Lil Red Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 [url="http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/ap/health/3878589.html"]Source here[/url] Pills Rendering Menstrual Period Optional By LINDA A. JOHNSON Associated Press Writer © 2006 The Associated Press TRENTON, N.J. — For young women with a world of choices, even that monthly curse, the menstrual period, is optional. Thanks to birth control pills and other hormonal contraceptives, a growing number of women are taking the path chosen by 22-year-old Stephanie Sardinha. She hasn't had a period since she was 17. "It's really one of the best things I've ever done," she says. A college student and retail worker in Lisbon Falls, Maine, Sardinha uses Nuvaring, a vaginal contraceptive ring. After the hormones run out in three weeks, she replaces the ring right away instead of following instructions to leave the ring out for a week to allow bleeding. She says it has been great for her marriage, preventing monthly crankiness and improving her sex life. "I would never go back," said Sardinha, who got the idea from her aunt, a nurse practitioner. Using the pill or other contraceptives to block periods is becoming more popular, particularly among young women and those entering menopause, doctors say. "I have a ton of young girls in college who are doing this," says Dr. Mindy Wiser-Estin, a gynecologist in Little Silver, N.J., who did it herself for years. "There's no reason you need a period." Such medical jury-rigging soon will be unnecessary. Already, the Seasonale birth control pill limits periods to four a year. The first continuous-use birth control pill, Lybrel, likely will soon be on the U.S. market and drug companies are lining up other ways to limit or eliminate the period. Most doctors say they don't think suppressing menstruation is riskier than regular long-term birth control use, and one survey found a majority have prescribed contraception to prevent periods. Women have been using the pill for nearly half a century without significant problems, but some doctors want more research on long-term use. The new methods should be popular. A non-scientific Web survey for the Association of Reproductive Health Professionals found at least two-thirds of respondents are bothered by fatigue, heavy bleeding, "really bad cramps" and even anger. Nearly half said they would like to have no period at all or decide when to have one. For some women, periods can cause debilitating pain and more serious problems. Two recent national surveys found about 1 in 5 women have used oral contraceptives to stop or skip their period. "If you're choosing contraception, then there's not a lot of point to having periods," says Dr. Leslie Miller, a University of Washington-Seattle researcher and associate professor of obstetrics and gynecology whose Web site, noperiod.com, explains the option. She points out women on hormonal contraception don't have real periods anyway, just withdrawal bleeding during the break from the hormone progestin. According to Miller, modern women endure up to nine times more periods than their great-grandmothers, who began menstruating later, married young and naturally suppressed periods for years while they were pregnant or breast-feeding. Today's women may have about 450 periods. Still, surveys also show most women consider monthly periods normal. Small wonder: Girls learn early on that menstruation is a sign of fertility and femininity, making its onset an eagerly awaited rite of passage. The period is "way over-romanticized," says Linda Gordon, a New York University professor specializing in women's history and the history of sexuality. "It doesn't take long for women to go from being excited about having a period to feeling it's a pain in the neck," said Gordon, author of "The Moral Property of Women: A History of Birth Control Politics in America." She says caution is needed because there's not enough data on long-term consequences of using hormones continuously. Gordon notes menopausal women for years were told that hormone drugs would keep them young _ until research uncovered unexpected risks. "People should proceed very cautiously," she says. Today's birth control pills contain far less estrogen and progestin than those two generations ago, but still increase the risk of heart attack, stroke and blood clots. The pill should not be used by women who have had those conditions, unexplained vaginal bleeding or certain cancers, or if they are smokers over 35. But there are benefits from taking oral contraceptives too, such as a lower risk of ovarian and endometrial cancer, osteoporosis and pelvic inflammatory disease. And forgoing periods means no premenstrual syndrome and a lower risk of anemia and migraines, says Dr. Sheldon Segal, co-author of "Is Menstruation Obsolete?" Segal has been involved in research for several contraceptives. Almost since the first pill arrived in 1960, women have manipulated birth control to skip periods for events such as a wedding, vacation or sports competition. Female doctors and nurses were among the first to block menstruation long-term to suit their schedules, said Susan Wysocki, head of the National Association of Nurse Practitioners in Women's Health. "They were then more comfortable recommending it to their patients," said Wysocki, who uses a vaginal ring to prevent menstruation. The idea gained momentum after Barr Pharmaceuticals launched Seasonale in November 2003. It's a standard birth control