jp2_rules Posted April 3, 2006 Posted April 3, 2006 but the movie didn't say anything about homosexuality being morally licit. that was brokeback mountain's job. the movie was simply showing an intolerance of all but those who followed the communist-like government. anyone who dared step outside their confines was excluded entirely from the community. was there/is there more behind that in hollywood's agenda about homosexuality? i don't know..maybe. but in this particular film, they are trying to make a point. did i want to watch two women kiss to make that point? no, not at all. but the point was made. i would like to add that it is impossible to learn the entirety of an issue without understanding both sides. so it is necessary to have "bad guys", no matter how predictable, in fims. just like we talk about utilitarianism in my ethics class. it doesn't mean by any stretch that that's what should be used, but we have to learn about it if we want to combat it. and i think V's role isn't really a typical and predictable bad guy anyway.
jp2_rules Posted April 3, 2006 Posted April 3, 2006 [quote name='dspen2005' date='Apr 3 2006, 02:42 PM']from what i understand, though, there is a character -- a bishop - is portrayed as being complicit with whatever travesty is going on.... the Catholc Standard and Times here in the Archdiocese of Philadelphia has classified it as "Adult w/ Reservations" -- in other words, it isn't good.... plus, it just doesn't seem that appealing to me to begin w/ [right][snapback]934353[/snapback][/right] [/quote] the bishop was compliant, and that was the problem. that problem is what they were showing in the movie. the problem is that the corruption spread everywhere; even into the church, which is firmly established. not to say the church is corrupt, but that members within it can be. and that is a problem; a [i]HUGE [/i]problem. and we need to realize that there are religious out there who have agendas, as sad as it is, and as little as we'd like to recognize the fact. and we need to be on guard against that, and letting it happen.
track2004 Posted April 3, 2006 Posted April 3, 2006 I really liked this movie. I thought that the adaptation of the graphic novel was really good, though in the graphic novel they never actually come out and say it was a Guy Faux mask (but the English people it was written for would have gotten that). I also thought that most of the imagery was more symbolic than anything else. The muslims, homosexuals and other 'unwanted' groups were very riminicent of Hitler's non-Aryan groups. The groups they picked are almost convention for the genre. The really intersting things I saw I only caught the second time I saw it. There is a lot of foreshadowing and subtle contextual clues about who is who and what they are trying to do. Most of all I guess, I was impressed how they used the mask as a symbol of individual freedom and how to fight against the government. Guy was a terrorist by today's standards, he wanted to blow up Parliment, granted he had his reasons but don't they all. The English holiday on the 5th of November was typically celebrated because the police caught him, tradition calls for burning effigies of him. But in the film V is fighting against the government, which is decidedly corrupt. I thought it was an intelligent use of characterizations and known history. The only real thing that disappointed me in the movie was how little Evie got to use her new found freedom. She becomes this amazing woman, but it is never really exploited. The thing to remember is that this wasn't written in the last 5 years, it was before 9/11 and yet it parallels what today could become. It reads a lot like 1984 or Farenheight 451, but since it was produced in today's society we can see how possible this fictional world is (and take offense or action).
Nathan Posted April 3, 2006 Posted April 3, 2006 I thought the film was ridiculous. It takes everything that is horrific about left-wing politics and calls it "conservatism." A shrewd ploy by liberal Hollywood to confuse people about who the real enemy is.
Socrates Posted April 4, 2006 Posted April 4, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' date='Apr 3 2006, 08:13 AM']Which, because you don't agree with it can be neither intelligent nor thought-provoking? [right][snapback]933943[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I don't regard its premises (which are actually kind of liberal cliches) particularly intelligent, and the only thoughts this kind of stuff provokes in me are about how full-of-it hollywood lefties are. V basically makes the usual predictable lefty "lessons": Fascists are bad. Racists are bad. Conservatives are basically just fascists and racist, and are also bad. Christians are bad. People who are against homosexuality are bad. People who fight Muslims are bad. Homosexuality is good. Non-Christians are good. Violent nihilists fighting "the system" are good. Hardly anything profound there, are even truly "bold" by Hollywood standards. For those who think the story "prophetic," it should be noted that the movie-makers changed the story to make the fascists and their rise to power like the Bush administration. As noted in one of the reviews, Alan Moore (a radical Leftist himself) had his name removed from the credits because he was not happy with how how his story was being turned into cheesy political propaganda. Islam and the Koran were not in the original graphic novel. As a reviewer noted, it was ironic that Christians were shown as repressors, while Islam was supposedly on the side of freedom and truth. Hollywood churns out movie after movie about the evils of "McCarthyism," repressed American society, the hypocrisy of organized religion, the joys of various forms of sexual "liberation," yet we see almost nothing about the evils of Communism or atheism, the tyranny and hypocrisy of political correctness, nor the rewards of a chaste life. The Hollwood folks repeatedly churn out the same Leftist tripe, then stand around slapping each other on the back, telling each other how "bold" and "provocative" they are. Yet make a movie about the Passion of the Christ, then you will see what really provokes the hollywood set! Remember all the furor over Mel Gibson? The Passion was roundly denounced by Hollywood leftists as unnacceptable hate speech, while Michael Moore was praised for his "boldness." Idiots like Andrew Sullivan even compared the non-political [i]Passion[/i] to [i]Farenheit 911[/i], condemning the religious film as right-wing political propaganda.
