Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Which is better?  

36 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1004852' date='Jun 13 2006, 03:19 PM']
What's your point? Sounds like you are looking for contention.
[/quote]
If by contention you mean I want to argue with someone, or cause a debate -- no, not at all. I wouldn't even have clarified if people weren't saying the poll needed other options.

I suppose it was snarky of me to comment on the result. I'm sorry if I upset anyone; it just made me sad.

Posted

hey, habit is only ahead by a slim margin . . . let's go white wash some pharisees and see if we can't change that !!

Posted

[quote name='journeyman' post='1005110' date='Jun 13 2006, 09:04 PM']
hey, habit is only ahead by a slim margin . . . let's go white wash some pharisees and see if we can't change that !!
[/quote]
:rolling:


:flowers:

EXACTLY the verses I was thinking about!

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

hrm. I don't think it's pharisaical to say going out of habit is better than desiring to go. Grace is received by going to Mass, whether they know it or not.

It is GOOD to desire to attend Mass (and be unable to go), but it is BETTER to actually be at Mass. God's grace is not dependent upon us (thank God) to flow. Yes, we must cooperate with it, but that's another debate. The person who goes to Mass has an opportunity to receive more grace than one who only desires to go but is not actually present.


I desire to help the poor, but if I do nothing but desire and not give what I can (even if it's only small) I'm not really helping. Whereas, if I give to the poor out of a sense of duty/habit, at least I am helping them.

Action is important.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

Why is it a laughing matter that it is close. I don't think the people (me) who voted for habit think desire is unimportant and I find your pharassee (and the exactly) comment rather insulting. The either or mentality displayed is childish. If you are bothered by the vote take your polls elsewhere. I will not participate again in any of your polls. That someone is going out of habit does not mean they have no desire. This either or dichotomous thinking is protestant and what causes division as it clearly is here. You post a poll and somehow think it is better to desire to recieve Christ than to actually recieve him, body, blood, soul, and divinity. Spiritual communion is not equal to real communion. No mention of those who attending not being in a state of grace in your poll, which the pharasses were not. That is why they did not recieve Christ! What I see is judging those who may not be blessed with the knowledge that you have and are accountable for in having a greater desire to go to Mass. Stop judging those around you in Mass and go. MAKE IT A HABBIT!

Edited by thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1005357' date='Jun 14 2006, 05:25 AM']
hrm. I don't think it's pharisaical to say going out of habit is better than desiring to go. Grace is received by going to Mass, whether they know it or not.

It is GOOD to desire to attend Mass (and be unable to go), but it is BETTER to actually be at Mass. God's grace is not dependent upon us (thank God) to flow. Yes, we must cooperate with it, but that's another debate. The person who goes to Mass has an opportunity to receive more grace than one who only desires to go but is not actually present.
I desire to help the poor, but if I do nothing but desire and not give what I can (even if it's only small) I'm not really helping. Whereas, if I give to the poor out of a sense of duty/habit, at least I am helping them.

Action is important.
[/quote]
Again, the poll said [b]only[/b] out of habit. Only means [i]there is no other reason[/i] -- no belief in God. I'm sorry if people thought I was trying to get at something I'm not. I'm not in any way trying to denigrate going to mass because it's a habit. I'm trying to figure out what matters to people here more: appearance or intention?

I wasn't trying to ask about phatmassers and their personal choices, and whether they feel like they want to go to mass every time they do. That's a totally separate issue, and I don't set any store in "feelings" at all.

So seriously -- Fides, a lapsed Catholic, now atheist college student who has moved back into his parents house after graduation, and goes to mass with them because he always used to and it's easier than not going, is better off than a pious but house-bound old lady who is now unable to make it to church?

Edited by philothea
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1005379' date='Jun 14 2006, 06:22 AM']
Why is it a laughing matter that it is close. I don't think the people (me) who voted for habit think desire is unimportant and I find your pharassee (and the exactly) comment rather insulting. [/quote]
I'm sorry. It wasn't in reply to you. I kid around with journeyman a lot, and I found it funny that he posted the exact thing I was thinking... and apparently I've been unclear enough that there are a lot of things I could have been thinking!

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1005379' date='Jun 14 2006, 06:22 AM']
The either or mentality displayed is childish. If you are bothered by the vote take your polls elsewhere. I will not participate again in any of your polls. [/quote]
Er, okay. Is there some way to know when "or" is an acceptable comparison?

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1005379' date='Jun 14 2006, 06:22 AM']
That someone is going out of habit does not mean they have no desire.
[/quote]
The poll states "ONLY" out of habit, like I pointed out to Fides, and mentioned a few weeks ago too. Only means, you know, that there's nothing else.

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1005379' date='Jun 14 2006, 06:22 AM']
This either or dichotomous thinking is protestant and what causes division as it clearly is here.
[/quote]
?? I'm just asking people's opinions on one situation. I clearly stated in the first post that neither of these situations is ideal. I don't even know if there's a "right" answer. I kinda go back and forth on what I think. My emotions say one thing; logic says another. I wanted to get a feel for people's opinions.

