Fidei Defensor Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Sep 20 2005, 06:19 PM']Very true.... my concern still lies with the fact that the emotions they experience are gravely disordered in regards to sexuality. (I know masturbation is also disordered, but it is a result of concupiscence and ALL experience the effects of concupiscence). But without a proper understanding (a TRUE understanding and grasp of sexuality) I'm not sure a homosexual (even if non-practicing) priest would be able to properly direct and assist his parishoners. [right][snapback]731780[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yes, you are right. Again, i think we need to examine the whole person in reguards to how they behave, rather than just base it on their orientation. You cannot assume that someone will do something either way just on that.
Thumper Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Sep 20 2005, 07:18 PM']Homosexuals are capable of being emotionally healthy as their dis-ordered state allows them to be. [right][snapback]731778[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Alright, then how is that quantitatively different from what my own fallen state allows me to be? In other words, what measurement are we using? And is it just to apply it to an entire group of people?
Fides_et_Ratio Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='fidei defensor' date='Sep 20 2005, 07:22 PM']Yes, you are right. Again, i think we need to examine the whole person in reguards to how they behave, rather than just base it on their orientation. You cannot assume that someone will do something either way just on that. [right][snapback]731784[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Even in looking at the whole person, the fact that we already know they have a disordered sexual inclination (that stretches beyond concupiscence) ought to speak volumes. Adding to temptation is never a good thing.
Thumper Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Sep 20 2005, 07:18 PM']Homosexuals are capable of being emotionally healthy as their dis-ordered state allows them to be. All of us have various burdens, some are impediments to religious life , some are not. [right][snapback]731778[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Sorry, I responded before I read your edit, and in that case still do not understand why homosexuality (given emotional health) is an impediments to the religious life. What is it about that particular disorder that interferes with the vocation to the priesthood?
cmotherofpirl Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='Thumper' date='Sep 20 2005, 07:23 PM']Alright, then how is that quantitatively different from what my own fallen state allows me to be? In other words, what measurement are we using? And is it just to apply it to an entire group of people? [right][snapback]731785[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thumper I had to edit my post to finish it. I had a attack.
curtins Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='Pio Nono' date='Sep 19 2005, 08:39 PM']JMJ 9/19 - St. Januarius I personally take offense at this. That's all I'll say about it. And yes, as a part of the board examinations to enter a seminary, a man is asked whether he is a homosexual - at least that's the process here at Mundelein. What they do with the information, I don't know. But, if you think about it...if a guy wants to get ordained bad enough, he just [i]might[/i] be willing to lie about his sexual orientation. Just a thought. [right][snapback]730476[/snapback][/right] [/quote] what other reason would there be for really wanting to be ordained other than to serve Christ in that manner? And if thats the reason then you would be a great follower and believer of Christ- and so you probably wouldnt lie on a test like that.
Fidei Defensor Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Sep 20 2005, 06:24 PM']Even in looking at the whole person, the fact that we already know they have a disordered sexual inclination (that stretches beyond concupiscence) ought to speak volumes. Adding to temptation is never a good thing. [right][snapback]731788[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thats not necesarily fair though. Someone can have SSA, yet be entirely normal when compared to any regular straight male. The only issue here is that it adds extra temptation, which is a valid argument.
Thumper Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 Glad you survived the cat attack! They can be vicious . . . and yet, so cute. Nice kitty.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='fidei defensor' date='Sep 20 2005, 07:29 PM']Thats not necesarily fair though. Someone can have SSA, yet be entirely normal when compared to any regular straight male. The only issue here is that it adds extra temptation, which is a valid argument. [right][snapback]731798[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Perhaps, though in addition to valid I would also suggest very serious. Temptation is not something to be taken lightly. And that is my main concern. It does not seem a very intelligent, nor pastoral move to increase the temptation to sin for a man for any reason, however pious his intentions may be.
Fidei Defensor Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Sep 20 2005, 06:30 PM']Perhaps, though in addition to valid I would also suggest very serious. Temptation is not something to be taken lightly. And that is my main concern. It does not seem a very intelligent, nor pastoral move to increase the temptation to sin for a man for any reason, however pious his intentions may be. [right][snapback]731804[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Again, a valid arguement. But, reguardless of the kind of temptation, it is just a temptation. Satan cannot make you do anything. You dont have to participate in it. We must remember that we can draw our strength from Christ. But, yes, i again see your point. But, do you think that someone can overcome the temptation, over time with prayer, and be unaffected by it?
crusader1234 Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Sep 20 2005, 06:15 PM']What a silly comment to make. Pointing out that homosexual attraction is a dis-ordered state as stated by the Church makes us people who are faithful to what the church says, not people with an agenda who usually villify their opponents by calling them homophobes. [right][snapback]731771[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I completely agree with you, I completely agree with the Church. However, I'm unaware that the Church (or you, for that matter) goes around promoting 'beating up pansies'. My comment wasn't intended to contradict anything you've been saying, it was directed at those talking about 'beating up pansies' - I'm sorry if it didn't come across that way.
avemaria40 Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 i agree w/u fidei defensor, if someone can overcome that temptation and they feel God's call to be a priest, why should they not be ordained, and then have to live alone or something?
