Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The official "I need help" thread...


Recommended Posts

sweetpea316
Posted

Ok well, I knew this would be coming soon, so here it is. The response to that letter I wrote. (from my mom, but she went to her pastor for help in answering it..it's a combo of their responses) Ugh. I don't even know where to start. If anything sticks out to yall that yall want to comment on, feel free. I can use all the help I can get. And this is still only the first topic on the list...whew. Thanks again and God bless!

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

You said that prayer is NOT a form of worship. I disagree. In my Webster's Concise English Dictionary the definition of prayer is:
1.an earnest request. 2. words addressed to God in WORSHIP. thanksgiving, etc.

This is why we do not pray to dead saints or to Mary. It is worship and we do not worship anyone but God. Prayer is worship. Matthew 15-8,9. 8 " These people honor me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me. 9 they worship me in vain; their teachings are but rules taught by men.NOT A MISCONCEPTION - PRAYER IS WORSHIP! MATTHEW 15:8,9 IS A CHIASTIC
PARALLELISM - "HONORING GOD WITH THEIR LIPS" IS "WORSHIPING GOD
IN VEIN."

THE DICTIONARY DEFINITION OF "MEDIATE" 1) one who intervenes between
two, either in order to make or restore peace and friendship, or form a
compact, or for ratifying a covenant 2) a medium of communication,
arbitrator

The definition of intercede is: to act between parties with a view to reconcile differences.

Read both and tell me what the difference is. They are both the same. So when people pray to dead saints or to Mary they are asking them to "go between" them and God. Which we both know is against what the Bible teaches. Where in the Bible does it say that the saints can see what is happening on earth or hear us?

"The true blessing is not to have the holy inhabitants bring our requests to the Lord like you said," but to have the Holy Spirit bring our requests to the Lord. Why would you want a human in heaven praying for you when you have God himself? Romans 8:26,27. The reason to ask someone else to pray for you is not to change God. His mind is made up already. But that I, or the person praying for me, to line themselves up to God's will. I pray because God wants us to pray to him.

After all, in James 5:16, we read that the prayers of a righteous man
> have great power.
>
THAT'S NOT WHAT THE PASSAGE SAYS, IT SAYS LITERALLY, "VERY STRONG IS THE
WORKING PRAYER OF A RIGHTEOUS MAN." PRAYER IS NOT A MEANS OF GRACE. IT
CANNOT BRING A PERSON ONE RAIN DROP OR ONE BIT OF HEALING IF IT ISN'T
GOD'S WILL. IT IS POWERFUL WHEN IT RECALLS GOD'S PROMISES AND REMINDS
BOTH PRAYING PERSON AND HEARING PERSON OF GOD'S LOVE AND GRACE. THE VERB
FORM IS IN THE MIDDLE VOICE - WHICH MEANS IT IS SOMETHING THAT IS DONE
TO THE PERSON REFLECTIVELY - NOT ACTIVELY. IN OTHER WORDS, THE PRAYER IS
EFFECTIVE IN CAUSING A PERSON TO RECALL GOD'S PROMISES, NOT THE POWER
THAT CAUSES GOD TO ACT. THE VERB POINTS THE ACTION BEING DONE TO THE
PERSON, NOT THE PERSON CAUSING THE ACTION TO HAPPEN.

How much more powerful must their prayers be then, those in God’s
> presence in heaven, than ours here on the sinful earth?


I DISAGREE BECAUSE OF ROMANS 8. WHAT MAKES A PRAYER POWERFUL IS GOD, NOT
MAN. AS PART OF GOD'S HOLY CHRISTIAN CHURCH MY
PRAYERS ON EARTH FOR JESUS' SAKE ARE ACCEPTABLE TO GOD. LOCATION DOESN'T
MAKE A PRAYER MORE ACCEPTABLE. IF SHE MEANS "THEY KNOW ABOUT OUR FUTURE
AND KNOW WHAT TO PRAY FOR" THEN I KNOW THERE ARE NO PASSAGES IN THE
BIBLE THAT SAY THAT! ONLY GOD IS OMNISCIENT! I GO BACK TO ROMANS 8 AND
THANK GOD HE IS PRAYING FOR ME, NOT SOME SAINT IN HEAVEN.



