Brother Adam Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 I've decided to set this poll up here instead of in the debate table because I'm not looking for a debate, and I don't want this thread to cause complications in our dialogue with non-Catholics on that forum who already have their hands full with a number of other important topics like salvation. As I told another PM'er, this has always just been a non-issue for me. I've never decided I believe in any of the apparitions, nor have I ever really studied them, nor do I outright reject the possibility of an apparition happening. But studying our faith, there have been many more pressing topics. I think the vast majority of the "Look its Jesus in an oil stain on the drive way" are the workings of overactive imaginations. so, pro-apparition people, why do you believe in them? I'm looking for more than 'the Church says so". Blind faith is fine, but I've decided in the little spare time I have to read up a little on this topic since it means so much to so many Catholics. What apparitions are you most fond of, and why? How are these apparitions Christocentric (CT 5-6)? How do they move others to faith. I know I'm going to get a lot of generalities, so I'm really looking for specific instances from different apparitions, and no, I don't have time to read a book, though I will do some short reading, though I'd prefer not to be linked to death. I'd like to hear from you personally as well. Blessings, Adam
Quietfire Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 Im indifferent, to be honest. I dont know enough about them in order to make a decision one way or another. I would like to visit some, like Lourdes, for one. Sorry I wasnt more helpful.
OLAM Dad Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 Fatima and Lourdes are two of my favorites. Why? The public miracles, witnessed by thousands. The prophecy The saints Do you pray the Rosary? If so, why? Is it just the result of an overactive imagination? Do you pray the Divine Mercy Chaplet? If so, why? Is it just the result of an overactive imagination? Even though apparitions are not part of the deposit of faith and nobody is obliged to believe them, they are part and parcel to being a Catholic. In this discussion it's necessary to separate the legitimate, time tested Marian apparitions from the oil spots on the driveway and the stains on the bottom of the tea cup type of signs that you're alluding to.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 I give a hesitent 'yes'. Just a quick search will reveal my skepticism for certain apparitions (i.e., Medjugorje). I give my consent to approved apparitions, mostly because the Church says so... However, more than just a "because the Church says so" answer from me is that I look at the aftermath... the miraculous medal (the most popular marian medal) is the direct result of an apparition, much of the Rosary (the Fatima prayer, and some say even the Rosary itself) is also the result of one or more approved apparitions. All the Church approved apparitions of Mary seem to have an effect on the building up of the entire Church (she said to St. Bernadette, "I am the Immaculate Conception"), etc. now obviously the dogma was not based solely on this apparition, but the apparition, in a sense, confirmed the general movement of the Church and came at an appropriate time to build up the faithful.
heyyoimjohnny Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 I believe in them. I guess they mean something to me because I have a very strong devotion to Mary. I'm suspicious of the ones that aren't approved, but as for the ones that are... why do I believe in them? It's just mom workin', doing her thing. I think they can move others to faith because, well, what a more wonderful way to go to Jesus than through His own mother? I can't get too specific about my own experience without referring you to books. And apparitions aren't a big focus of mine, although I can appreciate it when people share messages with me. But Mary is the one who is and continues to convert me to her Son, pretty much. She's been a wicked amazing channel of grace to me. So it kinda warms my heart to know she's appearing to people all over the place and doing the same thing to others, y'know? Anyways. You said you didn't want generalities, my apologies, sah!
