thessalonian Posted March 8, 2006 Posted March 8, 2006 There is a thread in the debate section asking when NFP is not okay. I posted my response and it gives me chills to write it up so I thought I would post it for the reflection of others. I've posted it before but it has been a while. When is NFP not okay Well let me tell you when NFP was not okay for me. My wife and I had our fourth child and three from her previous marriage, totalling seven. A healthy number by any days standards. She was thinking it was time to slow down and so we stopped at a Catholic book store to get an NFP book. My wife had a special devotion as a new Catholic to a blessed Gianna Berretta Mola at the time. We were even going to name our 4th Child Gianna if it was a girl but he was a boy. The woman who owned the store had a poster of Blessed GBM on the store window so my wife talked to her about the woman who died rather than have an abortion to save herself, choosing to allow her child to be born instead. She had cervicle cancer. Well the woman gave my wife the poster to take home. Then my wife asked about NFP books and the woman said I think people use it for contraception and so I don't use it. My wife told the woman that our son would have been named Gianna if he had been a girl. She said "well maybe your next child will be Gianna". Two years later we were pregnant again. It was September. In January we choose names and decided if it was to be a girl we would call her Gianna. Well on Feb 19th we found out that Pope JP II was going to canonize Blessed Gianna Berreta Molla a saint on May 16th. The due date for the baby was mid may. I am not kidding or making this up. But there is more. I've never known anyone to go to a canonization in Rome. It turns out that the Godmother for the baby was going to be in Rome in mid may and also the doctor who was to do the delivery set up a trip to go to the canonization as she had a devotion to BGBM who was a doctor as well. The Godmother left at the exact time the baby was born, 3:30 May 11 and the doctor gave birth to our baby Gianna as the last delivery she did before she left for Rome. Unbelievable but true story. The bottom line is if you think you need to slow down on having children and that your reasons are grave for doing so, God may see it otherwise. Little Gianna is the sweetest, cutest little girl. Always be open to life and you will recieve a great blessing. Blessings
ironmonk Posted March 8, 2006 Posted March 8, 2006 All, I've known Thess a long time and I remember him telling me about this as it was happening, before the baby was born. Children are a blessing, don't ever let anyone tell you otherwise and please defend children when they do. God Bless! ironmonk
Church Punk Posted March 8, 2006 Posted March 8, 2006 That is such a warm and awesome story, thank you for sharing.
prose Posted March 8, 2006 Posted March 8, 2006 Be careful how you word this. No life is more important than another, so it would have been [quote] "... within their right to undergo treatment," even if the treatment would have "indirectly compromised the pregnancy," said Bishop Elio Sgreccia, head of the Pontifical Academy for Life. "It is not morally required" by the church, he said, but the church recognizes such an act to be "a heroic decision to sacrifice oneself for someone else." A heroic act is, in fact, one that is not obligatory, said Bishop Sgreccia. If it were obligatory to give up one's life so that another could live, it would no longer be an example of heroism or martyrdom, he told Catholic News Service. By praising the sacrifice made by St. Gianna and Fedrizzi, the church "is not necessarily saying that forgoing treatment for a disease that might harm the child is the right thing to do," said Father Tadeusz Pacholczyk, a neuroscientist and director of education at the National Catholic Bioethics Center in Philadelphia. "The church is rather recognizing that a voluntary decision on behalf of one's unborn child is a powerful sign in the midst of a culture of death where the unborn child is routinely sidelined at the slightest provocation," he told CNS.[/quote] some women do not make this decision, and are not condemned because of it. Secondly, we also need ot be VERY CAREFUL about judging people's reasons to slow down. This is such a hard area because many Catholics have difficulty thinking of any reason at all to postpone pregnancy, so they have a hard time understanding other's decisions. Sorry to sound so preachy, I just get irritated that some people who are able to have many, many children become judgemental to those who (for reasons they may not understand) make an ethical choice not to. I am not saying this is you, I am saying that some people are like that, and it needs to be recognized. And just because some people use NFP in the worng way, doesn't make it bad. People use knives to kill people, this doesn't make the knife bad. (quote from: [url="http://www.catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/0501556.htm)"]http://www.catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/0501556.htm)[/url]
MilesChristi Posted March 8, 2006 Posted March 8, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 8 2006, 08:33 AM']There is a thread in the debate section asking when NFP is not okay. I posted my response and it gives me chills to write it up so I thought I would post it for the reflection of others. I've posted it before but it has been a while. When is NFP not okay Well let me tell you when NFP was not okay for me. My wife and I had our fourth child and three from her previous marriage, totalling seven. A healthy number by any days standards. She was thinking it was time to slow down and so we stopped at a Catholic book store to get an NFP book. My wife had a special devotion as a new Catholic to a blessed Gianna Berretta Mola at the time. We were even going to name our 4th Child Gianna if it was a girl but he was a boy. The woman who owned the store had a poster of Blessed GBM on the store window so my wife talked to her about the woman who died rather than have an abortion to save herself, choosing to allow her child to be born instead. She had cervicle cancer. Well the woman gave my wife the poster to take home. Then my wife asked about NFP books and the woman said I think people use it for contraception and so I don't use it. My wife told the woman that our son would have been named Gianna if he had been a girl. She said "well maybe your next child will be Gianna". Two years later we were pregnant again. It was September. In January we choose names and decided if it was to be a girl we would call her Gianna. Well on Feb 19th we found out that Pope JP II was going to canonize Blessed Gianna Berreta Molla a saint on May 16th. The due date for the baby was mid may. I am not kidding or making this up. But there is more. I've never known anyone to go to a canonization in Rome. It turns out that the Godmother for the baby was going to be in Rome in mid may and also the doctor who was to do the delivery set up a trip to go to the canonization as she had a devotion to BGBM who was a doctor as well. The Godmother left at the exact time the baby was born, 3:30 May 11 and the doctor gave birth to our baby Gianna as the last delivery she did before she left for Rome. Unbelievable but true story. The bottom line is if you think you need to slow down on having children and that your reasons are grave for doing so, God may see it otherwise. Little Gianna is the sweetest, cutest little girl. Always be open to life and you will recieve a great blessing. Blessings [right][snapback]906358[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thanks for sharing that. God always provides when we are open to receiving His gifts.
