Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

So...I got into a debate...


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Apr 5 2006, 08:48 AM']I can understand snapping with 40 hours plus 18 credits. I'd snap to. Almost anyone would. You should only take on what you can handle. Most students take 15 credits, spread out between theology, cat, and liberal arts classes and don't work or only work a few hours. Life is tough. I've cried more than once this semester. But at the same time you grow in knowledge and wisdom.
[right][snapback]936448[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I'm fine lol I know what I can handle. It's not as bad as I thought it was going to be. Hehe thank goodness work is slow sometimes so I can get homework done lol Yesterday's break down was a combination of 2 exams and a paper in one day compounded with worrying about certain people lol Feel lots better now though.

Brother Adam
Posted

There are only two teachers I think are truly unfair, and both are theology.

When you have to take CST with Miller, get yourself blessed just for your survival in that class. It's hell.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Apr 5 2006, 08:56 AM']There are only two teachers I think are truly unfair, and both are theology.

When you have to take CST with Miller, get yourself blessed just for your survival in that class. It's hell.
[right][snapback]936460[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

:wacko:

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='StColette' date='Apr 5 2006, 10:38 AM']Believe me I understand where Micah is coming from with the time issue. It takes every bit of mental ability and well physical ability I have to keep up with what I'm doing. 40hrs of work plus 18 credit hrs for  then homework. Then trying to manage to fit in time to spend with friends, then Mass, adoration, rosary (said in the shower lol). It can be rather exhausting both physically and emotionally. At the same time I'm think I'm used to working so much since during Middle School and High School I worked for my dad plus took care of school stuff. But as evident yesterday I finally had a nice emotional breakdown from stress lol skipped my last class and went and cried in Adoration, came out feeling a lot better. A lot of the time the entire work load gets really overwhelming where you just kinda want to scream. But I loved yesterdays Entrance for Mass. Put your hope in the Lord, have courage and be strong.
[right][snapback]936441[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I love you.

I'm not going to give up the devotions I've practiced. They are a part of my spiritual life and to drop them for anything short of a directive from a spiritual director would be dropping a part of who I am.

I have been trying to study harder lately, but I am still only able to skim texts. My grades, on average, remain nonetheless decent.

I made this thread because there was a debate over a principle, not because I was trying to discuss my own spiritual life. However, as it became tied almost immediately to my own spiritual life, I felt that I had to go into defense. You do not tell a scrupulant what a horrible job he is doing at something he tries very hard to do, against all reasonable hope (if such a thing exists), just because he is not capable of doing better.

The fact of the matter is that I cannot possibly read all that is assigned...even if I did drop everything else: prayer, work, social life, girlfriend, etc. The fact of the matter is indeed that I learn differently. I can't read like you all can...I've had to adapt...that is why I skim and pull out the basic argument when I have to, although it is better for me when the argument is handed to me in a bare bones form and I am given the chance to think about it (because, as StColette will tell you, I never stop thinking). That's probably why whenever teachers of difficult classes (such as catechetics, which is designed to weed out the disinterested students) use simple outline forms in class like bullet points, I get high marks, stay attentive, and do well.

Yes, I would learn more if I could learn from the original texts. However, I simply do not have that gift. I would be happy, however, to have an outline which references the original texts so that I could follow the basic structure and contemplate it on my own.

All attacks on my study habits thus far come from those who seem better at distilling information out of text. I, on the other hand, work in reverse.

Now, back to the original argument which was a matter of PRINCIPLE, not personality.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Apr 5 2006, 09:57 AM']I love you.

I'm not going to give up the devotions I've practiced.  They are a part of my spiritual life and to drop them for anything short of a directive from a spiritual director would be dropping a part of who I am.

I have been trying to study harder lately, but I am still only able to skim texts.  [b]My grades, on average, remain nonetheless decent.[/b]

I made this thread because there was a debate over a principle, not because I was trying to discuss my own spiritual life.  However, as it became tied almost immediately to my own spiritual life, I felt that I had to go into defense.  You do not tell a scrupulant what a horrible job he is doing at something he tries very hard to do, against all reasonable hope (if such a thing exists), just because he is not capable of doing better.

