Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm totally with Nathan on this one... He has a good perspective, a good heart, and is willing to embrace all truth as God's truth, however unpleasant it may be for Catholics....

I have to admit Thessalonian and St. Thomas More may mean well. But those of their persuasion have caused me tremendous scandal as a new Catholic.... It appears Vatican II has never been truly received by so many segments of the church (and I'm not talking clown masses and modernism here but JPII and Benedict XVI teaching).....

I have grown most tired and am becoming increasingly despondent about finding :weep: any widespread areas of lived Christian faith within American Catholicism outside of small subgroups..........

Catholic triumphalism is rearing its ugly head..... Anybody for a good heretic burning too?????

:weep: :weep: :weep:

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote name='HS_Dad' post='998888' date='Jun 6 2006, 07:15 PM']
I'm totally with Nathan on this one... He has a good perspective, a good heart, and is willing to embrace all truth as God's truth, however unpleasant it may be for Catholics....

I have to admit Thessalonian and St. Thomas More may mean well. But those of their persuasion have caused me tremendous scandal as a new Catholic.... It appears Vatican II has never been truly received by so many segments of the church (and I'm not talking clown masses and modernism here but JPII and Benedict XVI teaching).....

I have grown most tired and am becoming increasingly despondent about finding :weep: any widespread areas of lived Christian faith within American Catholicism outside of small subgroups..........

Catholic triumphalism is rearing its ugly head..... Anybody for a good heretic burning too?????

:weep: :weep: :weep:
[/quote]


It's not triumphantism. The KJV contains errors. Why do we need to use Protestant bibles which are affected by their traditions, when there are good Catholic versions available with the eye of Sacred Oral Tradition used to do the translating. It's not about whether Protestants are Christians or not. It's about recieving the authentic, non-corrupt word of God. You speak as if I wear Catholicism like I am some sort of Protestant hate monger. I am a long way from that. But where am I against Vatican II? Where does Vatican II say to use protestant Bibles? Apparently you have not read Dominus Iesus, because it is my impression that your post is dangerously close to indifferentism. The Church still teaches that there are heretics. The word did not go away. Now Protestants today are probably mostly material heretics rather than formal ones. But heretics, nevertheless.

[quote]I have grown most tired and am becoming increasingly despondent about finding any widespread areas of lived Christian faith within American Catholicism outside of small subgroups..........[/quote]

I find this incredibly insulting and suspect others on this board will as well. I suggest you retract it.You think I am not acting Christian because I say there are problems with the KJV and it shouldn't be used? What a load of carp.

[quote]But those of their persuasion have caused me tremendous scandal as a new Catholic.... [/quote]

Once again, it's scandalous to say the KJV had errors and should not be used. NONSENSE! If you are going to accuse me of scandalous behavior you had better have more to back it up than this bs. Retract please.

Catholicism is the fullness of the truth. Not by my doing. Nor am I in it by anything but the grace of God. I'll make no Apologies for openly declaring this to all, whether aethist, Protestant, or any other religion. I will find agreement where I can with protestants. But I will not make excuses for Catholicism or back down from upholding the purity of the faith as opposed to protestant religions which deny important doctrines such as the real presence of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ in the most holy Eucharist, of which it is said "unless you eat my flesh and drink my blood you shall not have life within you."

God bless

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

> It's not triumphantism.

Ok... you just seemed pugilistic when Nathan had such wonderful points about literary merit. I believe it is accepted Catholic understanding (read JPII) that members of the church committed less than Christ-like behavior in medieval times. Are you aware that it was illegal to read or own the bible in the contemporary idiom of English from about 1390 - until the rise of Anglicanism (this is NOT an apolegetic for Anglicanism)... Catholicism (as Christ prayed that "they may be one") is Christ's ideal.

> The KJV contains errors.

Sure, but Nathan dealt with the fact that it was going off of the Greek texts and not the Latin Vulgate translation of Greek texts and used the best scholarship of the time.... By being so anti the KJV and not admitting any literary merit to it, you appeared to be very close to the attitudes of those who killed Tyndale and not the JPII who grasped Billy Graham's thumb and told him "We are brothers."

Also, the NAB is perfect??