Pio Nono Posted September 21, 2005 Posted September 21, 2005 JMJ 9/20 - St. Andrew Kim Taegon Remembering also that, even if we do not like this pastoral decision of the Holy Father, we must give religious submission to it. He's doing it for the good of the Church. It's not that we "should" give religious submission, we [i]must[/i] for the good of the Church. I'm saying that it's not attacking the root of the problem (I like pspx's point about chanceries and rectors), but then again... I've been wrong a number of times before.
avemaria40 Posted September 21, 2005 Posted September 21, 2005 i understand that, and it's only by the grace of God that i have been able to accept the Church's teachings about women ordination and homosexual "marriage". Maybe this is one of those things.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted September 21, 2005 Posted September 21, 2005 [quote name='fidei defensor' date='Sep 20 2005, 07:35 PM']Again, a valid arguement. But, reguardless of the kind of temptation, it is just a temptation. Satan cannot make you do anything. You dont have to participate in it. We must remember that we can draw our strength from Christ. But, yes, i again see your point. But, do you think that someone can overcome the temptation, over time with prayer, and be unaffected by it? [right][snapback]731809[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yes, of course I think someone could overcome their homosexual attraction (by the grace of God), but until such a thing is managed, it would seem as though avoiding situations where one would be exposed to a great amount of temptation would be the more appropriate thing to do in such a case. It does not seem to me that it would be the case that homosexual attraction is something that could be easily managed and overcome in the seminary--the seminary is for growing in holiness, yes, but extraordinary struggles (ex. homosexuality which stretches beyond concupiscence brought on by the Fall) should be overcome and controlled before moving forward. The seminary is for learning theology and how to be a good priest, not for testing out whether one can or can not handle and control their homosexual temptations.
son_of_angels Posted September 21, 2005 Posted September 21, 2005 It is a sad thing to see such attitudes on display. Many of my friends in the past were openly homosexual. I disagreed with their behaviour, I witnessed the faith to them when I could, but they were still my friends. These people, even when in the most compromising of situations, still had the reason not to jump at the first male they saw. Homosexuals, even flagrant ones, usually are not sexual beasts that cannot prevent themselves from intercourse. [quote]but extraordinary struggles (ex. homosexuality which stretches beyond concupiscence brought on by the Fall) should be overcome and controlled before moving forward.[/quote] I agree, but the attitude many Catholics are taking suggests that homosexuality cannot be overcome, and even those who may have overcome it should be excluded from the priesthood.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted September 21, 2005 Posted September 21, 2005 As of now, we have to side with the Holy Father in his pastoral decision for the Church. The fact is that we do not know much truthfully about homosexuality, only that it is a disorder. All disorders can be overcome through grace. In my opinion, however, I strongly agree with the Holy Father's decision as it would not make sense to me to knowingly admit a man into the seminary before he has overcome such a serious disorder. Sexuality is a HUGE issue in the Church in these times and we need priests who are adaquately able to address that issue with a clear head. The view of the human person is integral to many aspects of the faith, a person who struggles with homosexual attraction has a slightly skewed view of the human person/relationships beyond the concupiscence we inherited through the Fall of Adam. Until it is dealt with properly and completely, avoiding the temptation and that which might contribute to temptation would seem to be the best course of action.
MC Just Posted September 21, 2005 Posted September 21, 2005 I cant even believe we are debating about it.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted September 21, 2005 Posted September 21, 2005 [quote name='MC Just' date='Sep 20 2005, 09:30 PM']I cant even believe we are debating about it. [right][snapback]732007[/snapback][/right] [/quote] On the one hand, neither can I. But... we debate women's ordination, artificial birth control, etc..... it was only time before we had to tackle the question of homosexuality as well. The world always wants to know "how far can we push the limit?"
Sojourner Posted September 21, 2005 Posted September 21, 2005 And, we should remember that we don't know the details of this particular instruction. It could well be that it has information which would affect this discussion that just hasn't yet been released.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now