Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='963107' date='Apr 27 2006, 03:00 PM']
Yep. I know I am motivated by the special pictures that I don't have ;) . And that is the thing. People ARE credited for spiritual posting with these tags. If it isn't working now, it isn't going to work just by adding more pics.
[/quote]
Well, the "Church Faithful" flag only means that you are faithful to the magisterium... it doesn't mean that you talk seriously about Catholicism on a regular basis.

There are other forum systems where people are rated by how good their posts generally are (slashdot), or they get ranks/titles depending on how usefully they participate (many forums).

I don't know what options IPB has, which is why I didn't make any particular suggestions, but I wouldn't be surprised if something like that couldn't be included.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='963101' date='Apr 27 2006, 01:52 PM']
I used to come here, and like that I could ask questions and have open discussion. Now I am reluctant to even tell my youth group to come here. They might not feel "Catholic Enough" because of this issue.[/quote]
Hey dUSt, have you ever heard this before?

Noel's angel
Posted

People get really unnecessarily angry sometimes and there is quite a bit of 'back-biting', snide little comments here and there. It all is a bit petty. Can we just try to get on and remember what we all have in common??? If you want to have specific debates with specific people, do it in private, not on a place which has the ability to influence a lot of people. There a lot of young people who come on here, amny of whom may be easily influenced, so maybe if specific debates could be kept either to a minimum or done privately, that would be good. If you want to debate about issues WITHIN catholicism, I don't believe Phatmass is the place for that. Sure, ask questions and help eachother learn and grow in faith and knowledge, but many of the current debates and those recent debates are uneccessary and do not help people to grow and practice charity. It just makes people angry and upset.

Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' post='963110' date='Apr 27 2006, 03:03 PM']
This brought another thought to mind. I think I really realized that maybe some changes needed to be made when I was considering things with my family. I was asking on here for websites to send them to get good reliable Catholic information. Someone suggested sending them to the defense directory. But I thought "If they stay in the directory, then ok, but what if they go into the phorum?" That was a red flag in my head. I want to be able to send anyone here and not worry that they're going to get a bad impression of the Catholic faith.
[/quote]
I completely agree. I've told a few people about phatmass. They're very interested, but then they never show up. I don't recommend it to people anymore. :(

In the shorter term, just with the mods we have and no big changes, I think a lot could be done. Move the silliest carp into the Creepy Aliens board (or have some other board just for silly stuff): polls on star wars, games soley intended to get your post count up, links to online meme quizzes, etc. Combine and move repetitive cliquish stuff like the "phan" clubs. That'd clear out 80% of the first page!

[quote name='sweetpea316' post='963110' date='Apr 27 2006, 03:03 PM']
I don't want phatmass to become like some of the other boards we discuss, where if someone says something from the opposite point of view, that they will immediatly be banned. I think we're much more charitable and loving than that, and are capable of awesome and beneficial conversation. And again, I don't know what to do about changing things... but I think with our forces combined, we can make phatmass a happier place. ^_^[/quote]
Same here! I totally want everyone to feel welcome. I like spontaneous, social, fun stuff. I don't want people banned, unless they're actually really disruptive. Being silly isn't distruptive. But given the way the phorum is set up now, mass, thoughtless posting is rewarded, and overwhelms any serious conversation.

Posted

Maybe we should reinstitute the back alley....

Posted

Don't be hard on yourself, dUSt! Like all things, there are ups and downs...cycles. Phatmass is a means were we can communicate, share our stories and come together as a community. Hang in there! :boxer:

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted (edited)

[quote name='prose' post='963101' date='Apr 27 2006, 03:52 PM']
Yes yes yes yes.... I used to come here, and like that I could ask questions and have open discussion. Now I am reluctant to even tell my youth group to come here. They might not feel "Catholic Enough" because of this issue.

Maybe the solution is to have a trad board? I don't know, but I do know that conversations about the Latin Masses, bad bishops/cardinals/ etc, illegitimit Masses/sacraments and stuff have been dominating the boards for the last few months. It is confusing to Catholics that follow teachings after Vatican II. It is confusing to people who have not been exposed to these views (like myself). Not that they are wrong, but they certainly try to make one form of Catholicism "better" than the other, and that is sad.


[/quote]


did you ever think that maybe the reason we Trads talk about bad bishops, bad cardinals, and the mass etc. is becuase there is a lot of problems in the Church right now? For the love of God open your eyes!

Edited by Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

As somebody with traditional leanings, I really wish that many of my fellow trads were more thoughtful and less verbal.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

I am annoyed by the debating, and usually I love to debate.

What needs to be done is on our shoulders, not dUSt's. We need to work better at keeping debate and discussions of that like in the debate board, and make sure what goes on there stays there. Part of the problem is that alot of debate starts here on the open mic because of a lack of charity, and then bad feelings linger into other boards and such, thus causing an over all bad feeling.

Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='963154' date='Apr 27 2006, 03:41 PM']
did you ever think that maybe the reason we Trads talk about bad bishops, bad cardinals, and the mass etc. is becuase there is a lot of problems in the Church right now? For the love of God open your eyes!
[/quote]
And discussing this on an internet phorum helps how?

Keyser Soze
Posted

Don't worry folks! I'm placing my stamp on all the threads that can be deleted.

That should clean up a lot of the filth here! :)

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='963168' date='Apr 27 2006, 04:48 PM']
And discussing this on an internet phorum helps how?
[/quote]



to inform people. to convert people. etc.
it usually helps to exchange ideas.

Posted

I think there's very little actual debate at the debate table... at least in the formal sense. And it seems like many of those actually break down eventually into some internet form of standoff. I feel like a few of them that I've actually found interesting actually had some intellectual content to them (eg soul has gender, my last back and forth w/ cam regarding guitars)

I think that the debate table should be limited to theological debate or application of church teachings. That is, it should be more closely regulated.

I don't think that open mic/creepy aliens should limit off-topic stuff. Catholicism embraces all of life, not just going to Church. If we didn't have any fun stuff chatting, then it would limit its ability to create community.

I do think that I often forget that there's anything else, but "The Word and Apologetics" could be repurposed to include apologetics, testimonies, insights, encouragements, etc. It's not clear that there's a forum for "Christian fellowship" (even though I really don't like the word fellowship).

Ignore freely. :thumbsup:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...