"You said that the Hail Mary is not a prayer to Mary? It is asking her to pray for us to God?" Which means it is a "prayer" to her to "pray" to God for you. Right? What are Hail Mary's?

What is the rosary if it is not a prayer?

God said " Call upon me in the day of trouble", not call upon Mary or the saints. Praying to Mary is to take God's glory away from where it belongs ~ to God alone and giving it to someone else. Which God forbids. Is 42:8 I will not give my glory to another.

You said "And even then, the Hail Mary is Scriptural also. (Luke 1:42-43, 48) THIS WAS NOT A PRAYER TO
MARY! IT WAS A STATEMENT OF FACT! NOTICE, ELIZABETH DID NOT ASK MARY TO
PRAY TO GOD FOR HER!
You forgot verse 47 where Mary said: My soul glorifies the Lord and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior. Her thankfulness in V 48 is because of what she says in V 49 "for the Mighty one has done great things for me-holy is his name. Not because she is Holy or a Saint or because of anything Mary has done. She is called blessed by me because of what God has done for her!

You said "The Catholic Church is clear about the centrality of Jesus. Without Him, these people would simply be dead, and no one would remain in the body of Christ after death. Praise to you, Lord Jesus Christ!" Does this mean they trust in Jesus alone for Salvation? If so, what is the purpose of penance?

Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Apr 2 2006, 06:26 PM']You said that prayer is NOT a form of worship. I disagree. In my Webster's Concise English Dictionary the definition of prayer is:
1.an earnest request. 2. words addressed to God in WORSHIP. thanksgiving, etc.  [right][snapback]933564[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]Then we must agree to disagree. Keep in mind that the Protestant understanding of "worship" is much shallower for they do not have the depth of the Eucharistic miracle in their faith. Adoration, giving glory, etc.. are acts of worship. To ask something of another is in no way worship.

As far as the concise dictionary, let us take a look at the first definition of prayer: an earnest request. Did they completely skip over this part? Really. The first understanding of prayer is an earnest request, only when it is applied to God, as the second definition denotes, is it a form of worship. They have only fueled the fire with this. Prayer is only worship when it is directed to God in asking or thanksgiving. Their own citation proves this.

[quote]Prayer is worship.[/quote]Sorry but this is not yet proven. See the first definition of prayer: an earnest request.

[quote]Matthew 15-8,9. 8 " These people honor me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me. 9 they worship me in vain; their teachings are but rules taught by men.NOT A MISCONCEPTION - PRAYER IS WORSHIP! MATTHEW 15:8,9 IS A CHIASTIC
PARALLELISM - "HONORING GOD WITH THEIR LIPS" IS "WORSHIPING GOD
IN VEIN."
[/quote]Why the yelling? *sighs* A sign of possessing the Truth is peace and joy, not yelling. Regardless, this does not approach the subject. This is once again a reference to God and not to the meaning of prayer in general. Here Matthew condemns false or hollow prayer that fails. This does not prove that [b]all [/b]prayer is worship.

[quote]The definition of intercede is: to act between parties with a view to [b]reconcile [/b]differences.  [/quote]Okay let us take this definition and apply it to what we are saying. When we pray to the saints (we shall henceforth include Mary for there is little distinction in this regard), we do not do so that they may [b]reconcile [/b]differences. This was down by Christ on the Cross and is being done now in the process of sanctification. When we pray to the saints we implore them to assist us in our process of coming closer to Christ. This is not to reconcile us. This is to ask for their prayers for us. They have created a straw man and are attacking that. It would be of benefit if they understood what is meant by praying to saints: an earnest request. What type of request? An earnest request for prayers. Nothing more, nothing less. It is not a form of worshiping them, nor is it asking them to reconcile this. I have never heard of a prayer that worshiped a saint, nor one that asked them to take away our sin or make us "right" with God. That is a straw man.

