Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Which is better?  

36 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

I realize very well that going to Mass and also wanting to is best!

I'm very curious to know what people think. I'm torn -- normally I'd say intention is everything, but Mass is such a big deal, with so many actual graces... I feel that actually being there is perhaps better? But, OTOH, that seems kind of wrong too.

:idontknow:

Posted

you definitely need to go. in today's world, church is very much seen as what we "Get out of it" but we have to remember that we aren't there for us primarily, we are there to give God the praise and worship that is due Him as Almighty God, regardless of how we feel about it.

Go, even when you don't want to. Commandment #3 isn't keep holy the Sabbath when you're "in the mood" :P:

and don't worry, God will teach your heart to match your head :)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='kateri05' post='993572' date='May 31 2006, 11:55 AM']
you definitely need to go. in today's world, church is very much seen as what we "Get out of it" but we have to remember that we aren't there for us primarily, we are there to give God the praise and worship that is due Him as Almighty God, regardless of how we feel about it.

Go, even when you don't want to. Commandment #3 isn't keep holy the Sabbath when you're "in the mood" :P:

and don't worry, God will teach your heart to match your head :)
[/quote]
:idontknow:

Option 1 is talking about someone [b]physically unable[/b] to go to Mass, either due to illness or location...

I know that people ought to go to Mass whether they feel like it or not. I was wondering who would receive more grace from God -- someone who wanted to go but couldn't, or someone who didn't want to go but went because it was easier than not going.

Edited by philothea
Posted

In my opinion from the scenarios you have laid out - Option 1, because the heart is in the right place.

The person going out of habit probably wouldnt be interested in mass and be distracted and even recieve the Eucharist out of habit...which makes me think - is that recieving it unworthily?

Peace,
Rob

Posted

oops sorry! didn't understand :sadwalk:

Posted

#1

God despises the luke warm.

Posted

[quote name='OLAM Dad' post='994696' date='Jun 1 2006, 02:01 PM']
#1

God despises the luke warm.
[/quote]
oui.

journeyman
Posted

I hope #1 is better - since I've missed Sunday Mass every other week since March, when my Mom went into the hospital - she's home again, but neither of my parents is up to independent living - until that changes, it seems likely that I will continue to take care of them alternate weekends - thank goodness my brother lives in the area and we can take turns

Posted

[quote]God despises the luke warm.[/quote]

I didn't think God despised anyone. I thought that God was love. :idontknow:

But nevertheless, he would still want us stop being luke warm on be on fire with the Holy Spirit!

And I had no idea how to vote!! It's a good question.

Posted

Um doing things out of habit is not bad, or even neutral, it is a very very good thing, as it indicates the firm disposition to do the good, so I vote #2 without further qualification.

Jesus will still vomit out the luke warm in the end.

Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' post='995546' date='Jun 2 2006, 02:24 PM']
Um doing things out of habit is not bad, or even neutral, it is a very very good thing, as it indicates the firm disposition to do the good, so I vote #2 without further qualification.
[/quote]
The question did say [b]only[/b] out of habit. There's only so much room to explain. ;)

I meant someone who doesn't want to go, but only does because that's the path of least resistance -- like when not going would be embarassing or difficult to explain.

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' post='995546' date='Jun 2 2006, 02:24 PM']
Um doing things out of habit is not bad, or even neutral, it is a very very good thing, as it indicates the firm disposition to do the good, so I vote #2 without further qualification.

Jesus will still vomit out the luke warm in the end.
[/quote]

I agree. Is Catholics dont go because it feels good, or to fulfill some cheap superficial emotional need. Commitment and devotion which become a habit, well is virtuous, and a sign of Grace.

I bet that God often tries to awaken those who go out of habit. I mean your surrounded by holy things, Word and Sacrament. Actually recieving the sacraments do guarantee you a share in grace, whereas those who are unable to attend, we can only hope.

SHALOM

Justified Saint
Posted

Life is all about habits and the holy life is about [b]good[/b] habits.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

..being there is better than not being there.

Ideally, there ought to be a third option--of both going and desiring to be there. However, given the choices and the point you are trying to make, I still say that being present at the Mass is a greater grace than only desiring to be there.

Even if you were truly unable to go, you might not be culpable for missing Mass, but it would still always be better to have been able to go. Whereas, it would NEVER be better for someone not to attend Mass.

thessalonian
Posted

Habitual vice is replaced by habitual virtue. Habit is not neccessarily bad as we have a tendancy to think. If the habitual attender is not in mortal sin, receiving our Lord in the state of grace cannot be compare with only a desire to receive him. Desire is good as well of course and the Lord will bless the shut in who desires to attend.

Posted

I would say that its my desire to go to mass that has formed my weekly habit.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

That is a missing category in this topic. But the question is a valid one because there are many who go to Church out of habit. Though I am not sure we can judge them as going to Church just out of habbit as we have a tendancy to do so it is not a valid one. In all honesty I don't think anyone going JUST out of habbit would continue in the faith. Some have a simplier faith with less understanding and so their reasons for going to Church may not be as deep as our own. But are they really going just out of habbit? Or are we simply being judgemental?

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

The poll is a simple comparison, asked for a particular reason. I'm not trying to categorize anyone, or fit every person into a slot. Which is better, a or b? The existence of other options doesn't have anything to do with the question.

I got the answer I suspected, and I think it explains why I'm not liking phatmass too much lately...

the 13th papist
Posted (edited)

in this particular case, it is important to look at what what has been said by the church. although not attending mass on the sabath is considered a mortal sin, desiring to go to mass and not being able to (assuming there is a legitimate excuse) is not a sin. on the flip side, we are called as catholic to FULL participation in the mass- that means paying attention, singing, and being prayerful. i dont think it is possible to judge whether or not somebody's lack of desire to be at mass can be considered sinful. so, objectively, niether are sinful.

In general regards to moral theology, intent is a very very large part of the sinfulness of an act, but is not everthing. somethings, like abortion, are sinful and bad no matter what the intentions may be.

There is also no denying the many graces recieved by a person who goes to mass over a long period of time. after following and participating in the outward actions of the mass, eventually an inner change of heart may take place, drawing the person deeper and deeper into the mysteries of faith.

with all that said, i wold rather have somebody with the strong desire to do go to mass and do does every reasonable thing in his power to get to the eucharist but is unable over somebody who just shows up to mass out of habit.

the luke warm are spit out of the mouth

"vitues are positive habits"

God Bless

Edited by the 13th papist
thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1004757' date='Jun 13 2006, 01:29 PM']
The poll is a simple comparison, asked for a particular reason. I'm not trying to categorize anyone, or fit every person into a slot. Which is better, a or b? The existence of other options doesn't have anything to do with the question.

I got the answer I suspected, and I think it explains why I'm not liking phatmass too much lately...
[/quote]


What's your point? Sounds like you are looking for contention.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...