Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The official "I need help" thread...


Recommended Posts

sweetpea316
Posted

There is a Question and Answer site that a friend is pulling a bunch of statements from and emailing to me... she sent me like 18 of them today. They are from the WELS Lutheran website and are supposedly according to the Catechism and whatnot. I'm really overwhelmed by it all and could use some input and pointers on how to either refute or correctly answer them. Thanks and God bless!

Here is the first one... (I'll try and space them out)

1. Q: Is it okay for a non-Catholic to pray the Rosary?

A: No. A non-Catholic should not pray the rosary. In fact, not even a Roman Catholic should pray the rosary. No one should, and for a number of reasons.

The first is that one of the prayers that is a key part of the rosary is "Hail Mary." This is a prayer offered to a human being. Since prayer is an act of worship, it is sinful to offer prayers to anyone but the Triune God. Sometimes Roman Catholics will state that they are praying to God through Mary, yet that is still making Mary a mediator, which credits her with playing a role that only Jesus has. As our Great High Priest, Jesus is our mediator (1 Timothy 2:5). We pray in Jesus' name, because he earned us the right to come to God in prayer. We are all children of God through faith in Christ Jesus. We can call God our "Father" because Christ made us God's children. When a person prays to Mary, that person is not only praying to someone who cannot hear us or help us, that person is giving honor to a human being that should be given to God alone.

The second problem with the rosary is that it turns prayer into something that helps us get to heaven. By saying so many "Our Fathers" and "Hail Marys" a person may receive an indulgence (reward point) which will help that person get to heaven. This is contrary to the gospel which tells us that Jesus earned heaven for us, that he did it all (1 Peter 3:18), that he offers eternal to us free of charge (Romans 6:23), that there is nothing we can do to earn it (Ephesians 2:8,9), and that prayer is a privilege we have as Christian which allow us to ask God for blessings, and honor and praise him for all he has done and continues to do for us.

Rather than praying the rosary, it would be good to pray the Lord's Prayer. If you want the help of printed prayers, there are many prayer books that you can use. You can also put the prayers in your own words as you speak to your heavenly Father. And remember, you can pray to God directly. You don't have to go through Jesus' mother or anyone else.

Posted (edited)

to pray to God and to pray to a saint are two different things.

prayers to a saint are intercessory.

pray
One entry found for pray.
Main Entry: pray
Pronunciation: 'prA
Function: verb
Etymology: Middle English, from Old French preier, from Latin precari, from prec-, prex request, prayer; akin to Old High German frAgEn to ask, Sanskrit prcchati he asks
transitive senses
1 : ENTREAT, IMPLORE -- often used as a function word in introducing a question, request, or plea <pray be careful>
2 : to get or bring by praying
intransitive senses
1 : to make a request in a humble manner
2 : to address God or a god with adoration, confession, supplication, or thanksgiving

Edited by ReinnieR
Brother Adam
Posted

Pray tell me Sweetpea, what do you think of blue coagulated milk?


Oh no... I just prayed to Sweetpea. :blush:

Posted

1 Timothy 2:5

we agree that Christ is the only one mediator between God and man yes this is true.

but the church as the Mystici Corporis Christi (Mystical Body of Christ) share in this mediation.

The saints doesn't take away the mediatorship of Christ

Posted

We always pray in Jesus' name. that's why we make the sign of the cross

Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Mar 26 2006, 08:39 PM']The first is that one of the prayers that is a key part of the rosary is "Hail Mary." This is a prayer offered to a human being. Since prayer is an act of worship, it is sinful to offer prayers to anyone but the Triune God. Sometimes[right][snapback]923131[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]Prayer is not an act of worship! Look at old and middle English. "I pray you," meant I "beg" or "plead" you. It is a form of asking a favor or intercession. No where does it imply worship.

[quote] Roman Catholics will state that they are praying to God through Mary, yet that is still making Mary a mediator, which credits her with playing a role that only Jesus has. As our Great High Priest, Jesus is our mediator (1 Timothy 2:5). We pray in Jesus' name, because he earned us the right to come to God in prayer. We are all children of God through faith in Christ Jesus. We can call God our "Father" because Christ made us God's children. When a person prays to Mary, that person is not only praying to someone who cannot hear us or help us, that person is giving honor to a human being that should be given to God alone.
[/quote]And what about Jews that prayed to God before Christ died? Did God not want their prayers? Give me a break...The entire Psalter was written before the Incarnation and is a prayer to God. Regardless...what about preachers? Are they not mediators in the sense that they mediate from God to the people? They preach and mediate God's word to people do they not? This is semantic game that they are loosing.