[quote]THAT'S NOT WHAT THE PASSAGE SAYS, IT SAYS LITERALLY, "VERY STRONG IS THE
WORKING PRAYER OF A RIGHTEOUS MAN." PRAYER IS NOT A MEANS OF GRACE. IT CANNOT BRING A PERSON ONE RAIN DROP OR ONE BIT OF HEALING IF IT ISN'T GOD'S WILL. IT IS POWERFUL WHEN IT RECALLS GOD'S PROMISES AND REMINDS BOTH PRAYING PERSON AND HEARING PERSON OF GOD'S LOVE AND GRACE. THE VERB
FORM IS IN THE MIDDLE VOICE - WHICH MEANS IT IS SOMETHING THAT IS DONE TO THE PERSON REFLECTIVELY - NOT ACTIVELY. IN OTHER WORDS, THE PRAYER IS EFFECTIVE IN CAUSING A PERSON TO RECALL GOD'S PROMISES, NOT THE POWER THAT CAUSES GOD TO ACT. THE VERB POINTS THE ACTION BEING DONE TO THE PERSON, NOT THE PERSON CAUSING THE ACTION TO HAPPEN. 
[/quote]Again with the all caps...1) Who said anything about healing? 2)Perhaps the pastor ought to realize just what Grace is. Grace is sharing in the life of God. Prayer's aim and intent is to do just that. Line is up with God's life or will. 3)No one has implied that it alter's God's mind or causes Him to ask. 4) Ever heard of Abraham pleading for Sodom? Read Gen 18:16-ff. Sounds like God based His action on Abraham's prayer...hmmm.....

[quote]I DISAGREE BECAUSE OF ROMANS 8. WHAT MAKES A PRAYER POWERFUL IS GOD, NOT MAN.  AS PART OF GOD'S HOLY CHRISTIAN CHURCH MY PRAYERS ON EARTH FOR JESUS' SAKE ARE ACCEPTABLE TO GOD. LOCATION DOESN'T MAKE A PRAYER MORE ACCEPTABLE. IF SHE MEANS "THEY KNOW ABOUT OUR FUTURE AND KNOW WHAT TO PRAY FOR" THEN I KNOW THERE ARE NO PASSAGES IN THE BIBLE THAT SAY THAT! ONLY GOD IS OMNISCIENT! I GO BACK TO ROMANS 8 AND THANK GOD HE IS PRAYING FOR ME, NOT SOME SAINT IN HEAVEN.
[/quote]Seems like he is directly contradicting Scripture here. I would point this out.

[quote]Is 42:8 I will not give my glory to another. [/quote]Right. He will not give his Latria to another, this does not affect dulia in any way.

[quote]You said "And even then, the Hail Mary is Scriptural also. (Luke 1:42-43, 48) THIS WAS NOT A PRAYER TO MARY! IT WAS A STATEMENT OF FACT![/quote]Exactly. We are stating a fact. What is his point?

[quote]You forgot verse 47 where Mary said: My soul glorifies the Lord and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior. Her thankfulness in V 48 is because of what she says in V 49 "for the Mighty one has done great things for me-holy is his name. Not because she is Holy or a Saint or  because of anything Mary has done. She is called blessed by me because of what God has done for her!
[/quote]He is starting to get it without realizing it. We as Catholics call Mary blessed because of her role in salvation history. God chose her to bear His Son and make her blessed in this way. We simply recongize this statement of fact.

[quote]Does this mean they trust in Jesus alone for Salvation? If so, what is the purpose of penance?
[/quote]An appeal to Christ's salvific action on the Cross. To ask for forgiveness.

I sense a lot of anger in this pastor. The wrath of man does not accomplish the will of God.

sweetpea316
Posted

Thanks so much for your quick answer Paphnutius. I appreciate it a lot. And I don't think the caps were meant for anger/yelling...I think those were to indicate what the pastor wrote from what my mother put. I'll definitely use your comments when writing back. And any others' input would be awesome too. Thanks and God bless! :)

Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Apr 2 2006, 07:52 PM']Thanks so much for your quick answer Paphnutius. I appreciate it a lot.  [right][snapback]933617[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
No problem. I am not sure how helpful they were for I really did not expound upon anything but simply pointed out where their arguments did not approach the topic.

