Fulton Sheen Warrior Posted April 29, 2006 Posted April 29, 2006 +JMJ+ I've been on www.fisheaters.com to hear recordings of Archbishop Fulton Sheen, and can't seem to figure them out. I looked at their "About us" section, and they say they beleive Pope Benedict XVI is the legitimate successor to St. Peter, yet they seem highly critical of the Church. My question is, Should I steer clear of this site?
OLAM Dad Posted April 29, 2006 Posted April 29, 2006 Only you can answer this question. If the behavior that you describe bothers you or could harm your faith then steer clear. otoh, if you find humor in some of their silliness and enjoy the discussions I see no harm.
brendan1104 Posted April 29, 2006 Posted April 29, 2006 [quote name='Fulton Sheen Warrior' post='965376' date='Apr 29 2006, 06:36 PM'] +JMJ+ I've been on www.fisheaters.com to hear recordings of Archbishop Fulton Sheen, and can't seem to figure them out. I looked at their "About us" section, and they say they beleive Pope Benedict XVI is the legitimate successor to St. Peter, yet they seem highly critical of the Church. My question is, Should I steer clear of this site? [/quote] Its fruits are varied. They have alot of great stuff, but their membership is varied- indult, SSPX, indpendent, sedevacantist, etc. So alot of it you have to disregard or discern with...
Fidei Defensor Posted April 29, 2006 Posted April 29, 2006 Visit with caution. They have some really great resources there, but do not necesarily take everything they say as fact. They are highly critical of the post-Vatican II Church. As Brendan said, they have a varied group of members, which do include those members who do not believe that the current Pope is the true successor of St. Peter. As well, as OLAM Dad said, if you feel uncomfortable about the content, I would stay away.
Peccator Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 The Apologetics section is excellent....that much I do know
Brother Adam Posted April 30, 2006 Posted April 30, 2006 Like others said, discern when you are there, just as if you were to visit a baptist or an athiest website.
Fulton Sheen Warrior Posted April 30, 2006 Author Posted April 30, 2006 +JMJ+ Thanks for the info...duly noted. I may look around (with th discernment of a papist). Something tells me I'm just going to stick with Fulton Sheen's stuff.
Theoketos Posted May 1, 2006 Posted May 1, 2006 There are other places to get the Fulton Sheen stuff... There is really too much malice over there for much fruit to bear.
Tarcisius Posted May 1, 2006 Posted May 1, 2006 [quote]discern when you are there, just as if you were to visit a baptist or an athiest website.[/quote] or a phatmass site.
Resurrexi Posted May 2, 2006 Posted May 2, 2006 [quote]Like others said, discern when you are there, just as if you were to visit a baptist or an athiest website.[/quote] OMGOSH! It a CATHOLIC website, not a heretcial website. The webstie itself is fine, but stay clear of the Sede v. SSPX v. Indult Debate Forum on the board. [quote]There are other places to get the Fulton Sheen stuff... There is really too much malice over there for much fruit to bear.[/quote] If you think that fact (though often exaggerated) is malice, then I guess you're right, Fisheaters is full of malice.
Cam42 Posted May 2, 2006 Posted May 2, 2006 [quote name='Theoketos' post='966350' date='Apr 30 2006, 09:46 PM'] There are other places to get the Fulton Sheen stuff... There is really too much malice over there for much fruit to bear. [/quote] Agreed.
