M.SIGGA Posted December 11, 2003 Author Posted December 11, 2003 I really didn't want to debate this on this thread, but now I have to. The establishment of the State of Israel is the key to the rise of radical Islam because it created a link between the hatred of Sunnis and Shiates where they could agree their territory and religion was being abused and invaded. You forgot to mention the most important factor!!! The complaints you are reading in the media are biased. Most Iraqis do not want the Coalition forces to pull out. In fact just yesterday the Patriarch of the Chaldean Church strongly urged the Coalition forces to maintain their current presence in Iraq. His point was that whatever the Americans were trying to do, it was working. Things were in fact better. The Chaldean Patriarch would naturally want to keep Americans around as long as possible b/c as soon as the U.S./Coalition forces leave, the Shiate majority is going to have his head on a stick. Most people don't seem to realize this, but the rule of radical Islam is a recent phenomenon. It began in the 1970's with the Wahabbie control of the House of Saud in Saudi Arabia and the the Ayatollah Khomeni's overtrhow of the Shah in Iran. Both of these things happened in the last 30 years. And in those 30 years radical Islam has been spreading like a cancer across the world where Islam is a presence (Africa, the Middle East, Asia). All of Islam is not the same; you haven't pointed this out and it's essential to understand the differences to understand Middle Eastern religious politics. Shiate Islam is the radical form of Islam with a primary focus soley on the written word of the Koran without consideration to context and interpretation (sort of like Sola Scriptura is for Protestants). Sunnis interpret the Koran and adjust it's teaching for everyday life. Iraq is a Shiate majority and there is no way a Shiate Muslim nation can function with a democracy because it is against the Koran - a government has to be incorporated with the people's religion in the Shiate branch of Islam. They also hate each other. Ayotollah is a Shiate leader; the Shah was Sunni. The Kurds are Shiate and Sadaam killed and tortured them because he is Sunni. AlQueda is Shiate and they hate the west because the Koran says everyone who attacks Islam (the West and Israel) is the infidel. Turkey and Egypt are western-friendly Islamic democracies only because there is a Sunni majority - there is no powerful Ayatollah in those nations. Sunnis are somewhat tolerant of Christians, and they were tolerant of Jews until the 50's when Israel became an independant state. Christianity only flourished in parts of the Middle East with a Sunni majority. Saudi Arabia is a Shiate majority and a fake ally that is only helping America because the stability of their economy depends on American investments - their monarchy is guilty of more human rights violations than Sadaam, but we can't cut them off because too much money is involved. I hope and pray for some form of stabalized government because a democracy cannot work and will not work in Iraq.
M.SIGGA Posted December 11, 2003 Author Posted December 11, 2003 Remember our soldiers are volunteers. The thousands who died under Iraq terrorism were not. They ALL need our prayers. You are absolutly right and this brings back the original purpose of the thread; 6 children 2 parents were killed today in liberation efforts. They were all Islamic and didn't know Jesus so pray for their souls and for their extended family. This might look like a small number of people, but a whole family was completely wiped out. If I had pics I would post them. If this happened in America there would be national outrage. Pray for peace.
God Conquers Posted December 11, 2003 Posted December 11, 2003 Actually, Radical Islam has been around much longer than Israel, however Israel has been the catalyst for the most recent 20th century conflicts. Shiite muslims and Sunni Muslims will band together towards a common goal if that goal is destruction of their common enemies. Saudi Arabians are Wahhabi Muslims, a form of Islam which is more fundamental and based on personal revelation through the Quran and the hadith (Stories and laws of Mohammed) which actually makes them a variation of Sunni rather than Shia, although they do not depend as much on ulama (muslim teachers/clerics). Anyways, you're right, what's importa
God Conquers Posted December 11, 2003 Posted December 11, 2003 sorry, got cut off there. What's important now is that we band together to ask healing on those nations. They have been scarred by war, their religious differences and exploitation for several centuries, and definately need the light of Christ.