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1005379' date='Jun 14 2006, 06:22 AM']
You post a poll and somehow think it is better to desire to recieve Christ than to actually recieve him, body, blood, soul, and divinity. Spiritual communion is not equal to real communion.[/quote]
What?? Where are you getting this from? I have never once said or thought anything like this.

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1005379' date='Jun 14 2006, 06:22 AM']
No mention of those who attending not being in a state of grace in your poll, which the pharasses were not. That is why they did not recieve Christ! What I see is judging those who may not be blessed with the knowledge that you have and are accountable for in having a greater desire to go to Mass. Stop judging those around you in Mass and go. MAKE IT A HABBIT!
[/quote]
Sorry... this isn't about judging anyone, except maybe a niggling fear that "nonconforming" people as a whole are judged without question by a large portion of phatmass. You have jumped to some conclusions about me that are not accurate.

Again, I apologize if I've upset you. This wasn't meant to be a trick question. I wish I'd been able to phrase it more clearly, and not triggered this reaction to what you thought I said.

Justified Saint
Posted (edited)

Well, I can't speak for others, but it seems like you can't say [b]only[/b] out of habit. I realize people use this phrase a lot and I suspect what they mean by it, but I think it shows a misunderstanding of what they are talking about. Habitualization is a basic condition for living with other people in a community, as such it is value-neutral. If you want to talk about [b]thoughtless[/b] haibts, or [b]bad[/b] habits then you need to qualify it as such.

Edited by Justified Saint
Posted

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1005500' date='Jun 14 2006, 10:25 AM']
Well, I can't speak for others, but it seems like you can't say [b]only[/b] out of habit. I realize people use this phrase a lot and I suspect what they mean by it, but I think it shows a misunderstanding of what they are talking about. Habitualization is a basic condition for living with other people in a community, as such it is value-neutral. If you want to talk about [b]thoughtless[/b] haibts, or [b]bad[/b] habits then you need to qualify it as such.
[/quote]
Actually, the value-neutral aspect of an established habit is [i]exactly[/i] why I chose that for the comparison. This isn't an easy question with one obviously right answer.

Obviously, "going to mass only to keep up the apperance of being religious" sounds rather biased. Same with, "only to see the cute altar server." The point was someone who doesn't believe in God, or the sacraments, or the efficacy of the mass, but goes for some other neutral reason. Habit seemed to fit.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1005462' date='Jun 14 2006, 11:20 AM']
Again, the poll said [b]only[/b] out of habit. Only means [i]there is no other reason[/i] -- no belief in God. I'm sorry if people thought I was trying to get at something I'm not. I'm not in any way trying to denigrate going to mass because it's a habit. I'm trying to figure out what matters to people here more: appearance or intention?

I wasn't trying to ask about phatmassers and their personal choices, and whether they feel like they want to go to mass every time they do. That's a totally separate issue, and I don't set any store in "feelings" at all.[/quote]
I know it said "only" out of havit. My vote still remains the same. Grace is not dependent upon our feelings/desires/motivations, it flows regardless (and as I said, cooperation is another story that wasn't part of the polling options). And the person who is actually present at Mass has a better opportunity for grace than the person who desires to go but can't make it.

It is better to actually receive the Eucharist than to desire it without reception. Desire comes and goes, but habit presents a real opportunity for growth and conversion through the grace one receives by attending Mass. A person going "only" out of habit is still going-- and that still says something. Ask a priest if they'd rather every person going to Mass "only out habit" just stay home. No priest would say yes-- GOING (/action) provides opportunity and grace. Desire is good, but action is better... desire is meant to lead to action.

[quote]So seriously -- Fides, a lapsed Catholic, now atheist college student who has moved back into his parents house after graduation, and goes to mass with them because he always used to and it's easier than not going, is better off than a pious but house-bound old lady who is now unable to make it to church?[/quote]
Both are good. It is still good that the homebound woman desires to be at Mass (hey, maybe a priest could bring her communion, or go celebrate Mass for her at her home)... but the atheist at Mass receives grace for going to Mass and also receives the opportunity for conversion and change of heart through the Sacred Liturgy. But I'm not sure these cases are really comparable... would it be better for the woman to be able to go to Mass? Yes. Would it be better for the atheist to skip Mass? No. Just because he doesn't want to be there or whatever, does not negate the outpouring of grace that comes from the Mass and worshipping in community.

Posted

and the other option said desired, but being unable . . . that indicated to me "prevented" from attending . . . as in sick . . . as in caring for someone else who is sick (the latter having been my case for the last few months)

does that change the scales of the balance any?

Posted

Well, this has certainly been a heated discussion.


From personal experience, I said it was better to go out of habit. I have been in both situations in my life, and comparing them going to Mass was definitely better. (I wasn't an athiest or anything, but I did mainly go to Mass because my family did and really didn't think much of it if I missed Mass for some other reason.)

