Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Why would Lucas, a Jewish person, quote compare a fictional character to Jesus. He doesn't seem the type to do that, especially since he tries to make each movie pg and appeal to *most* audiences.

Posted

in empire vader said luke will join the darkside or die.

the army says something like if you arent for us you are against us. how evil!

Posted (edited)

[quote name='musturde' date='May 20 2005, 06:09 PM'] Why would Lucas, a Jewish person, quote compare a fictional character to Jesus. He doesn't seem the type to do that, especially since he tries to make each movie pg and appeal to *most* audiences. [/quote]
I explained why this would happen in a post above.

I'm rethinking that explanation but only slightly.

Lucas's biggest influence is Joseph Campbell, a big name in comparative religion. Lucas specifically included Campbell's "hero's journey" in the plot and it is unsurprising that elements of various saving myths (virgin birth, etc) were also included.

My problem is not that Anakin said the line. Clearly that was misguided. My problem is Obi-wan's response. His response was so broad that it's logic, if not it's intention, applies equally to Jesus's statement. He could have put Anakin in his place but instead he made a statement that would indict anyone who would make such a statement as a Sith. The inclusion of the elements such as the virgin birth make this all the more striking, even if they really have nothing to do with it.

I have no high view of the liberals in the moviemaking industry to think that they're above intending it. I've certainly heard the same thing from other New Agers, so why not Lucas?

Edited by Mogmog
Posted

[quote name='Mogmog' date='May 20 2005, 09:08 PM'] I explained why this would happen in a post above.

I'm rethinking that explanation but only slightly.

Lucas's biggest influence is Joseph Campbell, a big name in comparative religion. Lucas specifically included Campbell's "hero's journey" in the plot and it is unsurprising that elements of various saving myths (virgin birth, etc) were also included.

My problem is not that Anakin said the line. Clearly that was misguided. My problem is Obi-wan's response. His response was so broad that it's logic, if not it's intention, applies equally to Jesus's statement. He could have put Anakin in his place but instead he made a statement that would indict anyone who would make such a statement as a Sith. The inclusion of the elements such as the virgin birth make this all the more striking, even if they really have nothing to do with it.

I have no high view of the liberals in the moviemaking industry to think that they're above intending it. I've certainly heard the same thing from other New Agers, so why not Lucas? [/quote]
What virgen birth? Anakin or Luke? I don't think I remember any of them having to do with virgen birth but I could be wrong. What was Obi's responce again? I don't really remember what he answered.

ardillacid
Posted

[quote name='Fixxxer' date='May 19 2005, 05:31 PM'] it seems like everymovie i read about on here, there always seems to be somethin in a movie against christianity. [/quote]



No kiddin? have you noticed the sewage that Hollywood pumps out of that filth hole? ;)

Posted

i really dont get how this could be against christianity still. the only thing i could see is 66 since nero stands for 666 and the emperor was evil in the movie. but wait ...theres that word MOVIE

Posted

[quote] What virgen birth? Anakin or Luke? I don't think I remember any of them having to do with virgen birth but I could be wrong. What was Obi's responce again? I don't really remember what he answered.[/quote]

Anakin was conceived without a father "by the miticholorians(sp?)"

As for Obi-wan's response, that would be the "Only Sith deal in absolutes."

Anyway, I'm pretty much done with this thread. I'm just going to move on to trying to convince myself that everyone else is right so I can enjoy the movie more.

ardillacid
Posted (edited)

Fixxer

^did you take your crazy pills this morning ;)

Edited by ardillacid
Posted (edited)

"Anyway, I'm pretty much done with this thread. I'm just going to move on to trying to convince myself that everyone else is right so I can enjoy the movie more."



see just enjoy the movie! thats why movies are made! for enjoyment... except spice world

Edited by Fixxxer
Posted (edited)

when you said Ep 3 i thought you meant a late model honda civic hatchback and when you said spoiler i thought you meant wing

haha

Edited by ReinnieR
Posted (edited)

ep3 could mean the gaming expo thing too


*never mind :P thats e3 heh

Edited by Fixxxer
  • 3 years later...
Posted

[quote name='Mogmog' post='594490' date='May 19 2005, 12:07 AM']The movie was sweet right up until Anakin said "If you're not for me, you're my enemy" and Obiwan said "Only Sith Deal in Absolutes." (Ironic, after Darth Sidius had said that evil was a point of view).

Am I the only one who sees that as a slam against Christianity (especially with the pseudo-messianic that was going on with Anakin). It really has me mad enough that I don't want to see any Star Wars again.[/quote]

You are definetly not the only one.

It is exactly that - you are very perseptive. Now work very hard to see why. I'll give you my opinion as to why it is there - although it is VERY involved. Anyway, I'd like to talk to you more about this as I would like to develop this further.

Posted

...wow...3 years old necroed.

Posted

Arise, ancient post, and do my bidding!
[img]http://abandonedrealms.com/realms/classes/images/necromancer.jpg[/img]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...