Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Sorry but if someone makes a comment so repugnant and uncalled for that the comment gets deleted and does nothing to apologize, I'm going to say something.

And since that someone is twelve, I'm not going to debate the kid. But I will call out the fact that he is a kid. Hence Tommy and the gameboy comments. Are they charitable? They're a heck of a lot more charitable then slapping the kid around theologically. (I'll save that for the adults who act twelve).

If the moderators feel that its ok for Tommy to continue to post when he's shown no remorse for his attacks on the Vicar of Christ, I will continue to demonstrate to any newcomers that the comments are coming from a child and should be taken as such.

He doesn't like it. Why? Because it spotlights that he is a child. It takes away the anonymity of the internet.


People need to show respect if they want to be respected.

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='Cam42' date='Mar 28 2006, 08:31 AM']There is a huge misunderstanding of what charity actually is.  Charity is not always about being "nice."  Sometimes being charitable is about presenting the truth to a given person in a straightforward way.

Ad hominem and ad hominem tu quoque attacks are actually pretty rare, however, I am very quick to call them (and all fallacies) out, not as a matter of repudiation, but rather as a means of how to learn how to debate properly.

Debating hard is not being uncharitable.  And it is very hard to discern the intent of what someone is typing.  Other times though it is very easy.  Tonality is hard, but reading a blatant slam is not. 

(While I have been guilty of slamming before and I am sure that I will in the future, it is usually as a response to an action that was levied at me to begin with.)

I think that we, as a board REALLY need to take a hard look at what true charity is, and what true charity is not. 

I have been asked, as a Church Scholar (and a formal theologian) to make a post on this; by one of the regulators.  I am working on putting together a post on this so it can be pinned to the board.  I have the text finished and have sent it on to one of my graduate professors in moral theology to confirm and give a sort of "nihil obstat" on the post.  As soon as this comes back I will post it and the regulator who asked will pin it to the board.

For the time being, I strongly suggest that we act in a charitable way, but charity is not always being sappy and caving into the opposition simply on the grounds of being "nice."  Because being nice isn't always an effective way to promote the truth.

It is often said that no one learn by beating a Bible over one's head.  That is not always the case.  Sometimes it takes a very stern wake-up call with the truth.

This has nothing to do with Lent.  This has to do with an incorrect view of charity.  We, as young Catholics, have not been properly catechized in what Charity truly is.  That is unfortunate.

While God is Love, as Pope Benedict says, He also is just.  Justice is not always being nice....ask the inhabitants of Sodom and Gammorah.  They will tell you.  Was that charitable?  Yes.  Was that nice?  Not necessarily.
[right][snapback]924806[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


make sure to include the Cliffs Notes version of your post...I get all :wacko: when I see huge blocks of text.

stbernardLT
Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Mar 27 2006, 10:12 PM']The board always gets sooo crabby during Lent!
[right][snapback]924656[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Especially on Fridays. (get it no meat) :lol_roll:

Ash Wednesday
Posted

*chortle*

Posted

[quote name='Cam42' date='Mar 28 2006, 06:31 AM']There is a huge misunderstanding of what charity actually is.  Charity is not always about being "nice."  Sometimes being charitable is about presenting the truth to a given person in a straightforward way.

Ad hominem and ad hominem tu quoque attacks are actually pretty rare, however, I am very quick to call them (and all fallacies) out, not as a matter of repudiation, but rather as a means of how to learn how to debate properly.

Debating hard is not being uncharitable.  And it is very hard to discern the intent of what someone is typing.  Other times though it is very easy.  Tonality is hard, but reading a blatant slam is not. 

(While I have been guilty of slamming before and I am sure that I will in the future, it is usually as a response to an action that was levied at me to begin with.)

I think that we, as a board REALLY need to take a hard look at what true charity is, and what true charity is not. 

I have been asked, as a Church Scholar (and a formal theologian) to make a post on this; by one of the regulators.  I am working on putting together a post on this so it can be pinned to the board.  I have the text finished and have sent it on to one of my graduate professors in moral theology to confirm and give a sort of "nihil obstat" on the post.  As soon as this comes back I will post it and the regulator who asked will pin it to the board.

