Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The schism has come....at last


Recommended Posts

Noel's angel
Posted

It's funny that in America there always seems to be some sort of major arguement (see above), but over here we just try to get on with things in the correct manner, well mostly. And if someone doesn't the Bishop deals with it and off we go again, happy as ever.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Raphael' date='Mar 8 2006, 06:06 AM']You cannot assault a priest, no matter who you are or what your cause is. :P:
[right][snapback]906336[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

oh but i would, trust me.lol

Edited by MC Just
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' date='Mar 8 2006, 09:40 AM']It's funny that in America there always seems to be some sort of major arguement (see above), but over here we just try to get on with things in the correct manner, well mostly.  And if someone doesn't the Bishop deals with it and off we go again, happy as ever.
[right][snapback]906494[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
America is a big, diverse place. The price of that diversity is that we are more often confronted face-to-face with disagreements.

Noel's angel
Posted

I guess. Up until I came on Phatmass I had never heard of half the things people talk about. Over here your'e Catholic or Protestant and that's it really

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Mar 8 2006, 08:15 AM']Wouldn't it be more prudent to kneel there continually and take a beating from the priest rather than fight back?

Conservative resistance, not reactionary rebellion, will win the day.
[right][snapback]906426[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

yeah i know, i wouldnt actually hit a priest, i would just keep kneeling there. That's my style. haha

AngelofJesus
Posted

I too, am from the LA archdiocese. Mahoney's crib.
Things that come out of our diocese are just :shock:

During our formation classes given by Diocesan
Master Catechists they flat out challenged the virginity
of my beloved Mother Mary. :o

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Mar 8 2006, 08:15 AM']Wouldn't it be more prudent to kneel there continually and take a beating from the priest rather than fight back?

Conservative resistance, not reactionary rebellion, will win the day.
[right][snapback]906426[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Good point! I forgot that if I took a beating I could then sue! The publicity would then get back to the Vatican!

Posted

[quote name='blovedwolfofgod' date='Mar 8 2006, 08:52 AM']back in the 1870s, the pope heard a conversation between the devil and Jesus. 75-100 years to destroy the church. well, he tried, he failed, but i think we can all see the effects of that attack.
[right][snapback]906411[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


what? got a link..or is this a joke

[quote name='Noel's angel' date='Mar 8 2006, 10:48 AM']I guess.  Up until I came on Phatmass I had never heard of half the things people talk about.  Over here your'e Catholic or Protestant and that's it really
[right][snapback]906507[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Reading the article I question. If a catholic church is not in communion with rome, and her believers do not obey the teaching of rome, than do we not just have another form of protestantism? To me cafeteria catholics are far more deprived than protestants

mariahLVzJP2
Posted

[quote name='PCPA2Be' date='Mar 7 2006, 10:54 PM']Well both of the churches I went to. . one was up by Magic Mountain and the other was in Anaheim. . .they were both under the archdiocese of Los Angeles.  Anaheim's Bishop (the Bishop of Orange) is Bishop Brown.  :(
[right][snapback]906260[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
our Bishop is Todd Brown. and honestly, im kinda confused as to when to kneel/stand, cause our diocese (Orange) changed it a while ago. and when i went to Arizona a couple of months ago it was a lil different from us.

toledo_jesus
Posted

over here in Richmond at the ODU CCM my friends and I were called out for kneeling during Mass. We weren't formally kicked out though. We were more like...ostracized.

I don't buy that community posture malarkey. We have the option, so there.

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 8 2006, 01:06 PM']over here in Richmond at the ODU CCM my friends and I were called out for kneeling during Mass.  We weren't formally kicked out though.  We were more like...ostracized. 

I don't buy that community posture malarkey.  We have the option, so there.
[right][snapback]906555[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

At our CCM I kneel and most of the congregation follows suit. ^_^ I just keep my mouth shut when the kneeling/standing issue comes up.

Posted

That pastor's entire argument is heavily laden with blatant irony...

Posted

I goto a very liberal chapel for mass on campus and I'm usually the only person there who kneels during communion. For obvious reasons I've started sitting up front more often.

MissScripture
Posted

Gosh, this reminds me of what happened earlier this year at my old high school. Some of my friends got in trouble for being "too pious" during Mass, because they kneeled The "faith formation coordinator" issued an announcement to be read in every religion class, and then talked to all three of them. It's such a sad state for things...

SeekingHisPlan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 8 2006, 12:06 PM']over here in Richmond at the ODU CCM my friends and I were called out for kneeling during Mass.  We weren't formally kicked out though.  We were more like...ostracized. 

