Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Here's a doozy...


Recommended Posts

Slave_of_the_Trinity
Posted (edited)

Alright, i was talking to my spiritual director about the Trinity and he said that the Most Holy Trinity is present in the Holy Eucharist because of the union of the Three Divine Persons. But another priest said that it would be a heresy to say that the WhOLE Trinity is present in the Holy Eucharist because it is not right to say that the Father and the Holy Spirit both have bodies. So... who's right? I think that it is fair to say that the Divinity of the Holy Trinity is Present in the Eucharist, but that it is Christ's Human Nature there as well. Does that make any sense? :idontknow:

Edited by Slave_of_the_Trinity
Posted

Im not an expert on trinitarian theology, but my understanding is in sacraments there is the act and that is attributed to christ/Father. and in celebrating that act the spirit brings others into it. This is a simple model that would need to be speculated depending. Pneumatology speaks of this in baptism. An issue I know in trinitarian theology is that the three are together, they are one, thus they are present as one. But the functional roles can be different. The spirit brings us into the communion, christ is the body and the host, and the father accepts the sacrifice..

like I said, not cannon, but good stuff

phatcatholic
Posted

hmm, this is my first time using this phrase to describe the presence in the Eucharist, so it could very well be heretical. what if we were to say this?:

--The Trinity is present [i]substantially[/i], but only the Son is present [i]personally[/i]

any thoughts?

Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' date='Apr 12 2006, 02:44 PM']hmm, this is my first time using this phrase to describe the presence in the Eucharist, so it could very well be heretical. what if we were to say this?:

--The Trinity is present [i]substantially[/i], but only the Son is present [i]personally[/i]

any thoughts?
[right][snapback]944399[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Sounds good...... Christ is present in the Holy Eucharist, Body, Blood Soul and Divinity therefore.......It is not only the substantial presence of the Body and Blood of Christ, it is his Soul and Divinity as well.

Insofar as the Athanasian Creed says:

6. But the Godhead of the Father, of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit is all one, the glory equal, the majesty coeternal.

7. Such as the Father is, such is the Son, and such is the Holy Spirit.

8. The Father uncreated, the Son uncreated, and the Holy Spirit uncreated.

9. The Father incomprehensible, the Son incomprehensible, and the Holy Spirit incomprehensible.

10. The Father eternal, the Son eternal, and the Holy Spirit eternal.

11. And yet they are not three eternals but one eternal.

12. As also there are not three uncreated nor three incomprehensible, but one uncreated and one incomprehensible.

13. So likewise the Father is almighty, the Son almighty, and the Holy Spirit almighty.

14. And yet they are not three almighties, but one almighty.

15. So the Father is God, the Son is God, and the Holy Spirit is God;

16. And yet they are not three Gods, but one God.

17. So likewise the Father is Lord, the Son Lord, and the Holy Spirit Lord;

18. And yet they are not three Lords but one Lord.

The divinity of Christ in the Eucharist is the same divinity of the Father and Holy Spirit....

Maybe someone else can enlighten us :idontknow: my speciality is Moral Theology and Canon Law, not Dogmatic Theology :P:

missionseeker
Posted

That makes sense.

Posted

Quote from Bishop Kevin Manning Bishop of Parramatta.

He has given Himself to us as food and drink in the Eucharist as our spiritual nourishment out of love. God's whole plan ..... is directed towards our being joined together more fully in the life of the Blessed Trinity which is the Communion of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. We start to share in this life when we are baptised, when, through the power of the Holy Spirit, we are joined to Christ and become adopted sons and daughters of the Father. [b]This sharing in the life of the Trinity is strengthened and increased through the Sacrament of Confirmation, and it is nourished and deepened through our participation in the Blessed Eucharist.[/b]

Through our eating His Body and drinking His Blood in the Eucharist we become united to the person of Jesus through His humanity: "Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood lives in me and I live in that person" (Jn 6:56). But, in being united to the humanity of Christ, we are at the same time united to His divinity and our mortal and corruptible natures are transformed by being joined to the source of life: "As the living Father sent me, and I draw life from the Father, so whoever eats me will also draw life from me" (Jn 6:57).