> Why do we need to use Protestant bibles which are affected by their traditions,
> when there are good Catholic versions available with the eye of Sacred Oral Tradition used to do the translating.

You don't.... nor should you as it would obviously cause you scandal as your heart is not open to your separated brothers.

> You speak as if I wear Catholicism like I am some sort of Protestant hate monger. I am a long way from that.

I am glad to hear that. But, there's a lot of history behind this... and if we're serious about Vatican II and Christ's command that we "all be one", we should exercise more discretion.

> But where am I against Vatican II?

Certainly nowhere consciously. I just think that Christian love should leave one open to the possibility that God may have tremendously used the KJV over the centuries to create strong Christians and to lead to cultures who could create Margaret Thatchers and Ronald Reagans to "incarnate" JPII's struggles against Communism and effect the miraculous.... Maybe I'm showing my age, but I don't think our time has fully grasped the wonderfully miraculous nature of the relatively peaceful collapse of Communism in Eastern Europe. To my historical imagination, clearly God used these three people from the Catholic and Anglo-Protestant traditions.

> Where does Vatican II say to use protestant Bibles?

It doesn't.

> Apparently you have not read Dominus Iesus,

I have.

> because it is my impression that your post is dangerously close to indifferentism.

No, but I am aware of the uncomfortable truth that there are flourishing "economies of salvation" in other
ecclesial communities. Also, when a priest confesses to me in confession that it "makes you want to become a Buddhist", it causes one to see even more clearly the difficulties within the Church in America at this time.

> The Church still teaches that there are heretics. The word did not go away.
> Now Protestants today are probably mostly material heretics rather than formal ones.
> But heretics, nevertheless.

Ok... heresy - to choose.... When we all sin don't we choose other than God's best for us?.... Maybe as a non-cradle Catholic I don't get this anger some have to those outside the church.... Shouldn't we love them and wish them to join us so that all the separated brethren should become one??? This anger always strikes me as the human desire for control and power and not the love of Christ.... Maybe this is my short-sightedness... But why anger?

> I find this incredibly insulting and suspect others on this board will as well.

All I meant is that there is lots of "ethnic" faith out there... Ethnic faith doesn't seem very real. Didn't Christ say we need to be willing to leave father and mother and children for his sake? Phatmassers are definitionally Catholic outliers in that 98%+ of young Catholics wouldn't be interested in posting and reading a forum like this.... I think there is definitely a lot of living faith here... And that includes many of the formal and closet SSPXers as well.

> I suggest you retract it.

Ok, I was just feeling despondent.... I know things are turning around as JPII's legacy is bearing fruit.

> You think I am not acting Christian because I say there are problems with the KJV and it shouldn't be used?

No, not at all... I just think the attitude you convey (lack of love, agressiveness, not seeing them as your brother in Christ)
to your separated brethren causes me scandal.

According to St. Thomas (II-II, Q. liii, a. 1) .....the omission of an external act, ....; it must be evil in itself, or in appearance;
According to [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/13506d.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/13506d.htm[/url] It is not the physical cause of a neighbor's sin, but only the moral cause, or occasion; further, this moral causality may be understood in a strict sense, ...., or in a large sense, as when a person without being directly concerned in the sin nevertheless exercises a certain influence on the sin of his neighbor

My point just being that negativity towards Protestants that seems only rational argument without love (See Paul in I Cor 13) appears to me to be so much argumentation and causes me to lose faith in the Church's ability to transform lives.... I know this is not true. It is not rational. But, it is the emotion I have and therefore causes me scandal. I've seen tremendous love for Christ in Evangelicalism and so much spiritual indifferentism amongst American lay Catholics. It causes me scandal.

> Once again, it's scandalous to say the KJV had errors and should not be used. NONSENSE!

I agree with you.

> If you are going to accuse me of scandalous behavior you had better have more to back it up than this bs. Retract please.

See above. You intended no commissions of scandal I am sure.

> Catholicism is the fullness of the truth. Not by my doing. Nor am I in it by anything but the grace of God.

Amen.

> I'll make no Apologies for openly declaring this to all, whether aethist, Protestant, or any other religion.

Just a linguistic thing. Isn't Christianity the religion and Catholicism the fullness?

> I will find agreement where I can with protestants.

Great!

