Jaime Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 Far too many times I've seen a blatant disrespect from Catholics towards priests, bishops and cardinals. While we are allowed to be critical of our church leaders, it is mandated by canon law to ALWAYS do so with respect and reverence to the office they hold. This has been ignored by some on this forum. From the Code of Canon Law [quote]Can. 212 §1. Conscious of their own responsibility, the Christian faithful are bound to follow with Christian obedience those things which the sacred pastors, inasmuch as they represent Christ, declare as teachers of the faith or establish as rulers of the Church. §2. The Christian faithful are free to make known to the pastors of the Church their needs, especially spiritual ones, and their desires. §3. According to the knowledge, competence, and prestige which they possess, they have the right and even at times the duty to manifest to the sacred pastors their opinion on matters which pertain to the good of the Church and to make their opinion known to the rest of the Christian faithful, without prejudice to the integrity of faith and morals, with reverence toward their pastors, and attentive to common advantage and the dignity of persons.[/quote] also [quote]Can. 1373 A person who publicly incites among subjects animosities or hatred against the Apostolic See or an ordinary because of some act of power or ecclesiastical ministry or provokes subjects to disobey them is to be punished by an interdict or other just penalties.[/quote] Can we voice our opinions? Yes and sometimes we are required to. But to do so in an insulting and disrespectful way to an ordinary scandalizes the faithful and gives an improper example to others. And quite frankly I'm sick of seeing it on public forums. dUSt has put the new "rephorumation" in place. I simply wanted to add that some of the rules are not simply his but the Church's. And we are required to follow them. This has been placed in Open Mic because there should be no debate on this subject. However I am taking bets on how quickly it will move to the debate table and eventually be a closed topic.
prose Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 No debate from me. I have been thinking this for a very long time. I have a hard time understanding blatant disrespect for bishops cardinals, even priests. Especially posting their names on chat forums to make sure that others, who may not have heard of them, are aware of how terrible people think they are. It is shameful to not only the people being mocked, but to us as Catholics who should be supporting our priests, bishops, and cardinals as representatives of the Church. Are some officials wrong in their thoughts and practice? Maybe. But we should not be condemning them publiclyy. So, hot stuff, absolutely no debate from me, only support, and one of these to whoever chooses to debate you :
morostheos Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 :applause: Thank you for posting this hot stuff! <-- These guys always deserve our respect!
Sojourner Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 I third the thanks for posting. This has definitely been bothering me lately.
Didacus Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 Make it four-folds for the post. Reverence should always be paid to priests and all clergy - no matter who, how old or when. For myself, I would not even go as far as openly disagree with members of the clergy; I would wait a for a proper moment to obtain clarification.
jasJis Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 Does this apply to comments about priests who have polka Masses, hand holding during the Our Father, sand in the holy water font, allow people on the altar during consecration, okaying the use of condoms, publically looks forward to women priests, publically and purposefully ignores civil law such as reporting clerical sex abuse, purposefully ignores USCCB rules and guidelines in addressing sexual abuse, preists who have glass chalices, etc.? What are the limits? Does this apply to non-Catholics voicing their opinions? I remember Bro Adam and dUSt having a disagreement about this... (Dang. Where's that pot stirring smilie.)
OLAM Dad Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 I agree...and disagree with what's been said. I agree that the office MUST ALWAYS be treated with the respect that it is due. otoh, I don't believe that means that criticising the actions of those who hold these offices is forbidden or wrong. Priest, Bishops, et al. have sacred responsibilities to us, their flock, and to God. The criticism must be respectful, however. With that said, the rules here at Phatmass are clear. [quote]Effective immediately, any negative criticism of the current Magisterium will result in deletion, and a warning from the moderators. [/quote] [quote name='jasJis' post='969641' date='May 3 2006, 11:21 AM'] (Dang. Where's that pot stirring smilie.) [/quote] [img]http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y19/materdei/stirthepot.gif[/img]
Jaime Posted May 3, 2006 Author Posted May 3, 2006 But one can take that (and do) as not being critical of the Magisterium as a whole. Some believe they have free reign to be disrespectful to individual priests, bishops and cardinals.
Brother Adam Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 Always know your place when you are speaking to "Father..." "Bishop..." or "Cardinal..." In other words, if they are "Father..." think about that title and what it means you are in relation to them. That is not to say one should condone sin or abuse.
Lil Red Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='969666' date='May 3 2006, 11:39 AM']Always know your place when you are speaking to "Father..." "Bishop..." or "Cardinal..." In other words, if they are "Father..." think about that title and what it means you are in relation to them. That is not to say one should condone sin or abuse.[/quote]exactly!
