Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote]I never cease being amazed at the different ways people, who try not to sin, try to get around the law of God or of the Church to gain some particular good by avoiding the purpose of the law while fulfilling the word of the law externally. [/quote]

There is no law against using NFP after getting married, and so these people aren't getting around anything, the "purpose" or the "word". They are entering into their Sacramental vocation, and exercising their duty as responsible parents.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Mar 14 2006, 11:49 PM']There is no law against using NFP after getting married, and so these people aren't getting around anything, the "purpose" or the "word". They are entering into their Sacramental vocation, and exercising their duty as responsible parents.
[right][snapback]912016[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Take that up with Fr. Jordan Auman.

I just wanted to post another well respected priest's opinion on the matter.

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Mar 14 2006, 11:49 PM']There is no law against using NFP after getting married, and so these people aren't getting around anything, the "purpose" or the "word". They are entering into their Sacramental vocation, and exercising their duty as responsible parents.
[right][snapback]912016[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
How is putting off parenthood because one can't afford it responsible? Rather, there's no point in entering the vaunted "Sacramental vocation" if you don't fulfil it by having children. We don't need a law to tell us what is responsible and what is not. Nor does one need to take a course to see when people are rationalizing questionable behavior.



I'm beginning to feel that putting the unitive ahead of rather than next to the procreative aspect of marriage is pretty popular.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 15 2006, 12:57 AM']We don't need a law to tell us what is responsible and what is not.
[right][snapback]912070[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

We don't need you to tell us either.

If you feel it is irresponsible behavior, then don't do it. I don't care what you and your wife or your fiance do. It's not my business.

I afford that same respect to every other couple. It's none of my business whether they use NFP after getting married or not. The Church has no teaching against it, and does not dictate to anyone when their circumstances justify the use of NFP. She provides general moral guidance. Beyond that, it's up to each couple to discern their own circumstances and evaluate their own consciences. As long as the couple understands the role of procreation in the vocation of marriage, they will have the proper disposition to make the right decision.

Edited by Era Might
Posted (edited)

[quote]How is putting off parenthood because one can't afford it responsible? Rather, there's no point in entering the vaunted "Sacramental vocation" if you don't fulfil it by having children. [/quote]

Children do not "fulfill" the vocation of marriage. People don't get married to have children, they get married because they love one another and want to share their vocation until they die. Sacramentally speaking, the consummation of carnal relations renders the union indissoluble. It doesn't matter if children are conceived or not. Children are an ordinary element of the vocation, but they do not "fulfill" it. If a woman dies on her wedding night, having consummated the marriage but not conceived (maybe because she wasn't in a fertile period), her marriage was not therefore "unfulfilled".

By your logic, NFP would never be justified, because if a married couple can't afford a child, they shouldn't be having relations anyway, since there's a chance that they could still conceive a child. The Church doesn't teach this. Children may be delayed, even at the beginning of a marriage, and carnal relations may still take place, because the Church does not propose children as the justification for a marriage. Children are the greatest fruit of marriage, but not its justification.

Your proposition does reduce children to a justification for marriage. "If you can't have children, then you shouldn't get married." This would disqualify barren women and the elderly, as well as those who have to delay pregnancy for legitimate reasons. The Church never suggests that these people can't get married, because children do not justify a marriage.

Every married couple should have a fervent desire for children, and a firm purpose to work towards the day when they can have children. With this understood, we need to leave it up to each couple to discern how best to live out their vocation as responsible parents.

Edited by Era Might
Posted (edited)

Double post.

Edited by Era Might
thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 14 2006, 10:57 PM']How is putting off parenthood because one can't afford it responsible?  [/quote]



This always bothers me. We determine what we can and can't afford. Do we believe God will not provide? I have 8 kids. Can I afford 8 kids? Not really or at least it sure doesn't seem like it with all the bills and the way the money goes out. But we have a roof over our heads, food, and clothes and go to a movie once in a while. Americans have a very distorted view of what "can't afford" means. By the way I've known other families who were open to life on less income than I have and they have survived as well. In fact over the years most, God has provided with expanding income to go with their expanded families.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Snakes on a plane, man. Snakes on a plane.
(Whatever happens, happens... and a gold star for anyone that got that...)


P.S. I appreciate the insights from everyone but especially :applause: for Era ;)

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Mar 15 2006, 01:12 AM'][b]We don't need you to tell us either.[/b] so touchy

If you feel it is irresponsible behavior, then don't do it. I don't care what you and your wife or your fiance do. It's not my business.

