Cam42 Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 I posted this on the other thread, but I think that it bears repeating..... I just spoke with a friend of mine who teaches in Rome and here is what he has to say..... [quote name='David-Maria A. Jaeger @ ofm' date=' jcd']Discussions had been going on in Rome for some years before the decision was made to omit the title "Patriarch of the West" from the Annuario Pontificio. Its appearance there had given rise to curious misunderstanding and misinterpretations. Thus, for example, there were those "progressive" Catholic writers who hypothesised that primatial authority of the Pope over the whole Church as such was really quite circumscribed, and that mostly the authority that the Pope exercised over bishops and their flocks was rather the authority of a Patriarch, in this case the "Patriarch of the West " (thus implicitly denying his authority over "the East"). Others went on to identify here a key to future ecumenical consensus, distinguishing between the Pope's far reaching authority as "Patriarch of the West" and what they hypothesised would be his very much more limited authority beyond "the West", i.e. beyond the Latin Church. Some Orthodox writers were also tempted to re-propose the theory of the "Pentarchy" with Rome, the "Patriarchal See of the West", being essentially no different from the "other four Patriarchates" of antiquity, except perhaps by precedence of honour etc. And even one or two less well informed clergymen of the Eastern Catholic Churches, speaking of the present Catholic communion, could occasionally be heard, rather fantastically, to speak of the Pope as being at some level just another Catholic Patriarch at the head of one of the Catholic Churches sui iuris. Now my friend, Confrère and colleague, Father Adrian Garuti, OFM, an ecclesiologist, who was head of the doctrinal office at the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (under Prefect Ratzinger) and now teaches both at the Lateran and our own Antonianum, published a number of articles, and a book, on this subject of the "Patriarch of the West", and I think those who wish to study it in greater depth would be best advised to consult those studies. In terms of all the areas of discourse involved: ecclesiology, ecumenism and canon law, I think the omission of "Patriarch of the West" should be a great help, preventing discourse from straying into dead-ends, and helping to focus more clearly on actual issues. It is not meant "against" anything or anyone. The theological differences of opinion within the Church, and the doctrinal divergences with the separate brethren, are as they are, and are not affected one way or the other by this removal of potentially misleading signposts; discussion of the universal Primatial office of the Successor of Peter can only benefit from a clearer focus on the actual issue: The Catholic Church's belief that, precisely as the Successor of St. Peter [and not by any other title emerging within the Church] the Bishop of Rome has ordinary, full, universal, and immediate truly episcopal jurisdiction over all the Pastors and faithful, over the whole Church and all the churches. Whether others agree or disagree, this is the issue, and not some irrelevancy such as the nonexistent attributes of an essentially superfluous honorific such as "Patriarch of the West." It goes without saying that there was nothing false or wrong about the title as a customary honorific, and it might very well have stayed. Just like the "Primate of Italy" (which is also essentially meaningless, since "primates" in the Church are historically "born" papal legates, which was ever the whole meaning of the office of primate inherent in certain Sees of Christendom). However, once it became occasion of "scandal", frequently misunderstood in damaging ways, it was best for it to go.[/quote] He is on the Faculty of Canon Law; Pontifical University "Antonianum" -Rome. I think that it is a very good explaination.....
Cam42 Posted March 2, 2006 Posted March 2, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' date='Mar 2 2006, 08:23 AM']Chicago? If anyone in America were to become a Patriarch, I would imagine it would be the Archbishop of New York. I think John Paul called it the "capital of the world". : [right][snapback]901365[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Actually, it would be Baltimore.....
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now