For the time being, I strongly suggest that we act in a charitable way, but charity is not always being sappy and caving into the opposition simply on the grounds of being "nice."  Because being nice isn't always an effective way to promote the truth.

It is often said that no one learn by beating a Bible over one's head.  That is not always the case.  Sometimes it takes a very stern wake-up call with the truth.

This has nothing to do with Lent.  This has to do with an incorrect view of charity.  We, as young Catholics, have not been properly catechized in what Charity truly is.  That is unfortunate.

While God is Love, as Pope Benedict says, He also is just.  Justice is not always being nice....ask the inhabitants of Sodom and Gammorah.  They will tell you.  Was that charitable?  Yes.  Was that nice?  Not necessarily.
[right][snapback]924806[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

i do not mean that you should cave in. Christ reprimanded people a lot, but he did it with love. It does not mean that your argument is any less valid because you leave the bite out of some of the words.

It doesn't mean they have to be watered down.

True charity would demand that we correct the ignorant out of love, but it would also not cease to love. It might mean that their feelings are hurt, but the important part is that it was still charitable.

Mary-Kathryn
Posted (edited)

If this young man is actually 12, then he cannot learn from those who give him a "black eye" with their speech...ridiculing him, humiliating him, or making less of him because he is young. He is just as important in God's eyes as the ones who can rattle off Church Law, apologetics, etc... The one difference between him and those of us who are adults, is that he is a young person seeking and we are the ones giving. But just what is it that we are giving?

Children learn at the feet of adults. If we want to teach a child, do it with kindness: Listen to him, tell him what you know, and don't alienate him. Even if he won't come around to your satisfaction, you have planted the seed. Perhaps he may push a few buttons, so what? That's not too abnormal. Listen, be kind in speech and plant the truth wherever you go. You may only see the seed; you have to let go and trust that God will nourish the tree.

In the end, even if this young man is older, the reminder to practice kindness in speech has been placed in front of me. For that I am grateful

Mary-Kathryn

Edited by Mary-Kathryn
Posted

[quote name='Mary-Kathryn' date='Mar 28 2006, 09:15 AM']If this young man is actually 12, then he cannot learn from those who give him a "back eye" with their sppech...ridiculing him, humiliating him, or making less of him because he is young.  He is just as important in God's eyes as the ones who can rattle off Church Law, apologetics, etc... The one difference between him and those of us who are adults, is that he is a young person seeking and we are the ones giving.  But just what is it that we are giving?

Children learn at the feet of adults.  If we want to teach a child, do it with kindness:  Listen to him, tell him what you know, and don't alienate him.  Even if he won't come around to your satisfaction, you have planted the seed. Perhaps he may push a few buttons, so what? That's not too abnormal. Listen, be kind in speech and plant the truth wherever you go.  You may only see the seed; you have to let go and trust that God will nourish the tree. 

In the end, even if this young man is older, the reminder to practice kindness in speech has been placed in front of me. For that I am grateful

Mary-Kathryn
[right][snapback]924892[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

And what about the guests that come to this site? What about the high schoolers that are regular posters? Charity affects them as well.

No one actually believes that I can give Tommy a time out or take away his gameboy. It is a light hearted way of saying "This kid is twelve. Take his offensive opinions with a grain of salt" There is nothing humiliating about it. Nor is there any intent to humiliate the boy. But visitors who read his posts and do not know anything about Tommy need to be shown that Tommy's opinions are not taken seriously by those who frequent here.

Now if Tommy was seriously looking to glean some wisdom on the Church, there would be absolutely no gentle mocking of the boy. But all you have to do is read through one thread that he's posted on to realize that he is being impudent, rude and offensive.

stbernardLT
Posted

I think Jesus was a very kind person in the majority of situations. I don't think it is necessarily a question of charity, but more of pride. We have people on this board who love of Christ and the rest of His people but have a chip on their shoulder.(my self included at times) If Jesus spoke with point blank authority and was never wrong it is because HE IS GOD, we are not. Our approach maybe should be one of more humility and comprise between each other instead of I'm right/Your wrong. Knowledge is a very awesome gift, but the wisdom of how to translate that knowledge to others with humility is even better.

