Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

KobeScott8
Posted

MichaelFilo
Just chill out a little bit dude!!!!
And maybe I could try and help you out if you would translate all that stuff you said in English. I don't understand what your saying. Can you tell me in simpler language please?????
Somebody-anybody???

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='May 18 2005, 10:29 PM'] I don't know who said you were half-retarded; I recall using the term "ignorant" simply because you expressed hope in the idea that Pope Benedict XVI, who was a principal former of the council, would scrap the whole thing.I do understand the anger at how the council was implemented... but saying it should be thrown out and especially the idea that it would be B XVI to do it was an idea ignorant of Ben's role in the Council.

ah well, anyway... [/quote]
We also have to take into consideration how important the Council was to Pope John Paul II. He also played a very important role in the Council and considered it vital to the life of the Church. I'll find the exact quote for you if you want. But the fact remains that, while we may not be happy with the way that certain factions have distorted the Council's findings/teachings, the Council did adress important issues and has helped in some ways. Yes, it has also hurt in some ways, but that's always going to happen because we are humans.

Guest Eremite
Posted

[quote]"In light of this, as you rightly observe, the Second Vatican Council differed from earlier councils because of its particular style. It was not a defensive style. Not once in the Council documents do the words anathema sit appear. It was an ecumenical style, characterized by great openness to dialogue, a dialogue described by Pope Paul VI as a 'dialogue of salvation.'

"This dialogue was not intended to be limited to Christians alone. It was meant to be open to non-Christian religions, and to reach the whole modern world, including those who do not believe. Truth, in fact, cannot be confined. Truth is for one and for all. And if this truth comes about through love (cf. Eph 4:15), then it becomes even more universal. This was the style of the Second Vatican Council and the spirit in which it took place.

"This style and this spirit will be remembered as the essential truth about the Council, not the controversies between 'liberals' and 'conservatives'-controversies seen in political, not religious, terms-to which some people wanted to reduce the whole Council. In this spirit the Second Vatican Council will continue to be a challenge for all Churches and a duty for each person for a long time to come."

--John Paul II, "Crossing the Threshold of Hope"[/quote]

Posted

Thank you. :D

Ash Wednesday
Posted

[quote name='KobeScott8' date='May 19 2005, 09:51 AM'] Just chill out a little bit dude!!!!
And maybe I could try and help you out if you would translate all that stuff you said in English. I don't understand what your saying. Can you tell me in simpler language please?????
Somebody-anybody??? [/quote]
I like you. :)

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted (edited)

[quote]hey ecclesiam, ur half retarded to say that you are going to pray that Pope Benedict XVI throws out all of vatican II. I think you need to read a little more on the subject of vatican two then realize how dumb you are to say something like that. I'm offended by this because u want to get rid of something that reformed our entire church. The fact that you even say you disagree with Vatican II and comment on it makes you a non-catholic. Rethinks your ideas.:angry:  [/quote]


so the Cathechesim is not infallibile? so how should i regard it?

I think That if the council is not interperted correctly then it should be scrapped.

Im all for it, if it is interpereted correctly.


sam

Edited by Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Ash Wednesday
Posted

I don't know who called you half retarded and dumb, but whoever said that was being a complete hypocrite about "reforming our entire church" -- reform begins from within.

Whoever wrote that ought to be ashamed of their conduct.

Posted

i agree that we should try to prevent all of the judging that goes on in the outside world.

Here let people be themselves and ask the questions they need to. It doesn't always mean something bad.

Sometimes people ask who is God. does that mean they don't believe anymore? no!

Simple faith, true faith. With it this all becomes so different. :)

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

im not saying who said it... (but if you want to know click on the homepage of phatmass and look at the comments for Papa! Papa! Papa!...you didn't here this from me)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...