Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Ash Wednesday
Posted
:huh:
Posted

Nevermind me. :) This is a touchy subject, and I shouldn't have responded at all. My, ah, troubles with menstruation have ruined my life.

Maybe after menopause I'll get a chance to try living...

Posted

I think I know where you are at, philothea. Its a touchy subject for me too. Supression was medically necessary for me at certain points in my life. However, completely supressing a woman's cycle "just because" is ridiculous.

Menopause at 22 was a pain in the arse. I rather enjoyed having a cycle again when it was over.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Sorry, my snarky comment was directed towards the "just because" people.

I was speaking from the experience of being a thyroid patient... needless to say my hormones are wacked enough. :(

Posted

No worries, Ash. Wacked hormones, I believe, are the bond which unites all women. :)

Posted

Amen, and amen.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Preach it, sister!!!

indescribable
Posted

so a friend of mine is out for a week of school because of pain from menstrating. along with cramps she gets blinding migranes. so now she only has 3 periods a year, and still has to be out of school/ commission those 3 weeks, but better than 12 weeks.

is that wrong?

benedictaj
Posted

OK, this I don't understand.

Maybe in a way I can, afterall, when your period comes at the wrong time, makes you mega grumpy and you feel like someone is plunging burning hot iron rods into your stomach... That isn't fun. But it IS a natural bodily function, and women have been coping for millennia! AND, it's related to our fertility! (duh ;) )

I guess we Catholics have an added edge to our understanding, with the theological view points... but even from a non-religious perspective... it still seems strange...

The Mater Dolorosa
Posted

The healthy and natural way to amend the problem is through exercise! Most women athletes do not menstrate. I've found it helps with the over all experience, less cramps and all the other fun stuff...MOOD SWINGS!! GIVE ME CHOCOLATE BEFORE I KILL SOMEONE! :maddest:

Posted

I envy women who have regular periods. I take the pill so that mine can be normal. I have a hormone disorder called PCOS (Polycystic Ovarian Syndrone) so the pill is part of my treatment. I'm all in favor of medicine being used to treat irregularity and periods that are so painful you can't function.

But to stop the periods 100% does seem strange to me - have doctors and scientists done enough research to really know how healthy it is to put a complete stop to the menstral cycle?

To consider our menstral cycle a "nuisaice" is a symptom of the age we live in.

Posted

[quote name='The Mater Dolorosa' post='988072' date='May 23 2006, 07:57 AM']
The healthy and natural way to amend the problem is through exercise! Most women athletes do not menstrate. I've found it helps with the over all experience, less cramps and all the other fun stuff...MOOD SWINGS!! GIVE ME CHOCOLATE BEFORE I KILL SOMEONE! :maddest:
[/quote]
:ninja:

uh... that doesn't affect fertility does it? :unsure:

Posted

[quote name='indescribable' post='987971' date='May 22 2006, 09:20 PM']
so a friend of mine is out for a week of school because of pain from menstrating. along with cramps she gets blinding migranes. so now she only has 3 periods a year, and still has to be out of school/ commission those 3 weeks, but better than 12 weeks.

is that wrong?
[/quote]


[quote name='KatS' post='988200' date='May 23 2006, 10:20 AM']
I envy women who have regular periods. I take the pill so that mine can be normal. I have a hormone disorder called PCOS (Polycystic Ovarian Syndrone) so the pill is part of my treatment. I'm all in favor of medicine being used to treat irregularity and periods that are so painful you can't function.

But to stop the periods 100% does seem strange to me - have doctors and scientists done enough research to really know how healthy it is to put a complete stop to the menstral cycle?

To consider our menstral cycle a "nuisaice" is a symptom of the age we live in.
[/quote]

Taking the pill for medical reasons is acceptable in the Church, but I heard recently that if this is so, that you should abstain from intercourse. I am not sure about that.

HOWEVER, make sure you ASK QUESTIONS. The pill is not necessarily the answer to PCOS. Don't just put a band-aid on a gushing wound. You might want to read this: [url="http://www.woomb.org/omrrca/vigil/fertilityDisorders.pdf"]http://www.woomb.org/omrrca/vigil/fertilityDisorders.pdf[/url]

Ash Wednesday
Posted

If a woman athlete is not menstruating, then to me that is a red flag that something may not be right. I used to think I was "athletic" when I was in a very strenuous exercise regimen and lost my cycle. It turned out that I didn't have enough body fat to have periods. So I doubt it's particularly healthy for a woman to be without periods even if they are active -- at least if they want kids.

I think exercise can reduce the severity of the side effects of menstruation, however.

Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='988406' date='May 23 2006, 12:40 PM']
If a woman athlete is not menstruating, then to me that is a red flag that something may not be right. I used to think I was "athletic" when I was in a very strenuous exercise regimen and lost my cycle. It turned out that I didn't have enough body fat to have periods. So I doubt it's particularly healthy for a woman to be without periods even if they are active -- at least if they want kids.

I think exercise can reduce the severity of the side effects of menstruation, however.
[/quote]
good points - agreed

Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='988406' date='May 23 2006, 01:40 PM']I think exercise can reduce the severity of the side effects of menstruation, however.
[/quote]Yes.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Isn't interesting that the people who insist on organic foods, and snarl at anyone who smokes or drinks will think nothing of stuffing hormones into their bodies to do the most un-natural things.
Don't mess with mother nature.

The Mater Dolorosa
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='988376' date='May 23 2006, 12:33 PM']
:ninja:

uh... that doesn't affect fertility does it? :unsure:
[/quote]


No, a very close friend of mine has 6 children :blink:

Posted

[quote]HOWEVER, make sure you ASK QUESTIONS. The pill is not necessarily the answer to PCOS. Don't just put a band-aid on a gushing wound. You might want to read this: [url="http://www.woomb.org/omrrca/vigil/fertilityDisorders.pdf"]http://www.woomb.org/omrrca/vigil/fertilityDisorders.pdf[/url][/quote]

Thank you very kindly! I clicked the link and it didn't work but I will try it later. :)

[quote]If a woman athlete is not menstruating, then to me that is a red flag that something may not be right. I used to think I was "athletic" when I was in a very strenuous exercise regimen and lost my cycle. It turned out that I didn't have enough body fat to have periods. [/quote]

Hope you're feeling better Ash. Yes, it is amazing that if your body senses something wrong it "switches off" your periods - a sign that you need to correct something if you want to have kids. In my case, I am too fat to have periods (because of insulin resistance).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...