VoxClamantis Posted May 11, 2006 Posted May 11, 2006 Hi, FultonSheenWarrior! I run the [url="http://www.fisheaters.com"]Fish Eaters Website[/url] so can let you know what the angle is: the site itself is set up to teach Catholics how to practice Catholicism according to the 1962 Missal and calendar (this is what the Being Catholic section is about). The site, then, is useful for anyone who worships in that way, whether they attend Masses offered by indult, Masses offered by the S.S.P.X., or whatever. The discussion forum is where things can get contentious. There, all trads are welcome, with rules in place designed to segregate the really heated stuff. Catholics who don't worship in the traditional way can still get a lot out of the Being Catholic section of the site. They'd just have to know that the Sacramental rites described are those used in 1962 and now by trads, that Scripture references are to the Douay (with the Septuagint Psalm numbering), and that liturgical dates refer to the 1962 Calendar. Hope this helps
Socrates Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 This was brought up in a thread that got locked and banished to the "Lame Board," but unfortunately, I think it says alot about whether or not Fisheaters.com is "good." [url="http://www.fisheaters.com/jpiispeech.html?insight=Jesus"]http://www.fisheaters.com/jpiispeech.html?insight=Jesus[/url] (This was linked to by a "fisheater" and the link was deleted, so mods feel free to delete the link - I just felt it is very relevent to this issue.) This is a "fun" page on Fisheaters.com which mocks his Holiness, the late Pope John Paul II. One types in any word, and a lot of randomly-generated nonsense phrases is produced, which the page mockingly calls the "great Catholic insight" of Pope John Paul II. Such sophomoric and pointless mockery of a deceased Supreme Pontiff of the Church certainly has no place on a Catholic website! I fail to see how any serious Catholic could possibly justify such blatantly disrespectful carp. [quote name='VoxClamantis' post='978685' date='May 11 2006, 02:51 PM'] Hi, FultonSheenWarrior! I run the [url="http://www.fisheaters.com"]Fish Eaters Website[/url] so can let you know what the angle is: the site itself is set up to teach Catholics how to practice Catholicism according to the 1962 Missal and calendar (this is what the Being Catholic section is about). The site, then, is useful for anyone who worships in that way, whether they attend Masses offered by indult, Masses offered by the S.S.P.X., or whatever. The discussion forum is where things can get contentious. There, all trads are welcome, with rules in place designed to segregate the really heated stuff. Catholics who don't worship in the traditional way can still get a lot out of the Being Catholic section of the site. They'd just have to know that the Sacramental rites described are those used in 1962 and now by trads, that Scripture references are to the Douay (with the Septuagint Psalm numbering), and that liturgical dates refer to the 1962 Calendar. Hope this helps [/quote] And just what might Catholics get out of your "John Paul II Randomly Says" page??
VoxClamantis Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 Socrates, you must not have read many of John Paul II's writings if you fail to see the humor in that. He famously used too many words and certain phrases. Don't lose your sense of humor, man.
Socrates Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 [quote name='VoxClamantis' post='978871' date='May 11 2006, 06:35 PM'] Socrates, you must not have read many of John Paul II's writings if you fail to see the humor in that. He famously used too many words and certain phrases. Don't lose your sense of humor, man. [/quote] I'm sorry, but I fail to see the humor in mocking a recently deceased Holy Father. Is there anything at all on that site treating Pope John Paul II (or Pope Benedict XVI) with respect and love? I'll admit, my experiences with Fisheaters are limited, but what I've seen there is mostly slander, calumny, and uncharity. There was nothing to make me wish to return to that site. (And I have "traditionalist" leanings myself in certain areas - so don't just dismiss me as a modernist "Neo-Con" (whatever that might mean).) And I can only imagine the howls of outrage that would arise from the "fisheater" crowd if Phatmass had a similar "humor" page mocking someone beloved of the "Rad-Trad" set. (How about "insight from Lefebre": "Jewish Perfidy no salvation of False Ecumenism Talmudic NeoCon"?)
VoxClamantis Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' post='978871' date='May 11 2006, 06:35 PM'] I'm sorry, but I fail to see the humor in mocking a recently deceased Holy Father.[/quote] 1) it isn't mockery. It's the same sort of ribbing and joking I'd give to my natural father. But then, I'm Italian and we tend to laugh a lot. 2) The Holy Father wasn't dead when the page went up [quote]Is there anything at all on that site treating Pope John Paul II (or Pope Benedict XVI) with respect and love?[/quote] There isn't much there treating Popes John Paul II or Benedict XVI one way or another aside from a few articles in the "For Catholics" section, none of which are disrespectful. [quote]I'll admit, my experiences with Fisheaters are limited, but what I've seen there is mostly slander, calumny, and uncharity. There was nothing to make me wish to return to that site. (And I have "traditionalist" leanings myself in certain areas - so don't just dismiss me as a modernist "Neo-Con" (whatever that might mean).)[/quote] Don't know where you could have seen something like that at the site, though at the discussion forum, people of all types show up, including people I disagree with. [quote]And I can only imagine the howls of outrage that would arise from the "fisheater" crowd if Phatmass had a similar "humor" page mocking someone beloved of the "Rad-Trad" set.[/quote] The very use of the term "rad trad" is something we're used to, if you catch my drift. Same with "the fisheater crowd" and the like. [quote](How about "insight from Lefebre": "Jewish Perfidy no salvation of False Ecumenism Talmudic NeoCon"?)[/quote] Since the site isn't an S.S.P.X. site, it isn't relevant. There are people who attend S.S.P.X. Masses at [i]the discussion forum,[/i] just as there are those, like me, who attend Masses offered by the F.S.S.P., or by the I.C.K, etc., and there are also sedevacantists. All trads of all types are welcome at the forum, and there is one -- and only one -- sub-forum where these different types of trads can debate about their differences. The rest of the forum is for discussion of what we all have in common. The [i]site itself[/i], though, is "pan-trad" and is so "radical" that even Latin Mass Magazine links to it from their site. Parish churches link to it. Don't make the mistake of confusing opinions you might see from some people at the forum with [i]the site itself[/i], which anyone who worships according to the 1962 Missal should find helpful.