[quote] And I don't think the caps were meant for anger/yelling...I think those were to indicate what the pastor wrote from what my mother put. [/quote]I hope so. I am just used to taking all caps as yelling.

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Apr 2 2006, 08:26 PM']You said that prayer is NOT a form of worship. I disagree. In my Webster's Concise English Dictionary the definition of prayer is:
1.an earnest request. 2. words addressed to God in WORSHIP. thanksgiving, etc. [/quote]
well, to be more precise, prayer isn't [i][b]always[/b][/i] a form of worship. if that's not what you said, then that is what you meant (or should have meant, i didn't read the letter u wrote). the catholic knows full well, and agrees with the protestant, that "words addressed to God" are worship. but, we're not talking about words to God. we're talking about words to the saints, and in this instance, we use the first definition of prayer given in her dictionary, [i]not[/i] the second one.


[quote]This is why we do not pray to dead saints or to Mary. It is worship and we do not worship anyone but God.[/quote]
we don't worship anyone but God either. glad we settled that....


[quote]Prayer is worship. [/quote]
not always, as her very dictionary shows.


[quote]Matthew 15-8,9. 8 " These people honor me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me. 9 they worship me in vain; their teachings are but rules taught by men.NOT A MISCONCEPTION - PRAYER IS WORSHIP! MATTHEW 15:8,9 IS A CHIASTIC PARALLELISM - "HONORING GOD WITH THEIR LIPS" IS "WORSHIPING GOD IN VEIN."[/quote]
hopefully, prayer is always in our "veins" :thumbsup: haha, seriously tho, her comment here is off-topic and a red herring. no one is denying that prayer to God constitutes worship. we're not even talking about prayers to God here. we're talking about prayers to the saints. this type of prayer is totally different, and undertaken with a totally different mindset.


[quote]THE DICTIONARY DEFINITION OF "MEDIATE" 1) one who intervenes between two, either in order to make or restore peace and friendship, or form a compact, or for ratifying a covenant 2) a medium of communication, arbitrator

The definition of intercede is: to act between parties with a view to reconcile differences. 

Read both and tell me what the difference is.[/quote]
despite what some secular dictionary might say, the Church uses these words with different senses in mind. its like she's trying to say that we [i]actually[/i] mean something other than [i]what we say we mean[/i] when we use these words. if anyone knows what the Church intends to say with certain words, it is the Church. Webster's Dictionary does not know the mind of the Church, but instead the everyday definition of words. what is at issue here is how [i]the Church[/i] understands intercession and mediation, and so that is what we should be working with here.

btw, sweetpea, if the use of different terms is not helpful for you, then u can really just ditch the argument and focus on how we believe that the saints do something different than what Jesus does. Deal with the concepts, instead of the words used to describe these concepts.


[quote]They are both the same. So when people pray to dead saints or to Mary they are asking them to "go between" them and God. Which we both know is against what the Bible teaches.[/quote]
where does the bible teach this? all the verses she'll be able to come up with refer to Jesus' singular mediation, but we don't believe that saints "mediate" like Jesus does, so these verses are irrelevant.


i'm sorry, but i'll have to respond to the rest later.

pax christi,
nick

ps: why is she yelling? good grief.....

phatcatholic
Posted

now, on to the rest of your mother's response.....


[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Apr 2 2006, 08:26 PM'] Where in the Bible does it say that the saints can see what is happening on earth or hear us?[/quote]
well, u can't just throw a couple verses at this question and be done with it. our understanding of the saints and their heavenly awareness of what takes place on earth is a logical deduction from what is said about them throughout all of scripture. these two links are especially helpful:
[b]--[url="http://ic.net/~erasmus/RAZ94.HTM"]Cloud of Witnesses: A Biblical Primer on the Communion of Saints[/url]
--[url="http://ic.net/~erasmus/RAZ530.HTM"]The Communion of Saints: Biblical Overview[/url][/b]


[quote]"The true blessing is not to have the holy inhabitants bring our requests to the Lord like you said," but to have the Holy Spirit bring our requests to the Lord.[/quote]
its not an either-or proposition. instead, it is [i]both[/i] a blessing to have the saints praying for us [i]and[/i] to have the Holy Spirit praying for us. no one is denying that great help that the Holy Spirit is for us in times of prayer, we just acknowledge the benefit of the saints as well.

btw, that makes me wonder, perhaps the Holy Spirit is usurping the role of Christ too? that is what we must hold if we go by her logic. i thought we only had one mediator between God and man???

