Cow of Shame Posted March 29, 2006 Posted March 29, 2006 [quote name='Sailahína' date='Mar 28 2006, 06:37 PM'] I don't like Natalie Portman. [right][snapback]925788[/snapback][/right] [/quote] What are you basing that on, exactly?
Seven77 Posted March 29, 2006 Posted March 29, 2006 that movie is rabidly anti Catholic.. decentfilms.com does the guy ever take his mask off?
inDEED Posted March 30, 2006 Posted March 30, 2006 [quote name='Seven77' date='Mar 29 2006, 03:42 PM']does the guy ever take his mask off? [right][snapback]927456[/snapback][/right] [/quote] No, he doesn't.
inDEED Posted March 30, 2006 Posted March 30, 2006 I didn't think it was SPECIFICALLY anti-Catholic as much as anti-establishment. It was okay...I probably wouldn't recommend it to anyone...But, it did raise some interesting questions.
TheOliverOrder88 Posted March 30, 2006 Posted March 30, 2006 (edited) Eh, I loved it and hated it. The Koran thing caught my eye. I really can't find enough disgust for its implications in the movie. Meaning, how the church/government executes homosexuals and all those "different" people. Then again nowadays Islamic run countries do the same. In the movie they claim the book to be beautiful and poetic. I dont understand that at all. The pedophile bishop looking back....1) This was written befor the exposing of all the scandals, so there isn't a direct coralation. 2) It is a consequence of what has happened. The Church is in a bad stereotype these days...this shows it. I liked it because of the story, the action at times was a bit violent...I dont like blood and gore, the one scene where he kills all the guards had a medium amount of it. I think it was smart. I enjoyed half of it. It was right about one or two things but wrong about it all. Edited March 30, 2006 by TheOliverOrder88
Antonius Posted March 30, 2006 Posted March 30, 2006 (edited) I really don't want to see a leftist propaganda film. [url="http://www.newyorker.com/printables/critics/060320crci_cinema"]David Denby of the [i]New Yorker [/i]reviews [i]V for Vendetta[/i].[/url] [url="http://www.godspy.com/reviews/a-review-of-v-for-vendetta-by-john-zmirak.cfm"]John Zmirak of [i]Godspy.com[/i] reviews [i]V for Vendetta[/i].[/url] Edited March 30, 2006 by Antonius
DemonSlayer Posted March 30, 2006 Posted March 30, 2006 (edited) [quote name='inDEED' date='Mar 30 2006, 07:07 AM']I didn't think it was SPECIFICALLY anti-Catholic as much as anti-establishment. It was okay...I probably wouldn't recommend it to anyone...But, it did raise some interesting questions. [right][snapback]927558[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yeah, the bishop/church in the film is meant to be Anglican, not Catholic. Edited March 30, 2006 by DemonSlayer
inDEED Posted March 30, 2006 Posted March 30, 2006 [quote name='Antonius' date='Mar 29 2006, 10:04 PM']I really don't want to see a leftist propaganda film. [url="http://www.newyorker.com/printables/critics/060320crci_cinema"]David Denby of the [i]New Yorker [/i]reviews [i]V for Vendetta[/i].[/url] [url="http://www.godspy.com/reviews/a-review-of-v-for-vendetta-by-john-zmirak.cfm"]John Zmirak of [i]Godspy.com[/i] reviews [i]V for Vendetta[/i].[/url] [right][snapback]928002[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Then don't...
inDEED Posted March 30, 2006 Posted March 30, 2006 [quote name='Antonius' date='Mar 29 2006, 10:04 PM']I really don't want to see a leftist propaganda film. [/quote] And, btw - that's EXACTLY what it is...
Oik Posted March 30, 2006 Posted March 30, 2006 M, are you being sarcastic? What did you think of the movie casue I am really seriously debating on whether to see it or not and I'd like to read what you thought (cus you bring an interesting perspective).
Oik Posted March 30, 2006 Posted March 30, 2006 I read your previous post and am wondering if you could elaborate.
