Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

So...I got into a debate...


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Apr 5 2006, 01:51 PM']Yah, St. Francis de Sales talks about that in his "Introduction to the Devout Life", how a housewife can't live the life of a Carthusian. She has to be holy being a housewife. She can't be off praying all the time. She has kids and a husband to take care of.
[right][snapback]936366[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I thought of something similar when I read the first post, only it was this quote by St. Frances of Rome (which I just spent about 20 minutes searching for on Google using random combinations of the words saint, woman, altar, housework, God, prayer). :wacko:

“It is most laudable in a married woman to be devout, but she must never forget that she is a housewife. And sometimes she must leave God at the altar to find Him in her housekeeping.”

Substitute student for married woman/housewife and studies for housekeeping.

Posted

[quote name='lucasmark83' date='Apr 5 2006, 09:47 AM']If I remember correctly, at orientation here in Steubie, they focused on how your vocation right now in college was to be a student, not to be a saint. [right][snapback]936358[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Why can't students be Saints?

[quote name='Sojourner' date='Apr 5 2006, 09:52 AM']Make your studies your prayer.
[right][snapback]936370[/snapback][/right][/quote]
Listen to Sojourner. :)

Anyways, I sympathize with you, Micah. I'm working two jobs and have a full-course load this semester, and it is difficult to find time to pray. But when I can't do vocal or meditative prayer, I try to offer up my studies as my prayer. You can glorify God by doing your work well for the love of Him. :)

Posted

In my days at Christendom College (which is about as Catholic and religious as you can get), a holy priest addressed this very issue.
He would say that the primary vocation of the students there was to be [b]students[/b] - that is to study!
He said that their duties as students must come first, and by living their vocation as students was serving God. He said this was a [i]college[/i], not a monastery or convent. While prayer and daily mass is good, he said students should not shirk their scholarly duties by saying they needed to spend more time praying in the chapel, etc.

Posted

A friend and I used to joke all the time at FUS about how are "primary vocation at this time was as a student" o what a joke.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Colleen' date='Apr 5 2006, 06:37 PM']Why can't students be Saints?
Listen to Sojourner. :)

Anyways, I sympathize with you, Micah. I'm working two jobs and have a full-course load this semester, and it is difficult to find time to pray. But when I can't do vocal or meditative prayer, I try to offer up my studies as my prayer. You can glorify God by doing your work well for the love of Him. :)
[right][snapback]936987[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
My prayer life doesn't interfere with my studies. I was trying to address a principle and, as stated before, I'd like it if the topic would stay on the principle, whatever the tangent was.

This is a hard issue to explain...that's why I'd like it to get back on course...or be deleted, as requested.

Posted

"do what is possible. Then do what is difficult. Soon, you'll find yourself doing the impossible." -St. Francis of Assisi

Posted

JMJ
4/6 - Fifth Thursday of Lent

If you can't make time to go to a twenty minute Mass every day, then perhaps you should look at how you're putting your schedule together. Also, as a student, remember that your first spiritual devotion is the study of your subject - that comes before the LOTH, the Rosary, and all other devotions, and it is proper for them to give way to study. You're not in the seminary anymore; you can't pray like you are.

*steps off soapbox*

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Pio Nono' date='Apr 6 2006, 05:49 AM']JMJ
4/6 - Fifth Thursday of Lent

If you can't make time to go to a twenty minute Mass every day, then perhaps you should look at how you're putting your schedule together.  Also, as a student, remember that your first spiritual devotion is the study of your subject - that comes before the LOTH, the Rosary, and all other devotions, and it is proper for them to give way to study.  You're not in the seminary anymore; you can't pray like you are.

*steps off soapbox*
[right][snapback]937439[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
To repeat myself a third time...this is not in reference to my devotions. I was discussing a principle.

By the way, I don't entirely agree...if I had so much homework that I was doing it from 8 am to 8 pm, then it would most likely lead to such great build up of stress that it would be horrible for my spiritual life. We must limit the amount of time we study so that we may have time to do other things, such as eat, socialize, pray, etc. If we are all study and nothing else, even if our studies are hard-pressed, we would spiritually suffer terribly. Man requires rest, food, prayer, and socialization. We must work on building up and maintaining our whole persons, not just our brains. My vocation as a student is about learning...that's not just book learning, but social learning, character growth, etc.

homeschoolmom
Posted

I agree with you, Raph, that there MUST be a balance in life. It leads to better health, etc. That's why if I had to work my way through college, I probably wouldn't try to make it through in four years.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Apr 6 2006, 07:45 AM']I agree with you, Raph, that there MUST be a balance in life. It leads to better health, etc. That's why if I had to work my way through college, I probably wouldn't try to make it through in four years.
[right][snapback]937468[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
That's all I'm saying is that there has to be balance...that we can't work all day. There must be time set apart for prayer...just offering up our studies, work, etc. as prayer is not enough...there needs to be time which is for restful, recollected prayer. That needn't take the form of Mass, the rosary, or other devotions, but it must be present.

Oh, and I work only about 10-12 hours a week...sometimes it kinda gets in the way, but not terribly. Like I said, this was supposed to be a matter of principle.

Anyway...if study has to be sacrificed a little for the sake of prayer or social time, then I believe that has to happen. Yes, study is primary, but studying to the point of neglecting our vocation to be human and Christian is ridiculous.

When the professors here or anywhere else assign so much stuff that students don't have a free moment without getting bad grades as a consequence, then there's something wrong with that. That's all I'm saying.

