MichaelFilo Posted May 18, 2005 Posted May 18, 2005 This topic really had no fitting place but this one. I'd just like to get a link to a traditionalist site, since Phatmass is unwelcoming to questions and topics revolving around traditionalism. I don't mean conservative forums, like PM, either. I doubt there are any, and my search has found nothing good for me. So, if you know of one, please post it, or PM me, seeing as how the mods just hate links to all things outside of the PM point of view when it comes to Catholicism (although liberal sites are just fine when they are linked). No point in going on for a rant here, if anyone can help me out, it's much appreciated. God bless, Mikey
Brother Adam Posted May 18, 2005 Posted May 18, 2005 Yes, schism typically is not welcome here or any orthodox Catholic site.
rachael Posted May 18, 2005 Posted May 18, 2005 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='May 18 2005, 08:03 AM'] *crickets chirping* [/quote]
dUSt Posted May 18, 2005 Posted May 18, 2005 [quote]This topic really had no fitting place but this one. I'd just like to get a link to a traditionalist site, since Phatmass is unwelcoming to questions and topics revolving around traditionalism. [/quote] No, we are not. We would love to clarify the orthodox view on any subject. [quote]I don't mean conservative forums, like PM, either... So, if you know of one, please post it, or PM me, seeing as how the mods just hate links to all things outside of the PM point of view when it comes to Catholicism (although liberal sites are just fine when they are linked). [/quote] A conservative forum that thinks links to liberal sites are just fine. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. And what exactly are you suggesting is the "PM point of view when it comes to Catholicism"?
MichaelFilo Posted May 18, 2005 Author Posted May 18, 2005 My point, dUst, was this. I cannot discuss Vatican II and ask questions about it's validity because that form of debate is closed. I cannot discuss the greater value of the Tridentine Mass over the Novus Ordo, because that is not allowed. As far as I know, I can't find a web forum that is very accepting to that form of debate. Simply put, none of those places can clarify what I don't understand, which is the whole point of debate, to either learn something or to teach someone something. And yes, a few links have been closed by fact that they linked to Traditionalist sites on the debate table. However, when discussing liberalism, it's fine to post all the links you can find.... it's really a double standard. The PM point of view : "Papa is always right, you are an idiot if you think the Catechism could be wrong, Tridentine mass is nice but all for the Novus Ordo, etc." That is the feel of this place. All those opinions are erronous at their very core. Of course, there is also the understanding of salvation, which I'd love to hear both sides of, but can't on PM. FFM also isn't any good, the whole section of the site that interested me went to hell in a handbasket. So, simply, I am looking to learn, in a place where I get a bit more education than CMOM saying "Wrong ". I guess this really would be the wrong place to ask, however. God bless, Mikey
Dave Posted May 18, 2005 Posted May 18, 2005 (edited) Here are 2 pages that are very good at explaining what extreme traditionalists believe and exposing their errors: [url="http://jloughnan.tripod.com/chetshet.htm"]http://jloughnan.tripod.com/chetshet.htm[/url] [url="http://matt1618.freeyellow.com/TRADIT.html"]http://matt1618.freeyellow.com/TRADIT.html[/url] Edited May 18, 2005 by Dave
MichaelFilo Posted May 18, 2005 Author Posted May 18, 2005 I just had a long winded reply that I posted. I deleted so that I would avoid spreading scandal (I am still learning, but must be cautious, because even sin sounds good until put into practice), and to discredit the rediculous arguements being put forth on both those sites. God bless, Mikey
WBOZ Posted May 18, 2005 Posted May 18, 2005 [quote name='MichaelFilo' date='May 18 2005, 01:26 PM'] I just had a long winded reply that I posted. I deleted so that I would avoid spreading scandal (I am still learning, but must be cautious, because even sin sounds good until put into practice), and to discredit the rediculous arguements being put forth on both those sites. God bless, Mikey [/quote] MichaelFilo- Your most recent post indicates at least a desire for proper formation. While I am somewhat confident that I would strongly disagree with a number of your positions, I would encourage you to review Sean McIlhenny's weblog RerumNovarum. He lists a number of traditionalist sites and forum discussions and while consistently opposing them he does not remove his links to their comments or materials. Unfortunately, because of what is at stake, namely our eternal souls, it is rare to find a discussion which does not devolve into name calling or anathematizing. You might also review the Catholic Answers Forum pages. From time to time an intelligent discussion will develop for a small span before it becomes hopelessly ensnared in personal sniping. You are going to have to weed through a lot of tripe before you can get a full picture of the pro/con "traditionalist" arguments. Pace a Bene