YMNolan Posted April 2, 2006 Posted April 2, 2006 I just saw it last night. Basically it was a series of ups and downs for me throughout the film. It certainly was blatant leftist propaganda. Interestingly enough, the original story in Alan Moore's graphic novel, was about the extremes of fascism v.s. anarchy. When Moore heard that the filmmakers had taking liberties to add in themes of American Leftwing thought v.s Rightwing thought, he detached his name from the film. The presence of two major themes I think really hurt the film. Inadvertantly, aside from the Bush bashing, the film makes some interesting statements about the other extreme. After all, V is a terrorist who combats violence with more violence. He also not once turns his blame inward and points to himself as a cause to state of the culture. So, there are some things to think about. Plus the action sequences were cool.
jp2_rules Posted April 3, 2006 Posted April 3, 2006 i saw the movie last week. i liked it overall. the movie was, for the most part, very well made. there were definitely some questions that it raised. but then again, isn't that something that movies and entertainment should do? otherwise we get caught not actually thinking about things. here's some of what i got from it. and i've discussed the movie extensively with friends and classmates here at school. by the way, don't read this if you're planning on seeing it and are afraid of spoilers.. the role of V is partially that of a hero. he brings down the system (the Man, for all you School of Rock fans). however, after he imprisoned the girl, he tries to justify himself. he says that the government did beastly things to him. she responds that he's in turn turned into a beast. she's not happy that he's doing things the way he is. so in that sense, and in the movie overall, they portray V as a crazy dude, trying to do what he thinks is right. unfortunately, his personal vendetta sometimes overshadows his other effort of trying to bring down a corrupt government. the pedophile priest. this really bothered a lot of people i know. it's not that i don't understand that, but i think it's making an interesting, and ultimately, good, point. it is showing that corruption can and does place everywhere; even in the solidly-established church. and yes, i know, it's anglican, and that's because the movie is set in england. they would have used a catholic priest if it was in the states. i think the pedophile aspect is unnecessary. but the point they were making, i believe, was how widespread the corruption was. the lesbian scene. i'm not sure on this one. there are different views on it. i think what they were trying to do is show that anyone who stepped out of the boundaries of what the government decided was acceptable was completely shunned. i'm not going to get into an argument about whether or not homosexuals should be shunned or not, but i think they were trying to pick a group that was outside now, and receives little tolerance, and showing that they recieved less in the world shown in the film. the violence in the movie was almost non-existent. the only violent scene i can recall was the one near the end with the guards. and it was all very stylized. it wasn't graphic at all. it was more of a, "oh, there's some liquid substance flying across the screen, that must be blood. and since that guy's falling, he must have just been cut." it was wasn't horrendous. ultimately in the movie, the londoners learn that they can stand up for themselves and not just do what the governmnet tells them to do. they aren't and shouldn't just sit back and get trampled on, simply because the government says so. and i think that's the main premise. they just use the "V for Vendetta" thing a lot, and put a lot of focus on the vendetta aspect of the film. i'm not sure i'd recommend it in a heartbeat, but i liked it overall. and like i said, movies aren't supposed to be mindless entertainment. and when it is, how many ideas are being put into your head that you don't even realize? this one makes you think, and even though i don't agree with it all, the fact that it causes one to think and presents some good points is a positive quality.
