Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

U.s. And Coalition Casualties


Recommended Posts

Posted

These are all the U.S. and Coalition Casualties as of December 8, 2003 that were relesed by the State Department. Many more have died everyday since this report was released. I was shocked that so many of them were so very young, most of were not even 40. Remember their souls and their families in your prayers, especially now because this is the first Christmas holiday that they will be missed by their families and friends.

This site puts a face on the lists of names that we hear about on the news. It's really really sad.

http://www.cnn.com/SPECIALS/2003/iraq/forces/casualties/

Posted

Wow, that is sad. Remind me again why these 100's of young men (and women) died?

Posted

Remind me why hundreds of thousands of Iraqis were slaughtered by the dictator.

Posted

Lack of timely global intervention/support for the uprising called for in 1991.

Don John of Austria
Posted

I hate to sound jaded but why are people getting all bent out of shap about this These casualties are NOTHING, this would be a single divisional engaugement in world war two( and not bad casualties for that) . I mean this is an increadably low death toll why are we so upset about it. We are doing fantasticly well.

Posted

I hate to sound jaded but why are people getting all bent out of shap about this These casualties are NOTHING, this would be a single divisional engaugement in world war two( and not bad casualties for that) . I mean this is an increadably low death toll why are we so upset about it. We are doing  fantasticly well.

If we were in a hot war, these would be low casualty numbers, but fighting has been called off for months now. This wasn't meant to be controversal, just a suggestion that it would be nice to remember these dead people and their families in prayer, especially since Christmas is coming up. The website and pics were added so you can know that it is a real person who lived a short life and died tragically that you are praying for, and also remember the soldiers that are still dying everyday.

Posted

If we were in a hot war, these would be low casualty numbers, but fighting has been called off for months now. This wasn't meant to be controversal, just a suggestion that it would be nice to remember these dead people and their families in prayer, especially since Christmas is coming up. The website and pics were added so you can know that it is a real person who lived a short life and died tragically that you are praying for, and also remember the soldiers that are still dying everyday.

I agree, and every soldier deserves to be more than a name, they deserve there picture to be seen and remembered.

Though this is a low casulaty count compared to ww1/ww2, i think most of us, including me under estimated the death toll this war would bring...

Don John of Austria
Posted

We are in a hot war, My father in law just got back. He is in his fifties and was in combat-- alot. It is a hot war. I don't mean to belittle the tragity to the families who lost people, but we Crushed a country this is Nationally (agian not personally) not much ofa sacrifice. We should be thankful, not complaining.

Posted

I have a question. Would you support the war if none of our guys died? Would you be more in favor of the war if we could guarantee no American casualties? I'm not implying you feel this way M.Sigga but sometimes I think that the way liberals talk about the casualites and the soldiers is just opportunistic.

Personally, I am more supportive of the war because of our casualties. These men are dying to make other men free. There is something noble about their sacrifice.

Don John of Austria
Posted

most of these men are dying because they wanted money to go to college. They are mercenaries fighting in a mercenary army, there is nothing noble about it ecept in the since of giveing good value to your employer. Are all of these men mere mercs, no but most are, and so now they have to fight. Well what did they ecpext when they signed up. Maybe this seems cynical but I have know plenty of guys in the army and most where just mercs plain and simple.

Posted

Even a mercenary can have a noble death if its for a noble cause. Their intentions might not be noble, but their sacrifice is.

Don John of Austria
Posted

Well I'll give you that, if your cause is noble even an merc can have an honorable death. D o you really think this cause is noble? I am not sayig it isn;t I just would like to know why you think it is.

hyperdulia again
Posted

this isn't a noble cause. truly going to war to liberate the iraqi people would have been noble

i am praying for all who have died and wwill die in this war.

Posted

Whether this cause is noble is certainly open for debate Hyper, and neither side pontificating is going to solve anything.

Personally, I do believe that the liberation of Iraq i noble, the following are some of my reasons:

The Iraqi people were under much persecution. (I am fully aware that there are other countries that have persecution and we haven't invaded them).

The threat of radical islam is a serious one to the peace and security of the world. Establishing a democratic presence in the Middle East, directly next to the most radical countries (Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Syria which all border Iraq) sends a clear message to the radical factions that we will take this threat seriously.

I believe (however misguided one may perceive this view) that our being in Iraq will increase the freedom of other Islamic states. I believe that since the men and women of these countries are indoctrinated into an ideolgy and have their access to information controlled that they will only be exposed the ideas of freedom and democracy and liberty by their immediate and effective presence in their midst. If Iraq is a success (this is of course not guaranteed) then it will make it clear to the people yearning to be free (this is most evident in Iran) that democratic government that avoids radical Islamic tendencies is a better option than what they presently have.

Posted

I have a question. Would you support the war if none of our guys died?  Would you be more in favor of the war if we could guarantee no American casualties?  I'm not implying you feel this way M.Sigga but sometimes I think that the way liberals talk about the casualites and the soldiers is just opportunistic.

Personally, I am more supportive of the war because of our casualties.  These men are dying to make other men free.  There is something noble about their sacrifice.

I guess my anti-Iraqi war opinion has drifted into this post. My only intent for this post was to pray for dead troops and their families at Christmas time and I didn't post anything political because that would have been opportunistic and cheasy, but I'm happy to explain how I feel if you really want to know lol.

