mortify Posted June 23, 2006 Posted June 23, 2006 hey guys, Recently my parish has had a new priest and at his first mass I noticed he was using a glass instead of a golden chalice. I remember hearing and reading glass is forbidden from a transcript of an interview with Cardinal Arinze but I thought maybe this was just a one time thing. I noticed however, that he did it again, and then he did it a third time. My parish has many priests who rotate masses and he's the only one to use a glass. I want to talk to him about it but I'm a bit nervous. I don't feel fit telling a priest what he should be doing, and I really don't want to come off as arrogant or rigid but I really want to get this straightened out. How do you guys suggest I approach this? mort
Fides_et_Ratio Posted June 23, 2006 Posted June 23, 2006 very cautiously. in all likelihood, he probably knows the "rules" (because, yes, it is forbidden to use a glass chalice (or really anything breakable including ceramics) to hold the Eucharist). you can ask him why he uses a glass chalice/what his reasoning for using one is... but in all honesty, he'll probably continue to use it.
Jaime Posted June 23, 2006 Posted June 23, 2006 I'd say "Wow is that your own personal chalice? Can I see it please? Its sooo pretty!" Then I'd accidentally drop it on the marble floor Then I'd go to confession
Birgitta Noel Posted June 23, 2006 Posted June 23, 2006 (edited) Edited June 23, 2006 by Birgitta Noel
KatS Posted June 23, 2006 Posted June 23, 2006 Are there any other reasons why glass should not be used, besides the fact that it can break? Sorry if that's a dumb question but ya gotta forgive me 'cuz I am a revert
MichaelF Posted June 23, 2006 Posted June 23, 2006 The chalice itself does not have to be gold, but it must at least be -lined- with gold inside. I'd send a letter to the Bishop, if there is no suitable senior Priest.
alicemary Posted June 24, 2006 Posted June 24, 2006 Why not just ask him? There does not have to be some deep, dark conspiracy. Above all be respectful, it is not for you to judge another.
Norseman82 Posted June 24, 2006 Posted June 24, 2006 [quote name='KatS' post='1011038' date='Jun 23 2006, 03:05 PM'] Are there any other reasons why glass should not be used, besides the fact that it can break? Sorry if that's a dumb question but ya gotta forgive me 'cuz I am a revert [/quote] As I recall, it is not only non-breakable material that must be used but also non-[i]porous[/i] material (since porous material can absorb the Blood). .
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted June 24, 2006 Posted June 24, 2006 (edited) Buy him a gold chalice as a welcome gift? Then again, that may set you back some big money... Edited June 24, 2006 by thedude
mortify Posted June 24, 2006 Author Posted June 24, 2006 Do we have a moral obligation to correct such things? Would it be a sin if i did nothing about it? And as of now I figure I'll ask it in the frame of a question, i.e. why are you using a glass; I don't think ill mention it being wrong. But if he doesn't get rid of it i'd hate causing problems by contacting the bishop. Anyway guys, thanks for your responses! ill be sure to pray about it.
alicemary Posted June 26, 2006 Posted June 26, 2006 You have the moral obligation to degrade a priest..yeah, that would be real wonderful. Maybe he could not afford a gold chalice, have you thought of that. Run to the bishop, not a great idea either. I go with just going up to him and speaking to the guy, don't be so judgemental. Look to your shortcomings and sins and do not be disrespectful to a man who has dedicated his life to serving Christ.
Jaime Posted June 26, 2006 Posted June 26, 2006 [quote name='alicemary' post='1012061' date='Jun 25 2006, 06:30 PM'] You have the moral obligation to degrade a priest..yeah, that would be real wonderful. Maybe he could not afford a gold chalice, have you thought of that. Run to the bishop, not a great idea either. I go with just going up to him and speaking to the guy, don't be so judgemental. Look to your shortcomings and sins and do not be disrespectful to a man who has dedicated his life to serving Christ. [/quote] Whooooaaa there partner.. Its not an issue of being snobby. Its an issue of protection and giving proper honor to Eucharist. Why can't glass be used? Its not durable. It can break. For a priest to choose to use glass is an abuse and its a dangerous one. And this isn't an issue about the priest's feelings. (Trust me he knows what he's doing) This abuse affects the congregation. On a larger scale, the priest by example is saying that its ok to disobey with the authority of the Church.
mortify Posted June 26, 2006 Author Posted June 26, 2006 [quote name='alicemary' post='1012061' date='Jun 25 2006, 05:30 PM'] You have the moral obligation to degrade a priest..yeah, that would be real wonderful. Maybe he could not afford a gold chalice, have you thought of that. Run to the bishop, not a great idea either. I go with just going up to him and speaking to the guy, don't be so judgemental. Look to your shortcomings and sins and do not be disrespectful to a man who has dedicated his life to serving Christ. [/quote] Hi Alice, Why do I get the impression that you already think I'm coming across as judgmental Would you be "degrading" a person by pointing out an error they've been making on multiple occasions? Is correcting a person being "judgmental"?
iggy Posted June 26, 2006 Posted June 26, 2006 If it were me, I would talk to another priest about it, and have the other priest talk to the one who uses the glass chalice. It seems like the long way around, but then the correction is not coming from "below" the priest, and you are not "running" to the bishop
morostheos Posted June 26, 2006 Posted June 26, 2006 maybe he's using a crystal chalice?? I don't think the use of crystal is specifically forbidden, and it is considered a precious material (which I think is another stipulation). It's always best to assume the best of others. If you are concerned, I would talk to him about it with charity and respect - best in a "want to learn more" fashion, I think. Ask, "why is your chalice different than the one the other priests use? what's it made out of?"
prose Posted June 26, 2006 Posted June 26, 2006 Okay, first of all, everyone needs to relax! My current parish just changes chalices this year. It was ultimately a budget issue. When they had the money and were able, they switched. Just ask. All of the priests that I have met are pretty kind and honest. At least you will have an answer. I can 100% GUARANTEE that someone else (probably several) have mentioned it to him already, so he is probably used to it.
Guest Rick777 Posted June 26, 2006 Posted June 26, 2006 I thought everybody was pretty relaxed about it? If you haven't mentioned anything Mortify, just casually bring it up....no harm there right? BTW he must know about the GIRM and what it states, but you bringing it up might make him think about using a Gold chalice instead. I actually beg to differ with you Prose, I bet that no one has even questioned his using the glass chalice.
alicemary Posted June 26, 2006 Posted June 26, 2006 I dont mean to sound mean, sorry. Just trying to understand the viewpoints expressed here. I dont see using glass as being disrespectful, I find using gold a lttle over done. In this day and age don't think it is necessary to use gold in a chalice. Personally I like the idea of using glass, and have seen it used many times. It is supposed to symbolize a cup, and a cup is glass. And if it breaks, so what? I have seen wine spill out of the cup several times, and have seen the chalice tip over. Of course this is something that you want to try and prevent, but it happens. I just don't get hung up on minute issues, there is a big world of issues out there, and this seems very trivial to me BUT I DO UNDERSTAND THAT IT IS IMPORTANT TO YOU. So that is why this forum is so nice to exchange views.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now