Socrates Posted April 3, 2006 Posted April 3, 2006 [quote name='jp2_rules' date='Apr 2 2006, 06:14 PM']i saw the movie last week. i liked it overall. the movie was, for the most part, very well made. there were definitely some questions that it raised. but then again, isn't that something that movies and entertainment should do? otherwise we get caught not actually thinking about things. here's some of what i got from it. and i've discussed the movie extensively with friends and classmates here at school. by the way, don't read this if you're planning on seeing it and are afraid of spoilers.. the role of V is partially that of a hero. he brings down the system (the Man, for all you School of Rock fans). however, after he imprisoned the girl, he tries to justify himself. he says that the government did beastly things to him. she responds that he's in turn turned into a beast. she's not happy that he's doing things the way he is. so in that sense, and in the movie overall, they portray V as a crazy dude, trying to do what he thinks is right. unfortunately, his personal vendetta sometimes overshadows his other effort of trying to bring down a corrupt government. the pedophile priest. this really bothered a lot of people i know. it's not that i don't understand that, but i think it's making an interesting, and ultimately, good, point. it is showing that corruption can and does place everywhere; even in the solidly-established church. and yes, i know, it's anglican, and that's because the movie is set in england. they would have used a catholic priest if it was in the states. i think the pedophile aspect is unnecessary. but the point they were making, i believe, was how widespread the corruption was. the lesbian scene. i'm not sure on this one. there are different views on it. i think what they were trying to do is show that anyone who stepped out of the boundaries of what the government decided was acceptable was completely shunned. i'm not going to get into an argument about whether or not homosexuals should be shunned or not, but i think they were trying to pick a group that was outside now, and receives little tolerance, and showing that they recieved less in the world shown in the film. the violence in the movie was almost non-existent. the only violent scene i can recall was the one near the end with the guards. and it was all very stylized. it wasn't graphic at all. it was more of a, "oh, there's some liquid substance flying across the screen, that must be blood. and since that guy's falling, he must have just been cut." it was wasn't horrendous. ultimately in the movie, the londoners learn that they can stand up for themselves and not just do what the governmnet tells them to do. they aren't and shouldn't just sit back and get trampled on, simply because the government says so. and i think that's the main premise. they just use the "V for Vendetta" thing a lot, and put a lot of focus on the vendetta aspect of the film. i'm not sure i'd recommend it in a heartbeat, but i liked it overall. and like i said, movies aren't supposed to be mindless entertainment. and when it is, how many ideas are being put into your head that you don't even realize? this one makes you think, and even though i don't agree with it all, the fact that it causes one to think and presents some good points is a positive quality. [right][snapback]933548[/snapback][/right] [/quote] The problem is that hollywood movies almost invariably only "make you think" in a Left-wing fashion. The "bad guys" are usually quite predictable - "fascism" or anything "conservative" (usually equated by hollywood), traditional religion or morality (usually protrayed as repressive, sick or hypocritical), and "big business" (which usually excludes Hollywood, of course). The viewer is almost never invited to question any of the Left's sacred cows. Even communists are almost never portrayed as villains. Rather than being "intelligent" or "thought-provoking," hollywood seems to basically repeatedly serve up one-sided and predictable Lefty propaganda.
Sojourner Posted April 3, 2006 Posted April 3, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' date='Apr 2 2006, 08:31 PM']Rather than being "intelligent" or "thought-provoking," hollywood seems to basically repeatedly serve up one-sided and predictable Lefty propaganda. [right][snapback]933568[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Which, because you don't agree with it can be neither intelligent nor thought-provoking?
toledo_jesus Posted April 3, 2006 Posted April 3, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' date='Apr 3 2006, 10:13 AM']Which, because you don't agree with it can be neither intelligent nor thought-provoking? [right][snapback]933943[/snapback][/right] [/quote] thought-provoking perhaps. However, too often what could stop at merely exposing hypocrisy turns into an affirmation of wrong-doing and sin. For example, no Christian would round up and execute homosexuals, but neither should they acknowledge that the homosexual has a morally licit attraction. That's what these movies end up conveying. They highlight the hypocrisy without providing a realistic portrayal of why homosexuality is wrong. Therefore, we can say that they do not provide a well-rounded assessment of the situation and cannot be called 'intelligent.'
dspen2005 Posted April 3, 2006 Posted April 3, 2006 [quote name='inDEED' date='Mar 29 2006, 06:07 PM']I didn't think it was SPECIFICALLY anti-Catholic as much as anti-establishment. It was okay...I probably wouldn't recommend it to anyone...But, it did raise some interesting questions. [right][snapback]927558[/snapback][/right] [/quote] from what i understand, though, there is a character -- a bishop - is portrayed as being complicit with whatever travesty is going on.... the Catholc Standard and Times here in the Archdiocese of Philadelphia has classified it as "Adult w/ Reservations" -- in other words, it isn't good.... plus, it just doesn't seem that appealing to me to begin w/
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now