dUSt Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 This is an open feedback thread, where I hope to get some honest advice from the phatmass community. I was talking to a long-time member about the state of phatmass. He/she told me that they don't participate in the phorums any longer for various reasons. He/she said that phatmass may be growing in numbers/traffic, but we are no longer growing spiritually. I respect this person's view, and consider this a failure on my part. So, please, let's talk about this, and come up with some ways that we can grow spiritually. Let's be open and honest about what this phorum is lacking and our problems. Maybe the problems with phatmass as a whole, or maybe the way we moderate or condone/condemn certain behavior. Then, let's come up with solutions. If phatmass no longer builds up Christ and His church, then phatmass should not exist. Period. Let's talk.
Brother Adam Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 (edited) Its funny I just had this conversation with a moderator. I don't know of any large forums that I can name that do well. Both of us were contemplating leaving on a more permenant basis. Note my witty new avatar and title. Since this community is a community, and the forums would mean nothing if it were not for the members, then the blame lies somewhere with the members and their attitude and behavior. Especially members who have been 'tagged' and serve as role models and authority figures (certianly scholars and moderators as they are limited in number) with their 'tags'. I cannot claim to know how to 'fix' it. There also seems to be problems with the huge number of trads on this board who have been leading others, including 'militants' over to the trad side. Phatmass just ain't no fun no more without the love that used to be here. Phatmass also doesn't seem to evangelize anymore. It just makes people angry. This of course is a generalization. I've had remarkable, spiritual, and uplifting private conversations with members in the past few weeks as well where a great deal of grace and growth has taken place. added...This is also one of the reasons why I have decided to dump Flyfree Ministries as an apologetics site, and make flyfree catholic forums instead - it will be a website built by several students here (content) to drive at good Catholic catechesis. I want it to serve as an aid to websites like phatmass that already have all of the apologetics down pat. It will teach things such as the Ecclesial Method and the Good News and its Proclamation, stuff that has been at the heart at the change in various US diocese and local parishes for the better in the past few years. Edited April 27, 2006 by Brother Adam
OverheadNite Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 Well I haven't been on here long, but I've started posting here and yea while alot of it has been goofing around, its helped me keep going to Mass every Sunday, and has brought me closer to Christ.
sweetpea316 Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 The fingers need to be pointed at ourselves. Definitely not you, dUSt. I have lots of opinions that I could say about the issue, but I dunno... I'm hesitant to criticize or step on any toes...
Noel's angel Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 Yeah dUSt, I don't think anyone can blame you for this. You do the best you can and it's brilliant! People are people and unfortunately you can't prevent people messing up the boards. I think the problem is that people sometimes get into the 'politics' of things too much. It's not about sharing faith for some people, but rather getting others to take 'sides'. I understand that you and the moderaters try your best to stop people breaking rules etc. and you can't be in every thread reading every post, but possibly harder penalties could be placed on those who go against the spirit of this site, those who post only to cause contraversy. My 2p worth. But dUSt, don't blame yourself, you rock and I still love coming on here because there are still many people here who do want to share their faith and grow together. It's a small minority who are bringing the rest down.
sweetpea316 Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 I agree, about the minority bringing the rest down. Sad but true. This site is not only for Catholics (thank goodness, or I technically wouldn't be allowed!) but I think that when discussions or debates arise, people tend to lose their charity and love, and are just trying to prove that they're right. That's one of the things that's been getting me down, because as someone who came here with an uncertain faith and wanted to learn more about Catholicism, it was very beneficial for me. (esp the defense directory! LOVE it!) I really don't want others who could be in the same situation to come here and be discouraged or get a bad impression. I don't like pointing fingers or placing blame... I just think that all of us members need to try and imitate Christ in our activities here, strive to be holy ourselves, and encourage others to be too.
Lounge Daddy Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 "Is Phatmass Spiritually Stagnant?" heck NO it has grown and its just what i need right now in my life
Keyser Soze Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 I think everything started going south when I started posting here.
heyyoimjohnny Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 (edited) I second sweetpea's post. I see a big lack of charity. I don't mean to say there's no charity excercised at all, but the lack upsets me enough to overlook the good. although, I do want to leave a few positive words. phatmass has helped me a wicked huge lot to connect to the Church as it should be, and not as some Church leaders in America paint it out to be, and phatmass has also helped me a lot in my discernment. Edited April 27, 2006 by heyyoimjohnny
OLAM Dad Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 As a relative newbie I've noticed a change as well. It seems to me that some lines need to be drawn. Open Mic and Creepy Aliens have pretty much identical flavors, one is for an older crowd but they both serve the same purpose. If you're looking for spirituality then you should stay away from these two. Converts Anonymous, Q&A, The Word and Apoligetics, and especially Vocation Station still have a very strong, Catholic spirituality to them. Vocation Station is pretty active and Phatmass is the online home to a lot of young people discerning religious vocations. It's really awesome and quite unique. Music, Flickz, and media lounge seems pointless, Open Mic could easily smell of elderberries up the threads in there. The most troubling area is the Debate Table. It is NOT about interfaith dialogue. Rather it's mostly about intrafaith arguing. I guess since there are so few non-Catholics around Phatmass there isn't much else to debate. Regardless, I don't think it's healthy or particularly lively. Just my $.02 worth.
jasJis Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 [quote name='dUSt' post='963056' date='Apr 27 2006, 12:53 PM']If phatmass no longer builds up Christ and His church, then phatmass should not exist. Period.[/quote]A little extreme, don't you think? What do you think is wrong? If you agree if something is wrong, can it be changed? If something can be improved, how do you effect it? Shut down pm if it can't be improved. I wouldn't call pm stagnant and end it there. Sometimes it's helpful, sometimes it IS harmful, and sometimes it's stagnant. But you've heard this from me over the years.