[note: always helpful to point out logical inconsistancies :thumbsup:]


[quote]Why would you want a human in heaven praying for you when you have God himself? Romans 8:26,27.[/quote]
well, as i'm sure you pointed out, "the prayers of the righteous availeth much" (James 5:16) and "the eyes of the Lord are upon the righteous, and his ears are open to their prayer" (1 Pet 3:12). that's all the reason in the world for me. see [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=49758&view=findpost&p=923983"][b]my earlier post[/b][/url] for more reasons why we would want to pray to "a human in heaven."


[quote]The reason to ask someone else to pray for you is not to change God. His mind is made up already. But that I, or the person praying for me, to line themselves up to God's will. I pray because God wants us to pray to him. [/quote]
who said we're trying to change God? we don't ask the saints to pray for us so that they will "change His mind", we ask them for the very reason that she articulated, because, as SAINTS in heaven enjoying the beatific vision through which they "understand fully" (1 Cor 13:12) the will of the Lord, they are MUCH more able to pray a prayer for us that is in complete accordance with his will. it is in this sense that their prayers are more effective than ours, [i]not[/i] b/c they are able to "change his mind."


haha, i'm having to do this in sections, sorry about that :blush: more to come after i eat.

pax christi,
nick

phatcatholic
Posted

on to part. 3.......


[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Apr 2 2006, 08:26 PM']> After all, in James 5:16, we read that the prayers of a righteous man have great power.

THAT'S NOT WHAT THE PASSAGE SAYS, IT SAYS LITERALLY, "VERY STRONG IS THE WORKING PRAYER OF A RIGHTEOUS MAN."[/quote]
what's the difference? talk about splitting hairs. lets look at how some different translations render James 5:16:

[b]NAS:[/b] "The effective prayer of a righteous man can accomplish much."

[b]ASV:[/b] "The supplication of a righteous man availeth much in its working."

[b]KJV:[/b] "The effectual fervent prayer of a righteous man availeth much."

[b]NRSV:[/b] "The prayer of the righteous is powerful and effective."

[b]RSV:[/b] "The prayer of a righteous man has great power in its effects."

[b]DRB:[/b] "For the continual prayer of a just man availeth much."

despite slight differences in wording, they all basically say the same thing. "great power", as you renedered it, and "very strong" as your mother rendered it [i]both mean the same thing[/i]. i'm not sure what she's trying to prove, but its not much.


[quote]PRAYER IS NOT A MEANS OF GRACE.[/quote]
i wonder if she means this sentence as it stands by itself, or does she mean "prayer is not a means of grace [i]if it isn't God's will[/i]." if she actually means that prayer is not a means of grace, w/o any qualification, than she has totally separated herself from scripture. anytime anyone receives strength, or healing, or victory, or encouragement, or vindication, or wisdom when they entreat the Lord, they receive his grace, which works these wonderful things in our lives.


[quote]IT CANNOT BRING A PERSON ONE RAIN DROP OR ONE BIT OF HEALING IF IT ISN'T GOD'S WILL. IT IS POWERFUL WHEN IT RECALLS GOD'S PROMISES AND REMINDS BOTH PRAYING PERSON AND HEARING PERSON OF GOD'S LOVE AND GRACE.[/quote]
agreed.