Era Might Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 I completely understand the URGE to rail on Bishops, believe me. I've been known to do it in my time. But this passage from Pope Leo XIII's "Sapientiae Christianae" has really held my tongue in check the last few years, and really convicted me against setting myself up as a superior of Bishops: [quote]Now, the administration of Christian affairs immediately under the Roman Pontiff appertains to the bishops, who, although they attain not to the summit of pontifical power, are nevertheless truly princes in the ecclesiastical hierarchy; and as each one of them administers a particular church, they are "as master-workers...in the spiritual edifice," and they have members of the clergy to share their duties and carry out their decisions. Every one has to regulate his mode of conduct according to this constitution of the Church, which it is not in the power of any man to change. Consequently, just as in the exercise of their episcopal authority the bishops ought to be united with the apostolic see so should the members of the clergy and the laity live in close union with their bishops. [b]Among the prelates, indeed, one or other there may be affording scope to criticism either in regard to personal conduct or in reference to opinions by him entertained about points of doctrine; but no private person may arrogate to himself the office of judge which Christ our Lord has bestowed on that one alone whom He placed in charge of His lambs and of His sheep[/b]. Let every one bear in mind that most wise teaching of Gregory the Great: "Subjects should be admonished not rashly to judge their prelates, even if they chance to see them acting in a blameworthy manner, lest, justly reproving what is wrong, they be led by pride into greater wrong. They are to be warned against the danger of setting themselves up in audacious opposition to the superiors whose shortcomings they may notice. [b]Should, therefore, the superiors really have committed grievous sins, their inferiors, penetrated with the fear of God, ought not to refuse them respectful submission. The actions of superiors should not be smitten by the sword of the word, even when they are rightly judged to have deserved censure[/b]."[/quote]
Didacus Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='969666' date='May 3 2006, 10:39 AM'] Always know your place when you are speaking to "Father..." "Bishop..." or "Cardinal..." In other words, if they are "Father..." think about that title and what it means you are in relation to them. That is not to say one should condone sin or abuse. [/quote] Very well said Bro, and that is precisely my point of view.
Sojourner Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='969666' date='May 3 2006, 12:39 PM'] Always know your place when you are speaking to "Father..." "Bishop..." or "Cardinal..." In other words, if they are "Father..." think about that title and what it means you are in relation to them. That is not to say one should condone sin or abuse. [/quote] [quote name='Era Might' post='969724' date='May 3 2006, 01:06 PM'] I completely understand the URGE to rail on Bishops, believe me. I've been known to do it in my time. But this passage from Pope Leo XIII's "Sapientiae Christianae" has really held my tongue in check the last few years, and really convicted me against setting myself up as a superior of Bishops: [/quote] Good posts, both of you. Can this be pinned, by the way? I think this is important.
jasJis Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 (edited) [img]http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y19/materdei/stirthepot.gif[/img] I'm still not sure what is accepted criticism or what isn't. I am definitely no Mahoney fan in particular. Posts have been made about Clergy who okay condoms for couples with a spouse that has aids, clergy who have liturgical dance, clergy who ignore the USCCB policies regarding the scandals, etc. Then again, I still have a ways to go on my warning level. [img]http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y19/materdei/stirthepot.gif[/img] Can I use 'idjut' in a loving manner? [quote]Should, therefore, the superiors really have committed grievous sins, their inferiors, penetrated with the fear of God, ought not to refuse them respectful submission. The actions of superiors should not be smitten by the sword of the word, even when they are rightly judged to have deserved censure."[/quote]Does this mean our superiors in Government as well? [img]http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y19/materdei/stirthepot.gif[/img] Can I use ding dong as a loving and respectful term? Edited May 3, 2006 by jasJis
Jaime Posted May 3, 2006 Author Posted May 3, 2006 I would never ever use ding dong in reference to a member of the ordinary
cappie Posted May 3, 2006 Posted May 3, 2006 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='969804' date='May 4 2006, 04:38 AM'] Whenever cappie comes on, I always stand up... [/quote] It should apply to everyone remember canon 219: No one may unlawfully harm the good reputation which a person enjoys, or violate the right of every person to protect his or her privacy The apostle St. Paul tells us that we must communicate the truth in charity, and charity in the truth. What he means is that in the defense of the truth, we must be very careful to be charitable with people. We must learn indeed, not to answer evil with evil, but to overcome evil with good.
jiyoung Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 I was once sort of told off by a (very orthodox Carmelite) sister for my comments on Cardinal Mahony, saying that I was speaking uncharitably. It's hard to hold my tongue, but it's not impossible...I'm trying to pound it into my head that I should be praying for these clergy, and not just criticizing them. So...yeah. I don't think it's wrong to necessarily bring attention to what they've been doing, but if we don't intend to pray for them, and if we do intend to insult them, then we just need to shut up and pray
Recommended Posts