jezic Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 i feel sorry for the people who have wierd psychologists. Here i think there is a good solid Catholic guy that does the screening.
MC Just Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 also, the Vatican is gonna have to dig deeper, many of the seminaries, called "pink palaces" are going to diguise themselves as orthodox so they wont be detected.
morostheos Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='argent_paladin' date='Sep 19 2005, 08:05 PM'] It is in fact hard to find a solid, faithful psychologist who agrees with the Church on all important matters. [right][snapback]730339[/snapback][/right] [/quote] It is true that it is very hard, but they are out there! [url="http://www.ipsciences.edu"]http://www.ipsciences.edu[/url] - Institute for Psychological Sciences - Catholic Psychologist certifications and degrees [url="http://www.aoccs.org/"]http://www.aoccs.org/[/url] - Alpha Omega Clinic
Pio Nono Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 JMJ 9/19 - St. Januarius [quote name='MC Just' date='Sep 19 2005, 07:35 PM']also, the Vatican is gonna have to dig deeper, many of the seminaries, called "pink palaces" are going to diguise themselves as orthodox so they wont be detected. [right][snapback]730473[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I personally take offense at this. That's all I'll say about it. And yes, as a part of the board examinations to enter a seminary, a man is asked whether he is a homosexual - at least that's the process here at Mundelein. What they do with the information, I don't know. But, if you think about it...if a guy wants to get ordained bad enough, he just [i]might[/i] be willing to lie about his sexual orientation. Just a thought.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='MC Just' date='Sep 19 2005, 08:32 PM']cool. how about also banning those with liberal minded tendencies. you know those who are so open minded that their brains fall out. [right][snapback]730469[/snapback][/right] [/quote] one step at a time. I think this move by the Holy Father will help to breech grievances held against the Church for the priestly scandals of a few years ago.
Joey1976 Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 I knew a Priest who said that went he went into the seminary a lot of gay seminarians would hit on him and he left but ended up going back and becoming a Priest. But he said he couldn't rat on them but now i think they are allowing seminarians to tell about if they see gay tendancies but they will remain anonymous if they tell on someone. The Church is reforming and that is good. There is hope. Praise God that we belong to Jesus' Church.
Socrates Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='Joey1976' date='Sep 19 2005, 09:20 PM']I knew a Priest who said that went he went into the seminary a lot of gay seminarians would hit on him and he left but ended up going back and becoming a Priest. But he said he couldn't rat on them but now i think they are allowing seminarians to tell about if they see gay tendancies but they will remain anonymous if they tell on someone. The Church is reforming and that is good. There is hope. Praise God that we belong to Jesus' Church. [right][snapback]730583[/snapback][/right] [/quote] They shouldn't rat on them - they should kick their arses! Some have emphasized the need for "manly recreation" in seminaries - preferrably something where the pansies can get beat to a pulp!
shortnun Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 Hi all, new here so please bare with me as I get used to posting replys. I agree with the questions that have been posed so far- how does the Vatican plan on coming up with concrete criteria that must be "met" or "broken" as a means of controlling enterence to the priesthood? Furthermore, is this going too far? I am reminded of the Church's pastoral teachings on the matter of homosexuality- that it is not the [i]person[/i] the chuch disapproves of, nor their thoughts, but rather their actions. The sins that the celebrant (the priest) has committed do not impact the validity of the sacraments administer. I am in full support of the psychological and other tests that religious priests, brothers, and sisters must endure as a part of their vocation, but it concerns me that the church is focusing on such a minute detail that seems hard to regulate. Glad to see such great topics of conversation around here- what a gift to the theological conversations of the church.
Thumper Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='Socrates' date='Sep 19 2005, 10:29 PM']They shouldn't rat on them - they should kick their arses! Some have emphasized the need for "manly recreation" in seminaries - preferrably something where the pansies can get beat to a pulp! [right][snapback]730595[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Ah, the sweet smell of charity. Yes, beating someone to a pulp is the essence of true manhood and holiness so often exhibited by the great saints. No wonder women can't be priests--not enough upper body strength.
Era Might Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote]Some have emphasized the need for "manly recreation" in seminaries - preferrably something where the pansies can get beat to a pulp! [/quote] Ok, let's calm down on the rhetoric. [quote][Homosexual persons] must be accepted with respect, compassion, and sensitivity. --CCC #2358[/quote]
dspen2005 Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Sep 19 2005, 03:08 PM']a few of my friends have gone to seminary, and I got the impression that their evaluations were quite thorough... [right][snapback]730039[/snapback][/right] [/quote] for me i had to have both a psychological evaluation as well as a psychiatric evaluation, which included interviews, as well as psych tests -- MMPI, Meyers-Briggs, and 2 or 3 others....