[quote]THE VERB FORM IS IN THE MIDDLE VOICE - WHICH MEANS IT IS SOMETHING THAT IS DONE TO THE PERSON REFLECTIVELY - NOT ACTIVELY. IN OTHER WORDS, THE PRAYER IS EFFECTIVE IN CAUSING A PERSON TO RECALL GOD'S PROMISES, NOT THE POWER THAT CAUSES GOD TO ACT. THE VERB POINTS THE ACTION BEING DONE TO THE PERSON, NOT THE PERSON CAUSING THE ACTION TO HAPPEN.[/quote]
she is dangerously close to denying the power of prayer. "ask and you will receive, seek and you will find, knock and it will be opened to you." it doesn't get much more clearer than that. i think this shows the great lengths that protestants will go to deny catholic doctrine. they'll even reject their own beliefs (surely your mother believes in the power of prayer) if they think it will get them one step closer towards refuting catholicism. :blink:


[quote]> How much more powerful must their prayers be then, those in God’s presence in heaven, than ours here on the sinful earth?

I DISAGREE BECAUSE OF ROMANS 8. WHAT MAKES A PRAYER POWERFUL IS GOD, NOT MAN.  AS PART OF GOD'S HOLY CHRISTIAN CHURCH MY PRAYERS ON EARTH FOR JESUS' SAKE ARE ACCEPTABLE TO GOD.[/quote]
let me make this clear: a saint's prayers are not more effective b/c of some power intrinsic to the saint. they are more effective b/c their prayers are in perfect accordance with the will of the Lord. so, its is [i]the alignment of their prayers with the will of the Lord[/i] that makes them effective. your mother is going to great lengths to prove this point, but we already agree.


[quote]LOCATION DOESN'T MAKE A PRAYER MORE ACCEPTABLE.[/quote]
well, in a sense it does, if your location is [i][b]before the very face of God[/b][/i]!! that is, unless your pastor would be so bold as to assert that he knows the will of God better than the saints in heaven. we understand the Lord as in a mirror dimly. the saints understand Him fully. the odds are in their favor :thumbsup:


looks like i have too many quote boxes. i'll conclude this in another post

pax christi,
nick

phatcatholic
Posted

part 4......


[quote]IF SHE MEANS "THEY KNOW ABOUT OUR FUTURE AND KNOW WHAT TO PRAY FOR" THEN I KNOW THERE ARE NO PASSAGES IN THE BIBLE THAT SAY THAT! ONLY GOD IS OMNISCIENT! I GO BACK TO ROMANS 8 AND THANK GOD HE IS PRAYING FOR ME, NOT SOME SAINT IN HEAVEN.[/quote]
"some saint in heaven." and the Body of Christ sheds a collective tear.......... :sadder:

this has never been about knowing the future, so there's no point to respond to this argument, other than to express your sorrow for it.


[quote]"You said that the Hail Mary is not a prayer to Mary? It is asking her to pray for us to God?" Which means it is a "prayer" to her to "pray"  to God for you. Right?[/quote]
yea, i guess, if we over-simplify the matter


[quote]What are Hail Mary's? [/quote]
its a prayer of praise and petition. we honor her [i]for the work that the Lord has done[/i] in her life and we ask her to pray for us. "Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners, now and at the hour of our death. Amen."


[quote]What is the rosary if it is not a prayer?[/quote]
well, [i]it is[/i] a prayer, basically, in both senses of the word. the hail mary's act as our request to Mary for her prayers. the meditations upon the life, passion, death, and resurrection of Jesus act as our worship of the Lord.


[quote]God said " Call upon me in the day of trouble", not call upon Mary or the saints.[/quote]
this verse is an affirmation of prayer to God, not a rejection of prayer to the saints. you will find no verse in the bible which says that we cannot pray to the saints.


[quote]Praying to Mary is to take God's glory away from where it belongs ~  to God alone and giving it to someone else. Which God forbids. Is 42:8 I will not give my glory to another. [/quote]
no it doesn't. as we've been saying in this thread, praying to the saints gives glory to the Lord. it affirms that he saves men, opens the gates of heaven to them, and gives them the grace to conquer death and to remain forever a member of the Body of Christ. prayer to the saints would not even exist where it not for the work of God in the lives of men. thus, praying to saints affirms all that he does for us and in us. it takes no glory away from God.

plus, we have examples throughout the bible of giving honor [i]to men[/i]:

Mat 15:4 Honour thy father and mother: And: He that shall curse father or mother, let him die the death.

