Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

I do not go to the closest parish out here at school (Although I am not a member there because I am not there often enough on weekends) because they are very orthodox and Eucharist centered. They have such amazing and holy priests, and understand the importance of the sacraments and the Mass that just amazes me everytime I am there. I have even considered moving back out here when I drop out, just so I can go to this parish. lol
Kinda silly though considering the neighborhood is WAAAAY out of my price range...

Dust's Sister
Posted

^ well hey, whenever I DO move out on my own, it will be CLOSE to the Parish I actually attend.. lol

Posted

I have heard stories about some dioceses being very strict about which parish you attend. I an fortunate here in that we are not that strict. I have never felt comfortable at eh parish closest to my home a 5 minute drive. So attend a much more active parish with more that 70 ministries that is 7 minutes from my house. That said especially during football season I find I am a roamin' Catholic hitting the closest mass.

missionseeker
Posted

At my old parish things were bad. REALLY bad. The members were... I don't know how to dedscribe them. It was almost like Indian castes. There were a few wealthy ones and everyone else was you know,... looked down on is probably the nicest thing to say. They were very condescending (which is a personal pet peeve I can't STAND it.) I don't know, it was BAD Basically I was not liked. My family was not liked. we were not like them (for which I thank God, if that's not too mean)

The preist had his own problems.

Any way since we live in an extremely anti Catholic and rural place we go to church over an hour away.

BUT I love it there. And they like me. (:scream: ) I hadn't been liked in years by people at church. I needed the people at this parish more than they will ever know, probably more than I will ever know. It has it its...quirks, but there I feel like God is there and not like He has been driven out.

[quote name='Mercy me' post='967750' date='May 1 2006, 08:57 PM']
I have heard stories about some dioceses being very strict about which parish you attend. I an fortunate here in that we are not that strict. I have never felt comfortable at eh parish closest to my home a 5 minute drive. So attend a much more active parish with more that 70 ministries that is 7 minutes from my house. That said especially during football season I find I am a roamin' Catholic hitting the closest mass.
[/quote]

you lucky dog

Paladin D
Posted

My family lives inbetween two parishes, 15 minute drive in either direction. We were attending one for a couple years, but due to jealously, church politics, lack of cooperation, and lack of spiritual support, we made the hard decision to leave.

We now attend the other parish that is the same distance away, only in the other direction; but we are playing it safe, and not getting really involved. It's sad, but my family was hurt big time. We're still friends with some people of our previous parish, but it's unfortunate how Catholics can treat other Catholics in their own parish.

missionseeker
Posted

echo that

Paladin D
Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' post='967857' date='May 1 2006, 11:22 PM']
echo that
[/quote]

On top of that, we were all heavily involved with the parish. Altar serving, choir, Justice & Peace, poor committee, etc. Now they have to make due because they screwed us over.

missionseeker
Posted

my mother was D.R.E. we were alter servers (there weren't many kids)
my mother was the only adult who was nice to some kids. We were in a Latin choir

Proud2BCatholic139
Posted

Well, I have been going to St. Agnus lately.

I love it there. It is really nice.

I guess, I need change once in a while.

Posted

So basically, you people have all decided to leave or not attend a certain parish because it does not provide the Spiritual graces you have been looking for. Isn't it a Catholic Church? What, the gates of hell have prevailed against that particular Parish? Do they not have the Sacraments? Is the Eucharist less blessed? Is the Holy Water diluted? The Church is run or controlled by the democratic vote of attendance? Aren't you doing the same thing as other people who attend a certain Mass because of the music, choir, particular priest?

You people just think your reasons are better, but you do the same thing. Justify it or try to logic it away, but you're doing the same thing I'm doing. I just haven't found a new 'parish' that fulfills my spiritual needs.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

My parish in the last 50 years has had more than its share of less than stellar priests. But in general the parishoners figured it was our parish, not the priests', and we stayed in spite our disagreements. Our families are there, our roots are there, the Eucharist is there. Its our church, and not the private domain of any one person. We stay.
Times are a changing, however. When the jobs started going, the people did as well. We are an inner city parish and our population is rapidly dying off, so we have merged with another church. People no longer seem to have the "my church" mentality and I haven't yet decided if its a good thing or a bad thing. There[i] is[/i] something to be said for tenacity.

Paladin D
Posted

[quote name='jasJis' post='968053' date='May 2 2006, 06:22 AM']
So basically, you people have all decided to leave or not attend a certain parish because it does not provide the Spiritual graces you have been looking for. Isn't it a Catholic Church? What, the gates of hell have prevailed against that particular Parish? Do they not have the Sacraments? Is the Eucharist less blessed? Is the Holy Water diluted? The Church is run or controlled by the democratic vote of attendance? Aren't you doing the same thing as other people who attend a certain Mass because of the music, choir, particular priest?

You people just think your reasons are better, but you do the same thing. Justify it or try to logic it away, but you're doing the same thing I'm doing. I just haven't found a new 'parish' that fulfills my spiritual needs.
[/quote]

When I mean "lack of spiritual support", I'm implying that the current priest doesn't seem to care that much about an individual's personal needs (in other words, not a very personal priest). He's a great priest, but he is used to teaching at a university more than running a parish.

I was not implying that the parish lacked any graces, or that it was inferior in that department; however, the congregation was the problem. It's one thing if you're a parishoner who just goes to mass, talk to a few people, and leave. It's a whole other story when you're heavily involved in parish duties, because some members of the parish have their own agendas, gossip and jealously become more apparent, and some deliberately make it difficult for you, and the lack of cooperation when it came to activities within the church.