pill taken for 12 weeks, with a break for withdrawal bleeding every three months. Amid wide acceptance by doctors, sales shot up 62 percent last year, to $110 million. Publicity for Seasonale made women wonder, if just four periods a year are OK, why have any at all? Users of Pfizer Inc.'s Depo-Provera, a progestin-only contraceptive shot lasting three months, usually are period-free after a year or two. There's now a generic version, but the drug can thin bones. And many women have been getting extra prescriptions so they could continuously stay on birth control pills, the Ortho Evra patch or the vaginal ring, rather than bleeding every fourth week. That schedule was set by the original birth control designers to mimic normal menstrual cycles. But the extra prescriptions have led to insurance company hassles. "What Seasonale did is get rid of that nuisance," says Dr. Peter McGovern of University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey. New extended-cycle contraceptives will do the same. Wyeth is hoping by late June to get Food and Drug Administration approval to sell Lybrel, its low-dose, continuous birth control pill; approval also is pending in Canada and Europe. Also in June, FDA should decide whether to approve Implanon, a single-rod, three-year contraceptive implanted in the upper arm that maker Organon USA has been selling it in Europe for a decade. Berlex Inc. is developing its own birth control pill for menstrual suppression. Barr, aiming to be a leader in extended contraception, last November bought the maker of ParaGard, an intrauterine device that blocks periods in some women. Barr's new product Seasonique, a successor to Seasonale, likely will get federal approval at week's end. Dr. Patricia Sulak, who researches extended contraception at Texas A&M College of Medicine, applauds this new trend. The doses in standard pills are now so low, she said, that having seven days off them raises the risk of pregnancy. "This redesign is way overdue," she says. "It's going to be the demise of 21-7." ----------------- this is such a bad idea! having a period is natural! when will we stop deciding that our fertility isn't a 'problem' to get rid of?
Sojourner Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 I know lots of people who have done this. Frankly, even before I was aware of problems with contraception, the pill scared me. I don't like the idea of messing with my hormones. The body is so mysterious and the balance of the inner workings is so delicate -- messing with that is like playing with fire. And now that I have a better understanding of suffering and life and theological concepts connecting the two, it's even more scary, for entirely different reasons.
Lil Red Posted May 22, 2006 Author Posted May 22, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' post='987302' date='May 22 2006, 02:27 PM']I know lots of people who have done this. Frankly, even before I was aware of problems with contraception, the pill scared me. I don't like the idea of messing with my hormones. The body is so mysterious and the balance of the inner workings is so delicate -- messing with that is like playing with fire. And now that I have a better understanding of suffering and life and theological concepts connecting the two, it's even more scary, for entirely different reasons.[/quote]exactly! there is still so much we don't know about the human body, and how medicines affect the body why would you want to mess with your health like that? never mind the theological concepts
Sojourner Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 [quote name='Lil Red' post='987307' date='May 22 2006, 03:32 PM'] exactly! there is still so much we don't know about the human body, and how medicines affect the body why would you want to mess with your health like that? never mind the theological concepts [/quote] Yeah. My general practice is don't mess with it as long as it's working.
scardella Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 I don't have periods, except at the end of sentences. It's very frightening and unexpected, so I tend to use run-ons. Ok, that sounds like Hayden or something.... Work gets to me sometimes.
musturde Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 [quote name='scardella' post='987327' date='May 22 2006, 03:08 PM'] I don't have periods, except at the end of sentences. It's very frightening and unexpected, so I tend to use run-ons. [/quote] Haha.. [quote] Ok, that sounds like Hayden or something[size=9].... [/size] [/quote] Thats a lotta periods.
be_thou_my_vision Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 Hey, let's just not be women anymore! Let's get rid of everything that makes us beautiful as women and become a sexless society!!!! (totally sarcastic)
Myles Domini Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 This sounds scary. How does this impact fertility in the long term? Arent people afraid of making themselves infertile?
Lil Red Posted May 22, 2006 Author Posted May 22, 2006 [quote name='Myles Domini' post='987369' date='May 22 2006, 04:09 PM'] This sounds scary. How does this impact fertility in the long term? Arent people afraid of making themselves infertile? [/quote] exactly!
prose Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 I have a completely different concern. If people don't have periods, how are they going to know that they are pregnant? And if they find out later, does this mean the number of late term abortions increases?