Rom 13:7 Render therefore to all men their dues. Tribute, to whom tribute is due: custom, to whom custom: fear, to whom fear: honour, to whom honour.

Phil 2:29 Receive him [Epaphroditus] therefore with all joy in the Lord: and treat with honour such as he is.

1 Pet 2:17 Honour all men. Love the brotherhood. Fear God. Honour the king.

there are many examples in the OT as well, but protestants are inclined to discredit the OT whenever it serves their purposes, so stick w/ these for now.


[quote]You said "And even then, the Hail Mary is Scriptural also. (Luke 1:42-43, 48)

THIS WAS NOT A PRAYER TO MARY! IT WAS A STATEMENT OF FACT! NOTICE, ELIZABETH DID NOT ASK MARY TO PRAY TO GOD FOR HER![/quote]
we can't pray with the words of scripture?? why does it matter if the words themselves were a prayer that a biblical character was saying? these words are inspired by tthe Lord. the entire bible --not just the parts where people are praying-- is a rich resource of material for prayer. this stipulation your pastor is making is simply unrealistic and unfair. surely the content of many of his own prayers, and the hymns that he sings during his worship services are made up of various verses in the bible that were not actual prayers in scripture but still invoke wonderful sentiments that we wish to express. when i know not what to say, i often rely on the words of scripture. this would seem to be sound advice for [i]all[/i] christians.


[quote]You forgot verse 47 where Mary said: My soul glorifies the Lord and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior. Her thankfulness in V 48 is because of what she says in V 49 "for the Mighty one has done great things for me-holy is his name. Not because she is Holy or a Saint or  because of anything Mary has done. She is called blessed by me because of what God has done for her!

You said "The Catholic Church is clear about the centrality of Jesus. Without Him, these people would simply be dead, and no one would remain in the body of Christ after death. Praise to you, Lord Jesus Christ!" Does this mean they trust in Jesus alone for Salvation? If so, what is the purpose of penance?[right][snapback]933564[/snapback][/right][/quote]
yes, catholics do trust in God alone for their salvation. penance is not contradictory to this. God has desired to forgive man of his sin through the sacrament of penance, and so man humbles himself, lowly and contrite before the Lord, and approaches Him through the sacrament so as to obtain the forgiveness of his sins. the Lord is the efficient cause and the primary actor in the sacrament. the priest is but his instrument. it is faith in God alone for our salvation that compels us to avail ourselves of this sacrament in the first place.

i hope that helps.

pax christi,
nick

franciscanheart
Posted
:blink: ... ill be praying. :D:
phatcatholic
Posted

btw, i kinda forgot that i was responding to someone's mother w/ my post, so i apologize if my tone was a little harsh. i certainly intend no disrespect.

sweetpea316
Posted

No worries. Thanks SO much for all of your help Nick. I'll read through it all several times and make sure I understand it all myself, so that I'm not just copying and pasting what someone else said, ya know? But yeah, I'll tweak it so that it's more mom intended. ^_^

sweetpea316
Posted

[url="http://www.justforcatholics.org/answers.htm"]http://www.justforcatholics.org/answers.htm[/url]

This was sent to me... is it yet another Protestant site pretending they understand what the Catholic Church teaches?

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Apr 4 2006, 08:00 PM'][url="http://www.justforcatholics.org/answers.htm"]http://www.justforcatholics.org/answers.htm[/url]

This was sent to me... is it yet another Protestant site pretending they understand what the Catholic Church teaches?
[right][snapback]935771[/snapback][/right][/quote]
u guessed it

btw , show [i]him[/i] this:
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/[/url]

sweetpea316
Posted

Here is another question that was addressed to me... I'd love to hear what yall have to say. Thanks! ^_^


Q: How do the Roman Catholics see Luther today, and do they still believe he is still wrong?

A: For about a generation the Roman Catholic Church has accepted many of Luther's ideas: worship in the language of the people instead of Latin, encouraging Bible study, more participation by the people in the liturgy.