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 18, 2005 Posted May 18, 2005 [quote name='MichaelFilo' date='May 18 2005, 01:28 PM'] The PM point of view : "Papa is always right, you are an idiot if you think the Catechism could be wrong, Tridentine mass is nice but all for the Novus Ordo, etc." That is the feel of this place. All those opinions are erronous at their very core. Of course, there is also the understanding of salvation, which I'd love to hear both sides of, but can't on PM. FFM also isn't any good, the whole section of the site that interested me went to hell in a handbasket. So, simply, I am looking to learn, in a place where I get a bit more education than CMOM saying "Wrong ". [/quote] I don't think that's the PM point of view. I think that Phatmass represents the Catholic Church very well. We do not believe that the pope is always right about everything, but do hold his infallibility and consider his stances in other matters very highly, even if we ultimately do not agree. I think that the Catechism is well represented here and given that it is the summary of the Catholic faith and the basis of much theology, I think it has its proper place here. I also think that there is nothing wrong with enjoying both the Tridentine and the Novus Ordo Missae. There is no inconsistency. As the former admin of FFM, I must defend. What happened happened because of a total lack of respect on the part of some as well as a general lack of traffic. No more website bashing.
MichaelFilo Posted May 18, 2005 Author Posted May 18, 2005 Thank you WBOZ. That's a big help. Rapheal, as much as I like you, you would be very wrong in assuming I am wrong on this. When I stated that the Catechism is not infalliable, I was told I was attacking the Catechism. When stating that popes do err and sometimes we have to make sure they are speaking for the whole Church, I was told that obedience to the pope is required even in falliable matters. The Tridentine Mass was simply a resimplification of the Mass said throughout the world since the apostolic age (albiet, it was not consistent between churches for a while). The Tridentine Mass is also the "eternal Mass". It is superior in liturgy than the Novus Ordo, by sheer fact that it has been used for so long. The Novus Ordo is also a creation of paper and pen, the Tridentine is a creation that came through practice (and was refined). At least historically speaking, it is superior. God bless, Mikey
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 18, 2005 Posted May 18, 2005 [quote name='MichaelFilo' date='May 18 2005, 03:20 PM'] Rapheal, as much as I like you, you would be very wrong in assuming I am wrong on this. When I stated that the Catechism is not infalliable, I was told I was attacking the Catechism. When stating that popes do err and sometimes we have to make sure they are speaking for the whole Church, I was told that obedience to the pope is required even in falliable matters. The Tridentine Mass was simply a resimplification of the Mass said throughout the world since the apostolic age (albiet, it was not consistent between churches for a while). The Tridentine Mass is also the "eternal Mass". It is superior in liturgy than the Novus Ordo, by sheer fact that it has been used for so long. The Novus Ordo is also a creation of paper and pen, the Tridentine is a creation that came through practice (and was refined). At least historically speaking, it is superior. [/quote] You are basing your judgment of PM on the arguments of a few of its members.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted May 18, 2005 Posted May 18, 2005 (edited) I agree. I was called "half retarted" (by someone who will go unnamed) because i was upset about how Vatican II was bieng interperted, so i said it would be better if it never happened. Edited May 18, 2005 by Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
MichaelFilo Posted May 19, 2005 Author Posted May 19, 2005 It's true, Rapheal. Because said people are the ones in mod positions. But to be fair, it's usually just one or two people, so you are right. However, no one ever feels the need to correct them, maybe because they like to post messages like "Wrong " but I can't tell. All I know is that this is how it seems, even if only being proported by a few people, silence is acceptance, and that is sufficient to create that certain "vibe". What is half retarded. Does that mean you are half way to being retarded, or are you half as intellegent as someone who is retarded? God bless, Mikey
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 [quote]What is half retarded. Does that mean you are half way to being retarded, or are you half as intellegent as someone who is retarded?[/quote] im definently leaning towards half way to being retarded.
