cappie Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 Pope drops a traditional papal title Pope Benedict XVI has renounced one of the traditional titles of the Roman Pontiff by dropping the title "Patriarch of the West." Catholic World News reports that the new 2006 edition of the Annuario Pontificio, the official Vatican yearbook, carries 8 other traditional titles for the Pope, but does not include the "Patriarch of the West" designation that appeared in previous editions. The first ceremonial copy of the Annuario was presented to Pope Benedict on 18 February 2006; the volume will not go on sale to the public until mid-March. The Pope is now identified in the Annuario as: "Bishop of Rome, Vicar of Jesus Christ, Successor of the Prince of the Apostles, Supreme Pontiff of the Universal Church, Primate of Italy, Archbishop and Metropolitan of the Roman province, Sovereign of the State of the Vatican City, Servant of the Servants of God." Pope Benedict, who reportedly made the decision himself to drop the title, evidently wished to eliminate any notion that the Holy See represents the Church of "the West," and is therefore separate from the Eastern tradition. The designation "Patriarch of the West," which traditionally appeared in that list of titles just before "Primate of Italy," has rarely been employed since the Great Schism of 1054, which separated the Orthodox churches from the Holy See. It was introduced into papal nomenclature in 1870, at the time of the First Vatican Council. Pope Benedict chose to remove the title at a time when discussions with the Orthodox churches have centred on the issue of papal primacy. The Holy Father wishes to emphasise the service that the Bishop of Rome performs for the entire Christian community, as the focus of unity in the universal Church. SOURCE Benedict XVI drops a traditional papal title (Catholic World News 1/3/06)
Myles Domini Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 (edited) This I didn't expect particularly from a Ressourcement scholar like Benedict XVI. Together with the Patriarchate of the North (Constantinople), the South (Alexandria), the East (Antioch) and the Centre (Jerusalem), the Patriarchate of the West was one of the 5 canonical jurdistictions agreed upon by the Council of Chalcedon. The idea of 'pentarchy' though completely unworkable in our times thanks to the fracturing of all the Eastern Patriarchates besides Constantinople and the spread of autocephaly in the Orient is especially cherished by the Orthodox. I dont know if they will understand Papa Bene's reasoning... Edited March 1, 2006 by Myles
dspen2005 Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 what's up w/ the Holy Father removing that title after the Pope's name? i can't say that I like it.... the CWN reported that it was in an effort, probably, to promote greater dialogue w/ the East. THis is just speculation since the Vatican has not given a reason behind the change. I think, if anything, it in a way diminishes the idea of the Pope in the fullness and completeness of his role as the Supreme Pontiff. In all due respect to the Holy Father -- b/c I am stoked about the guy -- are to expect that we may have to consider removing, 'Vicar of Christ' from his title?
Pio Nono Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 JMJ 3/1 - Ash Wednesday From what I understand, removing the title actually enhances Benedict's role as the Supreme Pontiff - by dropping the title, he's reaffirming that he's not just "Patriarch of the West," but the whole shootin' match.
dspen2005 Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 well, we knew that... b/c of the other title, "Supreme Pontiff of the Universal Church" (or something along those lines...)..... wouldn 't have both enhance? one building upon the other, maybe?
Myles Domini Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 [quote name='Pio Nono' date='Mar 2 2006, 02:52 AM']JMJ 3/1 - Ash Wednesday From what I understand, removing the title actually enhances Benedict's role as the Supreme Pontiff - by dropping the title, he's reaffirming that he's not just "Patriarch of the West," but the whole shootin' match. [right][snapback]901207[/snapback][/right] [/quote] In terms of Oecumenical dialogue thats more of a drawback than a blessing.
MilesChristi Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 His Holiness is full of little surprises. Who knows what he'll do next... :
Aloysius Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 yes he is... some of them very strange I thought the same as Myles when I first saw this. The only reasoning I could pick up was perhaps it is an attempt to make it easier to elect an eastern rite bishop to the papacy... but in that case I should think His Holiness should appoint another bishop as Patriarch of the West. Is he still considered Patriarch of the Latin Rite then? Just not 'of the west'? Other than a future eastern rite bishop, this move has me scratching my head. I suppose it's just the title patriarch of the west, and not the role of patriarch of the Latin Rite, that he dropped. And maybe that would make it easier for an Eastern Rite patriarch to ascend to the Papacy and in some way remain patriarch of his respective rite and there would be another that would ascend as patriarch of the Latin Rite that would be interesting...
