Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Alicemary

I don't think anyone is concerned with the spilling of a little wine. I know I couldn't care less about that. But if the break happens after transubstantiation,


well that's something to be concerned about.


The Eucharist is the cornerstone of our faith. Yet an overwhelming majority of Catholics are not aware of its importance to our lives and to the life of our Church. When a priest disregards what he is required to do with regards to the Eucharist, he's setting an example. He's inferring "I don't really care about this". And as a role model, he's reenforcing the underlying problem in our Church.

That the Eucharist is no big deal.


You state that there are "bigger problems" in the world. Please consider this.


There is no bigger solution in the world than the Eucharist.

That's why its so important

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

amen, hot stuff.

Posted

[quote]According to the existing law of the Church the chalice, or at least the cup of it, must be made either of gold or of silver, and in the latter case the bowl must be gilt on the inside. In circumstances of great poverty or in time of persecution a calix stanneus (pewter) may be permitted, but the bowl of this also, like the upper surface of the paten, must be gilt. [/quote]
-Catholic Encyclopedia

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03561a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03561a.htm[/url]

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='alicemary' post='1012371' date='Jun 26 2006, 08:10 AM']
I dont mean to sound mean, sorry. Just trying to understand the viewpoints expressed here. I dont see using glass as being disrespectful, I find using gold a lttle over done. In this day and age don't think it is necessary to use gold in a chalice. Personally I like the idea of using glass, and have seen it used many times. It is supposed to symbolize a cup, and a cup is glass. And if it breaks, so what? I have seen wine spill out of the cup several times, and have seen the chalice tip over. Of course this is something that you want to try and prevent, but it happens. I just don't get hung up on minute issues, there is a big world of issues out there, and this seems very trivial to me BUT I DO UNDERSTAND THAT IT IS IMPORTANT TO YOU. So that is why this forum is so nice to exchange views.
[/quote]
It might not be earth-shaking, but the church has said its forbidden. Maybe somebody just needs to buy him a gold chalice.
[url="http://www.catholicsupply.com/churchs/chalice.html"]http://www.catholicsupply.com/churchs/chalice.html[/url] $165+

Posted

What happened the the old chalice that the other priest was using?

Maybe someone needs to donate a chalice to your Church.

Posted

There are five priests in my parish they alternate masses every Sunday. Everyone of them uses a gold chalice except one priest, who has consecutively used the glass.

Availability of a gold chalice is not the issue (though I wish it was)

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1012496' date='Jun 26 2006, 12:52 PM']
There are five priests in my parish they alternate masses every Sunday. Everyone of them uses a gold chalice except one priest, who has consecutively used the glass.

Availability of a gold chalice is not the issue (though I wish it was)
[/quote]
Most priests I know received a chalice when they were ordained.

Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1012089' date='Jun 25 2006, 07:17 PM']
maybe he's using a crystal chalice?? I don't think the use of crystal is specifically forbidden, and it is considered a precious material (which I think is another stipulation).

It's always best to assume the best of others. If you are concerned, I would talk to him about it with charity and respect - best in a "want to learn more" fashion, I think. Ask, "why is your chalice different than the one the other priests use? what's it made out of?"
[/quote]

The fact of the matter is that it is clearly stated that the precious vessels used for the celebration of the Holy Eucharist have to be precious metals, not precious material. Crystal is not metal and it is very breakable, but the issue is that it is also very porous. That is why the vessels need to made of precious metals like gold or silver.

I agree with Iggy if you are self consious about telling a priest directly what he should do. A more experienced priest would certainly be able to inform the younger priest that what he is doing is forbidden.

Posted

[quote name='alicemary' post='1012371' date='Jun 26 2006, 07:10 AM']
I dont mean to sound mean, sorry. Just trying to understand the viewpoints expressed here. I dont see using glass as being disrespectful, I find using gold a lttle over done. In this day and age don't think it is necessary to use gold in a chalice. Personally I like the idea of using glass, and have seen it used many times. It is supposed to symbolize a cup, and a cup is glass. And if it breaks, so what? I have seen wine spill out of the cup several times, and have seen the chalice tip over. Of course this is something that you want to try and prevent, but it happens. I just don't get hung up on minute issues, there is a big world of issues out there, and this seems very trivial to me BUT I DO UNDERSTAND THAT IT IS IMPORTANT TO YOU. So that is why this forum is so nice to exchange views.
[/quote]

It is disrespectful though it may not seem so to you, but it is to Jesus because the chalice contains the Precious Blood of Christ. Glass and crystal contains pores in the material which may absorb some of the Precious Blood which is not good at all. Not all cups are glass either and the chalice is not just a symbol of a cup. It is the cup that contains the Most Precious Blood of Jesus Christ. If the Blood were to spill, it would be a serious issue, not just a minute issue.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...