Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Do you believe in 1 or more of the Church approved apparitions?  

98 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 10 2006, 11:30 AM']The simple point is that God speaks to us in many ways. There is nothing that does not speak of God in some fashion.  " If today you hear his voice harden not your hearts.," .  These (at least the real ones) are either real or the Church is being decieved.  I don't see how one can draw the later conclusion.

I posted a story several weeks ago about a man who was leading a very hedonistic lifestyle, drugs, sex, theft, you name it.  A book on Medjougorie, converted him.  He was transformed from a hateful, selfish person to a loving one hungry for God and has become a very devout Catholic preist.  It's an amazing story.  So has he been decieved in to becoming a priest?
[right][snapback]908076[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Any manner of means can draw us closer to God, Protestant included. That doesn't make something like an apparition authentic, simply becaue of the faith of the onlooker.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 9 2006, 02:11 PM']Don't get me wrong, I love Mary, she has brought me to Jesus on more than one occassion, but the whole MA thing still sits entirely uneasy with me.
[right][snapback]907357[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 10 2006, 11:39 AM']Any manner of means can draw us closer to God, Protestant included. That doesn't make something like an apparition authentic, simply becaue of the faith of the onlooker.
[right][snapback]908088[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Brother Adam, it appears we have something in common (not that I didn't think we did before, but we may be in the exact same boat on this one).

Last semester, I had a "crisis of Mary." I had to write a paper on 21st century Mariology (a brief summary of Mariology with a particular focus on the latter 20th century). And during my researching, I really began to name and identify things I had never previously contemplated about Mary. Now, lest I get off track here, Marian Apparitions.

One of the books I used for my research looked at the historical/cultural context from which each apparition arose. For me, the question is a more radical one than are these true, are these part of the deposit of faith, is this just someone's overactive imagination. My question is this: [b]Do the presence of these apparitions indicate/ hint toward greater problems/ deficiencies in the life of the Church?[/b]

Before I elaborate, know first[u] that I mean no disrespect to anyone[/u] with this statement. But the question still remains. I wonder if the peasant Church of France or Mexico saw in Mary a heroine because the Church wasn't acknoweldging the plights of the people. And if I may be so bold, if strictly masculine images of the divine left something more to be desired.

I feel as if my thoughts are somewhat scattered. But I agree with Brother Adam when he said above that here is something about Marian apparitions in general that makes me feel uneasy as well. I am thankful for dialogues such as this that allow all parties to deepen their faith. God Bless!

thessalonian
Posted

Shortnun,

"crisis of mary"???? Sounds like you were opening yourself up to being persuaded by dissenting view. What you are saying is that basically Lords and Guadalupe may well have been creations of the people in those areas and the stories are contrived. The Church was fooled. I think you should throw that book in the trash. Gudalupe has nothing to do with life in the Church. The people there in general were not Catholic but 9 million converted as a result of the apparitions. Do you think they were decieved in to becoming Catholic? I mean no disrespect either but have a serious problem with the nature of your post. I don't condemn anyone who doesn't go gung ho in to marrian apparitions. They should be approached with some caution. But to undermine them in the way that your post has is a serious error in my view. You've crossed the line with regard to submission to the Church.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

As for Marian Apparitions being a deposit of the faith, this is an invalid question. They are a part of the life of the Church. God has given us the means to discern his voice in the various ways he speaks to us. The Church applies those means which are a part of the deposit of the faith and has approved some Marian Apparitions. You undermine this approval with your questions and your posts. Yes, I am a bit steamed but have thought about your posts for several days so I am not just speaking off the handle. Your post second guesses the judgement of the Church concerning approved apparitions. That for me crosses the line of submission.

Edited by thessalonian
Brother Adam
Posted

For a minute there I thought you just up and disappeared ;)

You haven't even come close to proving your point. Speaking in tongues is approved by the Church and is practiced by many Catholics and leads to conversions, yet nearly every Catholic here would assert that rejecting speaking in tongues as babbling non-sense is an acceptable point of view. There really is no reason to take this personally or to get steamed. It is not an attack on the Church or on Mary.

Blessings,
Adam

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 14 2006, 07:14 AM']For a minute there I thought you just up and disappeared ;)

You haven't even come close to proving your point. Speaking in tongues is approved by the Church and is practiced by many Catholics and leads to conversions, yet nearly every Catholic here would assert that rejecting speaking in tongues as babbling non-sense is an acceptable point of view. There really is no reason to take this personally or to get steamed. It is not an attack on the Church or on Mary.

Blessings,
Adam
[right][snapback]911094[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Your post is nonsense. Individual instances of speaking in tongues are not approved by the Church. And yes, if one undermines the decisions of the Church regarding individual apparitions I think that is quite a different matter. I am not taking it personally. I do however rebuke those who put themselves above the judgements of the Church. Her post crossed the line. So it seems do you.

Edited by thessalonian
thessalonian
Posted

By the way, I do think that faithful Catholics can be rebuked. Paul gives us an example in Galations I believe. ;)

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 9 2006, 02:11 PM']I've come to the conclusion that they are not in any sense obligatory.
[right][snapback]907357[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
This is not entirely true. The person receiving the private revelation IS obliged to believe it and to act on it.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote]Catholic here would assert that rejecting speaking in tongues as babbling non-sense is an acceptable point of view. [/quote]

Firstoff, there is no way that one could have an authentic conversion JUST by hearing someone speaking in tongues, even if they were/are authentic. So your arguement fails on that alone. As I said above there are no approved post apostolic incidents of tongue speaking so your analogy also fails on that point.