So, by being united to Christ through the power of the Holy Spirit dwelling in us, we are drawn up into an eternal relationship of love with the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. Just as Jesus is the eternal Son of God by nature, so we become sons and daughters of God by adoption through the Sacrament of Baptism. Through the Sacraments of Baptism and Confirmation we become temples of the Holy Spirit who dwells in us.

By His in-dwelling we are made holy by the gift of Sanctifying Grace. Our hope, given to us through the Resurrection, is that we will one day share in the life of the Holy Trinity. Thus, we come to understand that God does not merely send us good things from on high, but [b]we are brought up into the inner life of God, the communion of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit.[/b]

thessalonian
Posted

There are different modes of prescence. God is present in all things. Even in the chair you are sitting in in some fashion. This does not however mean that if you eat the chair you will be eating God and this is not the kind of prescence in which Jesus is present in the Eucharist which is wholy and substantially, sacramentally, but not physically. You cannot have Jesus prescence without the prescence of the trinity. It's just not possible. So yes the Holy Spirit and the Father for that matter would be present in the Eucharist but it would not be the same prescence in which Christ is wholly, truly, substantially, and sacramentally present in the Eucharist. The answer must be yes, but don't ask me to explain it any further than this.

Blessings

Posted

"Thus the Trinity, Incarnation, and Eucharist are really welded together like a precious chain, which in a wonderful manner links heaven with earth, God with man, uniting them most intimately and keeping them thus united. By the very fact that the Eucharistic mystery does transcend reason, no rationalistic explanation of it, based on a merely natural hypothesis and seeking to comprehend one of the sublimest truths of the Christian religion as the spontaneous conclusion of logical processes, may be attempted by a Catholic theologian."

The Trinity ~ Incarnation ~ Eucharist

Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' date='Apr 11 2006, 09:44 PM']hmm, this is my first time using this phrase to describe the presence in the Eucharist, so it could very well be heretical. what if we were to say this?:

--The Trinity is present [i]substantially[/i], but only the Son is present [i]personally[/i]

any thoughts?
[right][snapback]944399[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

This makes me think of the Theotokos argument/limitations. Mary is the 'mother of God' in that she gave birth only to the second person in the trinity, assisting in the Jesus/Son of Man hypostatic union (as per RCIA).

Hence (proposal):

The Trinity is as substantially present in the Eucharist as Mary is the substantial Mother of the Trinity.

Another point of common sense (excuse my Chestertonian leanings):
Supose you were to use a time machine to go back and shake the hand of Christ. Would you be 'substanially' shaking hands with the Trinity? The answer and supporting reasons would be the same to confirm or deny the presence of the Trinity in the Eucharist.

Trent (Session XIII) had little to comment specifically on our topic of Trinitarian presence. It does, of course, repeatedly confirm the Transubstantiation of Christ. However its abscence of comment may deny the proposition of an arguable level of Trinitarian presence in the Eucharist in light of a sentence in the Intro.

Intro:
Wherefore, this holy council, stating that sound and genuine doctrine of the venerable and divine sacrament of the Eucharist, which the Catholic Church, instructed by our Lord Jesus Christ Himself and by His Apostles,.... forbids all the faithful of Christ to presume henceforth to believe, teach or preach with regard to the most Holy Eucharist otherwise than is explained and defined in this present decree.

Semi-relevant Trent Trivia:
Canon 11. If anyone says that faith alone is a sufficient preparation for receiving the sacrament of the most Holy Eucharist,[52] let him be anathema. And lest so great a sacrament be received unworthily and hence unto death and condemnation, this holy council ordains and declares that sacramental confession, when a confessor can be had, must necessarily be made beforehand by those whose conscience is burdened with mortal sin, however contrite they may consider themselves. Moreover, if anyone shall presume to teach, preach or obstinately assert, or in public disputation defend the contrary, he shall be <eo ipso> excommunicated.

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' date='Apr 13 2006, 08:15 AM']This makes me think of the Theotokos argument/limitations.  Mary is the 'mother of God' in that she gave birth only to the second person in the trinity, assisting in the Jesus/Son of Man hypostatic union (as per RCIA). 

Hence (proposal):

The Trinity is as substantially present in the Eucharist as Mary is the  substantial Mother of the Trinity. 

Another point of common sense (excuse my Chestertonian leanings):
Supose you were to use a time machine to go back and shake the hand of Christ.  Would you be 'substanially' shaking hands with the Trinity?  The answer and supporting reasons would be the same to confirm or deny the presence of the Trinity in the Eucharist.