I afford that same respect to every other couple. It's none of my business whether they use NFP after getting married or not. The Church has no teaching against it, and does not dictate to anyone when their circumstances justify the use of NFP. She provides general moral guidance. Beyond that, it's up to each couple to discern their own circumstances and evaluate their own consciences. As long as the couple understands the role of procreation in the vocation of marriage, they will have the proper disposition to make the right decision.
[right][snapback]912082[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
The only thing [b]I've[/b] seen from the Church about this [b]specific[/b] topic is what the Father said in Fides' post. Hmm. To me, it's a very specific situation and 'general moral guidance' doesn't address it fully.
So, ask a bishop the same question and see what answer you get.

And stop getting all huffy! ^_^

Or I shall taunt you a second time.

[img]http://www.angelfire.com/ny5/mpholygrail/images/frenchman1.jpg[/img]

Posted (edited)

Nobody's getting huffy.

I meant that literally. We don't need you to tell us anymore than we need a law. That's my whole point. We don't need people lecturing others on their private decisions as Catholics. They have a conscience. They don't need mine.

If they want someone's opinion, they can see their Priest.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 15 2006, 09:38 AM']The only thing [b]I've[/b] seen from the Church about this [b]specific[/b] topic is what the Father said in Fides' post.  Hmm.  [right][snapback]912217[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Fr. Richard Hogan, from the NFP forum at EWTN, was cited in the other thread, and pretty much said what I'm saying.

Posted

Points to ponder:

[quote]The first time Rome spoke on the matter was 1853, when the Sacred Penitentiary answered a dubium (a formal request for an official clarification) submitted by the bishop of Amiens, France. He asked, "Should those spouses be reprehended who make use of marriage only on those days when (in the opinion of some doctors) conception is impossible?" The reply was: "After mature examination, we have decided that such spouses should not be disturbed [or disquieted], provided they do nothing that impedes generation" (quoted in J. Montánchez, Teología Moral 654, my translation). By the expression "impedes generation," it is obvious the Vatican meant the use of onanism (or coitus interruptus, now popularly called "withdrawal"), condoms, etc. Otherwise the reply would be self-contradictory.

The next time the issue was raised was in 1880, when the Sacred Penitentiary issued a more general response . The precise question posed was this: "Whether it is licit to make use of marriage only on those days when it is more difficult for conception to occur?" The response was:[b] "Spouses using the aforesaid method are not to be disturbed; and a confessor may, with due caution, suggest this proposal to spouses, if his other attempts to lead them away from the detestable crime of onanism have proved fruitless."[/b] (This decision was published in Nouvelle Revue Théologique 13 [1881]: 459–460 and in Analecta Iuris Pontificii 22 [1883], 249.)[/quote]

[quote]But nowhere does Pius XI stress "plans" or "goals" to avoid having children. He does not teach that such a "desire" or such a "deliberate plan" is essentially sinful. What the Pope brands as sinful is "frustrating the marriage act" (vitiando naturae actum)—that is, "frustrating its natural power and purpose." But [b] when couples carry out conjugal acts on the infertile days exclusively, they are not frustrating the natural power and purpose of those acts that they perform on those days. Those particular acts do not have any natural [procreative] power and purpose to begin with. You cannot frustrate a nonexistent power or purpose.[/b]

The point comes through clearly in the most solemn passage of the encyclical. After referring to the recent decision of the Anglicans to permit contraception, Pius XI declares:

"The Catholic Church, to whom God has entrusted the defense of the integrity and the purity of morals, standing erect in the midst of the moral ruin that surrounds her, in order that she may preserve the chastity of the nuptial union from being defiled by this foul stain, raises her voice in token of her divine ambassadorship and through Our mouth proclaims anew: Any use whatsoever of matrimony exercised in such a way that the act is deliberately deprived of its natural power to generate life is an offense against the law of God and of nature, and those who indulge in such are branded with the guilt of a grave sin" (CC 56).

I have used the words deprived of at the point where standard English translation uses the words frustrated in. This makes the Pope’s true meaning a little clearer. The Latin verb he uses here is destituere. As Latin dictionaries show, this verb, when used with the ablative, as in this case (naturali sua . . . vi), means precisely "to deprive of," "to strip," or "to rob." In such constructions, the accompanying noun in the ablative case is that thing of which the rightful owner has been "deprived" or that has been "stripped" or "robbed" from him. [b]Now, of course, you cannot deprive anyone of something he never possessed to begin with. You cannot rob a man with no money any more than you can strip him if he is already naked. Likewise, as conjugal acts carried out precisely in the infertile period do not have any natural procreative potential, it is obvious that they cannot be deprived or robbed of that potential.[/b]

Pius XI’s successor, Pius XII, confirmed yet again the moral acceptability of NFP for serious motives in two allocutions of 1951. Since then, of course, we have had further confirmations of the doctrine from Paul VI (in Humanae Vitae) and John Paul II (in Familiaris Consortio and many other statements).[/quote]

toledo_jesus
Posted

yes, I read the piece you quoted during the other thread.