thessalonian Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 (edited) Glad you started this topic BA. It shows an openness in the area that relieves some of my concern. [quote]As I told another PM'er, this has always just been a non-issue for me. I've never decided I believe in any of the apparitions, nor have I ever really studied them, nor do I outright reject the possibility of an apparition happening. But studying our faith, there have been many more pressing topics. I think the vast majority of the "Look its Jesus in an oil stain on the drive way" are the workings of overactive imaginations. [/quote] I actually agree with this paragraph and like what you have stated. The Catholic faith is broad and vast and we don't need to be experts in it all on some level. An openness to these things is important. I do agree that alot of the oil stains on the driveway, mary in tree bark (I saw this over the weekend) Virgin Mary grilled coagulated milk actually does more damage to the Catholic faith by making it look ridiculous. Though I will not completely rule out all of these, I do think EXTREME caution is neccessary. As to why I am in favor of SOME of the apparitions, because the Church is wiser than I and has approved of several is the first and foremost reason for me. But this did not prevent me from studying the issue any more than because the Church says that the Eucharist is the body and blood, soul, and divinity of Christ, this should prevent me from a deeper understanding and a faith based on logic and reason as well. First of all I see that there were apparitions in scripture and so no reason why they would have stopped at the close of the NT. Angels, Moses, Elijah, relatives of those livng in Jerusalem, and of course John's vision in Rev 12 which I truly believe was the first apparition of the blessed mother. Secondly I cannot reconcile non-belief in them with belief in the Catholic faith. At least with regard to approved apparitions. If St. Dominic, Juan Diego, the three fatima children, St. Bernadette, and Sister Faustina (to name a non-marian one) were liars or were seeing an angel of light then the Church is very decieved in promoting the prayers (rosary, chaplet of divine mercy, oh my jesus forgive us our sins....etc. etc) that grew out of and were promoted by these apparitions. I can't reconcile the open promotion of them unless the apparitions that raised them to the level of a valid practice of the Church highly recommended to be performed on a daily basis, unless the apparition behind them is in fact true. Thirdly I have studied apparitions in general. The preponderance of evidence and the number of witnesses to events surrounding them, ie. the apperance of Mary in Egypt, seen by tens of thousands or perhaps a 100,000 as I recall, the miricle of the sun at fatima also seen by tens of thousands, the tilma of etc. etc.Juan Diego, etc. etc. makes it, for those who have studied these things difficult to deny them and it builds my faith. It also makes sense with Catholic Marian theology the way these things have occured and I think they point beautifully to what is happening in the world, to prophecies about the trimumph of the immucalate heart and the way that JPII declared 2004 as the year of the blessed mother and 2005 as the years of the Eucharist. I see incredibly apocolyptic implications in all of this. When it is all said and done we will be amazed at what these apparitions have shown about the final events in history. Also the way I think Fatima in particular ties in with the muslims has implications about the future. The issue between Christianity and Islam I believe must come to some sort of a head before the end of time. As to how are they Christocentric, I have read the messages of many of the apparitions. The rosary we know is very christocentric, being about his life, death, and resurrection. Many protestants have complained that the apparitions try to take the glory for Mary. I find nothing to be further from the truth. Promotion of the rosary is the mother pointing to her son. Further in the messages I have studied Mary talkes about her son (names him in some fashion) almost 50:1 over saying things like "I am the Immaculate conception". i.e. speaking of herself in any way. When she says such things, just as with the council of Ephesus which used Marian doctrine to flesh out who Christ was, her words about herself point to who Christ was. Well that's it off the top of my head for starters. Hope it helps. I do not recommend what I would call Mary chasing, that is looking for every apparition and every log that looks like the blessed mother. One could waste alot of time out in the woods looking for something to sell on ebay. However I think as a part of the total package, cautiously keeping an ear to the wind, with discernment, listening carefully toward the Church, one can use apparitions as a faith builder, innoculating the soul against a possible fall. This of course must always be tempered with a dose of making sure that Marian Apparitions or a certain apparition isn't the reason for beleiving. Blessings Thess Edited March 6, 2006 by thessalonian
thessalonian Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 I will perhaps add that my openness toward such phenomena is likely influence by my mother who I think held a similar discernment to mine in such matters. She was also cautiously open to them and trusted highly in the view of the Church in these matters.
Brother Adam Posted March 6, 2006 Author Posted March 6, 2006 (edited) Thanks for the replies. I appreciate the honesty. And I'm glad your relieved Thess though it bugs the hell out of me when people disagree with me so it automatically means I'm going to become a Protestant again. It couldn't be any further from the truth. I'm accused of being a Protestant all the time because I dont' believe in the charasmatic movement. Now figure that one out!!!!!!!! Edited March 6, 2006 by Brother Adam
thessalonian Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 6 2006, 03:18 PM']Thanks for the replies. I appreciate the honesty. And I'm glad your relieved Thess though it bugs the hell out of me when people disagree with me so it automatically means I'm going to become a Protestant again. It couldn't be any further from the truth. I'm accused of being a Protestant all the time because I dont' believe in the charasmatic movement. Now figure that one out!!!!!!!! [right][snapback]904349[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Oh, I don't think your going to become a protestant. Sorry for any offense.
journeyman Posted March 7, 2006 Posted March 7, 2006 You pretty much covered my thoughts . . . I don't think belief is essential . . . I do think that they reflect a more "activist" communion of the saints than most people are willing to credit . . . given the investigation the Church puts into apparitions before approval, I am willing to accept their findings, rather than go do the work myself . . . I also think there is a lot in Fides comment that the aftermath may be the leading indicator.