Even in Luther's lifetime the Roman Catholic Church began its own reformation, thus acknowledging that there was a need to reform.

However, three major themes or emphases in Luther's work are still rejected by the Roman Catholic Church. They are:

1) Authority in the church lies in Scripture alone (not in popes, councils, traditions, or human opinion.)

2) Justification and salvation are by God's grace alone. Not grace that enables us to do good works and gain God's favor, but grace that is God's favor based on his love without any merit in us.

3) God's grace becomes ours through faith alone, in Christ alone, not through our works or through a combination of faith and works, or by anything we do or have done.

Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Apr 6 2006, 02:30 PM']Here is another question that was addressed to me... I'd love to hear what yall have to say.  Thanks! ^_^
[right][snapback]937834[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
They hit some and miss others. Let me explain.

[quote]Q: How do the Roman Catholics see Luther today, and do they still believe he is still wrong? [/quote]As an excoummincated heretic. Yes he is still wrong in where his doctrinal points differ from Holy Mother Church.

[quote]A: For about a generation the Roman Catholic Church has accepted many of Luther's ideas: worship in the language of the people instead of Latin, encouraging Bible study, more participation by the people in the liturgy.
[/quote]These are practices and not particular to Luther. Latin is still the official language of the Church, and the preferable language of the Mass. The vernacular is the exception. Also, the Church has always promoted Bible study by those skilled enough to do so (meaning literate and educated). NB: The people have always assisted at Mass with the priest at the very least in prayer.

[quote]Even in Luther's lifetime the Roman Catholic Church began its own reformation, thus acknowledging that there was a need to reform.
[/quote]Reform in abuses and some practices yes, but I want to hammer home there was no need for reformation in doctrine or dogma.

[quote]1) Authority in the church lies in Scripture alone (not in popes, councils, traditions, or human opinion.)
[/quote]Correct. The Church is still non Sola Scriptura. We love our Tradition that has been handed down to us by the Apostles and thier successors.

[quote]2) Justification and salvation are by God's grace alone. Not grace that enables us to do good works and gain God's favor, but grace that is God's favor based on his love without any merit in us.[/quote]This is a misunderstanding of salvation. Good works are our response to grace in our life. We do not merit salvation. Try again.

[quote]3) God's grace becomes ours through faith alone, in Christ alone, not through our works or through a combination of faith and works, or by anything we do or have done.
[/quote]If you have a correct understanding of grace, that it is our participation in the life of God, then good works increases grace in us because are more aligned with the will, and thus life, of God.

I hope that helps. :ninja:

sweetpea316
Posted

www.GodOnThe.net/catholic_catechism
This one was sent to me today. It is supposed to be comparing what the CCC says to the Bible...but the person seems to not really understand what the CCC is talking about, therefore the site is quite uncool. And, of course it's going at it from the lovely Sola Scriptura point of view. Blargity.

Sooo, my mom was wanting a few websites that explain Catholic stuff well, but in a simple enough way for anyone to grasp. Which ones do yall recommend? :) (I'm so glad she's trying to find and is willing to read accurate stuff now! Praise God!!)

Posted

As to that webiste....it is too lengthy to reply topic by topic but let me know if you have any questions. You are correct, he misunderstands Catholicism and therefore attacks only straw men. I

sweetpea316
Posted

Yeah, there would be way too much on that site to cover on here. But thanks for checking it out...I was just wanting to see if it was as inaccurate as I thought.

[url="http://www.aboutcatholics.com/"]http://www.aboutcatholics.com/[/url]
[url="http://www.catholicbridge.com/"]http://www.catholicbridge.com/[/url] (great for Protestants!)

Can yall think of any other good sites that are easy to understand? (I'm afraid the defense directory might be a little over her head for now)

Thanks and God bless! ^_^

franciscanheart
Posted

If she has questions on specific things I think that New Advent would be an excellent resource. I usually have to read their articles a couple of times before I really understand things but that's what we're hoping for anyway, right (that she'll read and reread to try to understand what they are saying and not what she wants them to be saying)?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...