Thy Geekdom Come Posted June 2, 2008 Posted June 2, 2008 [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1554586' date='Jun 2 2008, 03:41 PM']ya, confusing, but a little clearer. so if the molecules of the bread are there, would it be correct to say that after consecration the host is both wheat bread (accident), plus the body, blood, soul and divinity of Christ (substance)? someone once insisted that it is no longer "bread" (accident) and only the substance of the Eucharist.. i disagreed because all my senses tell me there is bread, but my soul tells me there is the addition of the substance..[/quote] Well...see, this is what I mean about it getting confusing because we're not all able to know what each other thinks by certain terms. The bread does not remain wheat after consecration, because wheat is the substance of the bread (and transubstantiation means that the substance of bread ceases to exist), however, it does retain the outward form of wheat cells (that is, if you put the host under the microscope, that's what you'll see), but the substance is not wheat. The substance of wheat is replaced by the substance of Christ, but the accidents of wheat remain. It is the dogma of transubstantiation that what was bread and wine ceases to be those and actually become the Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of Christ. There is no longer any bread or wine after consecration. Let me use an analogy. You know petrified wood? It looks like wood, but it's not. The reason is because it once was wood, but minerals came along and took the place of wood as it rotted away. It is really rock with no wood remaining, but it appears to be wood. It's like that with transubstantiation, except that transubstantiation is instantaneous. So there is no wheat (or wine) remaining, but only Christ. What we see and taste only appears to be wheat (or wine). This is a very emphatic teaching especially because of Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament. If the Eucharist were Christ AND bread, then we would be worshiping both in the Blessed Sacrament, and that is unacceptable.
johnnydigit Posted June 3, 2008 Posted June 3, 2008 [quote name='Raphael' post='1554778' date='Jun 2 2008, 03:08 PM']Let me use an analogy. You know petrified wood? It looks like wood, but it's not. The reason is because it once was wood, but minerals came along and took the place of wood as it rotted away. It is really rock with no wood remaining, but it appears to be wood. It's like that with transubstantiation, except that transubstantiation is instantaneous. So there is no wheat (or wine) remaining, but only Christ. What we see and taste only appears to be wheat (or wine). This is a very emphatic teaching especially because of Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament. If the Eucharist were Christ AND bread, then we would be worshiping both in the Blessed Sacrament, and that is unacceptable.[/quote] great analogy! i think i see it much better now, as in Christ replacing the space and form that the bread molecules inhabit. before it was a "lifeless" accident of bread that has the "essence" of merely wheat, while after consecration it is the body of Christ, full of the essence of life, in the appearance of the accident of bread, down to the molecule. i imagine the appearance of the molecules are shinier and have stronger charges so if the molecules of wheat bread normally break down as carbohydrates in the stomach, are converted to sugars and fats to be used and stored as energy for individual cells, so does the Body of Christ get absorbed into every cell of your body. however, i'd like to think that the remainder that is expelled ceases to be the Eucharist and its essence has already "transferred" to your body and soul, like when the purificator and water touches the Eucharist, it ceases to be the Eucharist. =| .. > .. > .. > .. > ..
Thy Geekdom Come Posted June 3, 2008 Posted June 3, 2008 [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1555038' date='Jun 2 2008, 08:33 PM']great analogy! i think i see it much better now, as in Christ replacing the space and form that the bread molecules inhabit. before it was a "lifeless" accident of bread that has the "essence" of merely wheat, while after consecration it is the body of Christ, full of the essence of life, in the appearance of the accident of bread, down to the molecule. i imagine the appearance of the molecules are shinier and have stronger charges [/quote] lol, well, as far as I know, no one has ever tested the shininess of the accidents of the host after consecration. I'd imagine, though, that since the accidents of bread remain, and shininess is an accident, that it also remains the way it appeared. [quote]so if the molecules of wheat bread normally break down as carbohydrates in the stomach, are converted to sugars and fats to be used and stored as energy for individual cells, so does the Body of Christ get absorbed into every cell of your body. however, i'd like to think that the remainder that is expelled ceases to be the Eucharist and its essence has already "transferred" to your body and soul, like when the purificator and water touches the Eucharist, it ceases to be the Eucharist.[/quote] Actually this is something that, as far as I know, hasn't been officially pronounced upon (afterall, we didn't know nearly as much about the science of digestion the last time we had a council focusing heavily on the Eucharist). However, it is the case that the Church teaches that once the Body and Blood no longer appear to be bread and wine, then their substance has been converted to something else, which begs the question about what happened to the substance of Christ's Body and Blood, which are glorified, and can't decay. I think the pious answer (and I think it's in keeping with Church teaching) would be that the substance contributes to our substance in some way, i.e. transforming us, which essentially means "you are what you eat." I'm sure it's more complicated than that, but this will have to do for now. What is good is that this fits with the Church's theology on the sacraments and theosis (divinization), i.e. that by receiving the sacraments worthily, we become partakers in the divine nature and slowly transform to be more like God. God bless, Micah
Resurrexi Posted June 23, 2008 Posted June 23, 2008 Though only the Son is united to the human nature of Christ ("We believe and confess that divinity itself, whether you call it divine substance or nature, is incarnate only in the Son." D 392), the other persons are present in the Son by way of circuminsession ("Because of this unity the Father is entire in the Son, entire in the Holy Spirit; the Son is entire in the Father, entire in the Holy Spirit, the Holy Spirit is entire in the Father, entire in the Son." D 704). Obviously, the Father and Holy Spirit would be present in the Eucharist in the same manner in which they are present in the Person of Christ.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now