I will only defend the idea of going to war if I feel there is a just cause. Since I don't believe this was a just war, there is no way that I will ever support the original motive of going into a hot war with Iraq. I don't believe this is a hot war anymore, especially that can be compared to WWI or WWII. It has turned into a guerrilla war like Vietnam, where our soldiers do not always know who the enemy is anymore.

I support the American and Coalition efforts today that are trying to clean up this mess, and I support Bush's efforts to fix this situation as quickly as possible so American lives and Iraqi lives can return to normal.

Less casualties is always good, but it doesn't sway my opinion. If a war is just, then it must happen no matter the cost.

Please don't turn this into a debate and respect my Open Mic original post. Remember these souls and thier families in your prayers. Their families must be experiencing overwhelming pride that their sons and daughters died defending the freedom of foreign strangers, but they must also be feeling a sense of devistation and lost. Thanks.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Remember our soldiers are volunteers.

The thousands who died under Iraq terrorism were not.

They ALL need our prayers.

Posted

The threat of radical islam is a serious one to the peace and security of the world.  Establishing a democratic presence in the Middle East, directly next to the most radical countries (Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Syria which all border Iraq) sends a clear message to the radical factions that we will take this threat seriously. 

I believe (however misguided one may perceive this view) that our being in Iraq will increase the freedom of other Islamic states.  I believe that since the men and women of these countries are indoctrinated into an ideolgy and have their access to information controlled that they will only be exposed the ideas of freedom and democracy and liberty by their immediate and effective presence in their midst.  If Iraq is a success (this is of course not guaranteed) then it will make it clear to the people yearning to be free (this is most evident in Iran) that democratic government that avoids radical Islamic tendencies is a better option than what they presently have.

I have to take issue with this point, although I agree that the persecuted must be liberated.

I think that to violently tear down the only secular government in the region and to replace it with a democracy dominated by muslims is a poor way to stabilize a region of growing fundamentalist zeal.

I think it sends the message that, rather than attacking countries which directly fund and participate in terrorism in the Western world (Saudi Arabia, Syria, Iran) that America will attack a target of opportunity which historically has been supported by other western nations. This DOES send a message to those countries, but at the expense of a country less guilty of the support of terrorism.

As a Canadian, I do not support the war in Iraq. HOWEVER, I also do not support my country's position. It has turned it's backs on it's traditional allies and made a fool of itself to garner favor among the *expletive* French and Germans. I support the current policies of America concerning Iraq, even not letting other nations have rebuilding contracts.

Side Note: haha, that last bit sounds like American rhetoric towards Canada in 1812. "If we invade, they will FLOCK to us!" No one likes being invade. As much as I love you guys, If you invaded my home, I'd defend it.

Posted

First of all, you are misunderstanding serious considerations.

We do not know if the Democracy that will be in place will be one of radical Islam. In fact, Democracy cannot sustain radical Islam. Islam is an ideology, it is unsustainable in Democratic form. Name one Islamic democracy.

I am sure that the families of the 61,000 residents of Baghdad who were murdered by Sadaam Hussein would disagree with your contention that the invasion of Iraq has been to their expense. The complaints you are reading in the media are biased. Most Iraqis do not want the Coalition forces to pull out. In fact just yesterday the Patriarch of the Chaldean Church strongly urged the Coalition forces to maintain their current presence in Iraq. His point was that whatever the Americans were trying to do, it was working. Things were in fact better.

Finally, I do not think that America is so simple as to think "If we Invade, they will flcck to us." That wasn't my point. My point was that Democracy, freedom, liberty, and the rule of self-government are so attractive that they will lead to real change in the Arab world.

Most people don't seem to realize this, but the rule of radical Islam is a recent phenomenon. It began in the 1970's with the Wahabbie control of the House of Saud in Saudi Arabia and the the Ayatollah Khomeni's overtrhow of the Shah in Iran. Both of these things happened in the last 30 years. And in those 30 years radical Islam has been spreading like a cancer across the world where Islam is a presence (Africa, the Middle East, Asia). With a serious effort, this tide can be turned, but I think it will take cooperation from democratic countries dedicated to freedom (here I would only put Italy, United States, Poland (and some former communist countries in eastern europe), Australia, and England)

and the Christian churches. This means that Eastern Orthodoxy is going to have to become much more evangelical in nature, much less nationalistic (which I hope will lead to the eventual reunification of the eastern and western churches) and Roman Catholicism is going to have to confront seriously the threat that Islam poses against the faith. Evangelical Chrisitan churches will also be a part of this effort.

Them's some of my thoughts.

Posted

I didn't mean to say the PEOPLE of Iraq did not benefit, but the country itself is now gone.

However, radical Islam has been around since 661 AD, when Mohammed took over control of Mecca.

I also don't believe that democracy and Islam can mix, just as democracy and Christianity do not mix all of the time.

The concepts of freedom and liberty etc. are western ideas. The onset of democracy will not make the peoples who live under dictatorships immediately want it.

The World Powers have been trying to install democracy in the Middle East since the 19th Century, and Radical Islamic governments and revolutions have toppled parliaments and constitutions almost every time. The only nations which have endured democratically are Egypt and Turkey, because these countries have been most exposed to Western cultural influence.

I also do not support this western cultural influence because, although may be democratically instituted (i.e. at the will and pleasure of the people) it is certainly not Christian and is detrimental to their societies. What am I talking about? Western Cultural influence in these places is Wealth, Power, Smut, and the pursuit of all things Hollywood. This means Birth Control, Abortion and the like.

I honestly don't know what is better: fervent islamic religion, or sinful western attitudes.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...