Maybe we should put a new rule ino practice. After every disagreeable post, the person posting should put the words "I Love You". I would even consider doing this for Cam.

(in fact)

Cam42, I Love You.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' date='Mar 28 2006, 08:25 AM']But all you have to do is read through one thread that he's posted on to realize that he is being impudent, rude and offensive.
[right][snapback]924899[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

In addition, I can't help but wonder if, like many adolescents, he actually deep down [i]likes[/i] the angry attention he's getting from adults. It's like reverse rebellion, if you will. Where an adolescent may typically rebel and offend from a nihilistic standpoint -- he chooses to rebel and offend, but instead of being nihilistic of sorts, put it under some mask of a "traditionalist" viewpoint. But what it boils down to is the same old desire to offend and gain attention.

Mary-Kathryn
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' date='Mar 28 2006, 09:25 AM']And what about the guests that come to this site?  What about the high schoolers that are regular posters?  Charity affects them as well.

No one actually believes that I can give Tommy a time out or take away his gameboy.  It is a light hearted way of saying "This kid is twelve.  Take his offensive opinions with a grain of salt"  There is nothing humiliating about it.  Nor is there any intent to humiliate the boy.  But visitors who read his posts and do not know anything about Tommy need to be shown that Tommy's opinions are not taken seriously by those who frequent here. 

Now if Tommy was seriously looking to glean some wisdom on the Church, there would be absolutely no gentle mocking of the boy.  But all you have to do is read through one thread that he's posted on to realize that he is being impudent, rude and offensive.
[right][snapback]924899[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


I find it unecessary to mock a child. What may seem inconsequential in words to us, can leave a wound on someone young, if care in speech is not taken. If we present ourselves and the Truth of The Church in an upright manner, then those who come here regularly or as guests, will learn. If we engage in a boxing match of words with a child, then who will want to stick around to read the Truth? Coming from a fundamentalist background, I have seen and experienced this form of sharing of the "truth" and am extremely repulsed by it. Thanks be to God that I never saw this hapening among Catholics when I was in the process of converting or I might have gone running.

I have read through this young man's posts...and even posted to him. If he is angry, striking out or confused, listen to him. I believe his post said that he only came to his conclusions in November. That's pretty recent. Obviously something has been deeply bothering him for awhile. Talk to him kindly and in a conversational tone. Take the opportunity, plant the seed, and pray for him. Show him the posting rules. If he's rude or overtly inflammatory, guide him to better speech by showing him what not to do and how to converse in an appropriate matter.

let us pray for one another!
Mary-Kathryn

Cow of Shame
Posted

[quote name='Cam42' date='Mar 28 2006, 08:31 AM']There is a huge misunderstanding of what charity actually is.  Charity is not always about being "nice."  Sometimes being charitable is about presenting the truth to a given person in a straightforward way.[/quote]

Hey! I agree with Cam.

[quote]  I have the text finished and have sent it on to one of my graduate professors in moral theology to confirm and give a sort of "nihil obstat" on the post.  As soon as this comes back I will post it and the regulator who asked will pin it to the board.[/quote]

Yeah, yeah....I'll obstat your nihil one of these days.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Mar 28 2006, 07:35 AM']Really? I beg to differ
And yes, I said that I sent him to the corner. I meant like in boxing, but I can see how it could look like a "time out." We were not charitable last night.
[right][snapback]924811[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

If this is uncharitable, than a lot of people owe me an apology from another thread.

Posted

The Catechism says this about young people:

[quote]Even in childhood man can attain spiritual maturity: as the book of Wisdom says: "For old age is not honored for length of time, or measured by number of years. "Many children, through the strength of the Holy Spirit they have received, have bravely fought for Christ even to the shedding of their blood.[124][/quote]

We should be careful to address that someone may be talking out of immaturity, but also not look down upon them.

