Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Eucharistic Prayer in Silence?


Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' date='Oct 18 2005, 12:20 AM']Except for the fact that JPII is not calling for the rosary during mass.  That is a misinterpretation that Thumper has pointed out. [right][snapback]762086[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I never said JPII was calling for people to pray the Rosary during Mass, I claimed he said it doesn't not take away from the Liturgy, but instead helps one enter more deeply into the Mystery of the Liturgy.

Again, WHY would there be an objection (since the JPII document is specifically referring to objections at that point) about praying the Rosary before or after Mass? :huh:

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Oct 18 2005, 07:12 AM']I never said JPII was calling for people to pray the Rosary during Mass, I claimed he said it doesn't not take away from the Liturgy, but instead helps one enter more deeply into the Mystery of the Liturgy.

Again, WHY would there be an objection (since the JPII document is specifically referring to objections at that point) about praying the Rosary before or after Mass? :huh:
[right][snapback]762235[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I don't think anyone, anywhere, is saying you can't or even shouldn't pray the rosary before mass. I think I said it would be a great idea if someone would lead the rosary before every mass on Sunday.

Posted

I also don't see any problem squeezing in a decade after holy communion if you want that to be a prayer of thanksgiving for the Eucharist. I don't think you'd have time to pray the whole rosary before the blessing and benediction though. I sometimes say a hail mary, but typically just contemplate Who I have just received.

my biggest concern is people praying the rosary completely missing the responses throughout the mass, not paying attention to the readings or the prayers. That and the Church says it is not appropriate as hot stuff and Thumper have pointed out.

Course I suppose if you have a really bad homilist... :topsy: ;)

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Oct 18 2005, 08:16 AM']I don't think anyone, anywhere, is saying you can't or even shouldn't pray the rosary before mass. I think I said it would be a great idea if someone would lead the rosary before every mass on Sunday.
[right][snapback]762250[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
That is my point.

The excerpt from JPII's Letter on the Rosary at that point in the letter, is SPECIFICALLY addressing OBJECTIONS to the Rosary. Since there are no objections to praying the Rosary in relation to the Liturgy before or after Mass... what point is left to assume but during Mass?

[quote] also don't see any problem squeezing in a decade after holy communion if you want that to be a prayer of thanksgiving for the Eucharist. I don't think you'd have time to pray the whole rosary before the blessing and benediction though. I sometimes say a hail mary, but typically just contemplate Who I have just received.

my biggest concern is people praying the rosary completely missing the responses throughout the mass, not paying attention to the readings or the prayers. That and the Church says it is not appropriate as hot stuff and Thumper have pointed out. [/quote]
I don't think there would be a problem either, but the point was raised that we can't pray the Rosary "because it's not in the rubrics" (and setting aside the fact that the rubrics address the priest for a moment, this would mean that we cannot pray anything other than that which is provided in the Sacramentary. Thus, no Anima Christi for after Communion, but only the Communion antiphon, and certainly no Hail Mary's anywhere but before or after the Liturgical celebration. No prayers that aren't provided in the Sacramentary period. No wandering thoughts or devotions, save the exact words and postures provided in the Sacramentary... (which, again, really only addresses the priest)

Doesn't make much sense.
(and again, just to be clear, I am NOT advocating that the laity may do as they please during Mass)

Secondly, I think the distinction was already made about praying the Rosary to the exclusion of particpating in the Liturgy. If one were to sit in at Mass and pray the Rosary without paying attention to the Mass this would be wrong, yes. No one here has opted for the position of praying the Rosary instead of participating in the Liturgy. I don't see how this is an "either....or" proposition (i.e., Rosary OR Mass, you cannot do both... does one necessarily exclude the other?)?

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Oct 18 2005, 06:12 AM']I never said JPII was calling for people to pray the Rosary during Mass, I claimed he said it doesn't not take away from the Liturgy, but instead helps one enter more deeply into the Mystery of the Liturgy.

Again, WHY would there be an objection (since the JPII document is specifically referring to objections at that point) about praying the Rosary before or after Mass? :huh:
[right][snapback]762235[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


I don't think you'll find Thumper, Adam or myself arguing against praying the rosary before or after Mass. The rosary is the most powerful instrument of prayer that we have. JPII was a huge advocate for the rosary. Just not during Mass. And while this annoys PSPX, we don't have any contradictions between popes on the issue.

Again I would throw this out. If other sacraments are not able to overshadow the Liturgy of the Eucharist, why would the rosary?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...