> But I will not make excuses for Catholicism or back down from upholding the purity of the faith

Great!

> as opposed to protestant religions which deny important doctrines such as the real presence
> of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ in the most holy Eucharist, of which it is said "unless you
> eat my flesh and drink my blood you shall not have life within you."

Ok... but let's also acknowledge the importance of having the real presence of Christ in our hearts.
Mark 16:16 Dhouay-Rheims "He that believeth and is baptized, shall be saved: but he that believeth
not shall be condemned. " Aren't there those who are physically in the church who are formal as well
as material heretics? My bishop gave a homily once where he said, "We are becoming a generation
of believers who do not believe." Something to mull over.

> God bless

God bless you... I love your zeal for the Church. :)

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

You read way to much in to my posts. My first post to Nathan was said matter of factly, not pugilisticly. There are errors in the KJV that are influenced by protestant traditions that are traditions of man. That is simply a fact. They at least expunged Romans 3:38.

[quote]you appeared to be very close to the attitudes of those who killed Tyndale and not the JPII who grasped Billy Graham's thumb and told him "We are brothers."[/quote]

Once again, you read an AWFUL lot in to my posts. "very close to the attitudes of those who killed Tyndale"??? Yes, I am just seething at the protestant chap accross the isle and the LMCS friend around the corner. No, I think what I am seeing here is an attitude in you toward Catholics.



[quote]Ok... heresy - to choose.... When we all sin don't we choose other than God's best for us?.... Maybe as a non-cradle Catholic I don't get this anger some have to those outside the church.... Shouldn't we love them and wish them to join us so that all the separated brethren should become one??? This anger always strikes me as the human desire for control and power and not the love of Christ.... Maybe this is my short-sightedness... But why anger?[/quote]

As I said, you are reading alot in to what I say, especially anger. There was not a shred of anger in my post to Nathan, though there was in my post to you and I am afraid your apology seems a bit hollow at this point. You really need to examine yourself. You need to learn detachment. It is not anger to speak of heresy and heretics. The Rodney King brand of love is not what Christ taught and you better learn that as a Catholic. Jesus called the pharasees a "brood of vipers", "blind guides". St. Stephen laid it on pretty heavy to a group of Jews who stoned them, laying the foundation for the conversion of a super Apostle, later named Paul. I am quite sure he did not say this out of anger or spite but as a matter of factly, they are looking to trap me at every turn. It is what they were. Heresy is heresy whether chosen or not. Formal heretics choose it. Moral heretics do not. I give error no quarter but this does not mean I can not love my protestant brothers and sisters and try to gently lead them to the truth in a non-judgemental fashion. I leave that part up to God. I hightly suggest you read a book by Fr. Ralph Raoul called "Winning Souls for Christ" so that you can learn the difference between hating the heresy and loving the heretic. (in the ilk of hate the sin, love the sinner).

Becoming one is not a matter of ignoring differences.

You have my prayers.

God bless

Edited by thessalonian
Posted (edited)

I just think it's unfortunate that so many Catholics turn their nose up at a masterpiece of English literature like it's a worthless pile of garbage. Again, despite the cries of fundamentalist Protestant KJV-Onlyists the world over to the contrary, it is not [i]their[/i] Bible. (As I've said before, if King James' men knew that "born again" fundies and other non-Anglicans had hijacked their work they would roll over in their bloody graves.) The historical reality is that the King James Version is an Anglican translation. I would even go as far as to call it an Anglo-Catholic translation, as the scholars who produced it were firmly "High Church."

While the King James Version would not even be in the top-ten of translations that I would offer to a fellow Catholic or someone interested in Catholicism for study or every day reading, I believe that serious students of the Bible in English who ignore the KJV -- whether they are Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant, or Jewish -- are making a mistake. Its importance is huge; the impact that it has had on subsequent English-language Bible translations (Catholic ones included), English literature as a whole, and even the way we speak is immeasurable. It is no coincidence that the King James Version is a required text for English majors.