Trent (Session XIII) had little to comment specifically on our topic of Trinitarian presence.  It does, of course, repeatedly confirm the Transubstantiation of Christ.  However its abscence of comment may deny the proposition of an arguable level of Trinitarian presence in the Eucharist in light of a sentence in the Intro.

Intro:
Wherefore, this holy council, stating that sound and genuine doctrine of the venerable and divine sacrament of the Eucharist, which the Catholic Church, instructed by our Lord Jesus Christ Himself and by His Apostles,....      forbids all the faithful of Christ to presume henceforth to believe, teach or preach with regard to the most Holy Eucharist otherwise than is explained and defined in this present decree.

Semi-relevant Trent Trivia:
Canon 11. If anyone says that faith alone is a sufficient preparation for receiving the sacrament of the most Holy Eucharist,[52] let him be anathema. And lest so great a sacrament be received unworthily and hence unto death and condemnation, this holy council ordains and declares that sacramental confession, when a confessor can be had, must necessarily be made beforehand by those whose conscience is burdened with mortal sin, however contrite they may consider themselves. Moreover, if anyone shall presume to teach, preach or obstinately assert, or in public disputation defend the contrary, he shall be <eo ipso> excommunicated.
[right][snapback]945978[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

:clap:

Posted

[quote name='Slave_of_the_Trinity' date='Apr 11 2006, 08:25 PM']Alright, i was talking to my spiritual director about the Trinity and he said that the Most Holy Trinity is present in the Holy Eucharist because of the union of the Three Divine Persons.  But another priest said that it would be a heresy to say that the WhOLE Trinity is present in the Holy Eucharist because it is not right to say that the Father and the Holy Spirit both have bodies.  So... who's right?  I think that it is fair to say that the Divinity of the Holy Trinity is Present in the Eucharist, but that it is Christ's Human Nature there as well.  Does that make any sense?  :idontknow:
[right][snapback]944008[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
The way I tend to think of it (which seems to agree with the little I read of the other replies) is that the eucharist [i]is[/i] Jesus, but the Father and the Spirit are also present in a special way, since the three are inseperable (and it's through the power of the Holy Spirit that Jesus is present, etc.).

Posted

There are important distinctions that need to be made when speaking of the presence of Christ (and of the Trinity) in the mystery of the Eucharist.

First, Christ is present by the power of the prayer of consecration of the bread, which transforms the bread into His body; and second, He is present by the separate prayer of consecration of the wine, which transforms the wine into His blood. Thus, by the separate prayers of consecration the sacrifice of Christ is mystically rendered present as the bread and wine are changed into the body and blood of Christ, but because Christ -- through the power of His resurrection -- is ever-living, it follows that by [i]natural concomitance[/i] the consecrated bread, which has been transformed into His body, also contains His blood, soul, and divinity, while at the same time the consecrated wine, which has been changed into His blood, also contains His body, soul, and divinity. In other words, by the power of the prayers of consecration the bread and wine are changed into the Lord's body and blood, while through [i]natural concomitance[/i] the whole Christ is present in both of the Eucharistic species, which have been consecrated separately in order to mystically proclaim the Lord's sacrificial death.

Now as far as the presence of the Trinity in the Eucharist is concerned, although the persons ([i]hypostases[/i]) of the Trinity are really distinct from each other (because to say otherwise is to fall into the heresy of Sabellian modalism), they also indwell each other without separation or confusion. This mutual indwelling of the persons ([i]hypostases[/i]) of the Trinity is called the mystery of [i]perichoresis[/i] (co-inherence), which simply means that the distinct persons ([i]hypostases[/i]) of the Trinity are inseparable, since the whole of the divine essence is present in each person ([i]hypostasis[/i]). Thus, through [i]perichoresis[/i] the Father and the Spirit are present in the Eucharist along with the Son, but this mysterious presence of the Trinity within the Eucharist is dependent upon the primary mystery, which is the transformation of the elements into the body and blood of Christ by the separate prayers of consecration.