dspen2005 Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='Joey1976' date='Sep 19 2005, 10:20 PM']I knew a Priest who said that went he went into the seminary a lot of gay seminarians would hit on him and he left but ended up going back and becoming a Priest. But he said he couldn't rat on them but now i think they are allowing seminarians to tell about if they see gay tendancies but they will remain anonymous if they tell on someone. The Church is reforming and that is good. There is hope. Praise God that we belong to Jesus' Church. [right][snapback]730583[/snapback][/right] [/quote] my parish priest back home told me stories of when he was at the seminary in baltimore -- it was known as the 'pink palace' because of the open homosexual activity that was going on while it was seemingly known by the rectors (so I have been told)..... historically it has happened... so i think this document from the Holy See is a much needed definition on the role Catholic moral teaching in the seminaries -- although, it is a sad commentary to see that such a document is required....
dspen2005 Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 (edited) i join the others in asking, though... the efficacy of this document -- at least in the US among most American seminaries. some will take it to heart, but will all???? if the colleges haven't heeded Ex Corde Ecclesia -- what example have the seminaries to follow? Edited September 20, 2005 by dspen2005
Thy Geekdom Come Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='argent_paladin' date='Sep 19 2005, 07:05 PM']Unfortunately, psych tests have been used to keep orthodox seminarians out. It is quite easy to do since the vast majority of psychologists think that voluntary celibacy is a symptom of mental illness, that orthodoxy is a sign of rigidity and that obedience is a sign of immaturity. Therefore, liberal seminaries can say that they are screening out the unfit, without saying that they have a bias. Very sad. It is in fact hard to find a solid, faithful psychologist who agrees with the Church on all important matters. [right][snapback]730339[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Well, but the Archdiocese of Omaha did the screening in my case, not the seminary. It was good screening.
dspen2005 Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 The religious order paid 2 very of doctors -- both are daily communicants, faithful Catholics -- so I didn't face the common secular, atheistic psychological approach as many do, unfortunately.
dspen2005 Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 The religious order paid 2 very of doctors -- both are daily communicants, faithful Catholics -- so I didn't face the common secular, atheistic psychological approach as many do, unfortunately.
MC Just Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 the attitude of some people is just unbelievable. Our church in Usa gets rocked, mocked and desicrated by scandals brought by homo priests and im hearing people talk about "tolerance"towards them. You have got to be kidding me. When you find the root of a problem you dont say"lets just keep it here and see if it gets better, you get rid of it. Sometimes you have to just DO IT. You can't keep letting it dwell because in many cases it just gets worse and this is a case where i has gotten worse. Sad part is, this "tolerance attitude" is obviously liberal. When will we ever learn from our mistakes.
Era Might Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 (edited) Addressing the homosexual sub-culture in Seminaries does not require foaming belligerence. "Pansies" need to get "beat to the pulp"? This really happens. Homosexual persons are beaten down and murdered. It's nothing to joke about. The last thing we need as a result of this document is belligerence toward homosexual persons. We must be all the more firm, but compassionate, because it is not going to be understood. There are enough crazy Christians who hold "fagg**" signs any chance they get. We need to disavow such tactics, and offer a truly Christian response, one which does not compromise the truth, but recognizes that truth without compassion and charity is dead. Edited September 20, 2005 by Era Might
Pio Nono Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 JMJ 9/19 - St. Januarius [quote name='MC Just' date='Sep 19 2005, 10:27 PM']the attitude of some people is just unbelievable. Our church in Usa gets rocked, mocked and desicrated by scandals brought by homo priests and im hearing people talk about "tolerance"towards them. You have got to be kidding me. When you find the root of a problem you dont say"lets just keep it here and see if it gets better, you get rid of it. Sometimes you have to just DO IT. You can't keep letting it dwell because in many cases it just gets worse and this is a case where i has gotten worse. Sad part is, this "tolerance attitude" is obviously liberal. When will we ever learn from our mistakes. [right][snapback]730660[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Kicking homosexuals out is not getting at the root of the problem. Look at the numbers - pederasty and homosexuality do not go hand in hand. There's a general principle that we can run by which says that if it's an easy target, it might be the wrong one. We can nip this in the bud by kicking out the homosexuals, but it's going to have two major effects: (1) Any homosexual presence in seminaries will not be deleted - it will be pushed underground. And that's how this whole &^%# thing got started to begin with! (2) The root of the problem will remain full and alive. I don't know what that root is, but it does not seem to be homosexuality. I don't agree with an attitude of "tolerance" when it comes to homosexual men participating in a gay subculture. But it's a little disconcerting when getting homosexuals out of seminary is seen as merciful, since putting them with all those men can't be good for their psyches. I'm sorry, but have you been to a youth group meeting ever? And does ice run through your veins? The vast majority of people that priests work with are women, so the argument holds no water in my mind. I am also not convinced by arguments that say "priests marry the Church" - that's a (somewhat modern) Western pietism and not a universal theological belief. If you're going to kick homosexuals out of the seminary (or at least prevent them from joining), I need to see a good argument to be convinced. I have yet to see an argument.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now