Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

Yes God Picks Popes. But did Saint Athanasius know more than Pope Liberius I?

i would think so. Liberius Excommunicated him. Athanasius taught correct doctrine and after his death he was made a saint and the excommunication was declared null and void.

God picks popes. They can either follow God's will or they can not (like Pope liberius)

I am not claiming to be a bishop here. I am no Athansius but Lefebvre is.

[quote]"We therefore choose to keep our Faith and we cannot be mistaken in clinging to what the Church has taught for two thousand years. The crisis is profound, cleverly organized and directed, and by this token one can truly believe that the master mind is not a man but Satan himself. [b]For it is a master-stroke of Satan to get Catholics to disobey the whole of Tradition in the name of obedience."[/b][/quote]
-Archbishop Lefebvre


[quote]True Obedience

According to the great theologian, St. Thomas Aquinas, true obedience is a balance between twin errors of defect and excess, which are disobedience and false obedience (IIa IIae, Q104, 5 and 3). Today this second error is common among Catholics who, when the follow orders to depart from Tradition, think they are being obedient.

Obedience is the servant of Faith...not of Obedience. -- Spanish Proverb

God must always be obeyed no matter what he may ask of us. Such was the Patriarch Abraham's obedience.

Human superiors need not be obeyed if their orders violate the Faith. Such was the martyrs' obedience.

We ought to obey God...rather than men. -- Acts 5:29

And there is no reason why those who obey God rather than men should be accused of refusing obedience; for if the will of rulers is opposed to the will and the laws of God, these rulers exceed the bounds of their own power and pervert justice, nor can their authority then be valid, which, when there is no justice, is null. -- Leo XIII, Diuturnum Illud.

"Error by excess"--False Obedience

Excessive zeal even for obedience, if indiscreet, will surely lead to a great fall.

Satan's masterstroke is to have succeeded in sowing disobience to all Tradition through obedience (i.e. false obedience). -- Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre


[/quote]

missionseeker
Posted

so you're saying the most learned theologian in the world is wrong

(talking about Pope Benedict XVI)

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' date='Mar 26 2006, 01:03 AM']so you're saying the most learned theologian in the world is wrong

(talking about Pope Benedict XVI)
[right][snapback]922506[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


Im not saying anything. Archbishop Lefebvre said he was. And So does Bishop Fellay.

The Pope is the keeper of tradition and should not abandon it.

Anastasia13
Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Mar 25 2006, 07:26 PM']If you read the life of St. John Bosco you will see that  Don Bosco was able to have Martin Luther raised from Hell to testify to some Lutherans who were intent on his murder.
[right][snapback]922340[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
There are so many reasons I doubt that, especially if Don Bosco was a Godly man.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' date='Mar 26 2006, 01:09 AM']There are so many reasons I doubt that, especially if Don Bosco was a Godly man.
[right][snapback]922508[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


what is that supposed to mean?

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Mar 26 2006, 01:05 AM']Im not saying anything. Archbishop Lefebvre said he was. And So does Bishop Fellay.

The Pope is the keeper of tradition and should not abandon it.
[right][snapback]922507[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

said the pope was wrong? I'm confused

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

yes. Archbishop Lefebvre does not except what he calls "the modernistic" interpretation of Vatican II.

missionseeker
Posted

the interpretation is one thing what the documents actually say is another.

If he accepts the documents themselves but not the interpretation (which has more to do with indivual preists and bishops than the pope), that is two different things.
I'll agree with the idea that people have misinterpreted the documents of vaticanII and there is a widespread abuse of the liturgy

However, I know that the Lefebvrites do not think that the documents are in any way valid


I have a question.

St. Padre Pio was declared a saint by Pope John Paul II - you claim him as a saint, but I've heard some Trads say that NOTHING AT ALL after 1965 is relevant/oficial.

Why do they take the saints, that's like Cafeteria Catholics

Anastasia13
Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Mar 25 2006, 11:10 PM']what is that supposed to mean?
[right][snapback]922509[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Oh, wait, are you saying that was supposed to be one of the miracles ascribed to him?

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

yes.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' date='Mar 26 2006, 01:29 AM']the interpretation is one thing what the documents actually say is another.