Pio Nono Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 JMJ 3/2 - Thursday after Ash Wednesday Let's remember, too, that the title "Patriarch" has had a very nebulous meaning in the history of the West. For instance, Venice and Milan have traditionally been patriarchates, and if I remember right there is a "Patriarch of the West Indies" that hasn't been filled since the 1960s. Not sure of that last one, though. It's just not an important title for us. :
Era Might Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 Just speculation, but I wonder if this is maybe an attempt to separate the Church from "the West" in Muslim eyes, so that she is not identified with the military efforts of Western nations (eg, the United States), and a reenactment of the Crusades doesn't take place. That might be a little far-fetched (would Muslims even know of the title?), but I put it out there anyway.
Aloysius Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 I was dancin around the net and saw some speculation that he might be thinking about dividing up the west into other patriarchs... apparently as Ratzinger he expressed support for that idea... meaning it's possible we might see a real dramatic shift of Church structure with the institution of a patriarch of Africa, Asia... maybe even South America, and if the Anglicans ever get rid of that pesky little female ordination thing an Anglican patriarch as well. [url="http://donjim.blogspot.com/2006/03/patriarch-of-west.html"]http://donjim.blogspot.com/2006/03/patriarch-of-west.html[/url] [url="http://ansa.it/main/notizie/awnplus/english/news/2006-03-01_981469.html"]http://ansa.it/main/notizie/awnplus/englis...-01_981469.html[/url] [url="http://www.orthodoxytoday.org/blog/?p=925"]http://www.orthodoxytoday.org/blog/?p=925[/url] [quote]The image of a centralized state which the Catholic church presented right up to the council does not flow only from the Petrine office, but from its strict amalgamation with the patriarchal function which grew ever stronger in the course of history and which fell to the bishop of Rome for the whole of Latin Christendom. The uniform canon law, the uniform liturgy, the uniform appointment of bishops by the Roman center: all these are things which are not necessarily part of the primacy but result from the close union of the two offices. For that reason, the task to consider for the future will be to distinguish again and more clearly between the proper function of the successor of Peter and the patriarchal office and, where necessary, to create new patriarchates and to detach them from the Latin church. To embrace unity with the pope would then no longer mean being incorporated into a uniform administration, but only being inserted into a unity of faith and communio, in which the pope is acknowledged to have the power to give binding interpretations of the revelation given in Christ whose authority is accepted whenever it is given in definitive form.[/quote]
Pio Nono Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 JMJ 3/2 - Thursday after Ash Wednesday [quote]...and, where necessary, to create new patriarchates and to detach them from the Latin church...[/quote] Yeah, sounds like reaching out to Protestants. An Anglican patriarch would be pretty cool...but other than that there's no substantial quasi-church apart from Rome in the West. The Mozarabs aren't a church, and the Ambrosians already have their own Patriarch. It'll be interesting to follow this one. Ratzinger has elsewhere referred to Chicago as the "New Rome" in the past...? Although "Patriarch of Santiago de Compostela" would be awesome, too...
Era Might Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 Chicago? If anyone in America were to become a Patriarch, I would imagine it would be the Archbishop of New York. I think John Paul called it the "capital of the world". :
Pio Nono Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 JMJ 3/2 - Thursday after Ash Wednesday [quote name='Aloysius' date='Mar 2 2006, 05:34 AM']meaning it's possible we might see a real dramatic shift of Church structure with the institution of a patriarch of Africa, Asia... maybe even South America, and if the Anglicans ever get rid of that pesky little female ordination thing an Anglican patriarch as well. [right][snapback]901359[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Just thought of this...could this have anything to do with the fact that Benedikt has called the cardinals to Rome on 23 March?
Aloysius Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 ooooooooooOOOOooooooooooooo I'm not sure we can expect things to be moving that quickly... but you never know
Pio Nono Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 JMJ 3/2 - Thursday after Ash Wednesday [quote name='Aloysius' date='Mar 2 2006, 06:44 AM']I'm not sure we can expect things to be moving that quickly... but you never know [right][snapback]901373[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Normally I'd agree...but considering how Benedikt hasn't [i]done[/i] much over the past year, I figure this may have been in the works for a while.