There is one person specifically on these boards that drives me :crazy:, but I have never ever called this person out for it (despite the fact I know the person is young). I just succinctly make my point and leave it at that.

I think if someone is setting up for a debate, it is appropriate to "theologically clobber" them, no matter what their age. Someone else may be reading that needs the theology.

Brother Adam
Posted

On the other hand, even if they are young, they need to be called out. I don't know anyone that thinks the age of reason is much past 7 or 8. They need to know what they are doing is wrong, sinful. It is worsened, especially because they are spreading false information that could harm other visitors.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 28 2006, 10:23 AM']If this is uncharitable, than a lot of people owe me an apology from another thread.
[right][snapback]924962[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I don't think anyone called you names, but if I did, I appologize. Charitable or not, calling names is unkind.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 28 2006, 10:28 AM']On the other hand, even if they are young, they need to be called out. I don't know anyone that thinks the age of reason is much past 7 or 8. They need to know what they are doing is wrong, sinful. It is worsened, especially because they are spreading false information that could harm other visitors.
[right][snapback]924968[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I agree. But can't you say, "You are wrong" without calling him Tommy and threatening to take away his gameboy? That's demeaning. I'm surprised no one told him to go crying off to his mommy. That kind of talk doesn't make for a good debate.

Posted

[quote name='Mary-Kathryn' date='Mar 28 2006, 10:19 AM']I find it unecessary to mock a child.  What may seem inconsequential in words to us, can leave a wound on someone young, if care in speech is not taken.  If we present ourselves and the Truth of The Church in an upright manner, then those who come here regularly or as guests, will learn.  If we engage in a boxing match of words with a child, then who will want to stick around to read the Truth? Coming from a fundamentalist background, I have seen and experienced this form of  sharing of the "truth" and am extremely repulsed by it.  Thanks be to God that I never saw this hapening among Catholics when I was in the process of converting or I might have gone running.

I have read through this young man's posts...and even posted to him.  If he is angry, striking out or confused, listen to him. I believe his post said that he only came to his conclusions in November. That's pretty recent. Obviously something has been deeply bothering him for awhile.  Talk to him kindly and in a conversational tone. Take the opportunity, plant the seed, and pray for him. Show him the posting rules. If he's rude or overtly inflammatory, guide him to better speech by showing him what not to do and how to converse in an appropriate matter.

let us pray for one another!
Mary-Kathryn
[right][snapback]924956[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I don't find it necessary to mokc people either. But it can be rather fun. A brief list of my mocking on the board

suggesting that Catholic studies is not a real major
certain members have uncontrollable gas
certain members are actually the car from Knight Rider
others are in fact a rare breed of owl
some enjoy eggs made solely of pork

Oh and giving a timeout to a twelve year old.

If and when I've unintentionally hurt someone's feelings or stepped over a line, I apologize.


Calling him Tommy and threatening to take away his toys is not going to cause harm or damage. If it did, he has far greater issues to deal with.

And if you've read his posts, it must be clear to you that he is simply cutting and pasting. He is also trying to bully others on the board.

I think Ash is probably correct on her assessment. But no one has been mean to the kid.

Seriously

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Mar 28 2006, 10:31 AM']I agree. But can't you say, "You are wrong" without calling him Tommy and threatening to take away his gameboy? That's demeaning. I'm surprised no one told him to go crying off to his mommy. That kind of talk doesn't make for a good debate.
[right][snapback]924972[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

A message board is often reactionary. People read something absurd, faulty, and they react to how a persons 'attitude' is coming through. I can think of one church scholar who does it alot under the guise that "charity is not being nice". He doesn't just stick to issues, and he doesn't give respect, on the other hand, he gets personal, and regulators have never 'called him out on it.'

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Mar 28 2006, 10:31 AM']I agree. But can't you say, "You are wrong" without calling him Tommy and threatening to take away his gameboy? That's demeaning. I'm surprised no one told him to go crying off to his mommy. That kind of talk doesn't make for a good debate.
[right][snapback]924972[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Hey let's be fair

I've also tussled the little guy's hair

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...