[quote]The second problem with the rosary is that it turns prayer into something that helps us get to heaven. By saying so many "Our Fathers" and "Hail Marys" a person may receive an indulgence (reward point) which will help that person get to heaven. This is contrary to the gospel which tells us that Jesus earned heaven for us, that he did it all (1 Peter 3:18), that he offers eternal to us free of charge (Romans 6:23), that there is nothing we can do to earn it (Ephesians 2:8,9), and that prayer is a privilege we have as Christian which allow us to ask God for blessings, and honor and praise him for all he has done and continues to do for us. [/quote]That is a misunderstanding of indulgence. Indulgences do not remove sin, but the temporal punishment due from them. It has nothing to do with getting into heaven. Furthermore, all Grace has been given to the Church by Her Groom, Christ.

[quote]Rather than praying the rosary, it would be good to pray the Lord's Prayer. If you want the help of printed prayers, there are many prayer books that you can use. You can also put the prayers in your own words as you speak to your heavenly Father. And remember, you can pray to God directly. You don't have to go through Jesus' mother or anyone else.
[/quote]Perhaps he is missing the Pater Nosters, the Glorias, and the Apostles Creed all in there. Also, no one has denied that you may pray to God directly. sheesh talk about a straw man. <_<

Note: I did not have a good night at work tonight. :(

Posted

this was my response to somebody else when it was brought up

1 Timothy 2



let’s look at the first 2 verses



1 First of all, then, I ask that supplications, prayers, petitions, and thanksgivings be offered for everyone,

2 for kings and for all in authority, that we may lead a quiet and tranquil life in all devotion and dignity.



Notice the word petition (Intercession) Intercession is a synonym for mediation in the New Testament.



Hebrews 7:25



25 Therefore, he is always able to save those who approach God through him, since he lives forever to make intercession for them.



refers to Jesus as our one unique intercessor. Yet in 1 Tim. 2:5, all Christians are called to be intercessors (or mediators). Notice the first word in verse five: "For there is one God and one mediator."



1 Timothy 2:7



7 For this I was appointed preacher and apostle (I am speaking the truth, I am not lying), teacher of the Gentiles in faith and truth



"Apostle" is another synonym for mediator. The classical definition of an apostle is: "one sent with the authority of the one who sent him." That's also the definition of a mediator.



In short, St. Paul says we are all called to be mediators, for (or because) Christ is the one mediator, and for this reason, St. Paul was called to be a mediator of Christ's love and grace to the world.



Does our mediatorship conflict with the mediatorship of Christ?



Not at all.



Matthew 23:8



8 As for you, do not be called 'Rabbi.' You have but one teacher (Greek: didaskolos) and you are all brothers.



yet James 3:1 and Ephesians 4:11 tell us we have many teachers (Greek: didaskoloi) in the Church.



James 3:1



1 Not many of you should become teachers, my brothers, for you realize that we will be judged more strictly,



Ephesians 4:11



11 And he gave some as apostles, others as prophets, others as evangelists, others as pastors and teachers,



The key is to understand that the many teachers and mediators in the body of Christ do not take away from Christ as the one teacher and mediator, they fulfill His command to teach and mediate on this earth in Him. They are, and we are, members of His body.



Galatians 2:20



20 yet I live, no longer I, but Christ lives in me (or teaches or mediates in me); insofar as I now live in the flesh, I live by faith in the Son of God who has loved me and given himself up for me.



1 Corinthians 12:12-27



12 As a body is one though it has many parts, and all the parts of the body, though many, are one body, so also Christ.

13 For in one Spirit we were all baptized into one body, whether Jews or Greeks, slaves or free persons, and we were all given to drink of one Spirit.

14 Now the body is not a single part, but many.

15 If a foot should say, "Because I am not a hand I do not belong to the body," it does not for this reason belong any less to the body.

16 Or if an ear should say, "Because I am not an eye I do not belong to the body," it does not for this reason belong any less to the body.

17 If the whole body were an eye, where would the hearing be? If the whole body were hearing, where would the sense of smell be?

18 But as it is, God placed the parts, each one of them, in the body as he intended.

19 If they were all one part, where would the body be?

20 But as it is, there are many parts, yet one body.

21 The eye cannot say to the hand, "I do not need you," nor again the head to the feet, "I do not need you."

22 Indeed, the parts of the body that seem to be weaker are all the more necessary,

23 and those parts of the body that we consider less honorable we surround with greater honor, and our less presentable parts are treated with greater propriety,

24 whereas our more presentable parts do not need this. But God has so constructed the body as to give greater honor to a part that is without it,

25 so that there may be no division in the body, but that the parts may have the same concern for one another.

26 If (one) part suffers, all the parts suffer with it; if one part is honored, all the parts share its joy.

27 Now you are Christ's body, and individually parts of it.



This is the text that refers to Christians as "the body of Christ." We are so intimately one with one another that in verse 21, the text reads, "The eye cannot say to the hand, 'I do not need you,' nor again the head to the feet, 'I do not need you.' "



add the fact that we are so radically one with Christ that He can say in Matthew 25:40



40 And the king will say to them in reply, 'Amen, I say to you, whatever you did for one of these least brothers of mine, you did for me.'