Charms717RM1 Posted March 7, 2006 Posted March 7, 2006 Well like I've said in other threads- i used to be an agnostic. When I first came back to the faith I thought Marian devotion was reminscent of polytheism. However, i felt moved to accept her as my mother because the Church accepts her as its mother. I began to pray the rosary frequently- and it has enriched my life so much. It's brought me so much closer to Christ- closer than i ever thought possible. After having a set of prayer beads totally reverse my skepticism in such a short time- I tend to have an open mind about Marian apparitions.
thessalonian Posted March 7, 2006 Posted March 7, 2006 [quote name='journeyman' date='Mar 6 2006, 09:03 PM']You pretty much covered my thoughts . . . I don't think belief is essential . . . I do think that they reflect a more "activist" communion of the saints than most people are willing to credit . . . given the investigation the Church puts into apparitions before approval, I am willing to accept their findings, rather than go do the work myself . . . I also think there is a lot in Fides comment that the aftermath may be the leading indicator. [right][snapback]904874[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Most certainly the Churches witness in the aftermath is the greatest testimony to their authenticity. But we must be careful here. A part of the authenticity for instance of fatima, by which the church judged it was the fruits during and the witnesses during the events. The spirit most certainly moves some to participate in the event. There were sixty or seventy thousand who saw the miracle of the sun at fatima. This added to it's authenticity and the Churches eventual possitive judgement. God gave this miracle for the benefit of all. Not just those who experienced it. So I guess my point is that we should not be afraid of these events or of participating in them but doing it with discression, listening to the Church along the way even if the apparition is not approved officially. Especially since this doesn't come until after they are over. If we all waited till they were over alot of the evidence to authenticate them would not be there. There would be no fruit of the apparition for the Church to judge it by.
Brother Adam Posted March 9, 2006 Author Posted March 9, 2006 Are Marian apparitions part of the deposit of faith?
Fides_et_Ratio Posted March 9, 2006 Posted March 9, 2006 [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 8 2006, 09:30 PM']Are Marian apparitions part of the deposit of faith? [right][snapback]906921[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I don't think so. But to "disbelieve" something the Church has given approval to is somewhat oxymoronic, in a sense (not saying anything specifically to you or anyone else... just saying in general)...
Brother Adam Posted March 9, 2006 Author Posted March 9, 2006 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Mar 8 2006, 09:34 PM']I don't think so. But to "disbelieve" something the Church has given approval to is somewhat oxymoronic, in a sense (not saying anything specifically to you or anyone else... just saying in general)... [right][snapback]906974[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I don't think so, not necessarily. I think it falls along the lines of the interpretation of creation. Most clergy and bishops are evolutionists, but it is perfectly acceptable to be a creationist, it is a matter of science. This is a matter of personal devotion/private revelation. I'm not sure 'approval' is in any way attached to necessity as much as it is attached to 'not harmful to the faith'.
OLAM Dad Posted March 9, 2006 Posted March 9, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 8 2006, 08:30 PM']Are Marian apparitions part of the deposit of faith? [right][snapback]906921[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Emphasis is mine. [quote]Throughout the ages, there have been so-called "private" revelations, some of which have been recognized by the authority of the Church. [b]They do not belong, however, to the deposit of faith[/b]. It is not their role to improve or complete Christ's definitive Revelation, but to help live more fully by it in a certain period of history. Guided by the Magisterium of the Church, the sensus fidelium knows how to discern and welcome in these revelations whatever constitutes an authentic call of Christ or his saints to the Church. Christian faith cannot accept "revelations" that claim to surpass or correct the Revelation of which Christ is the fulfillment, as is the case in certain non-Christian religions and also in certain recent sects which base themselves on such "revelations". (CCC 67) [/quote] Edited March 9, 2006 by OLAM Dad
thessalonian Posted March 9, 2006 Posted March 9, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Mar 8 2006, 08:34 PM']I don't think so. But to "disbelieve" something the Church has given approval to is somewhat oxymoronic, in a sense (not saying anything specifically to you or anyone else... just saying in general)... [right][snapback]906974[/snapback][/right] [/quote] With regard to MA's being a part of the deposit of the faith, I would first say that the one that John had in Rev 12 was. However the rest of it is a bit tricky I think because while they are not a part of the deposit of the faith they are a part of the life of the Church. The living out of the deposit of the faith. We are given the means through the Church to discern them. They are the grace of God for mankind to motivate them to live the Gospel. Those that are consistent with the Gospel are authentic. They transmit the Gospel to us and give us a greater understanding of the depth of it. To ask this question of them ("are they a part of the deposit of the faith" is like asking if the priest standing up at Mass is a part of the deposit of the faith in some sense. He is not the Gospel but he is a part of the means that God uses to transmit the Gospel. If someone comes to us along the street and gives us something we need to hear and God intends for us to hear we are accountable for that are we not. If our wife tells us we spend to much time on the ocmputer and not enough with the kids are we to say "well that's not a part of the deposit of the faith". So I am not sure that the question is a valid one. Each is accountable fore the grace and light he is given no matter how God communicates it to them and we should not be closed to a valid form of his communication. The Church holds apparitions as one means of God's communication to us. It approves them. We are under some obligation here. Blessings Edited March 9, 2006 by thessalonian
