Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Fisheaters.com


Recommended Posts

Posted

it would be cool if your phatmass username is fisheater

Posted

The fact that you seperate "traditional Catholicism" with "Catholicism" illustrates the natural dividing aspect of your website. :)

VoxClamantis
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='979428' date='May 12 2006, 01:53 PM']
The fact that you seperate "traditional Catholicism" with "Catholicism" illustrates the natural dividing aspect of your website. :)
[/quote]

But there [i]is [/i] a divide. There are those who worship acc. to the 1962 Missal/calender (or older) and who see the post-Conciliar changes in those things as (at the least) unwise, and those who don't. There are those who have serious problems with (at least) the typical interpretations of Vatican II's documents, and those who don't. They're different groups, hence the adjective before the "Catholicism."

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='979428' date='May 12 2006, 02:53 PM'] The fact that you seperate "traditional Catholicism" with "Catholicism" illustrates the natural dividing aspect of your website. :) [/quote]

Oddly enough I find that just as many people do it the other way around. ;)


Very little of either group will see the similarities at all.


[quote name='VoxClamantis' post='979363' date='May 12 2006, 02:07 PM']Just last night I read this from a (non-trad) website:[/quote]

Yeah, they like U2 too. ;)

[quote]There [i]are [/i] the "Jansenist-esque" types out there in trad-land. Pray for them. But don't confuse them with traditional Catholicism itself. [/quote]

Sadly I find way too much of this and Feeneyism in many circles.

Then again, I find so much in the other too.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='brendan1104' post='965417' date='Apr 29 2006, 03:31 PM']
Its fruits are varied. They have alot of great stuff, but their membership is varied- indult, SSPX, indpendent, sedevacantist, etc. So alot of it you have to disregard or discern with...
[/quote]

Ditto as far as the discussion board goes. The main site has a lot of awesome Catholic information though. One of my favorite sources of information on different things.

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='967682' date='May 1 2006, 06:59 PM']
OMGOSH! It a CATHOLIC website, not a heretcial website. The webstie itself is fine, but stay clear of the Sede v. SSPX v. Indult Debate Forum on the board
[/quote]
hehe.... that's my favorite place there... <_< :D:


[quote name='VoxClamantis' post='979085' date='May 12 2006, 01:01 AM']The [i]site itself[/i], though, is "pan-trad" and is so "radical" that even Latin Mass Magazine links to it from their site. Parish churches link to it. Don't make the mistake of confusing opinions you might see from some people at the forum with [i]the site itself[/i], which anyone who worships according to the 1962 Missal should find helpful.
[/quote]

Amen. It has a forum for people to discuss openly differences in Catholicism(very unlike this site...), but many of the views of people there have nothing to do with the site itself, all of which is sound. Don't take the opinion of people like say me for instance, as the position of the site.

P.S. Hey Vox :).

Posted

[quote name='VoxClamantis' post='979489' date='May 12 2006, 03:03 PM']
But there [i]is [/i] a divide. There are those who worship acc. to the 1962 Missal/calender (or older) and who see the post-Conciliar changes in those things as (at the least) unwise, and those who don't. There are those who have serious problems with (at least) the typical interpretations of Vatican II's documents, and those who don't. They're different groups, hence the adjective before the "Catholicism."
[/quote]
Right. I would like to think of phatmass as a "Catholic" website, who accepts the teachings of the current magisterium without having any "serious problems" with it. The alternative follows the same path as Protestantism. Instead of accepting/following, with obedience, the teachings of the church, you accept/follow your personal interpretation of what you [b]think[/b] the church should teach. :(

The difference is that Protestants usually only look to the Bible for their personal interpretation, while it seems that most of the audience at fisheaters looks to the Bible and church documents for their personal interpretation.

VoxClamantis
Posted

[mod]Catholic vs Catholic debate. - dUSt[/mod]

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...