Cam42 Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 Mikey....if you want to talk about Trid vs. NO, you can find me online at Paltalk. If you want to discuss it, I would be willing to do a one on one thread with you, so that others can read and contemplate, but so that you can ask your questions with only my response, as to not get into multiple discussions and tangents. (Which aren't bad normally, but you have a specific issue that you want to deal with, that I have particular knowledge about.) Understanding the Liturgy was one of my foci in grad school. It was also an non-emphasis specialty of mine in undergrad. So, if dUSt can set it up, perhaps in the Q and A, I would be willing to take this on and try and help you. This is up to dUSt though.
Aloysius Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 I don't know who said you were half-retarded; I recall using the term "ignorant" simply because you expressed hope in the idea that Pope Benedict XVI, who was a principal former of the council, would scrap the whole thing.I do understand the anger at how the council was implemented... but saying it should be thrown out and especially the idea that it would be B XVI to do it was an idea ignorant of Ben's role in the Council. ah well, anyway...
Myles Domini Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 [quote]Thank you WBOZ. That's a big help. Rapheal, as much as I like you, you would be very wrong in assuming I am wrong on this. When I stated that the Catechism is not infalliable, I was told I was attacking the Catechism. When stating that popes do err and sometimes we have to make sure they are speaking for the whole Church, I was told that obedience to the pope is required even in falliable matters. The Tridentine Mass was simply a resimplification of the Mass said throughout the world since the apostolic age (albiet, it was not consistent between churches for a while). The Tridentine Mass is also the "eternal Mass". It is superior in liturgy than the Novus Ordo, by sheer fact that it has been used for so long. The Novus Ordo is also a creation of paper and pen, the Tridentine is a creation that came through practice (and was refined). At least historically speaking, it is superior. God bless, Mikey [/quote] Apologies if someone has attacked you untowards Mikey I cant imagine anybody meaning to do so however I can understand why you would be taken to task, as they say, for what you said. Your statements about the Catechism and the Papacy as you present them now are correct. The Catechism is not definitvely infallible in the same way that an ex cathedra statement or the canon of an Ecumenical Council is. However the Catechism cannot be wrong either. As you'll read in that same Catechism points 890-892 and Vatican II's document 'Lumen Gentium' paragraph 25 the magisterium even when it is not extraordinary is authoritative and binding. Guided by God it cannot be mistaken. It might not be able to arrive at a definitive definition of truth like the extraordinary magisterium can but the truth's it presents are not false, they are simply needing to be developed so as to become definitive. Thus criticising the Catechism leaves one open to being interpreted as refusing to accept a very essential dogma of the faith. As for the Pope's, indeed, they are to be checked and balanced. If a Pope speaks heresy his statements are invalid and his office is also because he has severed himself from the body. However, again this is not for us to decide but for the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. It is not for private individuals to try and judge the Church or the Popes. If the Holy Office finds no fault in the actions of a Pontiff how can any members of the faithful judge him? Based on what authority? Once again you can see how your phraseology could have been misinterpreted by the zealous fidelity of my fellow phatmassers. As for the Mass of Pope Pius V as opposed to that promulgated by Pope Paul VI. Though I dont agree entirely with your arguments in favour of the Old Mass I will admit that the texts of the Old Mass are amazingly beautiful, moreso than those of the New Mass. There are other things about it that I dont like i.e. the server being the only one to answer the responses, the short breadth of the liturgy of the word etc. But I do like the way the Mass began with Psalm 42 and ended with the 'last gospel' etc.etc. That being said I am a child of the 'Reform of the Reform'. there were some improvements in the Mass of Pope Paul VI and I do not want to go back but forth and develop the liturgy as it stands so as not to loose what good has come from post-conciliar reform but also to revive what goods were lost.