KnightofChrist Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 These are some of the things that are wrong with Fisheaters.com... and why Real Catholic shouldnt go to that site... source: www.catholicculture.org [quote]"The site as a whole implicitly and explicitly rejects the Novus Ordo Mass. " The section on the Mass entitled "The Mass I: Introduction" states: In this section, I focus solely on the traditional Latin Mass based on the Missal of 1962 which is used by the S.S.P.X. and by the F.S.S.P. After much study, I've come to the conclusion that, validity issues aside, the "Novus Ordo Mass" is inherently, tragically flawed, something my instincts and "common sense" have told me since I was a child. The very name of this Mass -- "Novus Ordo," i.e., "New Order" -- should make anyone with a true Catholic nature cringe, and its effects are so incredibly sad it almost hurts to think about it. It has turned out to be a "New Mass" for a "New Religion" -- and that religion ain't Catholic." In another place, the webmaster declares, "We must stop supporting the that which reeks of "the spirit of Vatican II," i.e., modernism -- the heterodox seminaries, the "Novus Ordo masses," . . . We must support only the true Catholic Faith -- the Faith of the Fathers -- with its traditional Latin Mass, traditional Sacraments, and traditional teaching." (The Church as Battered Bride) Notice that "Novus Ordo masses" is placed in quotation marks, implying that the New Mass is a Mass in name only. There are many other articles and links, especially in the section "For Catholics," that support this position. Examples include: * A Brief Defense of Traditionalism * Conservative -vs- Traditional Catholicism * Links to The New Mass I: Inalienable Right or Inferior Rite? and The New Mass II: Our Faith in Hymn at Catholic Apologetics International * Links to material from the Society of St. Pius X [/quote] [quote]"All of the material and resources offered are pre-Vatican II." A telling example of this is in the section dedicated to the writings of the Popes. Though most of the major encyclicals pre-1963 are included, not a single document since the Council is included. The same is true of other resources. The only exception to this is the documents of the Council itself. [/quote] [quote]"A "Dictionary of Dissent"" This "dictionary" is filled with sarcasitic remarks about the New Mass, current Church terminology, and the post-Conciliar Church. The overall effect is one of encouraging Catholics to disregard the authority of the Church on these issues. Here are a few examples: * "A is Not A" and "2+2=5" -- the kind of liberal or neo-conservative logic it takes to reconcile, for ex.: Mortalium Animos with the Assisi Events; Quo Primum and Mediator Dei with the Novus Ordo Mass; Mirari Vos with the entire Vatican II experiment and idea that the Church requires "renewal"; Testem Benevolentiae Nostra and Quas Primas with the post-conciliar view of government; Unam Sanctam with post-conciliar false ecumenism; and so forth. * Antisemite -- someone Jews hate. It could be someone who doesn't like Zionism or American funding of Israel. Or it could be someone who knows what the Talmud says. Whatever it is, whoever gets the label is expected to act guilty and apologize profusely lest his career, reputation, and any realistic hopes of fulfilling political ambition be destroyed. * Conscience -- . . . Traditional Catholic: "My informed conscience and years of study tell me that what's been going on in the Church since Vatican II is evil." * Man -- the new god. This concept is a result of a refocus from theology to anthropological philosophy. The new trend in "Vatican thinking" starts with man himself instead of starting with the God of revelation. It glosses over the reality of original sin and assumes that if man just gazes at himself long enough, he will then seek out God (Who may be found in any religion, but only "most fully" in the neo-Catholic religion). * There are also attacks on terms such as Liturgy of the Word, Liturgy of the Eucharist, priests who wished to be called by their given names, and much more.[/quote] [quote]"Unorthodox Catholic links" Here are just a few examples: * Catholic Apologetics International * Diocese Report * Una Voce * The Remnant * Chistian Order * Christus Rex * Society of St. Pius X [/quote]
dUSt Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 Fisheaters should be visited with the same caution one would have if they were visiting a [b]Protest[/b]ant site... because that is basically the theme of the website, they are [b]protest[/b]ing anything after Vatican II. It does have some good apologetical resources, just like some Protestant websites have some great apologetical resources to combat athiesm, etc. You just have to be careful to always stay true to the church and the magisterium, and not some idea, philosophy or movement.
