vatican II, Henri de Lubac, and the famed Hans Urs Von Balthasar he founded the theological journal 'Communio'. The three of them thus perpetuated the authentic spirit of Vatican II by giving the ressourcement a new voice.

Benedict XVI is a long standing friend of the Jewish Cardinal Lustiger and other cardinals of diverse ethnicity. He remains until this day through the communion of saints a deep friend of that great Pole, John Paul II, and shows no inclination towards Nazism. In his book 'Called to Communion' he reinforces his ideas of an ecclesiology based upon communio with a reduction of the role of Bishops conferences and an increase in the autonomy of the individual Bishops. He is not a centraliser at all, he simply insists on the purity of Catholic doctrine. Any Bishop whose initiatives are not tainted by heresy will find a new freedom under Benedict XVI who has always thought it necessary to remove unneccesary layers of red tape. Moreover, in his book 'Principles of Catholic Theology' he advocates reinterpreting the jurdistictional primacy of Rome in a way more closely in line with his ressourcement thinking modelled on that of the 1st millenia of Christianity thus making me hopeful for ecumenical relations between Rome and Constantinople under his Pontificate.

If his eyes are ringed its because he is tired. He tried to resign from the Roman Curia three times in the past fifteen years and suffered a cereberal hemorrage in 1991 indeed that temporarily affected his field of vision. Even yesterday in his address to the Cardinals following their concelebrated Mass he spoke about his trepidation and how he feels John Paul the Great still telling him 'Do not be afraid'. Even in death he remains devoted to the man who forced him to stay in Rome thrice and thus ensured his election as Pope, which I think the Pope wanted when he moved to immediately make Ratzinger dean of the College when the post opened. John Paul the Great made sure that Ratzinger could not leave Rome to return to his studies and by his actions he ensured Ratzinger would come to the forefront in the event of his death, which I think he knew was immanent.

John Paul the Great trusted this man with our faith for 23 years. Now lets trust him for as long as he God allows him hold of the keys to his house.

Ash Wednesday
Posted
:) :) :)

Smiles for Myles.
faith_my_eyes
Posted

I don't think that myduwigd meant that is was because his eyes are ringed is what makes him scary. I have rings around my eyes and I'm not even that old. I thnk he meant something else. You need to read everything that was said. I know what she means and I'm not sure if I can trust the Pope either. KEEP AN OPEN MIND.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Okay, let's back up just a second.

If you and myduwigd would both please calm down, I was under the impression that faith_my_eyes was speaking of knowing myduwigd well as a friend and getting to know HIM (or her) better. If I'm mistaken on that one, I apologize, but your posts are kind of rambling and confusing.

I wasn't the one who flew off the handle telling anyone to "get lost" so if there was anyone "looking to get into a fight" I don't think I would be the only one. So if you're here to talk about God, love, and charity, show some of it yourself, please. Thank you.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...