Now for the sake of clarity I will summarize what I said above: (1) the body and blood of Christ are present in the Eucharist through the separate prayers of consecration, which also have the effect of manifesting in a mystical way Christ's one oblation upon the cross; while (2) through what is called [i]natural concomitance[/i] the whole Christ (body, blood, soul and divinity) is present in both the consecrated bread and the consecrated wine; and finally, (3) through the mystery of [i]perichoresis[/i] (i.e., the mutual indwelling of the persons of the Trinity) the Father and Spirit are present with the Son -- in a dependent manner -- in the mystery of the Eucharist.

I hope that this explanation helps to clarify things for everyone.

God bless,
Todd

phatcatholic
Posted

apotheoun.......................would you agree with this statement?:

[quote name='phatcatholic' date='Apr 11 2006, 11:44 PM']--The Trinity is present [i]substantially[/i], but only the Son is present [i]personally[/i][right][snapback]944399[/snapback][/right][/quote]

Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='950673' date='Apr 17 2006, 10:01 AM']
apotheoun.......................would you agree with this statement?:

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='944399' date='Apr 11 2006, 08:44 PM']
--The Trinity is present [i]substantially[/i], but only the Son is present [i]personally[/i]
[/quote][/quote]
I would avoid the use of the word [i]substance[/i] in connection with the presence of the Father and the Spirit in the Eucharist, because that term is really best used only in connection with the transformation of the substance of the bread and wine into the body and blood of Christ. The presence of the Father and the Spirit with Christ in the Eucharist is connected instead to the co-inherence ([i]perichoresis[/i]) of the divine essence within the three persons of the Trinity. In other words, although the persons of the Trinity are really distinct from each other, they cannot be separated, which means that wherever the Son is, the Father and the Spirit are also present.

phatcatholic
Posted

maybe this is better?:

--The Trinity is present [i]essentially[/i], but only the Son is present [i]personally[/i]

of course, by "essentially" i mean in the metaphysical sense, as pertaining to the essence of a thing. maybe its improper to reduce what is involved into a catchy little phrase, but it would be helpful as a simple way to explain the reality of the Eucharist.

  • 2 years later...
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='954227' date='Apr 19 2006, 05:22 PM']maybe this is better?:

--The Trinity is present [i]essentially[/i], but only the Son is present [i]personally[/i]

of course, by "essentially" i mean in the metaphysical sense, as pertaining to the essence of a thing. maybe its improper to reduce what is involved into a catchy little phrase, but it would be helpful as a simple way to explain the reality of the Eucharist.[/quote]
I'm bumping this thread because Apotheoun linked to it and it interested me. I think the best way to phrase it would be to say that the Eucharist IS the Son, but [i]contains[/i] the Father and the Holy Spirit (through their perichoresis). It is possible to say that the Eucharist IS Jesus without it being the Father and the Holy Spirit because the Son IS NOT the Father or the Holy Spirit, however, one would have to admit that since they are all consubstantial (and because of perichoresis, which I recognize as a subtle distinction from consubstantiality), the Father and the Holy Spirit are personally present in the Most Blessed Sacrament, since their Persons are truly present in the Son, who is truly present in the Eucharist. It would seem therefore that all three are present in the Eucharist, but the Eucharist can be said TO BE only the Son. The Eucharist could not be said TO BE the Father or the Holy Spirit, but must be said to [i]contain[/i] them in the sense that they are present (not in the sense that they can be "contained" or limited).

Of course, if I'm wrong on this, I defer to the Magisterium.

johnnydigit
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='944572' date='Apr 12 2006, 07:27 AM']Jesus is present in the Eucharist which is wholy and substantially, sacramentally, but not physically.[/quote]

isn't this incorrect? i thought Jesus is there physically as well. the molecules of bread are there, but they are now the molecules of Jesus body (not skin/flesh molecules, but in the same substance of a bread molecule, as in a carbohydrate chain). His flesh, blood, and divinity is there, but our senses can't perceive these as we usually perceive things?

i see the Eucharist as the Trinity. like an icon, it is also a window to heaven. through it we can see the three persons of the Godhead. i can see and speak to the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit in that round host. i can even see Our Lady and the Saints in heaven through this window. to touch, smell, hear and taste it would be to touch, smell, hear and taste Jesus, the Father, and the Holy Spirit.
anything that a human can rationalize or perceive of the Trinity, they can do so in the Eucharist. "It's all me baby!"