The question is, does this intimate union with Christ and with one another cease when we die?

Of course not. In fact, it becomes more radical.

The saints in heaven are even closer to us than when they were here on earth, because it's Christ Who makes us one.



Matthew 17:20



20 He said to them, "Because of your little faith. Amen, I say to you, if you have faith the size of a mustard seed, you will say to this mountain, 'Move from here to there,' and it will move. Nothing will be impossible for you."



1 John 3:22



22 and receive from him whatever we ask, because we keep his commandments and do what pleases him.



Psalms 66:18



18 Had I cherished evil in my heart, the Lord would not have heard.



They are free from all sin, which hinders our prayers, and they're experiencing a union with God (and therefore with us) beyond anything we can fathom.



"They are like him for they see him as he is" (1 John 3:2). As "partakers of the divine nature" (2 Peter 1:4) in the fullest sense, they have gifts and powers beyond what "eye has seen or ear heard" (1 Corinthians. 2:9). If we could ask them to pray for us when they were here on earth, of course we can -- and should -- ask them to pray for us now.1 John 3:2



the Bible presents to us a number of good examples of the mediation of the saints in heaven.



2 Maccabees 15:12-16



12 What he saw was this: Onias, the former high priest, a good and virtuous man, modest in appearance, gentle in manners, distinguished in speech, and trained from childhood in every virtuous practice, was praying with outstretched arms for the whole Jewish community.

13 Then in the same way another man appeared, distinguished by his white hair and dignity, and with an air about him of extraordinary, majestic authority.

14 Onias then said of him, "This is God's prophet Jeremiah, who loves his brethren and fervently prays for his people and their holy city."

15 Stretching out his right hand, Jeremiah presented a gold sword to Judas. As he gave it to him he said,

16 "Accept this holy sword as a gift from God; with it you shall crush your adversaries."



This tells of a vision Judas Maccabeus has, in which he sees both Onias (a former high priest who had died) and Jeremiah the prophet (who had died over 500 years earlier) interceding, or mediating, for Israel.



The Book of Revelation gives us an even better description of the mediation of both the angels and saints in heaven.



Revelation 5:8, 14



8 When he took it, the four living creatures and the twenty-four elders fell down before the Lamb. Each of the elders held a harp and gold bowls filled with incense, which are the prayers of the holy ones.



14 The four living creatures answered, "Amen," and the elders fell down and worshiped.



Notice these elders are offering the prayers of the saints. This is the same ministry of mediation we see the angels performing in Revelation 8:3-4



3 Another angel came and stood at the altar, holding a gold censer. He was given a great quantity of incense to offer, along with the prayers of all the holy ones, on the gold altar that was before the throne.

4 The smoke of the incense along with the prayers of the holy ones went up before God from the hand of the angel.



and the martyrs in Revelation 6:10.



10 They cried out in a loud voice, "How long will it be, holy and true master, before you sit in judgment and avenge our blood on the inhabitants of the earth?"

Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Mar 26 2006, 08:39 PM']When a person prays to Mary, that person is not only praying to someone who cannot hear us or help us, that person is giving honor to a human being that should be given to God alone.

[right][snapback]923131[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
from the directory

[url="http://www.cin.org/users/james/questions/q040.htm"]http://www.cin.org/users/james/questions/q040.htm[/url]

sweetpea316
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 26 2006, 08:48 PM']Pray tell me Sweetpea, what do you think of blue coagulated milk?
Oh no... I just prayed to Sweetpea. :blush:
[right][snapback]923136[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
You are so clever.... :lol_roll:

And wow! Thanks for all of the quick responses thus far! Yall rock. I'm going to try and get back to her about every question she presented, but it's probably gonna be a long process. Thanks everyone for your willingness to help! I appreciate it more than yall know! ^_^

Posted

here's some more from the directory

[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=6229"]http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=6229[/url]

Posted (edited)

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Mar 26 2006, 09:06 PM'] I'm going to try and get back to her about every question she presented, but it's probably gonna be a long process. [/quote]Bring it on. I am in an argumentative mood tonight.
:starwars:

Edited by Paphnutius
Posted (edited)

i've heard Ephesians 2:8-9 used to support Sola Fide.

but we know that Faith without works is dead James 2:17

Matthew 7:21
"Not everyone who says to me, 'Lord, Lord,' will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only the one who [b]does[/b] the will of my Father in heaven.

Edited by ReinnieR
Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Mar 26 2006, 08:39 PM']

Rather than praying the rosary, it would be good to pray the Lord's Prayer. If you want the help of printed prayers, there are many prayer books that you can use. You can also put the prayers in your own words as you speak to your heavenly Father. And remember, you can pray to God directly. You don't have to go through Jesus' mother or anyone else.
[right][snapback]923131[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

so this means i can't pray for my mom if she's ill.?

she would have to pray to God directly?

