Mogmog Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 The movie was sweet right up until Anakin said "If you're not for me, you're my enemy" and Obiwan said "Only Sith Deal in Absolutes." (Ironic, after Darth Sidius had said that evil was a point of view). Am I the only one who sees that as a slam against Christianity (especially with the pseudo-messianic that was going on with Anakin). It really has me mad enough that I don't want to see any Star Wars again.
Kilroy the Ninja Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 Just a movie there. Just a movie. I doubt Lucas was "slamming" anyone.
Mogmog Posted May 19, 2005 Author Posted May 19, 2005 Dunno, it seemed rather direct to have a messiah-like figure say something that Jesus basically said and then have Obiwan call him a Sith for using absolutes. Then again, I do read things in sometimes.
Brother Adam Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 I think part of the point of the force is that there are no absolutes beyond there is a 'good' and a 'bad'.
Paladin D Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 [quote name='Mogmog' date='May 19 2005, 04:19 PM'] Dunno, it seemed rather direct to have a messiah-like figure say something that Jesus basically said and then have Obiwan call him a Sith for using absolutes. Then again, I do read things in sometimes. [/quote] I think it was more of the strict [b]"If you don't agree with me, then you're my enemy"[/b] type of thing. It sort of takes from what President Bush was first implying, "If you're not with us, then you're against us" type of idealogy. Obi-Wan loved Anakin, but he couldn't accept nor agree with his actions. Just as Christians love (or should love) someone, but not their sin. Plus, I wouldn't strictly compare Anakin to Christ, considering Anakin [b]falls to the dark side[/b]. Star Wars uses different elements from mythology and religion, it's base isn't soley from Christianity.
Fixxxer Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 it seems like everymovie i read about on here, there always seems to be somethin in a movie against christianity.
HomeTeamFamily Posted May 19, 2005 Posted May 19, 2005 [quote]Just a movie there. Just a movie.[/quote]
Mogmog Posted May 20, 2005 Author Posted May 20, 2005 Just a movie, yes, but if it intentionally compared Jesus to a sith it's certainly not a movie I'd watch twice. Obviously not everyone got that from that scene though, which is good. I certainly would have enjoyed the movie a lot more if I hadn't.
Lounge Daddy Posted May 20, 2005 Posted May 20, 2005 [quote name='Mogmog' date='May 19 2005, 07:57 PM'] Just a movie, yes, but if it intentionally compared Jesus to a sith it's certainly not a movie I'd watch twice. Obviously not everyone got that from that scene though, which is good. I certainly would have enjoyed the movie a lot more if I hadn't. [/quote] "not everyone got that from that scene though..." um, ya... how does Star Wars compare Jesus to Darth Vader? I guess I missed it. Either you are reading too much into a single line of dialogue or there was a crucifixion scene that I missed when I left to get more popcorn.
Mogmog Posted May 20, 2005 Author Posted May 20, 2005 OK, this was said more clearly in another thread but: A) His birth was foretold in prophecy B) It was a virgin birth C) According to the prohecy he would "save" his people (although we find this actually fulfilled in Luke) D) He paraphrazies a quote of Jesus (If you are not for me you are against me) E) In response to this quote Obi-wan says "Only Sith deal in absolutes" similar to charges commonly leveled against Christians by our relativistic culture, made all the more striking by the quote it is in response to. The thing about this quote is that it is incredibly out of place as others have pointed out. It is clearly the Jedi that deal in absolutes and the Sith that say things like "evil is a point of view."
Zoecool13 Posted May 20, 2005 Posted May 20, 2005 [quote name='Mogmog' date='May 19 2005, 11:44 PM'] The thing about this quote is that it is incredibly out of place as others have pointed out. It is clearly the Jedi that deal in absolutes and the Sith that say things like "evil is a point of view." [/quote] I think the quote worked just fine. It wasn't out of place at all. The Sith deal in absolutes, not the Jedi... remember that Anakin was to fulfill the prophecy according to Obi-Wan and Qui Gon Jinn.. He would bring balance back to the force... Yoda clearly points out to Obi-Wan and Mace Windu that this is just based on the perspective of one's point of view. Evil is not a point of view to the Sith... it is the way to happiness and power (and the only way- hence absolute)
Zoecool13 Posted May 20, 2005 Posted May 20, 2005 [quote name='Mogmog' date='May 19 2005, 11:44 PM'] C) According to the prohecy he would "save" his people (although we find this actually fulfilled in Luke) [/quote] The prophecy is to balance the force, not "save" his people... and Luke is not born of a virgin as the prophecy states, therefore he cannot be the choosen one that fulfills the prophecy.
1337 k4th0l1x0r Posted May 20, 2005 Posted May 20, 2005 Actually, in a twisted way Anakin fulfills the prophecy at the end of ROTJ when he kills the emporer. It was just a roundabout way of getting there.
Kilroy the Ninja Posted May 20, 2005 Posted May 20, 2005 [quote name='1337 k4th0l1x0r' date='May 20 2005, 12:52 AM'] Actually, in a twisted way Anakin fulfills the prophecy at the end of ROTJ when he kills the emporer. It was just a roundabout way of getting there. [/quote] Actually Anakin brings balance to the force exactly like he was supposed to in ROTS. In Ep. I and II and the beginning of III there are WAY too many Jedi in comparison to the Sith. By the end of ROTS the "balance" has been restored, that is, there are two Sith and two Jedi left. See, that's the problem with prophesy - sometimes it's just not the interpretation we really want. Also, I believe they answered the "virgin birth" issue when Palpatine was explaining to Anakin about the previous Sith who could manipulate metachlorines enough to produce spontaneous pregnancy. Nothing terribly mystical about that. Trying to say that Darth Vader is a Christ-figure is a real stretch. Trying to put words in Lucas' mouth is even worse. It's just a movie folks!