God help me if, when I'm a teacher, I do as my teachers did, "okay kids...read chapters 11 and 12 of your history books, do problems 1-35 of the math homework (yes, I want to see every step in the work), read chapter 7 of your science book, be sure to fill out your lab journals, learn your vocabulary words for the quiz tomorrow, read the short story in your fiction literature texts, pages 137-157, and answer the questions, oh, and don't forget to work on your thesis paper (yes, I'm aware that this is only sixth grade)...oh, and surely don't forget that you have to come back at 6:30 to get ready for the school play."

I'm serious...that's what it was like EVERY DAY!!! My parents were always so mad at the darn school...we'd be up until midnight and we'd still fail to finish it all...no wonder all three of us have poor self-esteem.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Apr 6 2006, 07:04 AM'].

Oh, and I work only about 10-12 hours a week...sometimes it kinda gets in the way, but not terribly.  Like I said, this was supposed to be a matter of principle.

[right][snapback]937473[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I wasn't speaking about you specifically, but what I would do if I felt my courseload + work was too much.

Ave Maria Totus Tuus
Posted

I feel ya man. I'm an engineering major and took all the "weed out" courses last semester, where the professors have to fail or drop half of the students. It's crazy sometimes with how much stuff I have to get done. I'm at a secular university, so professors don't even worry or consider anything about spirituality. They see it, especially with first year students, that if you are not in class or studying, you're gonna go out and drink and do something stupid.

Yet, even being at a secular university with a big party rep, I find myself praying a lot during the day for the people around me, from the guy who's drunk in class (yes, it happens) to the girl behind me talking about how she had sex last night, etc. I learn about fascinating concepts of science and engineering in my classes and constantly reflect on the power of God through the complexity of His Creation. In other words, I tend to find ways to stimulate my sprirtuality through my normal daily college routine. It's very fruitful.

Sorry if I didn't address you're issue, but I felt like contributing to the ongoing discussion.

Prayers for you and all us students balancing our lives!


Best advice I got freshman year:

Adapt and overcome.

Ave Maria Totus Tuus
Posted

I feel ya man. I'm an engineering major and took all the "weed out" courses last semester, where the professors have to fail or drop half of the students. It's crazy sometimes with how much stuff I have to get done. I'm at a secular university, so professors don't even worry or consider anything about spirituality. They see it, especially with first year students, that if you are not in class or studying, you're gonna go out and drink and do something stupid.

Yet, even being at a secular university with a big party rep, I find myself praying a lot during the day for the people around me, from the guy who's drunk in class (yes, it happens) to the girl behind me talking about how she had sex last night, etc. I learn about fascinating concepts of science and engineering in my classes and constantly reflect on the power of God through the complexity of His Creation. In other words, I tend to find ways to stimulate my sprirtuality through my normal daily college routine. It's very fruitful.

Sorry if I didn't address you're issue, but I felt like contributing to the ongoing discussion.

Prayers for you and all us students balancing our lives!


Best advice I got freshman year:

Adapt and overcome.

Brother Adam
Posted (edited)

On principle, I believe what the catechetics professors do is right. It's either force you to get everything you need in the classes they offer, or make more classes, take less students, and spread the program over more years. They want good catechists, not half baked catechists, and FUS does tend to produce some of the best. You may not have the devotional life of St. John of the Cross or St. Therese, but you will be santified through your studying. I like what the Missal I got says about being a better Catholic. When it comes to your work, do it well and diligently, even when it is hard.

My hardest day at Franciscan though does not compare in the least to my easiest day working regular hard labor. The intellectual stimulation is something for which there is no comparision. I would not trade going back to college for anything having spent several years breaking my back working 12, 14, 16 hours a day for carp pay in an atmosphere where no one cared.

I have more respect for a man who works for 40 years doing hard labor, caring for his family, and remaining an faithful obedient Catholic than for any theologian, professor, or other intellectual. And those who do find themselves in a job, such as a theologian, I firmly believe, must use his gift well, and use it with a great sense of humility, or it is wasted.

Edited by Brother Adam
Posted

Raph,

Thanks for your articulate posts. You've done an excellent job of conveying your frustration--both with your studies and with how people here on the boards responded. I relate to your frustrations in that I too have difficulty in balancing my prayer life and my academic life. I am thankful I go to a Dominican school where my prayer can truly be my studying, but that doesn't always make it easier.

There are many wise things that have been said here in response to your original post... particularly to make study your prayer. Please know that I hold you in my prayers.

_____________________________
[b]My hijacking: [/b]
[quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Apr 5 2006, 08:54 AM']The idea of taking my 2 1/2 year old to daily mass or  :shock: adoration just freaks me out. <sigh> someday, though...
[right][snapback]936374[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
If daily Mass in 25 mins... you should totally take HStot. Maybe something just the two of you do. See if you can sit up in front so he (she?) can watch everything the priest is doing.

As for adoration, if you're out running errands, just stop in for 15 mins. You'd be surprised at how much kids that age like quite and contemplation.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='shortnun' date='Apr 6 2006, 10:21 AM']_____________________________
[b]My hijacking: [/b]

If daily Mass in 25 mins... you should totally take HStot. Maybe something just the two of you do. See if you can sit up in front so he (she?) can watch everything the priest is doing.

As for adoration, if you're out running errands, just stop in for 15 mins. You'd be surprised at how much kids that age like quite and contemplation.
[right][snapback]937626[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Our parish has daily mass at 7:30 am and that is prime running time for the HStot. Not wiggling-- RUNNING. So, that's out. (I've done it-- many times... ) We also have 6:30 pm on Tuesdays and we sometimes go that. That works out sometimes. If we had 24 hour adoration, I'd do that, but we don't. :( We're working on getting a children's hour and that will be perfect. ;)

Cow of Shame
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Apr 5 2006, 09:44 AM']Whiner.
sorry...
[right][snapback]936352[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Ditto....

but I'm not sorry.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...