superkiddo7 Posted December 14, 2003 Posted December 14, 2003 Radical Islam? What kinda xenophobic fearmongering are you into? How is Iraq connected to Afganistan? Provide proof... if you cannot then I suggest you check your facts. To make charges without making citations is to outright lie and slander. Bare in mind that we were the ones that put Saddam in power in the 80's and Rumsfeld met and shook hands with Saddam http://www.gwu.edu/~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB82/ To kill innocents for our stupid mistakes is to be murderers twice over. As for the rightiousness of mecenaries - isn't that what so called "radical islam" calls for? 9-11 anyone anyone? If you support mercenaries and soldiers then why not the 9-11 highjackers? Moral absolutes smell of elderberries when you don't feel like living up to them, don't they?
superkiddo7 Posted December 14, 2003 Posted December 14, 2003 . We do not know if the Democracy that will be in place will be one of radical Islam. In fact, Democracy cannot sustain radical Islam. Islam is an ideology, it is unsustainable in Democratic form. Name one Islamic democracy. You could replace the word islam and islamic with Christian and it would actually be true. Christianity is a better example of a failed ideology as a way of governing - because christianity actually had the benefit of the reformation - which Islam has not had. It's like comparing a 2 year old to a 20 year old and saying that the twenty year old will always be better than the two year old. From that perpective it will because the two year old has yet to develop. But like any statistic it is a very skewed way of looking at the world more suited to propaganda than to the real world. Actually I can name one islamic democracy - Turkey. Secular in government but overwhelmingly islamic.
M.SIGGA Posted December 14, 2003 Author Posted December 14, 2003 You could replace the word islam and islamic with Christian and it would actually be true. Christianity is a better example of a failed ideology as a way of governing - because christianity actually had the benefit of the reformation - which Islam has not had. It's like comparing a 2 year old to a 20 year old and saying that the twenty year old will always be better than the two year old. From that perpective it will because the two year old has yet to develop. But like any statistic it is a very skewed way of looking at the world more suited to propaganda than to the real world. Actually I can name one islamic democracy - Turkey. Secular in government but overwhelmingly islamic. Islam is based almost absolutly on works, which in itself means it cannot be compared to Christianity. The reason of past Christian holy wars and Islamic jihad are also two completely different things. How does the Reformation tie into this? You really lost me here, please clarify and explain your statement. Thanks.
hyperdulia again Posted December 14, 2003 Posted December 14, 2003 Mary Immaculate, may thy foot which crushed the head of Satann crush all heresy.
Good Friday Posted December 14, 2003 Posted December 14, 2003 Although the original post did not, I think this thread now belongs in the Debate Table. And no, I'm not going to add my opinion on the Iraq war because it would be futile (I've been here and done this). Just throwing in my two cents that this should be moved to the Debate Table.
Hermione Posted December 14, 2003 Posted December 14, 2003 I believe (however misguided one may perceive this view) that our being in Iraq will increase the freedom of other Islamic states. I believe that since the men and women of these countries are indoctrinated into an ideolgy and have their access to information controlled that they will only be exposed the ideas of freedom and democracy and liberty by their immediate and effective presence in their midst. If Iraq is a success (this is of course not guaranteed) then it will make it clear to the people yearning to be free (this is most evident in Iran) that democratic government that avoids radical Islamic tendencies is a better option than what they presently have. If Iraq had invaded America and tried to impose on you an ideology that a better world came with suppression and that the freedom you grew up with was no more than blind idealism that led to a corrupted world, would you actually take them at their word? Would the rest of the Western world gradually mould themselves on the middle east just cos Iraq took over America? Just as you think the men and women of the middle east are indoctrinated into an ideology which they have accepted without question (i.e. being oppressed), they might feel the same way about Americans~ they might think you guys've been blinded by your unquestioned freedom~ What you think is good for the middle-easterns might not exactly be what they want or need...
M.SIGGA Posted December 14, 2003 Author Posted December 14, 2003 I initially wanted this to be a peaceful and prayerful thread and not a debate but it turned out to happen anyway. I don't even think people check out the link on the first post which is the most important thing And no one is praying b/c they are debating. Next time it's going straight to the prayer forum. I would rather Dust just close the topic.
cmotherofpirl Posted December 14, 2003 Posted December 14, 2003 It either needs closed or moved to the back alley.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted December 14, 2003 Posted December 14, 2003 Not all Shiate Muslims are radical. Shaite has been one of the two major Islamic factions since the early days of Islam. Islam split into Sunni and Shiate after disagreement over who the caliph was to be after the death of the five "rightly guided caliphs". Excuse my atrocious spelling.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now