i think anything short of His entirety in the Eucharist would be making short of the faith we have in Him.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='johnnydigit' post='1554072' date='Jun 2 2008, 02:59 AM']isn't this incorrect? i thought Jesus is there physically as well. the molecules of bread are there, but they are now the molecules of Jesus body (not skin/flesh molecules, but in the same substance of a bread molecule, as in a carbohydrate chain). His flesh, blood, and divinity is there, but our senses can't perceive these as we usually perceive things?

i see the Eucharist as the Trinity. like an icon, it is also a window to heaven. through it we can see the three persons of the Godhead. i can see and speak to the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit in that round host. i can even see Our Lady and the Saints in heaven through this window. to touch, smell, hear and taste it would be to touch, smell, hear and taste Jesus, the Father, and the Holy Spirit.
anything that a human can rationalize or perceive of the Trinity, they can do so in the Eucharist. "It's all me baby!"

i think anything short of His entirety in the Eucharist would be making short of the faith we have in Him.[/quote]

I had to go back a research a little bit on this one, but I feel pretty confident in saying that Jesus is not present in the sense of His molecules. The reason is in the Summa, tertia pars, Q. 76, articles 1-4. The way I understand it, "substance" as the Church uses it is a deeper sense than "substance" as science uses the word. The reason is that if you introduce the idea that Jesus' physical presence in the Blessed Sacrament exists in such a way that there's more than one part (i.e. multiple molecules, or even multiple atoms), then you could say theoretically that you can remove one of those parts, and if you did, would that part...that cell or molecule, be the whole Christ? This causes a huge difficulty, because any part of the Eucharistic host, no matter how small, must contain the whole Christ. "Substance," I believe, goes deeper in our theology to mean something closer to "nature." His human nature is divided into two substances: soul and body. I could be wrong, but I believe we would call molecular structure a "form" and not a substance, and form is a matter of dimension, shape, and other accidents, not of essence or substance. Substance, I think, is simply whatever physical human flesh is on a natural level beyond the scope of form, but that itself, I think, is a mystery.

I think the physical aspect of Christ's human nature is present in the Blessed Sacrament, but in a sacramental way, a way beyond our understanding. To be honest, I need to read [u]The Hidden Manna[/u] to get the best answers on the specifics involved in this.

Anyway, I think what Thess was saying was that Jesus' local presence is not in the Eucharist. The Church calls His "local presence" His presence wherever He Himself is present in the normal way (the way He walked the earth) not the sacramental way. So 2000 years ago, Jesus was locally present on earth. Now He is locally present in heaven and sacramentally present on earth. A lot of people say that Jesus isn't "physically" present in the Eucharist when they mean He isn't "locally" present because a lot of the terms are obscure in their exact meaning (which I suspect is one of the key reasons it's difficult to pin down exactly how Jesus is present in the Eucharist).

I want to make it clear, though, that I don't know all the answers to this and a bit of it is speculation (that, as far as I know, is in line with Church teaching, but I'll research it some more and let you know).

God bless,

Micah

johnnydigit
Posted

ya, confusing, but a little clearer.

so if the molecules of the bread are there, would it be correct to say that after consecration the host is both wheat bread (accident), plus the body, blood, soul and divinity of Christ (substance)? someone once insisted that it is no longer "bread" (accident) and only the substance of the Eucharist.. i disagreed because all my senses tell me there is bread, but my soul tells me there is the addition of the substance..

Posted

[quote name='johnnydigit' post='1554586' date='Jun 2 2008, 03:41 PM']ya, confusing, but a little clearer.

so if the molecules of the bread are there, would it be correct to say that after consecration the host is both wheat bread (accident), plus the body, blood, soul and divinity of Christ (substance)? someone once insisted that it is no longer "bread" (accident) and only the substance of the Eucharist.. i disagreed because all my senses tell me there is bread, but my soul tells me there is the addition of the substance..[/quote]

What you describe is Consubstantiation, which is what Lutherans believes. Consubstantiation says that the body and blood of Christ are present alongside the substance of the bread and wine, which remain present.

Transubstantiation, which is what Catholics believe, says the bread ceases to be bread, because it truly becomes the body, blood, soul, and divinity of Christ. The very substance of the bread changes. The substance of the bread no longer is there, but tt does keep the accidents, which are attributes. Meaning it still tastes, feels, and looks like bread, but it has truly become the body of Christ.

It's substance is changed but the accidents remain.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...