track2004 Posted April 4, 2006 Posted April 4, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' date='Apr 3 2006, 06:16 PM'] Islam and the Koran were not in the original graphic novel. As a reviewer noted, it was ironic that Christians were shown as repressors, while Islam was supposedly on the side of freedom and truth. [right][snapback]934618[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Sorry for my mistake. But even so the movie never said that Islam was right or even good. They said that the Koran has beautiful poetry which is true. Just because you don't believe in Islam doesn't mean that the writings aren't good. Hell we have to read Greek and Roman literature and no one really says that is not beautiful even though they were polytheists. It wasn't that Islam was "on the side of freedom and truth" it was that they were being unduely opressed.
jp2_rules Posted April 4, 2006 Posted April 4, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' date='Apr 3 2006, 07:16 PM']Yet make a movie about the Passion of the Christ, then you will see what really provokes the hollywood set! Remember all the furor over Mel Gibson? The Passion was roundly denounced by Hollywood leftists as unnacceptable hate speech, while Michael Moore was praised for his "boldness." Idiots like Andrew Sullivan even compared the non-political [i]Passion[/i] to [i]Farenheit 911[/i], condemning the religious film as right-wing political propaganda. [right][snapback]934618[/snapback][/right] [/quote] and yet hollywood stood back in awe at what the Passion did, and recognize Christians as an audience now. they (people who actually matter in Hollywood) actually look upon the Passion as something amazing, and have changed some of the ways they look at movies as a result. don't take their initial reaction to the film as the viewpoint of all there, or the way they view it now. i know it's easy to say that everyone in Hollywood has an agenda to force on the world, but the fact of the matter is, many of them are poor, ignorant people. and not everything they do has an agenda (although, yes, a lot does). the problem i have with what you are saying about this movie is that it does not come out and say, be homosexual, hate Christians. and it does not idolize the role of V.
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted April 4, 2006 Posted April 4, 2006 Yeah, I thought it was a cool movie at the beginning, but then I heard from a Catholic source it bashed the Catholic church.
Snarf Posted April 4, 2006 Posted April 4, 2006 I'm glad we have Socrates here to classify who's an idiot.
jp2_rules Posted April 4, 2006 Posted April 4, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' date='Apr 3 2006, 07:16 PM']...nor the rewards of a chaste life. [/quote] that's actually not true, either. Hollywood has realized that sex is no longer an answer. it's a question. it doesn't solve problems, it creates them. it's very interesting to see looking at Hollywood how lost and confused so many of the people are. they are searching along with the rest of the society. and they are realizing that sex, drugs, alcohol and atheism aren't helping them. that doesn't mean they don't continue to turn to them; it's just like converting, it takes time. however, they are searching, and they are learning as they search.
ninjakyle Posted April 4, 2006 Posted April 4, 2006 Mixed reactions from me. The theme that I did like was Evey overcoming her fear of death . . . and really willing to be a martyr for her cause (or V's cause). And when she was willing to die for what she believed in, she was suddenly free. Free from fear, and you can tell there was relief and peace in her. An understanding that if Christians had, I think we would be much better off. Although suicide terrorists are obviously disordered, they have passion and faith, something most of us Christians lack, but if we had it, we would change the world.
track2004 Posted April 4, 2006 Posted April 4, 2006 I really like that theme too, that without fear we are all free. It comes up in movies like Fight Club too. It isn't that we are (could be) suicide terrorists, but that we are so assured in what we believe that noone could make us deny it. It is somewhere between giving it all up and taking full control. On one hand giving up the fear and excuses makes us stronger and more ready than anythings, but on the other, we take control of the couse of our own lives by being able to say 'no matter what, this I know'.
Sojourner Posted April 4, 2006 Posted April 4, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' date='Apr 3 2006, 08:16 PM']Hollywood churns out movie after movie about the evils of "McCarthyism," repressed American society, the hypocrisy of organized religion, the joys of various forms of sexual "liberation," yet we see almost nothing about the evils of Communism or atheism, the tyranny and hypocrisy of political correctness, nor the rewards of a chaste life. The Hollwood folks repeatedly churn out the same Leftist tripe, then stand around slapping each other on the back, telling each other how "bold" and "provocative" they are. Yet make a movie about the Passion of the Christ, then you will see what really provokes the hollywood set! Remember all the furor over Mel Gibson? The Passion was roundly denounced by Hollywood leftists as unnacceptable hate speech, while Michael Moore was praised for his "boldness." Idiots like Andrew Sullivan even compared the non-political [i]Passion[/i] to [i]Farenheit 911[/i], condemning the religious film as right-wing political propaganda. [right][snapback]934618[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Given your disdain for Hollywood, and its inability to put out a decent, thought-provoking film, I'm a bit surprised that you ever watch movies. Why open yourself up to something you obviously find objectionable? I don't go to movies I know I'm going to hate. Life is too short to be so angry.
Oik Posted April 4, 2006 Posted April 4, 2006 One of the most disappointing aspects of Phatmass is seeing the Moderators, Faithful. Militants argue and insult each other. I find it discouraging that there are so many here that are quick to criticize others (both "liberals" and "conservatives"). We are in the seaon of the Great Fast, let's live Charity and Repentance.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now