Socrates Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 Yes, one should hold the offices of priest, bishop, and cardinal in respect. However, it is perfectly acceptable to point out the errors and misdeeds of clergy if these are truthful and done in charity for the purpose of correction. I suspect what this thread is largely about is Cardinal Mahoney. In immigration debates, we are told by some that we must follow the words of Cardinal Mahoney (a Cardinal not known for his faithfulness to Catholic Truth). When others disagree with his stance, they are accused of going against the Church. Then when "conservatives" point out that Cardinal Mahoney has hardly been a model of faithfulness and orthodoxy in other matters (and therefore we need not blindly follow his word on everything), we are accused of disrespect. While there should be respect for clergy, this should not be used as a tool to silence opposition to a particular political ideology. And one can find priests, bishops, and even Cardinals that disagree with the Church on any moral and dogmatic stance. It is not disrespectful to point out (in charity) that they are wrong. If the laity fails to speak out on serious problems involving the clergy, this allows these problems to fester and grow.
Jaime Posted May 4, 2006 Author Posted May 4, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Socrates' post='970176' date='May 3 2006, 06:28 PM'] Yes, one should hold the offices of priest, bishop, and cardinal in respect. However, it is perfectly acceptable to point out the errors and misdeeds of clergy if these are truthful and done in charity for the purpose of correction. I suspect what this thread is largely about is Cardinal Mahoney. In immigration debates, we are told by some that we must follow the words of Cardinal Mahoney (a Cardinal not known for his faithfulness to Catholic Truth). When others disagree with his stance, they are accused of going against the Church. Then when "conservatives" point out that Cardinal Mahoney has hardly been a model of faithfulness and orthodoxy in other matters (and therefore we need not blindly follow his word on everything), we are accused of disrespect. While there should be respect for clergy, this should not be used as a tool to silence opposition to a particular political ideology. And one can find priests, bishops, and even Cardinals that disagree with the Church on any moral and dogmatic stance. It is not disrespectful to point out (in charity) that they are wrong. If the laity fails to speak out on serious problems involving the clergy, this allows these problems to fester and grow. [/quote] One can have criticisms of Mahoney's liturgy and be respectful but when a cardinal is compared to satan and its inferred that the cardinal supports the sex slave trade, that's not respectful. It scandalizes the faithful and its a bad example and DIRECTLY violates canon law! Edited May 4, 2006 by jaime
Sojourner Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 [quote name='Socrates']However, it is perfectly acceptable to point out the errors and misdeeds of clergy if these are truthful and done in charity for the purpose of correction.[/quote] How can comments made on a public internet forum not made directly to the person in question be done for the purpose of correction? Isn't the point of correction to address concerns directly to a person believed to be in error? Otherwise, how do they profit from the correction?
OLAM Dad Posted May 4, 2006 Posted May 4, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' post='970370' date='May 3 2006, 09:28 PM'] How can comments made on a public internet forum not made directly to the person in question be done for the purpose of correction? Isn't the point of correction to address concerns directly to a person believed to be in error? Otherwise, how do they profit from the correction? [/quote] We don't directly address clergy here but we do talk about it and whether it would be appropriate or not in certain circumstances. We also point out what ought not be done by shining a light on those who are setting a bad example. These are valid activities, wouldn't you agree?
Sojourner Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 [quote name='OLAM Dad' post='970392' date='May 3 2006, 10:39 PM'] We don't directly address clergy here but we do talk about it and whether it would be appropriate or not in certain circumstances. We also point out what ought not be done by shining a light on those who are setting a bad example. These are valid activities, wouldn't you agree? [/quote] I think it's all well and good to address how one should or should not behave in certain circumstances. However, my personal opinion is that the use of "bad examples" from the clergy is not a valid activity, for a number of reasons. First and foremost, I think it's disrespectful. As others have noted, it creates an atmosphere in which it's all too easy to set ourselves in a position of judgement over those in authority over us. I think it encourages a critical, antagonistic spirit. I spent many, many years hearing my father nit-pick our church experience in the car on the way home, and as a result I've spent many, many years working through having a critical, nit-picky attitude toward church. Actually, this is one area in which being a baby Catholic is helpful -- I don't know all the details of how things should work. As long as the major things are in the right place, I can still worship without qualms. While I think it's important to address liturgical abuses, and I think a phorum such as this is a fine place to address questions people may have about things they've witnessed in Mass, it doesn't sit well with me to mock clergy, or to question their catholicity. I see stuff like this often on phatmass. To the best of my knowledge (and please correct me if I'm wrong) the Catechism is able to communicate quite a bit about right and wrong behaviors without once using a "bad example" from a member of the clergy as guidance. Would that we could do the same here.
dUSt Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 It is okay to discuss these issues and speak in general terms, but the line is crossed when we speak negatively towards the religious, especially when we name a specific person. It will not be tolerated, and the moderators have been given strict instructions to stop this behavior. Everyone, not just the mods, have the responsibility to "report" this negative criticism by using the "report" button. This, along with a general lack of charity and welcoming atmosphere, is the main reason why The Rephorumation is taking place. This trend has to stop before we continue with plans to grow.