Edited by Nathan
thessalonian
Posted

Nathan,

I can agree with your post. As a first choice bible among laity it would not get my recommend. For the serious Bible student it has value.

phatcatholic
Posted

hsdad..............i too was surprised by your response to thessalonian. you have [i]assumed[/i] a myriad of beliefs on his part based solely on his critique of the KJV. "those of their persuasion".......what does that mean? he said that the KJV was a poor translation, tainted by protestant tradition and all the sudden that means:

--he's a rad trad
--he hasn't received Vatican II
--he is hostile to protestants
--his heart his not open to our separated brethren
--he denies the economies of salvation in other ecclesial communities
--he has anger to those outside the Church
--he shows a lack of love towards protestants

?? :blink: ??

i think you have assumed way too much. one can criticize the KJV and still be open to Vatican II and all that it affirmed regarding the goodness and truth found in other Christian (and even non-Christian) communities.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Posted

Phatcatholic and Thessalonian.

Good comments....

Thessalonian, after I posted my long response, I looked back and realized you hadn't posted anywhere near as much the other individual mentioned. I apologize for reading too much into your post.

A couple things I have been struggling with lately which weighs in on all these matters.... (1) The book "God's Bestseller" is one I have read recently. It's about the struggles to get the bible into English in the early 1500's. Based on my personal history and knowledge of history as well, I am aware very strongly of the critical role love for the bible played in the growth of a literate republican culture in America and the growth of this "almost chosen people" to quote Abe Lincoln. (See recent First Things articles)... The growth of the modern mission movement within Evangelicalism and the tremendous grace it has spread around the world is another reality flowing from this love of God's Word.... Also, the confusion and indifference by so many priests and laity formed during the late 60's early 70's is difficult as well. So, it definitely is difficult.... I miss having scores of good Christian friends I could fellowship with who would know and love the word and didn't feel awkward talking about their personal faith lives.

(2) Catholicism feels so Hellenistic and overally philosophical.... It's as if it neglects the human person and how we should love God above all things and seek to give him honor and glory.... which will as fruit give us joy.

(3) Perhaps I miss JP2... His deep personalism led me into the Church as I felt it provided hope for a movement away from a dead scholasticism...

Anyways, I know there are many seeds growing.


God bless.

[quote name='thessalonian' post='999458' date='Jun 7 2006, 07:07 AM']
The Rodney King brand of love is not what Christ taught and you better learn that as a Catholic.
Jesus called the pharasees a "brood of vipers", "blind guides". St. Stephen laid it on pretty heavy to a group of Jews who stoned them, laying the foundation for the conversion of a super Apostle, later named Paul. [/quote]

I agree... I just think that we should see all the problems in the Church as they truly are. After all Jesus was
speaking this way to the chosen people. In love...

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

If I were to meet Billy Graham I would most definitely honor him.

I have not read that book. I have read Henry Graham's where we got the Bible. I ran in to an interesting article online the other day. It makes a couple of interesting points that 1) Part of the reason for the trouble getting the Bible in English was that there was little demand for it because people couldn't read. In Graham's book he says they even had to force people to buy them. Secondly, what I found interesting was that the Protestant verision KJV Bible was not widely distributed for quite some time because the King copyrighted it. The Rheims version did not do this and was more widely distributed. The KJV was not printed in the America's until 1777,

[url="http://www.catholicapologetics.net/apolo_20.htm"]http://www.catholicapologetics.net/apolo_20.htm[/url]

Yes, post Vatican II there have been many problems. This is not uncommon with councils in which there were significant changes in understanding. The world actually became primarily Arian after the council of Nicea for instance. 85-90% as I recall. But in time Arianism died out as the teachings of the Council took hold. Your observations about Catholics are not unfounded. But I see good things happening in this Archdicoese. (I'm in the same one as you). Perhaps you should drive up to our 6:30 AM men's group/Bible Study if you want some fellowship with men who love the word of God. We have a Bible study. It's at Epiphany.

God bless

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1000248' date='Jun 8 2006, 06:10 AM']
If I were to meet Billy Graham I would most definitely honor him.
[/quote]

Good!

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1000248' date='Jun 8 2006, 06:10 AM']
But I see good things happening in this Archdicoese. (I'm in the same one as you). Perhaps you should drive up to our 6:30 AM men's group/Bible Study if you want some fellowship with men who love the word of God. We have a Bible study. It's at Epiphany.
[/quote]

I've heard good things about Epiphany as well. Unfortunately its on the other end of the archdiocese for me...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...