VoxClamantis Posted May 12, 2006 Posted May 12, 2006 KnightofChrist, we have every right to be critical of the Novus Ordo Missae. We don't have to like it, we can criticize it (as does His Holiness Benedict XVI), and we can resolve to attend traditional Masses. Catholicculture.org says: [quote]"Notice that "Novus Ordo masses" is placed in quotation marks, implying that the New Mass is a Mass in name only. There are many other articles and links, especially in the section "For Catholics," that support this position."[/quote] -- but that is their leap in logic, not mine. Nowhere at FEW will one see the idea that the N.O. Mass is invalid. Dust, no, the site doesn't protest "anything after Vatican II." The Being Catholic section does defend the traditional Mass as contrasted with the Novus Ordo Missae, does defend the old cycle of readings and liturgical calendar as contrasted with the new, and does say that it is unwise for Pope John Paul II to have added Mysteries to the Rosaries, even if it was presented as a mere option. The "For Catholics" section talks a lot about what we all know has happened to the human element of the Church since the Council. One either acknowledges and talks about problems so they get fixed, or lives in denial as souls are lost. Just last night I read this from a (non-trad) website: [quote]I attended a Catholic high school and it's my firm belief that they did their best to destroy Catholicism, albeit inadvertently. They were so busy trying to *prove* everything through science, to rationalize it all for those who are ensconced in a world where such qualities are admirable, that they rationalized the mystical aspect of Catholicism away, leaving us with a framework of now meaningless rituals and beliefs. Oh, we knew *why* such things were believed but they were old, antiquated or illogical and could expound for hours on why. Unfortunately, this was cloaked in the framework of a Catholic education so many of us believed this is what the Church taught, or would teach once we had a modern pope. When people began to realize they wanted something more out of their beliefs, they had been taught to think that no such thing existed in Catholicism. They, therefore, looked elsewhere for the spiritual aspect they craved. Many found it in the neo-pagan movement or in eastern religions. These religions so emphasized the individual and self-empowerment that many former Catholics could easily either adapt these teachings into their current lifestyle or drop Catholicism all together in favor of this newly discovered belief system. The modern Catholic writers, in an attempt to stave off the mass flight of the faithful, have made the mistake of trying to make Catholicism a feel-good, down to earth religion, the "Chicken Soup" variety of Catholic spirituality, with all the imagery that goes with it (angels as cherubic infants or beautiful winged women, the WWJD bracelets, etc.), totally ignoring the rich history and teachings already available to them. Now, I'm not saying this is a bad thing. I'm well aware that Catholicism isn't everyone's cuppa tea. I'm simply explaining what I've seen happen in my life. I was one of the masses of Catholics who, once they hit college tried to maintain my faith life. I first ran into the Charasmatic movement, the Chicken Soup variety, which thoroughly disturbed me and my strict German sensibilites. However, I could not find another alternative, and went "What's the point?"and stopped going to mass. Then something interesting happened. I was introduced to my friend's roommates, both of whom were wiccan (or "recovering" Catholics). And, in the face of engaging in religious debate with them (a favorite past time in that household), I started reading up on paganism and wicca. I had zero intention of converting but I wanted to at least be knowledgeable as to what their point of view was. So I started reading and asking them questions: Why did you convert? What was it about wicca that drew you? etc. And their answers are summed up in the above paragraph. [/quote] Anyone wanting Mystery, beauty, ritual, rich symbolism, art, a profound sense of time, a sense of History and of connectedness with our ancestors, and all the other stuff that pulls people out of the Church and into paganism should look toward traditional Catholicism -- which isn't to say, of course, that traditional Catholicism is paganism. It's just that traditional Catholicism is aware enough of Truth and of human nature to know what people crave and need. There [i]are [/i] the "Jansenist-esque" types out there in trad-land. Pray for them. But don't confuse them with traditional Catholicism itself.
Recommended Posts