The lack of spiritual support wasn't the main reason, it was the congregation.

scardella
Posted

I'm not registered with a parish. (shock! horror!) For daily mass, I go to the most convenient, or else I couldn't go at all. My work precludes me from going to morning mass, so I go in the evenings, sometimes at a MWF 6pm parish, tues 5:30pm at another, and thurs 5:30pm elsewhere. I do usually go to the same mass on sat and sun at the same place most of the time. (I also help w/ the CYO there; it's my parents' parish.) I just don't feel like I should become a parishoner at one parish until I feel some sense of long-term stability (at least in location). I plan on moving again in a couple years, so... until then, I remain sort of home parish-less.

I guess it would help if my friends who also go to daily mass would all be at one parish...

Sojourner
Posted

I haven't attended Mass at the parish I'm registered in for about a year. There were a number of reasons for that decision. My rule of thumb in general is that it's best to stick it out -- as cmom said, there IS something to be said for tenacity. However, in this particular situation, looking at the totality of the circumstances, the best move for me was to find a different parish. It wasn't that my spiritual needs were not being met -- that can happen at any parish. There were other extraneous factors that made it a better decision for me to worship elsewhere.

Posted

[quote name='jasJis' post='968053' date='May 2 2006, 04:22 AM']
So basically, you people have all decided to leave or not attend a certain parish because it does not provide the Spiritual graces you have been looking for. Isn't it a Catholic Church? What, the gates of hell have prevailed against that particular Parish? Do they not have the Sacraments? Is the Eucharist less blessed? Is the Holy Water diluted? The Church is run or controlled by the democratic vote of attendance? Aren't you doing the same thing as other people who attend a certain Mass because of the music, choir, particular priest?[/quote]
Every Catholic church has the sacraments, which is sufficient for anyone, regardless of the human politics or lack of human leadership.

[quote]You people just think your reasons are better, but you do the same thing. Justify it or try to logic it away, but you're doing the same thing I'm doing. I just haven't found a new 'parish' that fulfills my spiritual needs.
[/quote]
Not at all. If I didn't have the option of attending a few different parishes within a few miles, I definitely wouldn't leave my parish, no matter how bad it was. I would try until it was futile to influence it for the good. If it was hopeless, I would most likely be minimally involved, but would never leave the sacraments, and especially wouldn't deny my family the sacraments.

Sounds like you are trying to justify your actions, but there is no excuse in the world that would justify you denying yourself and your family the sacraments. Especially over whatever human flaws that your diocese may have.

missionarybelle
Posted

We moved to our area 12 years ago and started going to the Chruch my parents met at. So even when we moved about 15 minutes away and are MUCH closer to a different church, we stayed at the church we've been going to for 12 years because we love it, we love the people and we love the priests.
My parish is my second home

CatholicCity*WOP*
Posted

I will attend A parish that will teach Orthodoxy..If that takes me 50 miles to a church then so be it. I am tired of being fed "Feel Good Catholicism"

Posted

[quote name='CatholicCity*WOP*' post='968242' date='May 2 2006, 07:55 AM']
I will attend A parish that will teach Orthodoxy..If that takes me 50 miles to a church then so be it. I am tired of being fed "Feel Good Catholicism"
[/quote]I will attend a parish that practices Christianity. I am tired of being fed "Do as I say, not as I do" Christianity.

missionseeker
Posted

You know that thing about a den of vipers?

That was my old church. (described by someone NOT in the parish, someone new to the town who no longer goes to any church at all)

Over 100 people from that place have left the Church altogether. That's about half the members. It went from 150 families to about 80 families in about three years.

The problem is the congregation. They do not really act Christian. If yor presence makes someone sin (which yeah, they absolutely HATED us) shouldn't you leave? So we did.

I dread going there in two weeks, please pray that I can do it.

Posted

[quote name='jasJis' post='968300' date='May 2 2006, 09:32 AM'] I will attend a parish that practices Christianity. I am tired of being fed "Do as I say, not as I do" Christianity. [/quote]

Only two people could claim otherwise.

One's God. The other's His mother.

Otherwise, someone's gonna do something against what they say. Best option is when they actually admit it.


[quote name='jasJis' post='968053' date='May 2 2006, 05:22 AM'] So basically, you people have all decided to leave or not attend a certain parish because it does not provide the Spiritual graces you have been looking for. Isn't it a Catholic Church? What, the gates of hell have prevailed against that particular Parish? Do they not have the Sacraments? Is the Eucharist less blessed? Is the Holy Water diluted? The Church is run or controlled by the democratic vote of attendance? Aren't you doing the same thing as other people who attend a certain Mass because of the music, choir, particular priest?

You people just think your reasons are better, but you do the same thing. Justify it or try to logic it away, but you're doing the same thing I'm doing. I just haven't found a new 'parish' that fulfills my spiritual needs. [/quote]

Am I going to learn heresy?

Am I going to want to cry all the time?

Am I never going to be able to receive the grace from the Most Blessed Sacrament because I cannot receive Holy Communion because I am not prepared because I have been distracted all Mass by abuses? (Yes, if you are not properly disposed for Holy Communion or do not receive you will not receive the same grace and this happens if the parish makes it particularly difficult to keep your heart and mind in Mass and not elsewhere).

Am I going to be asked to do things that are wrong? Will I be forced into disobedience?

Will I cause scandal by my own actions in accord with what is asked and not what is wanted?

Am I going to actually be going to a valid Mass?

Will my kids receive good education?

Will my spritual needs as far as education be met?

Will I ever be spiritually fulfilled (through Truth first, through the most sacred Liturgy next)?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...