It did a great job of making it clear that NFP is acceptable for "serious motives." However, it still falls short of answering the question of whether couples who choose to get married knowing they will put off children (for whatever reason) are correct in using NFP. It doesn't provide a guide for whether one should get married if circumstances (such as would lead many to practice NFP, por ejemplo: finances, getting used to married life, etc. Both of which I've seen touted as valid reasons) won't allow children immediately.

[quote name='Era Might']We don't need people lecturing others on their private decisions as Catholics.[/quote]

I'm not sure anybody was lecturing in either thread. Making statements is not lecturing, it's taking a position from which to argue. Since we weren't even debating facts, but rather the notion of 'responsibility' I can see the confusion.

Basically, my thinking is this: If you are not prepared to provide for a child in the way that you feel you should, there is nothing actually stopping you from getting married. However, if you want to marry then you [i]should [/i]be prepared to raise children even in your 'reduced' state of income. If you can afford to raise a child, even a "poor" one, then you're not justified in using NFP right away. If circumstances are such that you [i]literally[/i] could not raise a child due to extreme poverty or other such issues, then the prudent thing to do is to wait to marry until one is reasonably in control of one's affairs.

Obviously, this is for conditions existing before marriage.

Am I really far out here? I don't think so. I can't help feeling like this NFP thing is just a loophole for Catholics to get married and not have babies...and a lot of people do use NFP as a contraceptive. I would definitely like to see something specific come from the higher-ups.

Whatever, I'm gonna go start another thread about LIFETEEN.

:shock:






;) j/k

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Gah, my point wasn't to start up debate over this again... merely to say that I think the EWTN question could've been worded more clearly.

No one has said it's [i]wrong[/i] for a couple to begin their marriage using NFP, we've said it is [i]unwise[/i]. And this position is echoed by the words of at least one faithful priest. I am not intending to pit the opinions of priests against one another... but saying as a general rule it would seem unwise for couples to begin a marriage using NFP rather than waiting to get married until they were ready for children.

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Mar 15 2006, 10:20 PM']Gah, my point wasn't to start up debate over this again... merely to say that I think the EWTN question could've been worded more clearly.

No one has said it's [i]wrong[/i] for a couple to begin their marriage using NFP, we've said it is [i]unwise[/i]. And this position is echoed by the words of at least one faithful priest. I am not intending to pit the opinions of priests against one another... but saying as a general rule it would seem unwise for couples to begin a marriage using NFP rather than waiting to get married until they were ready for children.
[right][snapback]912977[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
it's time for healing.



I wish Norseman wasn't ignoring me. :grouphug:

Posted

First: I never posted in any other thread, so you could not have been referring to my quote.

Secondly: I think that it is very wise to make the decision to use NFP.

Third: I don't believe that marriage should be postponed just because you are not ready to have children. Children are not the sole purpose of marriage, they are a blessing of marriage, but not the sole purpose to be married. God made us with brains to be wise enough to determine what is best for our souls, and to be able to use natural methods to acheive that.

Last: I am not pitting priests against one another, I was posting Papal quotes.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

prose,

my post wasn't aimed specifically towards you or anyone one person, it was just in general. :)


(though, as an aside to your lastest post... your papal quotes are dealing with spouses in general, not specifically newlyweds... which is why the asking of a priest is prudent in such a case)

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='prose' date='Mar 15 2006, 11:48 PM']First: I never posted in any other thread, so you could not have been referring to my quote.

Secondly: I think that it is very wise to make the decision to use NFP.

Third: I don't believe that marriage should be postponed just because you are not ready to have children.  Children are not the sole purpose of marriage, they are a blessing of marriage, but not the sole purpose to be married.  God made us with brains to be wise enough to determine what is best for our souls, and to be able to use natural methods to acheive that.

Last:  I am not pitting priests against one another, I was posting Papal quotes.
[right][snapback]913044[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
nonono, I googled and found that piece too. I read it during the other thread. eet ees ze Eenglish. always with the messing up I am.

With all due respect, the papal quotes still don't answer the specific question.

That's why we're using the priest quote. It's a very specific situation, and a very specific question. What I'm seeing is that there isn't an opinion on this specific, particular, singular and focused question from anyone with any authority. Best we got is a priest.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...