Cam42 Posted May 20, 2005 Posted May 20, 2005 [quote name='Mogmog' date='May 19 2005, 02:07 AM'] The movie was sweet right up until Anakin said "If you're not for me, you're my enemy" and Obiwan said "Only Sith Deal in Absolutes." (Ironic, after Darth Sidius had said that evil was a point of view). Am I the only one who sees that as a slam against Christianity (especially with the pseudo-messianic that was going on with Anakin). It really has me mad enough that I don't want to see any Star Wars again. [/quote] George Lucas, admittedly says that Star Wars is a philosophy rather than a theology. I think that he is right. Speaking as one who has degrees in both, it is less like Christianity and more like a mix of platonic and eastern philosophy. There is no air of Christianity, other than what people ascribe to it. The problem is that the Catholics will look at it one way, Protestants another. Then you have to look at the similarities to Buddha, Shintoism, and Shaolin philosophy (which is a form of Buddhism). When this happens, as it often does in really good movies, the ideas are misconstrued. Don't read too much into the philosophy. It is fantasy. There is no galaxy far, far away that has Darth Vader and Obi-Wan. Enjoy the movie, for being what it is.....fun. Just my two cents.
Mogmog Posted May 20, 2005 Author Posted May 20, 2005 [quote]Evil is not a point of view to the Sith... it is the way to happiness and power (and the only way- hence absolute)[/quote] Actually saying evil is a point of way was quoting the Emperor trying to persuade Anakin to go over to the dark side. I thought the movie was making a good case for moral absolutes up until that point. [quote]Also, I believe they answered the "virgin birth" issue when Palpatine was explaining to Anakin about the previous Sith who could manipulate metachlorines enough to produce spontaneous pregnancy. Nothing terribly mystical about that.[/quote] It doesn't really matter how they explain it. It's a striking parallel though in and of itself it proves nothing. Saving myths often have a virgin birth. [quote] The prophecy is to balance the force, not "save" his people... and Luke is not born of a virgin as the prophecy states, therefore he cannot be the choosen one that fulfills the prophecy. [/quote] I suppose that is the case. Nevertheless, Obi-wan and Qui-gon and likely others had expectations of a savior figure. As 1337 k4th0l1x0r pointed out, he fulfilled this destiny eventually. Heck, they could have included other parallels and I wouldn't have had a problem with it. With Lucas's primary inspiration being Joseph Campbell you would expect them. It's just when you take these parallel's and then put the words of Jesus on the lips of this character and then have such a typically anti-Christian comment made in response that I take notice. [quote] George Lucas, admittedly says that Star Wars is a philosophy rather than a theology.[/quote] True, but his personally spirituality, or so he said in Time (around when Ep 1 came out), isn't far off from Star Wars which to me, a former student of Eastern religions, smells a bit more of New Age than anything from over there. In any case, it is the norm for both New Age people and Buddhists, Taoists, etc. to have a problem with absolutes. In America, where they have to interact with Christians this can often give rise to a certain animosity towards Christianity. That is certainly my experience of it anyway. I don't think it's at all far fetched that someone with such a philosophy would take a slam at Christians (although not necessarily Christ since they no doubt believe that he was just an enlightened human or some such nonsense). Books by Americans on Buddhism do that often enough anyway. Anakin was making a false absolute of himself in that scene, so he deserved some criticism. Attacking all absolutes is simply nonsense, especially in a movie about good and evil. I can accept (and indeed expect) relativism from movies in America. The part I won't tolerate is any intentional slander of Christianity.
1337 k4th0l1x0r Posted May 20, 2005 Posted May 20, 2005 [quote name='Kilroy the Ninja' date='May 20 2005, 07:27 AM'] See, that's the problem with prophesy - sometimes it's just not the interpretation we really want. [/quote] Yep. Two different interpretations of the same prophecy. Sidious wanted the balance to be more of a balance between good and evil, or really that the pendulum would swing the other way for awhile. The Jedi wanted the balance to be the elimination of the Sith in order to usher in a golden age for them. Balance doesn't always have to be a good and evil balance. Ultimately, both interpretations of the prophecy came true. Through Anakin, Sidious supressed the Jedi and founded a galactic empire and the Jedi destroyed the last Sith master.
Fixxxer Posted May 20, 2005 Posted May 20, 2005 darth vader said pretty much the same thing in the empire strikes back. wheres the thread for that quote
Mogmog Posted May 20, 2005 Author Posted May 20, 2005 [quote] darth vader said pretty much the same thing in the empire strikes back. wheres the thread for that quote[/quote] Which quote are you referring to?
jmjtina Posted May 20, 2005 Posted May 20, 2005 [quote name='Lounge Daddy' date='May 19 2005, 09:28 PM'] "not everyone got that from that scene though..." um, ya... how does Star Wars compare Jesus to Darth Vader? I guess I missed it. Either you are reading too much into a single line of dialogue or there was a crucifixion scene that I missed when I left to get more popcorn. [/quote] :crackup: Where's Spector? He's good for this kind of dialouge as well.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now