If he accepts the documents themselves but not the interpretation (which has more to do with indivual preists and bishops than the pope), that is two different things.
I'll agree with the idea that people have misinterpreted the documents of vaticanII and there is a widespread abuse of the liturgy

However, I know that the Lefebvrites do not think that the documents are in any way valid
I have a question.

St. Padre Pio was declared a saint by Pope John Paul II - you claim him as a saint, but I've heard some Trads say that NOTHING AT ALL after 1965 is relevant/oficial.

Why do they take the saints, that's like Cafeteria Catholics
[right][snapback]922513[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Lefebvre taught that Vatican II was a valid council called by a valid pope. He said that it was taken over by modernists. and that the documents were written ambigiously, and have been interpreted in light of modernism.

those trads were probably Sedevecantists. Most trads believe that the Saints Canonized are real saints, becuase their canonization just means that they are in heaven.

Brother Adam
Posted

Pope Benedict XVI was a modernist? Well I'll be :censored:

That's actually pretty much the most backwards thing I've ever heard on phatmass.

Mary-Kathryn
Posted

Here's my hero


[url="http://www.presentationmate.com/wilbourn_memorial.htm"]http://www.presentationmate.com/wilbourn_memorial.htm[/url]

Hope the link works...oh by the way, I'm not affiliated with this company in any way. Just was looking for a picture of Trey that would post here..I'm not computer savvy. Trey died the last day of the war.

I know, I know, I just pulled a :hijack:


You are missed Trey,
Mary-Kathryn

Fidei Defensor
Posted

Sam, how old are you?

I think that should settle who knows more, you or Pope Benedict.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='brendan1104' date='Mar 25 2006, 09:14 PM']Luther is definitely in hell.

era, what will you think of my spiritual father if his "excommunication" and "schism" are annuled/lifted?
[right][snapback]922324[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Wow! How do you know this information? Do you know for certain Martin Luther is in hell? I think God is the only One who has the authority when it comes to one's salvation. Point is LeFabvre rejected the authority of the pope; an office appointed by Christ Himself, and ordained his own bishops against the authority of the pope. If that's not evil, I don't know what is. I don't see LeFabvre becoming a saint anytime soon. That's just me. Anyone is free to argue against me, but I don't think these kind of actions are pleasing to God.

Edited by Anthony
Posted (edited)

[quote name='brendan1104' date='Mar 25 2006, 09:14 PM']Luther is definitely in hell.

era, what will you think of my spiritual father if his "excommunication" and "schism" are annuled/lifted?
[right][snapback]922324[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

LeFabvre died in schism. Therefore, isn't it a little late for his excommunication to be annuled? If I remember right, the four bishops he ordained repented and returned to Rome, but I don't believe he did. Sorry, but you have no valid argument.

Edited by Anthony
Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Mar 25 2006, 09:22 PM']^_^  Marcel Lefebvre is such a good Bishop. i know all of you do not think that but, hes Book Open Letter to Confused Catholics  is inspiriong. I read it. He writes so charitably and so clearly.

Marcel Lefebvre, Ora Pro Nobis.
[right][snapback]922333[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

EENS, are you still associated with SSPX? You really are sending mixed signals to the rest of the people at phatmass. You say you're not involved with the SSPX, but yet you defend LeFabvre.

Posted

While I can agree that the "spirit of Vatican" represents a serious problem...Lefebre disagreed the same way Luther did: By leaving the Church and staying in schism out of free will.

No saint has ever done that to my knowledge..so no I consider him the same I do other protestants.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

The fixation on Lefebrve reminds me of the cultish way people adhere to "the Gospel According to Fatima" and pay more attention to that than the actual Catechism and Bible. Time to take a look at the big picture and move on, people.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='Anthony' date='Mar 26 2006, 11:55 AM']EENS, are you still associated with SSPX?  You really are sending mixed signals to the rest of the people at phatmass.  You say you're not involved with the SSPX, but yet you defend LeFabvre.
[right][snapback]922687[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


I support the SSPX, but im not "associated with them" anymore than i am "associated" with the FSSP or the Jesuits, or any other Fraternity, Society, or relegious order.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...