Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I love this question. I am under the impression that it's a big thing to switch to another parish. I hope a priest can clarify that. But I think I've unfortunately hijacked two other threads. How rude and unthinking of me. (I feel all ego-maniac and stuff now.)

So.

When is it okay to switch parishes? Is it a big deal? Why leave? What are you leaving? What are you gaining?

Brother Adam
Posted (edited)

As I answered in a previous thread,

Normally, you would never switch parishes, unless of course you moved away. As in the diocese of steubenville, parishioners are required to attend the parish to which they live in (parishes, like schools, are zoned).

Edited by Brother Adam
Posted

When you move or die

Posted

Or get employed by another parish ;)

kamiller42
Posted

From previous thread:

I see no problem with attending mass in another parish. Even better, helping out.

I guess I see the role of the parish and faith a little different than you. It's not there to hand deliver a deep faith to me. The parish is there as a local faith community, a family. Each member is experiencing their faith in a different way. The church is there to facilitate deepening my faith, like a gym is there to assist the athlete in strengthening his muscles. What I get out of my workout is mostly up to me. (I use a gym metaphor. I feel the same about schools and education.)

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='967298' date='May 1 2006, 05:16 PM']
Or get employed by another parish ;)
[/quote]

Typically folks dont attend mass or confession at parishes they are employed at.

Posted

I don't see how you could be a youth minister and not attend the parish you are ministering to. Or a pastoral care associate....

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='967316' date='May 1 2006, 05:31 PM']
I don't see how you could be a youth minister and not attend the parish you are ministering to. Or a pastoral care associate....
[/quote]

Well, you work there obviously, and attend events you need to with your group, but usually the parish priest would not want you confessing to him since you are his employee. Imagine how ackward "Father I stole $10 out of the offering" would be.

Posted

lol

Okay, so I go to confession to our other priest. Monsignor does 1/2 of the Masses on weekends, so I go to him. Or I go to the penance services and choose a priest there.

Or occasionally I go to another parish.

But I go to Mass at this parish all the time.

Actually, let me add to that...

I think it is okay to go to the parish priest where I work. Volunteers go to him all the time. why [i]wouldn't[/i] I go to him?

Brother Adam
Posted

The norm taught here as a directive from most diocesian offices is that it is perferable not to go to confession to your employing priest as to not put him in an socially ackward situation if you must confess sins against your employer (Church).

Posted

I personally have switched parishes, I serve daily mass for my local parish, however, my voulunteer work came to an end when I was insulted severely by the parish priest. I currently attend mass 30 miles away, however I will be living down there next summer to have a decent job to make decent money to pay for college.

I am employed by that parish as well, and will receive the sacrament of confirmation there.

Sincerely Yours in Christ,

Ed L.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='967316' date='May 1 2006, 02:31 PM']
I don't see how you could be a youth minister and not attend the parish you are ministering to. Or a pastoral care associate....
[/quote]

That's an easy one. Its about boundaries. Part of belonging to a parish is getting your needs met. Ministry is about meeting the needs of your youth. If you belong to the same parish that you minister in, its very easy to start blurring lines.




I never belonged to the parish that hired me. Now attending mass at the parish you work is a different matter but that's not being a member of the community.

Apotheoun
Posted

A person can attend services at any Catholic parish (of any rite), and I have even be registered at a parish that was not my geographical parish in the past. In fact for two years (from 2003 to 2005) I attended a Byzantine parish, while I was still a member of the Roman rite, and at the end of that probationary period I petitioned for an official change of [i]sui juris[/i] Church.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Some parishes are ethnic, some are territorial.

Dust's Sister
Posted

There is a Catholic Church that's 5 minutes away from my house, but I prefer to go to one that is 15 minutes away from my house... and I just recently registered there. There are plenty of reasons why I attend. St. Maria Goretti's rather then St. Vincent De Paul's.. but I won't get into that...

as for me, I think it's doesn't matter which Catholic church you attend, as long as you make to Mass. :)....... Just do whatever reaches your heart.

~Darvon

Though whatever Church you do attend weekly.... I would at least register there...

Resurrexi
Posted

I dont have a parish that I go to Mass at. The only time I go to the parish I'm registered at is for confession (I dont go to the NO and wouldnt unless there was no other option). Twice a month, when they have the indult I go there, and twice or thrice a month, when they don't have the indult, I go to the Divine Liturgy.

I think it is perfectly fine to switch parishes if you want to go to a more traditional parish.

Posted

[quote]I never belonged to the parish that hired me. Now attending mass at the parish you work is a different matter but that's not being a member of the community.
[/quote]


Why would you attend Mass at one Church, but be a member of another Church community? That doesn't make sense.

Our priest said something very eloquent about this in one of his homilies. He said something along the lines of:

I was asked once whether or not going to Mass was important. I said ABSOLUTELY. Not only for your own faith, but for the faith of all the members around you. Each member contributes to this Mass and as such contributes to one another's faith. We grow with eachother in struggles, and in good times. When we choose not to attend Mass together, it hurts everyone.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='967581' date='May 1 2006, 06:38 PM']
Why would you attend Mass at one Church, but be a member of another Church community? That doesn't make sense.

Our priest said something very eloquent about this in one of his homilies. He said something along the lines of:

I was asked once whether or not going to Mass was important. I said ABSOLUTELY. Not only for your own faith, but for the faith of all the members around you. Each member contributes to this Mass and as such contributes to one another's faith. We grow with eachother in struggles, and in good times. When we choose not to attend Mass together, it hurts everyone.
[/quote]

I may not have been clear Prose. I went to mass at the church I was working almost every Sunday. But I never became a member of the Church. I felt that this was one of the sacrifices one must make to be effective in ministry. It is so easy to blur boundaries. And I knew that I was not going to be a member of that church for 20 years so joining it would be a mistake.

That was my personal take on it. I'm not saying its a universal truth. It was just right for me.

Posted

Well, after I moved, I started to attend a different parish, although not the one closest to my house.

When one parish offers daily adoration from 6am-10pm, frequent benediction, and required adult catechesis when your child attends CCD.... and all the other parishes in the city [b]combined[/b] don't offer as much, there's a reason why every mass is overflowing at that parish. I'm not worried about me, but I attend this parish for the sake of my family. If you want your family to be Eucharistic centered instead of community centered, you attend a Eucharistic centered parish.

Anyway, my two cents.

Dust's Sister
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='967639' date='May 1 2006, 07:27 PM']
Well, after I moved, I started to attend a different parish, although not the one closest to my house.

When one parish offers daily adoration from 6am-10pm, frequent benediction, and required adult catechesis when your child attends CCD.... and all the other parishes in the city [b]combined[/b] don't offer as much, there's a reason why every mass is overflowing at that parish. I'm not worried about me, but I attend this parish for the sake of my family. If you want your family to be Eucharistic centered instead of community centered, you attend a Eucharistic centered parish.

Anyway, my two cents.
[/quote]

You said it better than me.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...