I don't buy that community posture malarkey.  We have the option, so there.
[right][snapback]906555[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

(sorry for the long post)

I kneel to receive Communion, and am trying to figure out whether I received a backhanded scolding for it the other day or not. I had been wanting to kneel to receive for ages, but never had the nerve to do it. I wasn't sure how it was looked upon in our diocese (Hamilton Ontario, Canada) and I didn't want to create a big fuss. So for a while, I would genuflect before receiving. Then one of the ladies who has been in our parish for years basically told me, "If what is on your heart is to kneel then you had best kneel. Father doesn't have a problem with that, nor should he. And so I knelt.

Recently, I started cantoring, and was told by the head cantor, "When you're in the sanctuary for Communion, you stand. Kneeling might distract someone." She then went on to give me a speech on how, "Your reverence is in your heart, and you don't need to kneel." It didn't feel like she was referring *just* to standing in the sanctuary, but to my kneeling in general.

I accepted the standing bit., and since starting to cantor, have discovered that I probably would stand anyway in the sanctuary. Standing instead of kneeling in the sanctuary seems counter-intuitive in a way, but I [i]do[/i] feel very conspicuous receiving in the sanctuary since I am directly in the sight line of everyone who is receiving or is back in their seats. Kneeling then may well be distracting, whereas I don't think it is if I am just one in a long line of communicants. If I thought it was attention-grabbing, I wouldn't do it.

However, in talking to my priest recently, he was very careful to assert several times, "When you are in the sanctuary, I want you always to stand to receive. You can't draw attention to yourself in any way." He then went on to ask, "Why [i]do[/i] you kneel anyway?" It surprised me, first because his tone sounded very accusatory, and second because he and I had a *long* conversation about posture when receiveing back when I used to genuflect before receiving. He knew my reasons then and was OK with it. Now I feel as though both he and the head cantor feel like my regular practice of kneeling is excessive in some way.

ETA: The fact that I even stand *in* the sanctuary for Communion is a whole seperate issue, and one that I haven't yet sorted out my convictions on. For now I'm just doing what my priest has told me to do, and trying to sort things out.

Edited by SeekingHisPlan
toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='morostheos' date='Mar 8 2006, 02:37 PM']At our CCM I kneel and most of the congregation follows suit.  ^_^  I just keep my mouth shut when the kneeling/standing issue comes up.
[right][snapback]906624[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
the western half of the diocese has always been better. We got the crazies over here in Tidewater.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 8 2006, 03:48 PM']the western half of the diocese has always been better.  We got the crazies over here in Tidewater.
[right][snapback]906703[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Oh, I wouldn't say that. The grass always seems greener on the other side. :rolleyes:

But the majority of the college students here are from the Northern Virginia area, so there isn't much protesting from them. :)

I must say though, having Fr. Patrick here is a BIG help!

Edited by morostheos
Posted

Why do people make such a big deal about it kneeling when recieving? I don't get it, if its allowed then its fine. Why any Priest would have a problem with it I'm not sure...

I think as long as people don't put value statements behind our actions everything should be fine. ie 'I kneel because it is [i]more[/i] reverent than standing' 'I recieve on the tongue because it is [i]more[/i] reverant than in the hand'. If you feel more reverent doing it then you should, but its important to know that it is all looked at as proper by the Church.

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' date='Mar 8 2006, 02:33 PM']Why do people make such a big deal about it kneeling when recieving?  I don't get it, if its allowed then its fine.  Why any Priest would have a problem with it I'm not sure...

I think as long as people don't put value statements behind our actions everything should be fine.  ie 'I kneel because it is [i]more[/i] reverent than standing' 'I recieve on the tongue because it is [i]more[/i] reverant  than in the hand'.  If you feel more reverent doing it then you should, but its important to know that it is all looked at as proper by the Church.
[right][snapback]906735[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Kneeling, etc., was always regarded as more reverent in our culture. The reason for doing these things in worship is to show reverence.
And that was how it was done everywhere until recent decades.

Only God can judge the heart, but shouldn't public worship show reverence outwardly?

The problem is these "liberal Catholics" (incuding those in the clergy) do not like reverence for God.

stbernardLT
Posted

This is all kind of new to me becuase I never been to church where people didn't kneel from after the "Holy, Holy" till the priest closes the tabernacle or sits. I guess I might be a little deprived (not really), but my thoughts are this. If at the name of Jesus every knee should bend, then shouldn't that be the case even more when in his presence. I feel really sorry for our Lord because he died on a cross for us and we can't even kneel for him. :ohno:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...