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='ReinnieR' date='Mar 26 2006, 10:18 PM']i've heard Ephesians 2:8-9 to support Sola Fide.

but we  know that Faith without works is dead James 2:17

Matthew 7:21
"Not everyone who says to me, 'Lord, Lord,' will enter the kingdom of heaven,  but only the one who [b]does[/b] the will of my Father in heaven.
[right][snapback]923185[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

All Eph 2 says is that we aren't Pelagians. We can't make it to heaven by our works, but through faith, and faith works. :)

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 26 2006, 09:22 PM']All Eph 2 says is that we aren't Pelagians. We can't make it to heaven by our works, but through faith, and faith works. :)
[right][snapback]923190[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
true

sweetpea316
Posted

Something that I remember hearing Fr. Corapi say in one of his talks is that, if you have a problem with the rosary, then you must have a problem with the gospel. Heh.

I found this link in the Defense Directory... the whole site is good in my opinion. Is it pretty legit? Just making sure, cause I wanna pass it along. [url="http://davidmacd.com/catholic/mary_rosary.htm"]http://davidmacd.com/catholic/mary_rosary.htm[/url]

Thanks again for the responses! I'll probably post another one of the questions later today. Until then... God bless! ^_^

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Mar 27 2006, 08:31 AM']Something that I remember hearing Fr. Corapi say in one of his talks is that, if you have a problem with the rosary, then you must have a problem with the gospel. Heh. [right][snapback]923509[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
:punk:

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Mar 27 2006, 08:31 AM']I found this link in the Defense Directory... the whole site is good in my opinion. Is it pretty legit? Just making sure, cause I wanna pass it along.  [url="http://davidmacd.com/catholic/mary_rosary.htm"]http://davidmacd.com/catholic/mary_rosary.htm[/url]

Thanks again for the responses! I'll probably post another one of the questions later today. Until then... God bless!  ^_^
[right][snapback]923509[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
if they're there then phatcatholic has usually done a pretty good job of making sure they're legit. of course he would not have time to search them in detail but from my own experience they have all been pretty reliable (especially on the heavier issues).

phatcatholic
Posted

its ironic that, despite their staunch and unwavering defense of 1 Tim 2:5, most protestants have no idea what mediation is :blink: i explained this verse and how it relates to our prayers to the saints in this post:
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=48788&view=findpost&p=904264"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...ndpost&p=904264[/url]

oh, and the catholicbridge.com site is excellent, in my opinion. he does a great job of making catholic doctrine easy to understand. plus, his site is designed well.

phatcatholic
Posted

also, here's something i wrote on another board explaining why we pray to saints:[list]we pray to saints because we believe that they too are members of the one Body of Christ, and because the quality of their prayer often surpasses our own. [. . .]

their prayers are more likely to be in accordance with His will, and thus, more likely to please him and to be answered. James says that some ask but don't receive b/c they ask wrongly (cf. James 4:3), and John, that the Lord will answer those prayers that are in accordance with his will (cf. 1 John 5:14). Patron saints, in particular, b/c of their familiarity w/ the particular things with which we struggle, know exactly what to pray for, whereas we often fail. and, of course, "the prayers of the righteous availeth much" (James 5:16) and "the eyes of the Lord are upon the righteous, and his ears are open to their prayer" (1 Pet 3:12). now, why does the Lord single out the righteous? it is b/c they are in union with Him and they long to do His will. while these verses certainly apply to the saints on earth, i think they can also apply to the saints in heaven. who among created being is more righteous and in closer intimacy with the Lord than they are, who see the Lord face to face? "For now we see in a mirror dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall understand fully, even as I have been fully understood" (1 Cor 13:12).

we also pray to saints b/c this action confirms and glorifies the work of Christ in the lives of the saints. We would not be able to pray to them were it not for Jesus Christ. without Him, these people would simply be dead, and no one would remain in the Body of Christ after death, nor would they enter heaven.
[/list]

Posted (edited)

[quote name='phatcatholic' date='Mar 27 2006, 02:26 PM']its ironic that, despite their staunch and unwavering defense of 1 Tim 2:5, most protestants have no idea what mediation is :blink: i explained this verse and how it relates to our prayers to the saints in this post:
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=48788&view=findpost&p=904264"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...ndpost&p=904264[/url]

oh, and the catholicbridge.com site is excellent, in my opinion. he does a great job of making catholic doctrine easy to understand. plus, his site is designed well.
[right][snapback]923973[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
i remember those posts.

i couldve directed her there!!

what's wrong with me? i'm such a butt.

Edited by ReinnieR

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...