Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The schism has come....at last


Recommended Posts

Myles Domini
Posted

[url="http://mliccione.blogspot.com/2006/03/schism-has-comeat-last.html"]The schism has come....at last [/url]

..........

Posted

I knew this was coming. Last week, when I was in California on vacation, I went to two different Masses. I could count on one hand the people who knelt after the Agnus Dei. My friend and I looked around, bewildered. They also stand until the last person has received Holy Communion. I refused to stand. One stands for the President. One kneels for Jesus. I'm just grateful to not be in that Archdiocese.

missionseeker
Posted

wow

Posted

WOW.....

what is going on?!

I read a little bit more in one of the other links and it finished with this...

"Fortunately, Bishop Brown will be retiring in five years and we can hope and pray that the new bishop will be one of the young, traditional men of the stripe of Bishop Olmstead in Phoenix or Bishop Bruskewitz in Lincoln, Nebraska."

so hopefully this will get smashed by Rome and this Bishop will get things sorted out.

missionseeker
Posted

Who is the bishop?

Posted

Bishop Brown? thats all I got from it...

Posted

Well both of the churches I went to. . one was up by Magic Mountain and the other was in Anaheim. . .they were both under the archdiocese of Los Angeles. Anaheim's Bishop (the Bishop of Orange) is Bishop Brown. :(

Posted

People are crackers. Instead of setting up a united front against things like abortion, contraceptives, etc. They're berating their own kind over something like this.

Posted

This is my diocese... :( They've basically alienated them first by taking away the TLM after their priest retired, given them a new liberal priest, and now this. It seems like Bishop Brown is trying to eradicate any trace of conservative Catholicism. They've been charged with disobeying the Bishop, thus Rome and God. But they forget that the norm is kneeling, and this is just a diocesan thing. And that Cardinal Arinze has said that you can't be barred from kneeling if that is what you wish to do. I've heard of Bishop trying to pull people up when they kneel to receive communion...preposterous. That's a choice one is entitled to make.

Our diocese is right up Mahony's alley...it smells of elderberries. Our vocations are down (most go to religious instead of diocesan if at all) and I hear the seminary (St. John's in Camarillo) has a lot of dissident teachers. A priest who came from my home church was telling me about it, and how it confused him because it seemed that these teachers were teaching the exact opposite of what the Church teaches. This is the sad state of our diocese...please pray for us :(

Posted

After I saw it myself last week. . .I started praying right then. Prayers for you and your diocese in front of the Blessed Sacrament. God bless you for remaining Catholic. . .as a less steadfast person might consider leaving. (When our own former bishop did some not-so-good things here a couple of years ago, I saw some parishioners actually stop going to church.)

God bless you. Stay strong.

Posted

[quote name='jiyoung' date='Mar 7 2006, 11:36 PM']This is my diocese... :( They've basically alienated them first by taking away the TLM after their priest retired, given them a new liberal priest, and now this. It seems like Bishop Brown is trying to eradicate any trace of conservative Catholicism. They've been charged with disobeying the Bishop, thus Rome and God. But they forget that the norm is kneeling, and this is just a diocesan thing. And that Cardinal Arinze has said that you can't be barred from kneeling if that is what you wish to do. I've heard of Bishop trying to pull people up when they kneel to receive communion...preposterous. That's a choice one is entitled to make.

Our diocese is right up Mahony's alley...it smells of elderberries. Our vocations are down (most go to religious instead of diocesan if at all) and I hear the seminary (St. John's in Camarillo) has a lot of dissident teachers. A priest who came from my home church was telling me about it, and how it confused him because it seemed that these teachers were teaching the exact opposite of what the Church teaches. This is the sad state of our diocese...please pray for us :(
[right][snapback]906294[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Good they'll get one of my cd's when it drops..

Posted

try pulling me up from kneeling and see what he gets. More than just a fish slap.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='MC Just' date='Mar 8 2006, 07:44 AM']try pulling me up from kneeling and see what he gets. More than just a fish slap.
[right][snapback]906330[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
You cannot assault a priest, no matter who you are or what your cause is. :P:

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Mar 8 2006, 06:06 AM']You cannot assault a priest, no matter who you are or what your cause is. :P:
[right][snapback]906336[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

It wouldn't be assault, it would be self-defense.

Desert Walker
Posted

God help this Church of ours.... :(

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

back in the 1870s, the pope heard a conversation between the devil and Jesus. 75-100 years to destroy the church. well, he tried, he failed, but i think we can all see the effects of that attack.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' date='Mar 8 2006, 08:50 AM']It wouldn't be assault, it would be self-defense.
[right][snapback]906372[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Wouldn't it be more prudent to kneel there continually and take a beating from the priest rather than fight back?

Conservative resistance, not reactionary rebellion, will win the day.

Posted

In my diocese we stand. I would prefer to kneel, but I am also all about unity within the Church. Our bishop also is very conservative, and when I asked him about it he said that either ofrm is acceptable, but in our diocese, it is the norm to stand. If the CCB changes us to ask us to kneel that would be fine with me too.

I had a big problem with it for a long time. Now, I would prefer a united congregation than a divided one over something like posture.

I absolutely agree with Old_Joe on this one.

Posted

There's *got* to be something we don't know about going on here . . . I mean . . . what bishop would be crazy enough to bar kneeling after receiving the Eucharist? No one would think that kneeling was a sign of disrespect . . . it doesn't make any sense!!!

Posted

it might be disobedience, but i would think excommunication is harsh.

I have heard about strange things happening in CA though, so i can't say this surprises me overly much.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...