Looking back on my life of virtue and the grace present in my life at the time when I was going to Mass out of habit, it was immeasurably better than when I was not going to Mass. When I was in college I lived in the middle of the rainforest in Canada for a semester and was unable to attend Mass. I really wanted to, and set aside my own worship time on Sundays, but it is not the same. Not having those graces present in my life made me realize just how much grace we recieve simply by attending Mass.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1005868' date='Jun 14 2006, 09:17 PM']
I know it said "only" out of havit. My vote still remains the same. Grace is not dependent upon our feelings/desires/motivations, it flows regardless (and as I said, cooperation is another story that wasn't part of the polling options). And the person who is actually present at Mass has a better opportunity for grace than the person who desires to go but can't make it.
[/quote]
Hrm. I find this compelling, but with further analysis it seems flawed. You could be [i]a saint[/i] and not be able to go to mass. You could not be a saint and be going to mass only out of habit. Being present at Mass means that you are guaranteed the benefit of the graces granted to those present, but wanting to go, and being truly unable to -- obviously your inability is God's will. What can better than the will of God?

Or do we believe that God's will denies necessary grace from some one who desires to serve him? Is God a technical perfectionist, or does he care about your heart more?

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1005868' date='Jun 14 2006, 09:17 PM']
It is better to actually receive the Eucharist than to desire it without reception. Desire comes and goes, but habit presents a real opportunity for growth and conversion through the grace one receives by attending Mass. A person going "only" out of habit is still going-- and that still says something. Ask a priest if they'd rather every person going to Mass "only out habit" just stay home. No priest would say yes-- GOING (/action) provides opportunity and grace. Desire is good, but action is better... desire is meant to lead to action.
Both are good. It is still good that the homebound woman desires to be at Mass (hey, maybe a priest could bring her communion, or go celebrate Mass for her at her home)... but the atheist at Mass receives grace for going to Mass and also receives the opportunity for conversion and change of heart through the Sacred Liturgy. But I'm not sure these cases are really comparable... would it be better for the woman to be able to go to Mass? Yes. Would it be better for the atheist to skip Mass? No. Just because he doesn't want to be there or whatever, does not negate the outpouring of grace that comes from the Mass and worshipping in community.
[/quote]
Sure, but none of this addresses the question, and I don't see why the cases can't be compared. Which would [i]you[/i] rather be? The atheist at mass or the devout homebound person?

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='journeyman' post='1006562' date='Jun 15 2006, 10:04 PM']
and the other option said desired, but being unable . . . that indicated to me "prevented" from attending . . . as in sick . . . as in caring for someone else who is sick (the latter having been my case for the last few months)

does that change the scales of the balance any?
[/quote]
Nope.

I recognized that those who were home were home for grave reason(s).

[quote name='philothea' post='1006626' date='Jun 16 2006, 12:02 AM']
Hrm. I find this compelling, but with further analysis it seems flawed. You could be [i]a saint[/i] and not be able to go to mass. You could not be a saint and be going to mass only out of habit. Being present at Mass means that you are guaranteed the benefit of the graces granted to those present, but wanting to go, and being truly unable to -- obviously your inability is God's will. What can better than the will of God?[/quote]
I'm not sure I would agree that God's will would ever be for someone to miss Mass. He may allow them the evil of missing Mass for various grave reasons, but I do not believe that God's will would ever be actively for someone to miss Mass.

[quote]Or do we believe that God's will denies necessary grace from some one who desires to serve him? Is God a technical perfectionist, or does he care about your heart more?
Sure, but none of this addresses the question, and I don't see why the cases can't be compared. Which would [i]you[/i] rather be? The atheist at mass or the devout homebound person?
[/quote]
It wouldn't be God's will denying grace...

No, God is not a techincal perfectionist, but I know that He would rather have you at Mass than not there. They cannot be compared because they are radically different. Both are goods. It is good to be a Mass, period. It is good to desire to be at Mass, period. If one has grave reason(s) to not attend Mass, then yes, it is a good to desire to be there. However it is better for the atheist to be present at Mass. The Sacrifice of Calvary made present at each and every Mass has immeasureable graces that flow from it-- it has the power and opportunity to truly touch a person.

I wouldn't want to be either of them-- I'd rather be a devout person attending Mass every Sunday. If I had to choose, I would still say I would rather be there than not be able to go. The Sacrifice of the Mass is powerful beyond compare.

Justified Saint
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1005670' date='Jun 14 2006, 12:45 PM']
Actually, the value-neutral aspect of an established habit is [i]exactly[/i] why I chose that for the comparison. This isn't an easy question with one obviously right answer.

Obviously, "going to mass only to keep up the apperance of being religious" sounds rather biased. Same with, "only to see the cute altar server." The point was someone who doesn't believe in God, or the sacraments, or the efficacy of the mass, but goes for some other neutral reason. Habit seemed to fit.
[/quote]

Ok, well there seems to be big difference between saying going to mass only out of habit and going to mass as an atheist out of habit. The former does not imply the latter.

Posted

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1006692' date='Jun 16 2006, 02:06 AM']
Ok, well there seems to be big difference between saying going to mass only out of habit and going to mass as an atheist out of habit. The former does not imply the latter.
[/quote]


I agree.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...