Lil Red Posted May 22, 2006 Author Posted May 22, 2006 [quote name='prose' post='987418' date='May 22 2006, 04:58 PM']I have a completely different concern. If people don't have periods, how are they going to know that they are pregnant? And if they find out later, does this mean the number of late term abortions increases?[/quote]i didn't even think about that
Dreamweaver Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 Yeah, this is disgusting. To me, menstruation is a sign of a healthy, functioning body. Many female problems have symptoms that alter menstruation, how could you tell if you had a problem if it were completely suppressed? As Prose mentioned, pregnancy would be a concern too, birth control pills aren't 100% foolproof.
HopeToLive Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 [quote name='prose' post='987418' date='May 22 2006, 03:58 PM'] I have a completely different concern. If people don't have periods, how are they going to know that they are pregnant? And if they find out later, does this mean the number of late term abortions increases? [/quote] I think the way it works is that the hormones in the different forms of birth control stop you from ovulating. Like when you have a baby, your homones change and you start to produce milk, well, as long as you are nursing your baby, you won't have your period, because you aren't ovulating. Your body 'knows' that there is an infant already being cared for so your body naturally won't allow you to get pregant. It's God's way of designing us to naturally space births. The more I see how God set this up for us, to work so naturally and beautifully, the less I understand how people can see it all as a 'bother' or a 'problem' that has to be dealt with. Grrrrrrrrrr Ok i'll get off my soap box now.
jiyoung Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 This is just weird...I haven't been having periods for a while, but that's something that's a [i]problem[/i]. Not to say that I really miss it, but it sort of makes me feel really sterile and weird. It's part of being a woman! This isn't natural and it just sounds strange. I've heard it said that radical feminism seeks equality by stripping away everything that makes them women--basically, turn themselves into sterile versions of themselves, almost men. It seems like this is just another step in that direction...
prose Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 Well, the thing is, BC pills work three ways at once. They attempt to stop ovulation, but sometimes our bodies still pass an egg. So then the horomones also change the mucus so that sperm has a difficult time living in that environment, and finally make the uterus hostile to any eggs that may be fertilized. And you can still ovulate when you are breastfeeding. That is why it is so important to have your NFP charts up to date. Anyways, the point is that it is not impossible to get pregnant while on the pill. In fact, I have 4 friends who were all on the pill, and they all got pregnant. Chad and I teach NFP and do NFP talks all the time, and we always tell people that fertility is not a disease. It is a gift that needs to be respected.
Lil Red Posted May 22, 2006 Author Posted May 22, 2006 [quote name='jiyoung' post='987441' date='May 22 2006, 05:17 PM'] This is just weird...I haven't been having periods for a while, but that's something that's a [i]problem[/i]. Not to say that I really miss it, but it sort of makes me feel really sterile and weird. It's part of being a woman! This isn't natural and it just sounds strange. I've heard it said that radical feminism seeks equality by stripping away everything that makes them women--basically, turn themselves into sterile versions of themselves, almost men. It seems like this is just another step in that direction... [/quote] yeah, radical feminism makes women into men. or tries to at least [quote name='prose' post='987442' date='May 22 2006, 05:18 PM']Chad and I teach NFP and do NFP talks all the time, and we always tell people that fertility is not a disease. It is a gift that needs to be respected.[/quote]keep it up! you guys are an awesome witness!
avemaria40 Posted May 22, 2006 Posted May 22, 2006 I'm so sick of society's attempts to subjugate women! They think they are liberating us but how can they be when they are pitting us against everything that makes us women? Now in society, women are told that fertility is a "curse", that it's almost sinful to breastfeed in public (though dressing immodestly is not), that we should never have kids, and to turn ourselves into sex objects. Now, we're told to suppress our periods? That's despicable and I don't see anything healthy about it
Colleen Posted May 23, 2006 Posted May 23, 2006 [quote]"What Seasonale did is get rid of that nuisance," says Dr. Peter McGovern of University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey.[/quote] It's interesting that this is a man saying this.
philothea Posted May 23, 2006 Posted May 23, 2006 (((sigh))) Can't say I'm not envious of people who are ignorant enough to do this...
Ash Wednesday Posted May 23, 2006 Posted May 23, 2006 I can't say that I really love the ol' monthly experience, myself. But I'm not going to warp my hormones for life over it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now