The fact of the matter is that I cannot possibly read all that is assigned...even if I did drop everything else: prayer, work, social life, girlfriend, etc.  The fact of the matter is indeed that I learn differently.  I can't read like you all can...I've had to adapt...that is why I skim and pull out the basic argument when I have to, although it is better for me when the argument is handed to me in a bare bones form and I am given the chance to think about it (because, as StColette will tell you, I never stop thinking).  That's probably why whenever teachers of difficult classes (such as catechetics, which is designed to weed out the disinterested students) use simple outline forms in class like bullet points, I get high marks, stay attentive, and do well.

Yes, I would learn more if I could learn from the original texts.  However, I simply do not have that gift.  I would be happy, however, to have an outline which references the original texts so that I could follow the basic structure and contemplate it on my own.

All attacks on my study habits thus far come from those who seem better at distilling information out of text.  I, on the other hand, work in reverse.

Now, back to the original argument which was a matter of PRINCIPLE, not personality.
[right][snapback]936464[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Solution: Less Sleep. :P:

But, another fact is that 2 hours of devotions/prayer doesn't take away that much time from your day... make a schedule and stick to it.

Posted

Wait till grad school

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' date='Apr 5 2006, 10:02 AM']Wait till grad school
[right][snapback]936471[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

lol.... yep. :mellow:

Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' date='Apr 5 2006, 11:02 AM']Wait till grad school
[right][snapback]936471[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Or working a full-time job.

Or marriage and kids.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Apr 5 2006, 08:57 AM']I love you.[right][snapback]936464[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Love you too!

Posted

Being in law school (which is definately way more reading than undergrad!!!!) and discerning a vocation, I can sympathize with your difficulty in balancing homework and prayer. What helps me is to set up a regular prayer/study schedule...like what they do in convent (and probably in the seminary). So I set aside specific times for prayer and specific times for class/homework. It means making sacrifices in terms of doing other things, but I think that it can definately be done, regardless of your homework load.

Brother Adam
Posted

Wait until grad school.

Or working a full-time job.

Or marriage and kids.



haha. In the fall I'll have all three! :yahoo:

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

The full time job I won't mind. In fact, I'm certain I'll enjoy it more than school...I will, afterall, be doing something I love.

As for grad school...I'm still not sure if I'll be going. ;) If I get teacher certification, I just might not.

As for marriage and kids...yes, but they are both a cause of stress and a relief from it.

I went to Mass and feel a lot better.

Adam, what did you bold that one sentence for?

Brother Adam
Posted

If you aren't flunking out, things can't be all that bad. :)

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Apr 5 2006, 12:12 PM']If you aren't flunking out, things can't be all that bad. :)
[right][snapback]936539[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
They're not all that bad. It's just that, as a scrupulant, I have a hard time coming to terms with my faults and seeing that not all are sins...some are just weaknesses. I've accepted the weakness of my abilities in studying, now...I accepted them at Mass. The important thing is that I learn...if the way I learn happens to be different from others, that's the way God made me...if it happens not to be the way the teachers would like...well...tough, that's their problem...as long as I'm learning and doing well in the end, and all for Christ, I am doing well.

I want to elaborate on my study, since I can see how one couldn't easily understand. I wasn't really raised to be able to read well. We never read much when I was a kid...never. My Catholic school would assign so much written homework that we would be up until midnight or later every night doing that and had no time for reading (it drove my parents nuts...they hated how much homework we got...it really was a ton). Because of the workload, I'd get horrible grades and low self-esteem. However, the same thing that caused the weakness gave me a strength. I observe more because I have more time to observe...because I had low self-esteem, I spent my recesses alone, didn't talk to others much, etc. As a consequence, I used my time to think and contemplate. As I got older, I realized that if I could just get a basic outline of information on something philosophical or theological or scientifically theoretical, I could contemplate it constantly. This got me into the habit of thinking constantly (as Jen will tell you). Needless to say, it doesn't work on things like history, which, although I love it, I never do well in, because every little fact is important and you can't just know an outline and then realize the rest from your own thought process. Most people take in information and break it down and simplify. I take the broken down and build up and elaborate. That's why when I have to read something for class, I can never pick out the important points...I end up highlighting practically the whole darn document (my roommate laughed at me for it, once). If, however, a teacher taught in a very outline-style format, I'd be in a great class. Professor Bolster here does so...he's like, "such and such-CT 9, this, CCC 25, this other thing, CCC 672..." It's all straight-forward and allows me to think about and ponder the material and fit it all together, rather than trying to take it apart. My method teaches me more, gives me a greater understanding of the material, helps me to put it in better terms for myself and others, and takes less time (and is therefore adaptable to my schedule).