thessalonian Posted March 8, 2006 Author Posted March 8, 2006 (edited) Prose, I agree with your post. It was not intended to be a putdown of NFP or women who have fewer children at all. I am just saying that we should lean toward generosity in life and be very careful in how we use NFP. My wife and I do use it. And if the unitended consequence of BGBM saving her life was to loose the child that would have been okay. However her allowing her child to live was a heroic act and certainly played a significant part in her canonization. Edited March 8, 2006 by thessalonian
Ash Wednesday Posted March 8, 2006 Posted March 8, 2006 [quote]Sorry to sound so preachy, I just get irritated that some people who are able to have many, many children become judgemental to those who (for reasons they may not understand) make an ethical choice not to. I am not saying this is you, I am saying that some people are like that, and it needs to be recognized.[/quote] I went to a traditionalist Catholic board once and that seemed to be the prevailing attitude. The place seemed like one big giant "who is the best Catholic by having the most babies" contest.
prose Posted March 8, 2006 Posted March 8, 2006 No debate, just wanted to say 2 bits. The story is beautiful, and absolutely what every person should keep in mind before considering postponing or avoiding pregnancy. Thanks for the insight, I was just a little on edge this morning.
OLAM Dad Posted March 9, 2006 Posted March 9, 2006 This father of six thanks you for your commitment to life! That's a very inspiring story. fwiw, I think having a lot of children IS a sign of one's faith just as a habit is. (speaking of debate topics )
OLAM Dad Posted March 10, 2006 Posted March 10, 2006 [quote name='Monoxide' date='Mar 8 2006, 10:22 PM']beaver dam right! [right][snapback]907005[/snapback][/right] [/quote]
Brother Adam Posted March 10, 2006 Posted March 10, 2006 [quote name='OLAM Dad' date='Mar 8 2006, 07:25 PM']This father of six thanks you for your commitment to life! That's a very inspiring story. fwiw, I think having a lot of children IS a sign of one's faith just as a habit is. (speaking of debate topics ) [right][snapback]906886[/snapback][/right] [/quote] And shows that you are blessed and your quiver is full of arrows!
OLAM Dad Posted March 10, 2006 Posted March 10, 2006 [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 10 2006, 07:53 AM']And shows that you are blessed and your quiver is full of arrows! [right][snapback]907930[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Not full, just comfortably crowded.
Luthien Posted March 10, 2006 Posted March 10, 2006 Haha you all rock. I agree, practicing NFP while leaning towards generosity to life is the way to go. God always provides for you.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 (since the debate table topic was closed...) Another opinion of well respected priest from Rome: [quote]By on on Friday, March 10, 2006 - 7:27 pm: Father, Recently it has come up as to the appropriateness of newlyweds practicing natural family planning as a means of delaying the birth of children (for whatever reasons)at the beginning of a marriage. Is is truly wise/responsible to begin a marriage practicing natural family planning, or ought the couple wait until they would be ready to embrace children to get married? Thanks, curious about NFP -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- By Fr. Robert Auman (fr_auman) on Tuesday, March 14, 2006 - 8:17 am Curious about NIP, If the fiancees have the necessary reason(s) to make the practice of NFP morally acceptable, then they should not get married, until those reasons no longer exist. To start practicing NFP soon after entering marriage puts a burden on the couple that could easily wind up in divorce. Newly weds need all of the natural and supernatuiral helps to make their marriage work out; and one of the natural helps is sexual intercourse. I never cease being amazed at the different ways people, who try not to sin, try to get around the law of God or of the Church to gain some particular good by avoiding the purpose of the law while fulfilling the word of the law externally. With prayers, Fr. Auman [/quote] [url="http://www.askfather.net/discus/messages/874445/875047.html?1142324263"]http://www.askfather.net/discus/messages/8...html?1142324263[/url]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now