Cam42 Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 I just spoke with a friend of mine who teaches in Rome and here is what he has to say..... [quote name='David-Maria A. Jaeger' date=' ofm, jcd']Discussions had been going on in Rome for some years before the decision was made to omit the title "Patriarch of the West" from the Annuario Pontificio. Its appearance there had given rise to curious misunderstanding and misinterpretations. Thus, for example, there were those "progressive" Catholic writers who hypothesised that primatial authority of the Pope over the whole Church as such was really quite circumscribed, and that mostly the authority that the Pope exercised over bishops and their flocks was rather the authority of a Patriarch, in this case the "Patriarch of the West " (thus implicitly denying his authority over "the East"). Others went on to identify here a key to future ecumenical consensus, distinguishing between the Pope's far reaching authority as "Patriarch of the West" and what they hypothesised would be his very much more limited authority beyond "the West", i.e. beyond the Latin Church. Some Orthodox writers were also tempted to re-propose the theory of the "Pentarchy" with Rome, the "Patriarchal See of the West", being essentially no different from the "other four Patriarchates" of antiquity, except perhaps by precedence of honour etc. And even one or two less well informed clergymen of the Eastern Catholic Churches, speaking of the present Catholic communion, could occasionally be heard, rather fantastically, to speak of the Pope as being at some level just another Catholic Patriarch at the head of one of the Catholic Churches sui iuris. Now my friend, Confrère and colleague, Father Adrian Garuti, OFM, an ecclesiologist, who was head of the doctrinal office at the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (under Prefect Ratzinger) and now teaches both at the Lateran and our own Antonianum, published a number of articles, and a book, on this subject of the "Patriarch of the West", and I think those who wish to study it in greater depth would be best advised to consult those studies. In terms of all the areas of discourse involved: ecclesiology, ecumenism and canon law, I think the omission of "Patriarch of the West" should be a great help, preventing discourse from straying into dead-ends, and helping to focus more clearly on actual issues. It is not meant "against" anything or anyone. The theological differences of opinion within the Church, and the doctrinal divergences with the separate brethren, are as they are, and are not affected one way or the other by this removal of potentially misleading signposts; discussion of the universal Primatial office of the Successor of Peter can only benefit from a clearer focus on the actual issue: The Catholic Church's belief that, precisely as the Successor of St. Peter [and not by any other title emerging within the Church] the Bishop of Rome has ordinary, full, universal, and immediate truly episcopal jurisdiction over all the Pastors and faithful, over the whole Church and all the churches. Whether others agree or disagree, this is the issue, and not some irrelevancy such as the nonexistent attributes of an essentially superfluous honorific such as "Patriarch of the West." It goes without saying that there was nothing false or wrong about the title as a customary honorific, and it might very well have stayed. Just like the "Primate of Italy" (which is also essentially meaningless, since "primates" in the Church are historically "born" papal legates, which was ever the whole meaning of the office of primate inherent in certain Sees of Christendom). However, once it became occasion of "scandal", frequently misunderstood in damaging ways, it was best for it to go.[/quote] He is on the Faculty of Canon Law; Pontifical University "Antonianum" -Rome. I think that it is a very good explaination.....
dspen2005 Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 indeed it was.... i guess my dismay was at the seeming removal of the pomp surrounding the person of the Pope... for me, I wish, at times, that we would bring back Papal Coronations and the practice of carrying him on his throne.... oh man, that would be a sight. would it not?
Era Might Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 A blogger pointed out this passage from Ratzinger's note on the expression "Sister Church" when he was Prefect of the CDF: [quote]In Christian literature, the expression begins to be used in the East when, from the fifth century, the idea of the Pentarchy gained ground, according to which there are five Patriarchs at the head of the Church, with the Church of Rome having the first place among these patriarchal sister Churches. In this connection, however, it needs to be noted that no Roman Pontiff ever recognized this equalization of the sees or accepted that only a primacy of honour be accorded to the See of Rome. It should be noted too that this patriarchal structure typical of the East never developed in the West. [/quote] [url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20000630_chiese-sorelle_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congrega...sorelle_en.html[/url]
dUSt Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 He dropped patriarch of the west because he's going to come up with the brand new "Patriarch of the Whole World". Duh.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now