Church Punk Posted March 9, 2006 Posted March 9, 2006 [quote name='OLAM Dad' date='Mar 6 2006, 03:01 PM']Fatima and Lourdes are two of my favorites. Why? The public miracles, witnessed by thousands. The prophecy The saints Do you pray the Rosary? If so, why? Is it just the result of an overactive imagination? Do you pray the Divine Mercy Chaplet? If so, why? Is it just the result of an overactive imagination? Even though apparitions are not part of the deposit of faith and nobody is obliged to believe them, they are part and parcel to being a Catholic. In this discussion it's necessary to separate the legitimate, time tested Marian apparitions from the oil spots on the driveway and the stains on the bottom of the tea cup type of signs that you're alluding to. [right][snapback]904207[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I completely agree with you. I am a stong believer in Fatima, Lourdes a) The evidence that is presented is unwavering, we have the testimonies of the 3 children seers in Fatima who choose death by boiling rather than reveal break Our Ladys instructions. Bernadette was tried countless times and suffered through so much and still remained true to Our Lady. b) There was a solid message attached to each that is a call for conversion of hearts and a return to the Catholic faith c) Countless miricales attached to each, most notible the miricle of the sun witnessed by 70 000 people at Fatima. d) As for prophecy, we have to predictions of the end to WWI the begining of WWII the rise of Communism etc. Also with Fatima we have the dates that things happen. It seems everything attached to Fatima happens on the 13. Oct 13 Our Lady appears. Sr. Lucy dies on a 13. its Chilling.
Brother Adam Posted March 9, 2006 Author Posted March 9, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 9 2006, 08:30 AM']With regard to MA's being a part of the deposit of the faith, I would first say that the one that John had in Rev 12 was. However the rest of it is a bit tricky I think because while they are not a part of the deposit of the faith they are a part of the life of the Church. The living out of the deposit of the faith. We are given the means through the Church to discern them. They are the grace of God for mankind to motivate them to live the Gospel. Those that are consistent with the Gospel are authentic. They transmit the Gospel to us and give us a greater understanding of the depth of it. To ask this question of them ("are they a part of the deposit of the faith" is like asking if the priest standing up at Mass is a part of the deposit of the faith in some sense. He is not the Gospel but he is a part of the means that God uses to transmit the Gospel. If someone comes to us along the street and gives us something we need to hear and God intends for us to hear we are accountable for that are we not. If our wife tells us we spend to much time on the ocmputer and not enough with the kids are we to say "well that's not a part of the deposit of the faith". So I am not sure that the question is a valid one. Each is accountable fore the grace and light he is given no matter how God communicates it to them and we should not be closed to a valid form of his communication. The Church holds apparitions as one means of God's communication to us. It approves them. We are under some obligation here. Blessings [right][snapback]907142[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I'm not sold on Marian apparitions being the same thing as your wife telling you that you spend too much time on the computer. Perhaps it can be a means of communication, but it is said that so can dreams and so can babbling nonsense and calling it tongues. Certianly I appreciate the faith people have in them. Because they are private revelation I see nothing that would bind a Catholic in believing in them that had trouble believing in them. I've come to the conclusion that they are not in any sense obligatory. It is obligatory that one is baptized, absolutely necessary, so I compare it in that sense. Certianly there is a hierarchy of truths to consider here as well. Don't get me wrong, I love Mary, she has brought me to Jesus on more than one occassion, but the whole MA thing still sits entirely uneasy with me.
thessalonian Posted March 10, 2006 Posted March 10, 2006 [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 9 2006, 01:11 PM']I'm not sold on Marian apparitions being the same thing as your wife telling you that you spend too much time on the computer. [/quote] The simple point is that God speaks to us in many ways. There is nothing that does not speak of God in some fashion. " If today you hear his voice harden not your hearts.," . These (at least the real ones) are either real or the Church is being decieved. I don't see how one can draw the later conclusion. I posted a story several weeks ago about a man who was leading a very hedonistic lifestyle, drugs, sex, theft, you name it. A book on Medjougorie, converted him. He was transformed from a hateful, selfish person to a loving one hungry for God and has become a very devout Catholic preist. It's an amazing story. So has he been decieved in to becoming a priest?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now