Socrates Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' post='971778' date='May 4 2006, 08:22 PM'] I think it's all well and good to address how one should or should not behave in certain circumstances. However, my personal opinion is that the use of "bad examples" from the clergy is not a valid activity, for a number of reasons. First and foremost, I think it's disrespectful. As others have noted, it creates an atmosphere in which it's all too easy to set ourselves in a position of judgement over those in authority over us. I think it encourages a critical, antagonistic spirit. I spent many, many years hearing my father nit-pick our church experience in the car on the way home, and as a result I've spent many, many years working through having a critical, nit-picky attitude toward church. Actually, this is one area in which being a baby Catholic is helpful -- I don't know all the details of how things should work. As long as the major things are in the right place, I can still worship without qualms. While I think it's important to address liturgical abuses, and I think a phorum such as this is a fine place to address questions people may have about things they've witnessed in Mass, it doesn't sit well with me to mock clergy, or to question their catholicity. I see stuff like this often on phatmass. To the best of my knowledge (and please correct me if I'm wrong) the Catechism is able to communicate quite a bit about right and wrong behaviors without once using a "bad example" from a member of the clergy as guidance. Would that we could do the same here. [/quote] When clergy commit or help perpetuate serious evils which effect the public and the common good of the Church, it is often necessary that these be addressed publicly in order that they may be brought to attention and stopped. As a journalist, you should be able to appreciate this. For instance, the "conservative" Catholic press had been reporting on the sexual abuse crisis in the Church, and its cover-up by homosexual-friendly liberal bishops, and the homosexual and heterodox atmosphere permeating much of the seminaries, long before the "mainstream" press got a hold of these stories. If such things were brought to attention and "nipped in the bud" early on, how much damage to the Church could have been averted? It is necesarry to have a laity informed on such issues. Simply taking a "hear no evil, see no evil, speak no evil" attitude with regards to the clergy allows clerical problems to fester hidden and become huge public problems. The truth should not be glossed over in the name of a false "piety." (And for specific issues to be addressed, names and places often have to be mentioned. Talking in vague terms will not get the guilty punished.)
Sojourner Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' post='972751' date='May 5 2006, 07:24 PM'] When clergy commit or help perpetuate serious evils which effect the public and the common good of the Church, it is often necessary that these be addressed publicly in order that they may be brought to attention and stopped. As a journalist, you should be able to appreciate this. For instance, the "conservative" Catholic press had been reporting on the sexual abuse crisis in the Church, and its cover-up by homosexual-friendly liberal bishops, and the homosexual and heterodox atmosphere permeating much of the seminaries, long before the "mainstream" press got a hold of these stories. If such things were brought to attention and "nipped in the bud" early on, how much damage to the Church could have been averted? It is necesarry to have a laity informed on such issues. Simply taking a "hear no evil, see no evil, speak no evil" attitude with regards to the clergy allows clerical problems to fester hidden and become huge public problems. The truth should not be glossed over in the name of a false "piety." (And for specific issues to be addressed, names and places often have to be mentioned. Talking in vague terms will not get the guilty punished.) [/quote] It is true that I support an informed laity. And, I am all about getting the guilty punished. But I'm also a firm believer in 1) respecting authority and 2) innocence until proof of guilt. I also believe that there are channels set in place through which disciplinary action/correction of clergy is to be taken, and that those channels don't include phatmass. I think there is a responsibility on the part of the laity to keep leaders accountable, but that must always be done with humility and respect. That has been, sadly, lacking in a large percentage of comments I've seen of late on phatmass. I also don't harbor any illusions about the people on phatmass being "in the know" enough about most things posted about clergy to be in a position of being able to call out the wrongdoing of their superiors. As a journalist who write about the law, not only do I respect the right of people to know information, but I also have a high degree of respect for the ideals of justice. We are not the ones who've been chosen to be finders of fact in regards to the world's clergy. If you want to stand in judgement over members of the clergy, there are proper channels to do so. Otherwise, it's just gossip.
dUSt Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' post='972751' date='May 5 2006, 05:24 PM'] When clergy commit or help perpetuate serious evils which effect the public and the common good of the Church, it is often necessary that these be addressed publicly in order that they may be brought to attention and stopped. As a journalist, you should be able to appreciate this. For instance, the "conservative" Catholic press had been reporting on the sexual abuse crisis in the Church, and its cover-up by homosexual-friendly liberal bishops, and the homosexual and heterodox atmosphere permeating much of the seminaries, long before the "mainstream" press got a hold of these stories. If such things were brought to attention and "nipped in the bud" early on, how much damage to the Church could have been averted? It is necesarry to have a laity informed on such issues. Simply taking a "hear no evil, see no evil, speak no evil" attitude with regards to the clergy allows clerical problems to fester hidden and become huge public problems. The truth should not be glossed over in the name of a false "piety." (And for specific issues to be addressed, names and places often have to be mentioned. Talking in vague terms will not get the guilty punished.) [/quote] This is not a debate. Religious will not be negatively criticized on this website. Period. There are ways to discuss important issues such as abuses, etc without slandering our priests and bishops. I am not at ALL discouraging anyone to take action if they have knowledge of a priest or bishop failing his duty--you SHOULD do something about it (follow the instructions in Redemptionis Sacramentum). What I am saying is phatmass is not the outlet for this. Again, cased closed.
Jaime Posted July 9, 2008 Author Posted July 9, 2008 I think a few people need to be reminded of this. Especially of dUSt's last post.
Recommended Posts