Guest Eremite Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 [quote]When I stated that the Catechism is not infalliable, I was told I was attacking the Catechism.[/quote] Pope Benedict addresses the authority of the Catechism in his "Introduction to the Catechism of the Catholic Church": [quote]"This brings us to the question already mentioned before, regarding the authority of the Catechism. In order to find the answer, let us first consider a bit more closely its juridical character. We could express it in this way: analogously to the new Code of Canon Law, the Catechism is de facto a collegial work; canonically, it falls under the special jurisdiction of the Pope, inasmuch as it was authorized for the whole Christian world by the Holy Father in virtue of the supreme teaching authority invested in him. ... "This does not mean that the catechism is a sort of super-dogma, as its opponents would like to insinuate in order to cast suspicion on its as a danger to the liberty of theology. What significance the Catechism really holds for the common exercise of teaching in the Church may be learned by reading the Apostolic Constitution Fidei depositum, with which the Pope promulgated it on October 11, 1992--exactly thirty years after the opening of the Second Vatican Council: 'I acknowledge it as a valid and legitimate tool in the service of ecclesiastical communion, as a sure norm for instruction in the faith.' "The individual doctrine which the Catechism presents receive no other weight than that which they already possess. The weight of the Catechism itself lies in the whole. Since it transmits what the Church teaches, whoever rejects it as a whole separates himself beyond question from the faith and teaching of the Church."[/quote] [quote]I was told that obedience to the pope is required even in falliable matters.[/quote] This is true. We owe submission of intellect and will even to non-infallible teachings of the Roman Pontiff. At the very least, this requires us to avoid publicly disputing what he has taught: [quote]"The third proposition of the Professio fidei states: 'Moreover, I adhere with religious submission of will and intellect to the teachings which either the Roman Pontiff or the College of Bishops enunciate when they exercise their authentic Magisterium, even if they do not intend to proclaim these teachings by a definitive act.' To this paragraph belong all those teachings on faith and morals - presented as true or at least as sure, even if they have not been defined with a solemn judgment or proposed as definitive by the ordinary and universal Magisterium. Such teachings are, however, an authentic expression of the ordinary Magisterium of the Roman Pontiff or of the College of Bishops and therefore require religious submission of will and intellect. They are set forth in order to arrive at a deeper understanding of revelation, or to recall the conformity of a teaching with the truths of faith, or lastly to warn against ideas incompatible with these truths or against dangerous opinions that can lead to error. (CDF, "Doctrinal Commentary on the Professio Fidei") [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDFADTU.HTM"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDFADTU.HTM[/url][/quote] Pope Pius XII also reiterated this principle in "Humani Generis": [quote]"Nor must it be thought that what is expounded in Encyclical Letters does not of itself demand consent, since in writing such Letters the Popes do not exercise the supreme power of their Teaching Authority. For these matters are taught with the ordinary teaching authority, of which it is true to say: 'He who heareth you, heareth me'; and generally what is expounded and inculcated in Encyclical Letters already for other reasons appertains to Catholic doctrine. But if the Supreme Pontiffs in their official documents purposely pass judgment on a matter up to that time under dispute, it is obvious that that matter, according to the mind and will of the Pontiffs, cannot be any longer considered a question open to discussion among theologians."[/quote] [quote]The Tridentine Mass is also the "eternal Mass".[/quote] No Liturgical form is "eternal". All Liturgical rites develop and change, and all will eventually pass away to be replaced by the heavenly Liturgy. [quote]"So we see that at the latest by the tenth or eleventh century the Roman Rite has driven out the Gallican, except in two sees (Milan and Toledo), and is used alone throughout the West, thus at last verifying here too the principle that rite follows patriarchate. But in the long and gradual supplanting of the Gallican Rite the Roman was itself affected by its rival, so that when at last it emerges as sole possessor it is no longer the old pure Roman Rite, but has become the gallicanized Roman Use that we now follow. These Gallican additions are all of the nature of ceremonial ornament, symbolic practices, ritual adornment. Our blessings of candles, ashes, palms, much of the ritual of Holy Week, sequences, and so on are Gallican additions. The original Roman Rite was very plain, simple, practical. Mr. Edmund Bishop says that its characteristics were 'essentially soberness and sense'. ...Once these additions were accepted at Rome they became part of the (new) Roman Rite and were used as part of that rite everywhere." (1913 Catholic Encyclopedia, "Liturgy" entry)[/quote]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now