However, it is still a weakness that I'm not able to read as much as others...but it's a weakness I just have to accept. Dr. Hildebrand said that there was nothing wrong with my method, as long as it taught me what I needed to know for the course. Well...I accept the weakness...God will use the way I am forced to study for the ultimate good of the Kingdom. I don't have to be insulted by the fact that others have strengths I do not have, nor be jealous of them.

Now...if only more professors would realize that some people need to learn this way...oh well.

Posted

Pray for the intercession of JP2. He was a student once. St. John Vianney as well. He had troubles in his studies.

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Apr 5 2006, 09:16 AM']Okay, so a lot of students on campus go to Mass everyday, pray the rosary everyday, pray the Liturgy of the Hours everyday, go to adoration weekly, etc.

I was telling a friend of mine that the professors here do not calculate into their homework the amount of time it takes for the students to pray (much less work in order to afford attending) and therefore assign large and multiple readings.  Now, daily Mass is one hour...rosary approx. half an hour, LOTH combined is 20 minutes to one hour, depending on how much and what way you pray...comes to around 2 hours a day.

He said that as students, we're obliged to look first to our studies as the source of our spiritual life.  While I agree that our academics are important to our vocations and even spiritual lives, I can't agree with his notion that, if the choice for scheduling falls between Mass and homework (so long as the homework isn't completely pressing gradewise), that we should skip daily Mass and other devotions in order to study.  He seems to think that we should, even for relatively unimportant study.

I take as my defense Bl. Mother Teresa.  Her vocation was to serve the poor prayerfully and with love.  When her sisters came to her and told her that they needed more time to serve the poor because they couldn't get their work done, she said that they should add more time for adoration instead.

Now...fulfilling our vocations is vital to the spiritual life...but the primary vocation which feeds all others is the call of Baptism, and attending to the grace of that Sacrament.  Therefore, our being Christians is the primary vocation, not being students.  As such, we need to spend time in prayer outside of our studies.  From that prayer time and from the devotions we practice, we are given greater strength to study.  I answer, therefore, that to take study to such an extreme as he has taken it is to overlook our need for this prayerful source of grace, the grace we need to keep ourselves studying and free from burnout.

Comments?  Corrections?
[right][snapback]936333[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Hey, if your priorities tell you that you should go to unnecessary daily mass every single day (by the way, daily mass here is only like 20 minutes...so I don't know what's going on over there) then do it. But be prepared to devote less time to your studies and do poorly.

You don't need to go to Daily Mass, and if you're having trouble meeting the demands placed upon you then perhaps you should adjust your workload or your prayerload. Either or.

Or, you can just do what I do. Read less, make up the answers as you go, and get a B.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Apr 5 2006, 08:57 AM']I made this thread because there was a debate over a principle, not because I was trying to discuss my own spiritual life.  However, as it became tied almost immediately to my own spiritual life, I felt that I had to go into defense.  You do not tell a scrupulant what a horrible job he is doing at something he tries very hard to do, against all reasonable hope (if such a thing exists), just because he is not capable of doing better.[right][snapback]936464[/snapback][/right][/quote]
raph, i pray for you. no one's life is easy. what i consider to be easy, might be incredibly hard for you. and vice versa. please know that you have my prayers in everything you do.

that being said, in all charity, if you don't want people to comment on your life, don't put your life out there for people to comment on.

God bless you this year :)

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Apr 5 2006, 01:25 PM'](by the way, daily mass here is only like 20 minutes...so I don't know what's going on over there)
[right][snapback]936652[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
What's going on here is that it's Franciscan University...

lucasmark83
Posted

[quote]What's going on here is that it's Franciscan University...[/quote]

Good Call

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...