I would certainly hope that they would not say those incidents of Acts 2 and Acts 10 are not babbling nonsense. If the Church approved of a certain instance of tongue speaking as authentic I would hope they would not say it is nonsense. As for my example with the preist the issue with his conversion was not just the apparition but the Gospel message that went with it and in particular the message of the Eucharist that was conveyed correctly through the apparitions. I think the fruit of Medjogorie will bear out it's authenticity but time will tell.

I am also aware that arguements will never convince those who don't want to be convinced.

Edited by thessalonian
Brother Adam
Posted

[quote]Your post is nonsense.  [/quote]

That was deep.


[quote]Individual instances of speaking in tongues are not approved by the Church.[/quote]

The charismatic movement, along with everything that comes with it, is approved by the Church. That includes tongues, unless you're saying the Church is stupid and doesn't know about the 'gift of tongues' that is praticed.

[quote]  And yes, if one undermines the decisions of the Church regarding individual apparitions I think that is quite a different matter. [/quote]

No, I don't think it is. The Church does not require one to believe in apparitions, nor do they require Catholics to pray the rosary.

[quote] I do however rebuke those who put themselves above the judgements of the Church.[/quote]

Then you are blinded by what I am truly asserting. I haven't in any way put myself above the judgments of the Church. I have said before, and will say it again, I reserve judgment on apparitions, just as I reserve judgment on the approved charism of speaking in tongues. I don't disagree with the Church.

[quote]Her post crossed the line.  So it seems do you.[/quote]

No it didn't, and it is your fantasy to induldge in if you want to continue to assert that it did.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote]Firstoff, there is no way that one could have an authentic conversion JUST by hearing someone speaking in tongues, even if they were/are authentic.[/quote]

Then you haven't been to Franciscan. :)

[quote] So your arguement fails on that alone.[/quote] You're not doing to hot yourself buddy.

[quote]As I said above there are no approved post apostolic incidents of tongue speaking so your analogy also fails on that point.[/quote]

See previous post.

[quote]I would certainly hope that they would not say those incidents of Acts 2 and Acts 10 are not babbling nonsense. [/quote]

Yes, let's stretch your argument to say that we are saying what we are not saying .Sounds like Jack Chick and John McCarthy to me! Protestant tendancies indeed!

[quote]I am also aware that arguements will never convince those who don't want to be convinced.[/quote]

The purpose of an argument isn' t to convince anyone of anything.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

I just lost all respect for you. If you wish to personally slam me with ad hom take it offline . There, say what you like. Bye.

Edited by thessalonian
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Authentic Marian Apparitions (one of the criteria used for judgment by the Church) tend to have lasting conversions.

I daresay "lasting" is a problematic word for Steubenville conversions-- especially people who would be converted by someone speaking in tongues at a FOP or whathaveyou.

I DO believe in the gift of tongues. What I criticize in the modern-day babble without interpretation. Tongues is meant to BUILD up the Church (read St. Paul's letters)... tongues without interpretation in a public setting is blantantly false.

Posted

I know this is off topic, because this isn't about Marian Apparitions, but I have been reading this very heated thread with interest. Adam, I noticed that you made mention above that the Church doesn't require us to believe in the Rosary. I was wondering, perhaps it was from the tone of the rest of the thread that made me curious, but do you believe in the Rosary? Do you pray the Rosary? I was just wondering where that example came from. I don't wish to start a debate, I was just trying to ascertain your views.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='PCPA2Be' date='Mar 14 2006, 10:26 AM']I know this is off topic, because this isn't about Marian Apparitions, but I have been reading this very heated thread with interest.  Adam, I noticed that you made mention above that the Church doesn't require us to believe in the Rosary. I was wondering, perhaps it was from the tone of the rest of the thread that made me curious, but do you believe in the Rosary?  Do you pray the Rosary? I was just wondering where that example came from. I don't wish to start a debate, I was just trying to ascertain your views.
[right][snapback]911280[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I pray the rosary daily. As I said, I love Mary, and she has brought me to her son Jesus more times than I can count.

+Blessings+

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

NO FAITHFUL CATHOLIC HAS A RIGHT TO UNDERMINE OFFICIALLY APPROVED MARIAN APPARITIONS. KEEP SUCH DISSENT TO YOURSELF UNLESS YOU HAVE A QUESTION REGARDING SUCH DISSENT THAT AIDES YOU IN YOUR UNDERSTANDING AND SUBMISSION TO THE CHURCHES OFFICIAL DECISIONS.

Edited by thessalonian
thessalonian
Posted

[quote]Authentic Marian Apparitions (one of the criteria used for judgment by the Church) tend to have lasting conversions. [/quote]

This is an important point. If one has followed the bayside appartions eventually those who were caught up in them followed after them when they became disobedient and antagonistic toward the Church WHILE THEY WERE OCCURRING. There was also some alleged appartions in the Church that many preists and religous supported. Toward the end of them they also became disobedient toward the Church and many of those converted through them followed after the schism that was caused by them. The fruit they bore ended up rotten.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 14 2006, 10:36 AM']NO FAITHFUL CATHOLIC HAS A RIGHT TO UNDERMINE OFFICIALLY APPROVED MARIAN APPARITIONS.  KEEP SUCH DISSENT TO YOURSELF UNLESS YOU HAVE A QUESTION REGARDING SUCH DISSENT THAT AIDES YOU IN YOUR UNDERSTANDING AND SUBMISSION TO THE CHURCHES OFFICIAL DECISIONS.
[right][snapback]911296[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I'm sorry that you don't really have any clue as to my, or shortnun's position. I think you need to take a few more days off :)

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 6 2006, 01:29 PM']I've decided to set this poll up here instead of in the debate table because I'm not looking for a debate, [right][snapback]904190[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

But it's getting close.... Let's keep this friendly, or it's getting moved.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...