prose Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 [quote]There also seems to be problems with the huge number of trads on this board who have been leading others, including 'militants' over to the trad side. Phatmass just ain't no fun no more without the love that used to be here. [/quote] Yes yes yes yes.... I used to come here, and like that I could ask questions and have open discussion. Now I am reluctant to even tell my youth group to come here. They might not feel "Catholic Enough" because of this issue. Maybe the solution is to have a trad board? I don't know, but I do know that conversations about the Latin Masses, bad bishops/cardinals/ etc, illegitimit Masses/sacraments and stuff have been dominating the boards for the last few months. It is confusing to Catholics that follow teachings after Vatican II. It is confusing to people who have not been exposed to these views (like myself). Not that they are wrong, but they certainly try to make one form of Catholicism "better" than the other, and that is sad. As for the growth, I find that many of the people that I liked chatting with about Catholicism and apologetics simply are not here any more. I am not sure why. I LOVE reading about our faith and how it has developed and grown over the years. I grow with discussions about authority and stuff (not challenging it, but supporting it, and its history). I am one of the biggests goofs here, and I like that, but I certainly find that many times if I need help or direction or even a boost of support in my faith I am reluctant to express here because I am afraid of being attacked for not being Catholic enough. One thought: Maybe the Prayer Room could be more prominant somehow? Like maybe the top of the list, not the bottom when we login. Or maybe have a link to it pinned at the top of all the forums as a reminder to go there. I think that people tend to forget it is there.
Andrea348 Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 vocation station has become a lot more active than it used to be. it used to be pretty slow when i first came to pm, but now it is much busier. i love to spend time there because there are so many wonderful people posting about their discernment process.
prose Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 [quote]If phatmass no longer builds up Christ and His church, then phatmass should not exist. Period.[/quote] I agree, but even with flaws, PhatMass does and always will build up Christ and His Church. Don't let Satan convince you otherwise just because you are hearing some things that need improving. Some things need improving, but rely on its MEMBERS not necessarily it MAKER.
philothea Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 The silly and pointlessly argumentative threads get more attention than the thoughtful, spiritual threads. It's pretty disheartening to post something serious that has taken a lot of thought, and have it pretty much ignored, while people blab on about trivial stuff. I know that is the nature of people and the internet -- being thoughtful takes, you know, [i]thought[/i]. Arguing and being silly, not so much. The more people you have, the more pronounced this turn toward triviality will be. I'll try to think if there's any possible fix. One problem seems to be that generic Catholic/religious discussion doesn't have its own forum -- it gets mixed up on Open Mic with the blather there. Really, I don't know if splitting off another forum would help any. I know one thing that [b]highly[/b] motivates people here: graphics and special titles. I don't know what can be done along those lines, but if there was a way that people could be credited for posting good spiritual content... you'd see a lot more of it, I bet.
morostheos Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 I definitely have felt things being a bit stagnant spiritually lately. I've learned so much about the Catholic faith by posting on here, but lately it seems like there's been a lot of whining and bickering. Those aren't really things you can change directly, but maybe we could step up the spiritual/prayer aspect a bit more - Like getting the living rosary that P5 Covenant had going on their site for a while back up and things like that. Another idea (and I don't know if it would work or not, but I'll throw it out there since it popped into my head) would be to create smaller groups of people that could get to know each other better to counteract some of the "getting big" part of the board. Maybe they could have a time each week to "meet" and discuss the Gospels for next Sunday or a topic of choice or something...I don't know. You could have people volunteer to lead discussions on certain topics. But the more I go on and on the more time this idea would take to implement, so I'll stop now. :
prose Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 [quote]I'll try to think if there's any possible fix. One problem seems to be that generic Catholic/religious discussion doesn't have its own forum -- it gets mixed up on Open Mic with the blather there. Really, I don't know if splitting off another forum would help any.[/quote] I think that the spiritual stuff goes to open Mic because it is the most often posted in forum. I know I post there all the time. There really isn't a "Catholic Discussion" area. I think you are right though . I would probably post most in Open Mic still b/c that is where I normal talk. [quote]I know one thing that highly motivates people here: graphics and special titles. I don't know what can be done along those lines, but if there was a way that people could be credited for posting good spiritual content... you'd see a lot more of it, I bet.[/quote] Yep. I know I am motivated by the special pictures that I don't have . And that is the thing. People ARE credited for spiritual posting with these tags. If it isn't working now, it isn't going to work just by adding more pics. Although I would really like two more pics!!!
sweetpea316 Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 [quote name='prose' post='963101' date='Apr 27 2006, 02:52 PM'] Yes yes yes yes.... I used to come here, and like that I could ask questions and have open discussion. Now I am reluctant to even tell my youth group to come here. They might not feel "Catholic Enough" because of this issue. [/quote] This brought another thought to mind. I think I really realized that maybe some changes needed to be made when I was considering things with my family. I was asking on here for websites to send them to get good reliable Catholic information. Someone suggested sending them to the defense directory. But I thought "If they stay in the directory, then ok, but what if they go into the phorum?" That was a red flag in my head. I want to be able to send anyone here and not worry that they're going to get a bad impression of the Catholic faith. I don't want phatmass to become like some of the other boards we discuss, where if someone says something from the opposite point of view, that they will immediatly be banned. I think we're much more charitable and loving than that, and are capable of awesome and beneficial conversation. And again, I don't know what to do about changing things... but I think with our forces combined, we can make phatmass a happier place.
ardillacid Posted April 27, 2006 Posted April 27, 2006 (edited) I think there is a lot of anger on phatmass. note my signatyre Edited April 27, 2006 by notardillacid
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now